The 1958 All-Big Ten Conference football team consists of American football players chosen by various organizations for All-Big Ten Conference teams for the 1958 Big Ten Conference football season.

All-Big Ten selections

Quarterbacks

• Randy Duncan, Iowa (AP-1; UPI-1)
• Dale Hackbart, Wisconsin (AP-2; UPI-2)
• Dick Thornton, Northwestern (AP-3; UPI-3)

Halfbacks

• Ron Burton, Northwestern (AP-1; UPI-1)
• Willie Fleming, Iowa (AP-1; UPI-3)
• Don Clark, Ohio State (AP-2; UPI-1)
• Dean Look, Michigan State (AP-3; UPI-2)
• Bob Ptacek, Michigan (UPI-2)
• Ray Jauch, Iowa (AP-2; UPI-3)
• Ted Smith, Indiana (AP-3)

Fullbacks

• Bob White, Ohio State (AP-1; UPI-1)
• Bob Jarus, Purdue (AP-2; UPI-2)
• Don Horn, Iowa (UPI-3)
• John Hobbs, Wisconsin (AP-3)

Ends

• Rich Kreitling, Illinois (AP-1; UPI-1)
• Jim Houston, Ohio State (AP-1; UPI-2)
• Sam Williams, Michigan State (AP-2; UPI-1)
• Tom Franckhauser, Purdue (AP-2; UPI-2)
• Curt Merz, Iowa (AP-3; UPI-3)
• Gary Prahst, Michigan (UPI-3)
• Dave Kocourek, Wisconsin (UPI-3)

Tackles

• Gene Selawski, Purdue (AP-1; UPI-1)
• Andy Cvercko, Northwestern (AP-1; UPI-3)
• Jim Marshall, Ohio State (AP-2; UPI-1)
• Jim Heineke, Wisconsin (AP-2; UPI-2)
• Dan Lanphear, Wisconsin (UPI-2)
• John Burroughs, Iowa (UPI-3)
• Gene Gossage, Northwestern (AP-3)
• George Genyk, Michigan (AP-3)

Guards

• Ron Maltony, Purdue (AP-1; UPI-2)
• Jerry Stalcup, Wisconsin (AP-1; UPI-2)
• Bill Burrell, Illinois (AP-2; UPI-1)
• Ellison Kelly, Michigan State (UPI-1)
• Gary Grouwinkel, Iowa (AP-3; UPI-3)
• Mike Rabold, Indiana (AP-2; UPI-3)
• Bill Kerr, Indiana (AP-3)

Centers

• Dick Teteak, Wisconsin (AP-1; UPI-3)
• Mike Svendsen, Minnesota (AP-2; UPI-1)
• Jim Andreotti, Northwestern (AP-3; UPI-2)

Key

AP = Associated Press^[1]

UPI = United Press International, selected by the conference coaches^[2]

Bold = Consensus first-team selection of both the AP and UPI