- 1987: Mabbutt
- 1988: Waddle
- 1989: Thorstvedt
- 1990: Gascoigne
- 1991: Allen
- 1992: Lineker
- 1993: Anderton
- 1994: Klinsmann
- 1995: Sheringham
- 1996: Campbell
- 1997: Campbell
- 1998: Ginola
- 1999: Carr
- 2000: Carr
- 2001: Sullivan
- 2002: Davies
- 2003: Keane
- 2004: Defoe
- 2005–06: Berbatov
- 2006–07: Keane
- 2007–08: Lennon
- 2008–09: Keane
- 2009–10: Dawson
- 2010–11: Modrić
- 2011–12: Parker
|