The 1967 Little All-America college football team is composed of college football players from small colleges and universities who were selected by the Associated Press (AP) as the best players at each position. For 1967, the AP selected two teams, each team having separate offensive and defensive platoons.^[1]

First team

Offense

• Quarterback - Charles McKee (senior, 6'1", 190 pounds), Lawrence
• Halfback - Don Hass (senior, 5'11", 196 pounds), Montana State
• Halfback - Carl Garrett (junior, 6'0", 215 pounds), New Mexico Highlands
• Fullback - Lee White (senior, 6'4", 232 pounds), Weber
• End - Haven Moses (senior, 6'3", 196 pounds), San Diego State
• End - DeWayne Nix (junior, 5'11", 180 pounds), Texas A&I
• Tackle - Eddie Joyner (senior, 6'1", 227 pounds), Lenoir-Rhyne
• Tackle - John Gloisten (senior, 6'5", 220 pounds), Wagner
• Guard - Spergon Wynn (senior, 6'3", 198 pounds), Lamar Tech
• Guard - Leland Hughes (senior, 6'2", 245 pounds), Delta State
• Center - Victor Bender (senior, 6'2", 230 pounds), Northeast Louisiana

Defense

• Defensive end - William Hanna (senior, 6'2", 220 pounds), Northern Arizona
• Defensive end - Jeff Queen (senior, 6'1", 230 pounds), Morgan State
• Defensive tackle - Claude Humphrey (senior, 6'5", 253 pounds), Tennessee A&I
• Defensive tackle - Dave Williams (senior, 6'0", 212 pounds), Fairmont (West Virginia)
• Middle guard - Ray Pedersen (senior, 6'3", 218 pounds), Northern Iowa
• Linebacker - Robert Beers (junior, 5'9", 220 pounds), Montana
• Linebacker - Dave Fagusa (senior, 6'2", 195 pounds), Rochester
• Linebacker - Richard Jaeger (senior, 6'3", 230 pounds), Gustavus Adolphus
• Halfback - Major Hazelton (senior, 6'1", 190 pounds), Florida A&M
• Halfback - Steve Dockery (senior, 5'11", 175 pounds), Maryville (Tennessee)
• Safety - Robert Willbanks (senior, 6'1", 184 pounds), Arlington State

Second team

Offense

• Quarterback - Bob Toledo, San Francisco State
• Halfback - Doug VanBoven, Central (Iowa)
• Halfback - Lennie Holton, Northern Michigan
• Fullback - Richard Moore, Western Kentucky
• End - Aaron Marsh, Eastern Kentucky
• End - Henry McKay, Guilford
• Tackle - Mike Donovan, Northeastern
• Tackle - Bob Deim, Arlington State (Texas)
• Guard - Tom Funches, Jacksonville State
• Guard - Willie Banks, Alcorn
• Center - James Lietzki, Mankato State

Defense

• Defensive end - Alfred Beauchamp, Southern
• Defensive end - Joe Hornak, Waynesburg
• Defensive tackle - Marvin Upshaw, Trinity (Texas)
• Defensive tackle - Art Shell, Maryland State
• Middle guard - Mike Tomasini, Colorado State
• Linebacker - Gary Jones, Whitman
• Linebacker - Herbert Cooper, Wesleyan
• Halfback - Mac Sauls, Southwest Texas
• Halfback - Lou Ciccone, Glassboro
• Safety - Mike Johnston, Alfred