The episode was written by Jeff Martin and directed by Rich Moore.
Jon Lovitz made his fourth guest appearance on The Simpsons, this time as musical director Llewellyn Sinclair, as well as Llewellyn's sister, who runs the Ayn Rand School for Tots. The episode generated controversy for its original song about New Orleans, which contains several unflattering lyrics about the city. One New Orleans newspaper published the lyrics before the episode aired, prompting numerous complaints to the local Fox affiliate; in response, the president of Fox Broadcasting issued an apology to anyone who was offended. In the chalkboard gag of the next episode, "Homer the Heretic", Bart writes "I will not defame New Orleans."[3]
Despite the controversial song, the episode was well received by many fans, and show creator Matt Groening has named it one of his favorite episodes.
Plot
Marge announces to the Simpson family that she intends to audition for the role of Blanche DuBois in Oh! Streetcar!, a local musical production of A Streetcar Named Desire. The family ignores her, and she leaves for her audition, feeling especially unappreciated by Homer. The director, Llewellyn Sinclair, immediately rejects Marge, explaining that Blanche is supposed to be a "delicate flower being trampled by an uncouth lout". However, as a dejected Marge calls home and takes Homer's dinner order, Llewellyn realizes that she is perfect for the role.
At Llewellyn's suggestion, Marge enrolls Maggie at the Ayn Rand School for Tots, a daycare centre run by Llewellyn's sister, Ms. Sinclair. Ms. Sinclair immediately confiscates Maggie’s pacifier. Aided by the other toddlers at the daycare, Maggie manages to get her pacifier back, and redistributes all the other toddlers' confiscated pacifiers.
Marge and Ned, who is playing Stanley Kowalski, rehearse the scene in which Blanche breaks a glass bottle and attacks Stanley, which Marge has been struggling with. Homer repeatedly interrupts the rehearsal. Imagining that Stanley is Homer, Marge takes out her frustration--she smashes the bottle and lunges at Ned, injuring him.
The Simpson family attends the musical, and Homer is moved by Marge's performance, though during the curtain call Marge mistakes his sadness for boredom. After the show, Homer tells her that he was saddened by Blanche's plight as a woman in need of compassion but who receives only neglect and mistreatment from men like Stanley. Marge is moved by Homer's sincerity and impressed that he understood the musical so well, and the two happily leave the theater.
Production
Writing and music
Producer James L. Brooks pitched the idea of Marge playing Blanche DuBois.
"A Streetcar Named Marge" was conceived about two years before it aired on television.[4] Jeff Martin first pitched the idea of Homer being in a theatrical production of 1776; producer James L. Brooks then suggested that Marge could play Blanche DuBois in A Streetcar Named Desire. Brooks saw that Marge's relationship with Homer was similar to Blanche's relationship with Stanley, and he wanted to use that fact to build the emotional arc for an episode. The estate of Tennessee Williams would not let the show use large excerpts from the actual play, since the work was copyrighted.[4] However, Fox lawyer Anatole Klebanow said that original songs based on the play were acceptable. According to producer Mike Reiss, Klebanow even promised to "take [their] case to the Supreme Court to get [the] episode aired."[5] Martin later explained that while the songs made the episode funnier, they also made it harder to write.[4]
The Maggie subplot was present in Martin's episode pitch.[6] The music in the sequence is Elmer Bernstein's march theme from The Great Escape. Simpsons composer Alf Clausen secured the rights to the score, along with the original orchestra charts. The Great Escape had been Martin's favorite film as a child, and he said "it was so exciting and so stirring" to hear the music being performed by the Simpsons' studio orchestra.[4]
Animation
"A Streetcar Named Marge" posed a challenge to the show's animation directors. The episode contains many long set pieces, especially during the third and final act, which includes the end of the Maggie subplot and the performance of the musical.[4] Several scenes required the animators to draw dozens of background characters.[7]Rich Moore, the head director, initially feared the episode would not be completed in time.[6]David Silverman, the supervising director, also had doubts;[6] according to Martin, Silverman sent back a cartoon of himself reading the script with his eyes popping out, and his jaw dropped.[4] Producer Al Jean said that Moore "worked himself to death" to produce the episode's most elaborate sequences.[6]
A number of scenes that appeared in the storyboard and animatic were reordered or dropped altogether in the final version of the episode. Much of the Maggie subplot, for example, was modified before the episode aired. A scene in which the babies lock Ms. Sinclair in her office is missing from the final version of the episode.[8]
This was the last episode of the series to be animated by Klasky Csupo.
Alfred Hitchcock walking his dogs, a reference to his cameo in The Birds
Though Oh! Streetcar! is based on A Streetcar Named Desire, the title of the musical alludes to the theatrical revueOh! Calcutta! Besides Blanche and Stanley, characters from A Streetcar Named Desire who appear in Oh! Streetcar! include Stella (played by Helen Lovejoy), the Young Collector (played by Apu Nahasapeemapetilon), Mitch (played by Lionel Hutz), the Doctor (played by Chief Wiggum), Steve (played by Jasper Beardley, although Apu originally said he was playing Steve), and Pablo (originally played by Otto Mann but taken over by Llewellyn prior to curtain). The musical's closing song, "Kindness of Strangers", is a reference to Blanche's last line in the original play: "I have always depended on the kindness of strangers." However, the song is very cheery in tone, intentionally missing the point of Blanche's line, which is meant by Tennessee Williams to be ironic.[4]
At the beginning of the episode, the beauty pageant contestants sing Janis Ian 's "At Seventeen" a song which is, ironically, a critique of beauty pageants.[10] Maggie plays "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy" on a toy xylophone but Homer asks her to stop. The Maggie subplot uses the musical score of The Great Escape and contains several other allusions to the film. At one point, Ms. Sinclair punishes Maggie by sending her to a playpen called "the box", a play on the solitary confinement facility called "the cooler" from the 1963 film. Maggie even bounces a ball against the wall of the playpen, as Steve McQueen's character Virgil Hilts does throughout the film while he is in confinement.[2]
The episode contains multiple references to Ayn Rand's novels and Objectivist philosophy. Maggie's daycare center is the "Ayn Rand School for Tots", and Ms. Sinclair can be seen reading a book called The Fountainhead Diet, a reference to Rand's novel The Fountainhead. On the wall of the daycare is a poster that reads "Helping Is Futile", an allusion to Rand's rejection of the ethical doctrine of altruism. Another wall sign reads "A Is A", the law of identity, which plays a central role in Rand's novel Atlas Shrugged.[11] The Ayn Rand School for Tots is seen again in the 2012 short film "The Longest Daycare".[12]
In the scene when Homer, Bart and Lisa pick up Maggie from the daycare center, babies are perched all over the building, staring at the family and quietly sucking on pacifiers. This is a parody of the final shot of Alfred Hitchcock's The Birds.[13]: 11:05-11:07 Indeed, a cartoon-version of Hitchcock can be seen walking his dogs past the daycare, a reference to his own cameo appearance in the film.[5] The episode also contains an allusion to Joseph Cotten in the opera scene in Citizen Kane, in which Homer plays with a shredded playbill while he watches his wife in the musical.[2][13]: 12:25-12:29
The Simpsons creator Matt Groening includes the episode among his favorites.
In its original broadcast, "A Streetcar Named Marge" finished 32nd in ratings for the week of September 27 – October 4, 1992, with a Nielsen rating of 11.8, equivalent to approximately 11.0 million viewing households. It was the second highest-rated show on the Fox network that week, following Married... with Children.[18]
Since airing, it has received very positive reviews from fans and television critics. Michael Moran of The Times ranked the episode as the seventh best in the show's history.[19]Entertainment Weekly's Dalton Ross lauded it as "the show's best ever musical episode",[20] while Dave Kehr of The New York Times called it a "brilliant ... parody of Broadway musicals that should be required viewing for every Tony voter."[21] In a list of his favorite episodes, Kevin Williamson of Canadian Online Explorer added, "As pitch-perfect eviscerations of community theatre go, this tops Waiting for Guffman."[22] In 2019, Consequence ranked it number four on its list of top 30 Simpsons episodes.[23]
Series creator Matt Groening has listed it as one of his own favorites, calling the subplot "Maggie's finest moment",[24] and future Simpsons guest star Trey Anastasio said the episode "may have been the best TV show ever".[25] Executive producer James L. Brooks also listed it as one of his favorites, saying it "showed we could go into areas no one thought we could go into".[26] Following the episode, the Ayn Rand Society called Groening to say they were amazed at the references to Rand. They also asked him if the show was making fun of them.[7]
In 1993, "A Streetcar Named Marge" and "Mr. Plow" were submitted for the Primetime Emmy Award for "Outstanding Comedy Series". Before this season, the series had only been allowed to compete in the "Outstanding Animated Program" category, winning twice, but in early 1993 the rules were changed so that animated television shows would be able to submit nominations for "Outstanding Comedy Series".[27] However, the Emmy voters were hesitant to pit cartoons against live action programs, and The Simpsons did not receive a nomination. The Simpsons' crew submitted episodes for Outstanding Comedy Series the next season, but again these were not nominated.[28] Since then, the show has submitted episodes in the animation category and has won seven times.[29]
Controversy
Writer Jeff Martin (pictured here in 1994) received criticism for satirizing New Orleans
The musical within the episode includes a controversial song depicting the New Orleans which existed during the period in time A Streetcar Named Desire was set in, referring to the city as a "home of pirates, drunks and whores", among other things. Jeff Martin, the writer of the episode, intended for the song to be a parody of a song in Sweeney Todd, which speaks of Victorian Era London in unflattering terms ("There's No Place Like London"). Martin said: "The whole story of it is just me imitating Stephen Sondheim."[30] Al Jean later explained that two Cajun characters were supposed to walk out of the theater in disgust, but none of the voice actors could provide a convincing Cajun accent.[31] An early version of the scene can be seen in an animatic included in the DVD boxset.[32][13]: 12:15-12:24
Before the premiere of the fourth season, the producers sent two episodes to critics: "Kamp Krusty" and "A Streetcar Named Marge".[6] A New Orleans critic viewed "A Streetcar Named Marge" and published the song lyrics in his newspaper before the episode aired.[31] Many readers took the lyrics out of context, and New Orleans' then-Fox affiliate, WNOL-TV (then-owned by musician Quincy Jones; the Fox affiliation for the area later moved to WVUE), received about 150 to 200 calls on the day the episode aired. The station manager noted that not all the calls they received were complaints, stating, "Half of them were very negative and half of them were very positive. Quite a few of them actually agreed with the lyrics."[33] Several local radio stations also held on-air protests in response to the song.[34]
At the urging of WNOL, Fox president Jamie Kellner released a statement on October 1, 1992:
It has come to our attention that a comedic song about New Orleans in tonight's episode of "The Simpsons" has offended some city residents and officials. Viewers who watch the episode will realize that the song is in fact a parody of the opening numbers of countless Broadway musicals, which are designed to set the stage for the story that follows. That is the only purpose of this song. We regret that the song, taken out of context, has caused offense. This was certainly not the intention of "The Simpsons" production staff or Fox Broadcasting Company.[35]
The Simpsons' producers rushed out a chalkboard gag for "Homer the Heretic", which aired a week after "A Streetcar Named Marge". It reads, "I will not defame New Orleans." The gag was their attempt to apologize for the song and hopefully bring the controversy to an end.[30] "We didn't realize people would get so mad", said Al Jean. "It was the best apology we could come up with in eight words or less."[36] The issue passed quickly, and a person in a Bart Simpson costume even served as Krewe of Tucks Grand Marshal at the 1993 New Orleans Mardi Gras.[37]
The episode generated further controversy in September 2005, when Channel 4 in the United Kingdom decided to air the episode a week after Hurricane Katrina struck New Orleans. Arguing that the episode was an insensitive choice, given recent events, several viewers filed complaints with Ofcom. Two days later, Channel 4 apologized on-air and directly contacted all those who had complained. Channel 4 had screened the episode for offensive content, but the reviews focused on the main content of the episode, and the song was not considered a key part of the plot. Channel 4 promised to update their review process to ensure that similar incidents would not occur.[38]
^Jean, Al (2004). The Simpsons Season 4 DVD commentary for the episode "Homer the Heretic" (DVD). 20th Century Fox.
^ abcdefgMartin, Jeff. (2004). Commentary for "A Streetcar Named Marge", in The Simpsons: The Complete Fourth Season [DVD]. 20th Century Fox.
^ abReiss, Mike. (2004). Commentary for "A Streetcar Named Marge", in The Simpsons: The Complete Fourth Season [DVD]. 20th Century Fox.
^ abcdeJean, Al. (2004). Commentary for "A Streetcar Named Marge", in The Simpsons: The Complete Fourth Season [DVD]. 20th Century Fox.
^ abGroening, Matt. (2004). Commentary for "A Streetcar Named Marge", in The Simpsons: The Complete Fourth Season [DVD]. 20th Century Fox.
^Moore, Rich. (2004). Commentary for "A Streetcar Named Marge", in The Simpsons: The Complete Fourth Season [DVD]. 20th Century Fox.
^Goldman, Eric; Iverson, Dan; Zoromski, Brian (January 4, 2010). "Top 25 Simpsons Guest Appearances". IGN. Archived from the original on March 6, 2007. Retrieved January 15, 2022.
^ abcRich Moore and David Silverman (2004). "Art & Animation: A Streetcar Named Marge: Animatic with Illustrated Commentary". The Simpsons: The Complete Fourth Season: Disk 1 (DVD) (Collector's ed.). OCLC55034037.
^Justin, Neil (May 20, 2007). "Insiders name their favorite episodes". Star Tribune. p. 10F.
^Holloway, Diane (February 2, 1993). "'Simpsons' get Emmy 's respect — Academy lets series drop cartoon status to compete as sitcom". Austin American-Statesman. p. B4.
^Jean, Al (2004). The Simpsons season 4 DVD commentary for the episode "Mr. Plow" (DVD). 20th Century Fox.
