Arnold tongues are observed in a large variety of natural phenomena that involve oscillating quantities, such as concentration of enzymes and substrates in biological processes and cardiac electric waves. Sometimes the frequency of oscillation depends on, or is constrained (i.e., phase-locked or mode-locked, in some contexts) based on some quantity, and it is often of interest to study this relation. For instance, the outset of a tumor triggers in the area a series of substance (mainly proteins) oscillations that interact with each other; simulations show that these interactions cause Arnold tongues to appear, that is, the frequency of some oscillations constrain the others, and this can be used to control tumor growth.
One of the simplest physical models that exhibits mode-locking consists of two rotating disks connected by a weak spring. One disk is allowed to spin freely, and the other is driven by a motor. Mode locking occurs when the freely-spinning disk turns at a frequency that is a rational multiple of that of the driven rotator.
The simplest mathematical model that exhibits mode-locking is the circle map, which attempts to capture the motion of the spinning disks at discrete time intervals.
Standard circle map
Arnold tongues appear most frequently when studying the interaction between oscillators, particularly in the case where one oscillator drives another. That is, one oscillator depends on the other but not the other way around, so they do not mutually influence each other as happens in Kuramoto models, for example. This is a particular case of driven oscillators, with a driving force that has a periodic behaviour. As a practical example, heart cells (the external oscillator) produce periodic electric signals to stimulate heart contractions (the driven oscillator); here, it could be useful to determine the relation between the frequency of the oscillators, possibly to design better artificial pacemakers. The family of circle maps serves as a useful mathematical model for this biological phenomenon, as well as many others.
The family of circle maps are functions (or endomorphisms) of the circle to itself. It is mathematically simpler to consider a point in the circle as being a point in the real line that should be interpreted modulo, representing the angle at which the point is located in the circle. When the modulo is taken with a value other than , the result still represents an angle, but must be normalized so that the whole range can be represented. With this in mind, the family of circle maps is given by:
where is the oscillator's "natural" frequency and is a periodic function that yields the influence caused by the external oscillator. Note that if for all the particle simply walks around the circle at units at a time; in particular, if is irrational the map reduces to an irrational rotation.
The particular circle map originally studied by Arnold, and which continues to prove useful even nowadays, is:
Another way to view the circle map is as follows. Consider a function that decreases linearly with slope . Once it reaches zero, its value is reset to a certain oscillating value, described by a function . We are now interested in the sequence of times at which y(t) reaches zero.
This model tells us that at time it is valid that . From this point, will then decrease linearly until , where the function is zero, thus yielding:
and by choosing and we obtain the circle map discussed previously:
Glass, L. (2001) argues that this simple model is applicable to some biological systems, such as regulation of substance concentration in cells or blood, with above representing the concentration of a certain substance.
In this model, a phase-locking of would mean that is reset exactly times every periods of the sinusoidal . The rotation number, in turn, would be the quotient .
Consider the general family of circle endomorphisms:
where, for the standard circle map, we have that . Sometimes it will also be convenient to represent the circle map in terms of a mapping :
We now proceed to listing some interesting properties of these circle endomorphisms.
P1. is monotonically increasing for , so for these values of the iterates only move forward in the circle, never backwards. To see this, note that the derivative of is:
which is positive as long as .
P2. When expanding the recurrence relation, one obtains a formula for :
P3. Suppose that , so they are periodic fixed points of period . Since the sine oscillates at frequency 1 Hz, the number of oscillations of the sine per cycle of will be , thus characterizing a phase-locking of .
P4. For any , it is true that , which in turn means that . Because of this, for many purposes it does not matter if the iterates are taken modulus or not.
P5 (translational symmetry). Suppose that for a given there is a phase-locking in the system. Then, for with integer , there would be a phase-locking. This also means that if is a periodic orbit for parameter , then it is also a periodic orbit for any .
To see this, note that the recurrence relation in property 2 would become:
so since due to the original phase-locking, now we would have .
P6. For there will be phase-locking whenever is a rational. Moreover, let , then the phase-locking is .
Considering the recurrence relation in property 2, a rational implies:
and equality modulus will hold only when is an integer, and the first that satisfies this is . Consequently:
meaning a phase-locking.
For irrational (which leads to an irrational rotation), it would be necessary to have for integers and , but then and is rational, which contradicts the initial hypothesis.
For small to intermediate values of K (that is, in the range of K = 0 to about K = 1), and certain values of Ω, the map exhibits a phenomenon called mode locking or phase locking. In a phase-locked region, the values θn advance essentially as a rational multiple of n, although they may do so chaotically on the small scale.
The limiting behavior in the mode-locked regions is given by the rotation number.
The phase-locked regions, or Arnold tongues, are illustrated in yellow in the figure to the right. Each such V-shaped region touches down to a rational value Ω = p/q in the limit of K → 0. The values of (K,Ω) in one of these regions will all result in a motion such that the rotation number ω = p/q. For example, all values of (K,Ω) in the large V-shaped region in the bottom-center of the figure correspond to a rotation number of ω = 1/2. One reason the term "locking" is used is that the individual values θn can be perturbed by rather large random disturbances (up to the width of the tongue, for a given value of K), without disturbing the limiting rotation number. That is, the sequence stays "locked on" to the signal, despite the addition of significant noise to the series θn. This ability to "lock on" in the presence of noise is central to the utility of the phase-locked loop electronic circuit.
There is a mode-locked region for every rational number p/q. It is sometimes said that the circle map maps the rationals, a set of measure zero at K = 0, to a set of non-zero measure for K ≠ 0. The largest tongues, ordered by size, occur at the Farey fractions. Fixing K and taking a cross-section through this image, so that ω is plotted as a function of Ω, gives the "Devil's staircase", a shape that is generically similar to the Cantor function.
One can show that for K<1, the circle map is a diffeomorphism, there exist only one stable solution. However as K>1 this holds no longer, and one can find regions of two overlapping locking regions. For the circle map it can be shown that in this region, no more than two stable mode locking regions can overlap, but if there is any limit to the number of overlapping Arnold tongues for general synchronised systems is not known.
The circle map also exhibits subharmonic routes to chaos, that is, period doubling of the form 3, 6, 12, 24,....
Chirikov standard map
The Chirikov standard map is related to the circle map, having similar recurrence relations, which may be written as
with both iterates taken modulo 1. In essence, the standard map introduces a momentum pn which is allowed to dynamically vary, rather than being forced fixed, as it is in the circle map. The standard map is studied in physics by means of the kicked rotorHamiltonian.
^Nakao, M.; Enkhkhudulmur, T.E.; Katayama, N.; Karashima, A. (2014). Entrainability of cell cycle oscillator models with exponential growth of cell mass. Conference of Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society. IEEE. pp. 6826–6829.
^Guevara, M.R.; Glass, L. (1982). "Phase locking, period doubling bifurcations and chaos in a mathematical model of a periodically driven oscillator: A theory for the entrainment of biological oscillators and the generation of cardiac dysrhythmias". Journal of Mathematical Biology. 14 (1): 1–23. doi:10.1007/BF02154750. PMID7077182. S2CID2273911.