This is a list of All-American Girls Professional Baseball League players who posted the best fielding averages in the history of the circuit.
The career fielding records are based on players who appeared in a minimum of six seasons. The regular season fielding records are based on pitchers throwing in at least 20 games and position players appearing in at least 50 games.
| Position | Player | Record | Seasons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Maxine Kline | .972 | 1948-1954 |
| Catcher | Ruth Lessing | .973 | 1944-1949 |
| First base | Margaret Danhauser Dorothy Kamenshek Betty Whiting |
.982 | 1943-1950 1943–1951, 1953 1944-1952 |
| Second base | Sophie Kurys | .957 | 1943-1952 |
| Third base | Fern Shollenberger | .942 | 1946-1954 |
| Shortstop | Lavonne Paire | .945 | 1944-1953 |
| Outfield | Doris Satterfield | .971 | 1947-1954 |
| Position | Player | Record | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pitcher | Lillian Faralla Maxine Kline Jean Marlowe Mary Reynolds Elaine Roth Nancy Warren |
1.000 | 1951 1953 1952 1950 1953 1954 |
| Catcher | Mary Rountree | .986 | 1952 |
| First base | Dorothy Kamenshek | .995 | 1949 |
| Second base | Sophie Kurys | .973 | 1946 |
| Third base | Ernestine Petras | .965 | 1952 |
| Shortstop | Alva Jo Fischer | .972 | 1949 |
| Outfield | Betty Wagoner | 1.000 | 1948 |