This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: "Alpha roll" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (October 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) This article's factual accuracy is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help to ensure that disputed statements are reliably sourced. (November 2008) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)

The alpha roll is a dog training technique that is considered outdated by many modern-day dog trainers. The theory behind the training method is that dogs are hierarchical animals. The technique is used to teach the dog that the trainer or owner of the dog is the pack leader (alpha animal). Methods include when a dog misbehaves to pin the dog on its back and held in that position, sometimes by the throat.

History

The alpha roll was first popularized by the Monks of New Skete, in the 1978 book How To Be Your Dog's Best Friend.[1] However, in the 2002 second edition of the book, the monks recanted and strongly discouraged the technique, describing it as "too risky and demanding for the average dog owner."[2] Although the 1978 book is widely regarded as a classic in dog training literature and highly recommended for people trying to better understand their dog, the alpha roll is now highly controversial among animal behaviorists because the theory of canine dominance has since been disproved. In the original context, the alpha roll was meant to be used only in the most serious cases.[3]

The theory behind the alpha roll is based on a research study of captive wolves kept in an area too small for their numbers and composed of members that would not be found together in a wild pack. These conditions resulted in increased numbers of conflicts that scientists today know are not typical of wolves living in the wild.[4] Behaviors seen in wolves (specifically the alpha roll) living in atypical social groups and crowded conditions do not translate to domestic dog training, especially because using the technique can be harmful to both the handler and the dog.[5]

Effects

It has been argued by some that a dog will only forcibly flip another onto its back during a serious fight where the intent may be to kill the opponent.[6]

The name "alpha roll" is considered to be a misnomer by some wolf researchers because the practice when used as a behavioral correction bears little relation to the natural behavior shown by wild wolves. David Mech refers to this behavior as "pinning", a dominance behavior.[7]

While "alpha rolling" can appear to be effective in the short term, there are serious questions about the safety of implementing this technique, as well as potential long-term negative behavioral effects of doing so.[8]

Contemporary use

The use of the alpha roll is currently viewed unfavorably by the positive reinforcement training community as an outdated technique.[9] In addition, the same scientist, David Mech, who pioneered the theory of "alpha" behavior has since debunked his own theory.[10]

Position statements on dominance released by AVSAB[3] question the science behind training techniques that rely on dominance theory. They recommend the alpha roll should never be used by inexperienced trainers, and never to correct undesired behavior caused by the dog's failure to understand a command. Used in a controlled way and coupled with praise and rewards when the dog changes its behavior appropriately, it may have positive effect in the short-term, but there is disagreement about its long-term effectiveness and safety. A 2009 study by the University of Bristol's Department of Clinical Veterinary Sciences showed that methods of handling that relied on dominance theory actually provoked aggressive behavior in dogs with no previous known history of aggression. The study also examined the development of hierarchy in domestic dogs and found that no definitive hierarchical structure developed within the group, leading study authors to question the alpha role in this group.[11]

Nevertheless, there are some modern-day dog trainers and animal researchers who have argued that the alpha roll is valid because dominance does exist in dogs and to deny it is motivated by political correctness.[12] American Adjunct Professor of Zoology Patricia McConnell who is an expert in animal behaviour, wrote in her book The Other End of the Leash, “In some training and behavioural circles, all talk of dominance is classed as politically incorrect, and that these people are ardently opposed to anyone using the word in the context of dogs”.[13] Portuguese animal behaviourist Roger Abrantes argues the reasons that many people have difficulty comprehending the theory of dominance are because the term is poorly defined and political correctness.[14] Colin Tennant, who is the chairman of the Canine and Feline Behaviour Association, said “It is political correctness. If you treat a dog like a human it will treat you like a dog”.[12] Psychologist and dog trainer Stanley Coren in the 2001 book How to Speak Dog wrote, "You are the alpha dog... You must communicate that you are the pack leader and dominant".[15] Mexican-American dog trainer Cesar Millan argues that “Dogs are social pack animals with a leader and followers”.[16]

References

  1. ^ The Monks of New Skete (1978). How To Be Your Dog's Best Friend. Little, Brown & Company. ISBN 0-316-60491-7.
  2. ^ The Monks of New Skete (2002). How To Be Your Dog's Best Friend (2 ed.). Little, Brown & Company. ISBN 0-316-61000-3. In the original edition of this book, we recommended a technique we termed "the alpha-wolf rollover"...We no longer recommend this technique and strongly discourage its use to our clients.... The conditions in which it might be used effectively are simply too risky and demanding for the average dog owner; there are other ways of dealing with problem behavior that are much safer and, in the long run, just as effective.
  3. ^ a b American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior. "Position statement on the use of dominance theory in behavior modification of Animals" (PDF). American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior. Archived from the original on 16 December 2011. Retrieved 2 July 2016.
  4. ^ Adam Miklosi (2007). Dog Behavior, Evolution and Cognition. Oxford University Press. pp. 83–93. ISBN 978-0-19-295852-5.
  5. ^ Yin, S. "New study finds popular "Alpha Dog" training techniques can cause more harm than good". Archived from the original on 15 August 2011. Retrieved 5 May 2011.
  6. ^ Wilde, N. (2001). "Leadership vs. Dominance". Retrieved 8 October 2007.
  7. ^ Mech, L.D. (1999). "Alpha status, dominance, and division of labor in wolf packs". Canadian Journal of Zoology. 77 (8): 1196–1203. doi:10.1139/z99-099.
  8. ^ "New Study Finds Popular "Alpha Dog" Training Techniques Can Cause More Harm than Good". Dr. Sophia Yin. 9 March 2009. Retrieved 22 February 2019.
  9. ^ Cameron, Ross (27 September 2016). "Guys, We Need to Talk About Behaviorists". CCPDT. Archived from the original on 23 February 2019. Retrieved 22 February 2019.
  10. ^ eduweb (15 February 2008), "Alpha" Wolf?, archived from the original on 21 December 2021, retrieved 22 February 2019
  11. ^ Bradshaw, John W.S.; Blackwell, Emily J.; Casey, Rachel A. (2009). "Dominance in domestic dogs—useful construct or bad habit?". Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research. 4 (3): 135–144. doi:10.1016/j.jveb.2008.08.004.
  12. ^ a b Chittenden, Maurice (8 August 2010). "Pet trainers tussle over whose method is top dog". The Times.(subscription required)
  13. ^ "DOGS AND DOMINANT BEHAVIOUR". Dog Listener. 1 July 2012.
  14. ^ "Roger Abrantes On Dominance".
  15. ^ Coren, Stanley (2001). "20". How to Speak Dog (First Fireside ed.). Simon & Schuster. p. 250. ISBN 0-684-86534-3.
  16. ^ "How to Tell Which Dog is Alpha: Dog Pack Hierarchy". 24 August 2020.
Categories