This article may contain an excessive number of citations. Please help remove low-quality or irrelevant citations. (June 2017) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Canadian Association for Equality
AbbreviationCAFE
FounderJustin Trottier
TypeRegistered Educational Charity
PurposePublic education and outreach
HeadquartersCanadian Centre for Men and Families (Toronto)
Official language
English
Key people
James Brown (President)

The Canadian Association for Equality (CAFE) is a Canadian non-profit organization. CAFE has frequently been characterized as a men's rights group by sources,[1][2][3][4] though the organization denies this.[5] In March 2014 the Canadian Association for Equality was granted charitable status by the Canada Revenue Agency, making it the first charity focused on men's issues.[6]

CAFE is sometimes portrayed as a moderate and academic voice,[7] particularly by members of men's movement, such as author Warren Farrell,[8] though media reports have characterized the group as controversial,[2][9][10] and various feminist, student, and anti-domestic violence groups associate CAFE with more radical men's rights organizations such as A Voice for Men.[1][11] CAFE spokesperson Justin Trottier has denied these allegations.[12]

CAFE hosts a regular series of speakers and talks, featuring speakers such Warren Farrell, University of Ottawa English Professor Janice Fiamengo, and McGill Professors Katherine K. Young and Paul Nathanson. Other events have included a presentation by York University Sociologist Dr. Robert Kenedy on the new discipline of male studies, a talk by National Post columnist Barbara Kay on family courts and fatherhood, and a talk by prostate cancer survivor Aaron Bacher on men's health.[13][14] The group has also hosted anthropologist Lionel Tiger.[13]

History

Campus activities

CAFE became the focus of mainstream media attention when they hosted controversial author and masculinist Warren Farrell to speak at the University of Toronto on November 16, 2012. The talk was met with protests from a coalition of activist groups, U of T Students United Against Sexism. The protesters accused Farrell and CAFE of "misogyny, and of protecting and denying male privilege."[15][16] The event attracted a group of about 50-100 protesters who argued that Farrell's talk was hate speech and chanted "No Hate Speech on Campus" throughout the demonstration. The event was briefly delayed after protesters blocked access to the venue, before police intervened, allowing the event to proceed.[15][16] Police and campus police who were stationed at the event arrested one protester before releasing them without charge, while another was cautioned for assaulting a police officer.[16] After the protest, several of the women who had protested against Farrell's talk were subjected to online bullying and harassment, after their pictures, names, and other identifying information were posted on the website register-her.com, which was operated by American men's rights group A Voice for Men.[9][17][18]

Follow up events in CAFE's monthly lecture series were also marked by significant protest, and required a police or campus police presence. These events included a presentation by Professor Janice Fiamengo titled "What's Wrong with Women's Studies,"[19] and a panel discussion by McGill academics Professors Katherine K. Young and Paul Nathanson, authors of Spreading Misandry: The Teaching of Contempt for Men in Popular Culture. After protests at a CAFE event in April 2012, A Voice for Men uploaded a video of one of the protesters. The video quickly reached more than 100,000 views online, while hundreds of men's rights activists posted comments threatening to beat, rape, and murder the woman in the video. The woman told Maclean's that men's rights activists distributed her home address and personal information online, and sent her hundreds of graphic, and sexualized threats of violence - some of which included personal details such as her favourite bars and her dog's name.[20]

CAFE has faced resistance from student's unions and other activist groups in attempting to set up campus chapters. The University of Toronto Student Union rejected an application for ratification from the University of Toronto Men's Issues Awareness Society in 2012, and in March 2013 the Ryerson Students' Union (RSU) rejected the application for ratification from the Ryerson Equality Association for failing to "centre women's voices." The Ryerson group was led by two female students.[21][22] In the week prior to rejecting the group, the RSU had passed an emergency motion to oppose "the concept of misandry," a position they then referenced to justify the group's prohibition.[23] In January 2014 the Canadian Association for Equality announced it would sponsor events at Ryerson hosted by members of the University community, starting with a presentation by female men's activist Karen Straughan in February 2014.

By 2016, CAFE was affiliated with 15 men's issues campus groups across Canadian universities.[24] The group frequently sponsors events hosted by the University of Toronto Men's Issues Awareness Society."[25] In November 2015, the Ryerson University Men's Issues Awareness Society was denied certification.[24][26]

Charity application

In March 2014 the Canadian Association for Equality was granted charitable status by the Canada Revenue Agency. In its application for charitable status, the group listed organizations such as the Women's Legal Education and Action Fund, Egale Canada and the Status of Women Canada as potential participants in panel discussions and other CAFE events. When informed that they had been listed as potential participants in CAFE events on the application, however, LEAF charged CAFE with being "very disingenuous" with their application, noting that "we absolutely are not associated with this group and what they stand for," while an Egale Canada spokesman made it clear that "Egale is not affiliated or associated with [CAFE] in any way." Queens University Professor Sarita Srivastava was "stunned" to learn that CAFE had claimed to be "currently" setting up a panel discussion with her on their charitable status form, noting that she had declined to participate in such a discussion months earlier. Several individuals and organizations listed on the application suggested that CAFE had a "problem with their reputation" and had invited listed feminist individuals and groups on the application "to counter criticism that they are anti-feminist and one-sided."[27]

Equality Day Concert

In May 2014, CAFE organized an Equality Day concert in support of men's parental rights and Conservative MP Maurice Vellacot's Bill C-560, "An Act to amend the Divorce Act (equal parenting)," which was defeated on May 28. The event was scheduled to take place at Artscape Gibraltar Point, a performance space on the Toronto Islands, but Artscape cancelled the event days before it was scheduled to place, after receiving an email which indicated that the event might be a political one, in contravention of Artscape's policies.[2] An Artscape spokesperson suggested that the event had been presented to them as "a fair and equitable event that was family-friendly and a lovely music festival," but that Artscape had elected to cancel the event after it "turned political."[2][28] Three of the musical acts which had been scheduled to perform at the event later suggested that they had been misled about the event's purpose and CAFE's platform. Musical group the Hogtown Brewers apologized for their involvement, noting that "we were not aware of the true nature" of CAFE, and suggesting that "we would not have knowingly supported this cause." Similarly, musical group Giraffe suggested that "we feel that we were not fully informed about what it was that is being supported here," and that CAFE had been "intentionally misleading to us in its effort to entice us to play this show."[29]

Canadian Centre for Men and Families

In 2013, the Canadian Association for Equality announced plans to build Toronto's first "Men's Centre," to be named the Canadian Centre for Men and Families.[9][30] After a successful capital campaign, the Centre opened in downtown Toronto in November 2014, under the directorship of CAFE co-founder Justin Trottier.[31] The Centre runs a variety of men's programs: counseling and peer support, a fathering group, legal services, mentorship for boys and young men, and support for male victims of domestic violence, sexual abuse and trauma. The center has worked to raise awareness of domestic violence against men, and Trottier has said that "We've long known that domestic violence victims span all ages, races and ethnicities. Now we're becoming aware they also span all genders and sexual orientations. Yet fathers and their children experiencing abuse often have no place to go."[32]

Writing about male suicide rates, The Province writer Kent Spencer called the center "the country's first men's-only shelter in Toronto, which provides safe space, peer support and services  for male victims of trauma and violence."[33]

In August 2017, CAFE became the first organization for male survivors of domestic abuse authorized by Legal Aid Ontario to provide legal aid certificates to male victims of domestic violence.[citation needed]

Pride parade controversy

On June 27, 2014 Pride Toronto revoked CAFE's permit to march in the 2014 World Pride Parade, despite regulations which prohibited the cancellation of permits after June 21.[34] Pride Toronto executive director Kevin Beaulieu explained the decision to bar CAFE from the parade by suggesting that it had been made out of concern that the CAFE's work "may contravene the spirit of the Mission, Vision and Values of Pride Toronto,"[34][35] and in response to public concerns "about the activities and purpose of CAFE and whether they actually match the intent they express"[1] CAFE representatives characterized the decision to exclude their organization from the parade as "regrettable," asserting that the organization is "not anti-woman" and is "absolutely inclusive."[1][36] Despite having their permit to march revoked, CAFE members marched in the June 29 Parade, alongside marchers from the Sherbourne Health Center, a community clinic focused on the health needs of new immigrants to Toronto, the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender community, and the homeless or under-housed. The CAFE members initially arrived at the parade wearing CAFE T-shirts, but were asked to wear Sherbourne Health Center T-shirts instead, and they passed out CAFE buttons along the parade route. Speaking to the press after the Parade, Sherbourne Health Center's director of human resources stated that the group had been unaware of the controversy surrounding CAFE's participation in the parade. Stating that "Sherbourne unequivocally does not endorse or support CAFE," he suggested that "had we had time to conduct any background research, we would have politely declined their request to join us."[37] In June 2015, CAFE was banned from all future events organized by Pride Toronto, in response to community complaints that the participation of CAFE would "directly undermine the participation of queer, lesbian and trans women in the Pride Parade."[38]

On August 23, CAFE walked in the Ottawa Pride parade. The Ottawa Sun, which covered their participation, interviewed Tammy Dopson, chair of the community advisory committee, who explained they received "no complaints about CAFE participating in the parade this year" and went on to say "Unless they're practising hate speech, there's no reason to exclude them," said Dopson. "Like many other people marching the parade, people agree and disagree."[39]

Billboard Campaigns

In March 2015, CAFE unveiled a billboard in downtown Toronto, which asserted that "half of domestic violence victims are men," and that "no domestic violence shelters are dedicated to us." The campaign coincided with International Women's Day,[40] and took place shortly after Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne announced a three-year plan to combat sexual violence.[41] In a news release, CAFE suggested that Wynne's violence against women initiative "reinforces sexist stereotypes that ignore violence against men, gays, and lesbians, and endanger children with abusive mothers."[41] In an interview with CBC, Trottier stated that while "initiatives to combat violence against women are necessary and praiseworthy," policies "should be built on facts rather than bound by ideologies."[42]

The National Post noted in its coverage of the campaign that CAFE's claim was based on a Statistics Canada survey from 2009, which found that roughly similar numbers of men and women experienced spousal violence in Canada. The same survey, the Post noted, had also found that women were twice as likely to be injured by spousal violence, three times more likely to be the victims of serious violence, and seven times more likely to fear for their lives.[41][43] Responding to the billboard campaign, The Globe and Mail writer Leah McLaren wrote that CAFE's stance on the issue was "beyond ludicrous," suggesting that the group had a "topsy-turvy world view." Responding to the billboard, Todd Minerson of White Ribbon Campaign said that "women are more likely to experience violence in an intimate relationship [by] many, many times," adding that "women are more likely to experience more severe and, in fact, far more likely to experience fatal violence,"[42] Social worker Gary Direnfeld was also critical of the billboard. "The way that that is presented is misleading," he said. Acknowledging that "there aren't shelters dedicated to men," Direnfeld suggested that "the need is so disproportionately greater for women that that is where the bulk of the money goes."[44]

Penny Krowitz, who is the executive director of Act to End Violence Against Women was also critical of the billboard. Speaking to the National Post, she said "If we had enough men coming forward saying, 'I need shelter from this abusive woman' or 'I need shelter from this situation,' do you not think that we would have provided those services to men?" and adding that "if service providers were finding that there was such a need for men's shelters, there would be men's shelters,"[45]

In November 2015, CAFE unveiled a second billboard on the theme of fatherlessness and parental alienation. The image showed a girl being pulled out of the loving arms of her father, with the text "I am not parental prey. Help me keep mommy AND daddy."[46][irrelevant citation]

Indigenous Boys and Men

CAFE has joined calls for Canada's Inquiry Into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women to include boys and men, based on the fact that 70% of murdered indigenous people are men.[47] University of Saskatchewan professor Rob Innes has said that, it "might not be the best idea" for those wishing to expand the inquiry to include men to ally with CAFE, because "as men's rights activists do in general—they point towards men being disadvantaged because of feminists."[48] CBC reporter Stephanie Cram, who called CAFE "one of the loudest and most controversial voices in so-called men's rights activism," wrote that the group "undermined" the drive to include men in the inquiry. According to Cram, Trottier's claim that there had already been many inquiries into missing aboriginal women was "simply not true."[47] She also cited a 2016 Statistics Canada report, which found that Indigenous women experience double the rate of violent victimization of Indigenous men.[49][47]

Red Pill film screening

In December 2016, CAFE organized a screening of The Red Pill, a documentary film about the men's rights movement directed by Cassie Jaye, at Ottawa's Mayfair theatre. The Mayfair cancelled the screening following community and advertiser complaints that CAFE was spreading hatred and homophobia on campus, and allegations that the group had been dishonest in its Canada Revenue charity status application.[50] According to the Mayfair's co-owner, the cancellation was followed by a "48-hour avalanche of hateful insults," including death threats, from supporters of CAFE and the film. Responding to the intimidation, the theatre's co-owner said "If there was an ounce of 'Oh, I'm sorry guys' before, that went away quickly." The film was later shown at Ottawa's City Hall theatre.[50][51]

References

  1. ^ a b c d Andrew-Gee, Eric (27 June 2014). "Men's rights group excluded from Toronto Pride parade". thestar.com.
  2. ^ a b c d Sieniuc, Kat (29 May 2014). "Concert organized by men's rights group cancelled". The Globe and Mail.
  3. ^ Strapagiel, Lauren (15 April 2013). "Men's rights movement sees resurgence among millennial males". The Huffington Post.
  4. ^ Other sources:
  5. ^ "FAQ". Canadian Association for Equality. Retrieved 19 February 2022.
  6. ^ Jim Brown (presenter) (21 May 2014). Does the men's equality movement need charity status? (Radio). The 180. CBC Radio One. Archived from the original (Excerpt) on 10 December 2014. Retrieved 8 June 2017. This week CAFE (The Canadian Association For Equality) sent out a press release saying it was the first men's issues group to be granted deemed a registered charity by the Canadian government. The group often draws protests when it holds public events as some critics say its mandate is less about protecting men's rights than disputing those of women, but board member Adam McPhee says the group's new status will help ensure true men's equality and access to services in Canada.
  7. ^ Strapagiel, Lauren (15 April 2013). "Men's Rights Movement Sees Resurgence Among Millennial Males". The Huffington Post. Retrieved 6 May 2013.
  8. ^ Farrell, Warren (24 September 2013). "Rigid campus feminism: is it forever? (blog)". mindingthecampus.com. Archived from the original on 25 September 2013.
  9. ^ a b c Nino Gheciu, Alex (15 August 2013). "Controversial men's rights group fundraising for a Centre for Men and Families". thestar.com.
  10. ^ Other sources:
  11. ^ Other sources:
  12. ^ Donachie, Mike (20 November 2014). "Controversial men's equality group wants to turn a corner with Toronto centre". Metro. Archived from the original on 31 May 2015. Retrieved 22 November 2014.
  13. ^ a b Kay, Barbara (5 June 2013). "Calling all male bashers". National Post. Archived from the original on 2014-11-22. Retrieved 2014-11-22.
  14. ^ Other sources:
  15. ^ a b Rollmann, Hans (Fall 2013). "Patriarchy and higher education: organizing around masculinities and misogny on Canadian campuses". Culture, Society and Masculinities. Men's Studies Press. 5 (2): 179–192. doi:10.3149/CSM.0502.179 (inactive 19 January 2024).((cite journal)): CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of January 2024 (link)
  16. ^ a b c Smeenk, Dan (17 November 2012). "Arrest, assaults overshadow "men's issues" lecture". The Varsity.
  17. ^ Smith Cross, Jessica (25 February 2013). "Men's issues or misogyny? Controversial men's group to discuss women's studies". Metro. Archived from the original on 29 November 2014. Retrieved 22 November 2014.
  18. ^ Bredin, Simon (14 January 2013). ""Men's issues" groups test limit of free speech on campus". The Varsity.
  19. ^ See press reports:
  20. ^ Rekai, Mike (5 August 2013). "Angry young men: the early days of fathers' rights has spawned a movement whose vitriol is considerably more pitched". Maclean's Magazine.
  21. ^ Alleyne, Allyssia (12 March 2013). "Men's Issues: It's Complicated". The Eye Opener. Retrieved 6 May 2013.
  22. ^ Hall, Diana (5 March 2013). "New RSU Policy Challenges New Men's Issues Group". The Eye Opener. Retrieved 6 May 2013.
  23. ^ Greenfield, Samuel (26 March 2013). "RSU wears the pants". The Ryersonian. Archived from the original on 2014-11-29. Retrieved 6 May 2013.
  24. ^ a b Collier, Rachel (9 November 2015). "Ryerson men's issues group says students' union shutting out male voices". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 11 January 2016.
  25. ^ Furey, Anthony; Network, Postmedia. "Gender issues speech balanced, informative". Toronto Sun. Retrieved 11 January 2016.
  26. ^ Patriquin, Martin (11 November 2015). "The new bogeyman on Canadian campuses". Maclean's Magazine. Retrieved 11 January 2016.
  27. ^ Spurr, Ben (24 June 2014). "Men's rights group used feminists' names on charity application". NOW Magazine. Retrieved 24 June 2014.
  28. ^ Other sources:
  29. ^ Ostroff, Joshua (30 May 2014). "Men's rights concert in Toronto cancelled upon discovery it was a men's rights concert". The Huffington Post.
  30. ^ Sources:
  31. ^ Sources:
  32. ^ DeMontis, Rita (23 June 2016). "Men also suffer from domestic abuse". Toronto Sun.
  33. ^ Spencer, Kent (20 July 2016). "Canadian suicides prompt look at men's roles in a changing world". The Province. Retrieved 2 March 2017.
  34. ^ a b Kay, Barbara (30 June 2014). "At Pride Toronto: militant feminist dogma trumped rights". National Post. Archived from the original on 2014-10-14. Retrieved 2014-11-22.
  35. ^ Other sources:
  36. ^ Watson, HG (28 June 2014). "WorldPride Toronto bars men's rights group CAFE from parade". Daily Xtra.
  37. ^ Watson, HG (3 July 2014). "Men's rights group CAFE slips into WorldPride parade". Daily Xtra.
  38. ^ Honderich, Holly (19 June 2015). "Men's rights group barred from Toronto's Pride Parade". Toronto Star.
  39. ^ Bay, Julienne (23 August 2015). "Controversial men's group marches in Capital Pride". Ottawa Sun. Retrieved 11 January 2016.
  40. ^ Smith Cross, Jessica; Westwood, Rosemary (6 March 2015). "Toronto #LetsTalkMen billboard stirs controversy with domestic violence claim". Metro. Archived from the original on 9 March 2015. Retrieved 10 March 2015.
  41. ^ a b c Edmiston, Jake; Thompson, Nicole (9 March 2015). "TORONTO: CAFE group unveils billboard about male victims of domestic abuse, accuses Ontario of forgetting about them". National Post.
  42. ^ a b Staff writer (10 March 2015). "Domestic violence against men target of controversial campaign". CBC News.
  43. ^ McLaren, Leah (12 March 2015). "Leah McLaren: How men's rights groups are distorting the debate about equality". The Globe and Mail.
  44. ^ Staff writer (11 March 2015). "Social worker: domestic violence campaign misleading". Hamilton News. AM900 CHML. Archived from the original on 3 March 2016.
  45. ^ Troup Buchanan, Rose (13 March 2015). "Male domestic abuse billboard 'LetsTalkMen' criticised". The Independent.
  46. ^ Médias, Groupe des Nouveaux. "ICI Radio-Canada.ca | Information, radio, télé, sports, arts". Radio-Canada (in Canadian French). Retrieved 11 January 2016.
  47. ^ a b c Cram, Stephanie (17 December 2016). "Drive to include men in MMIW inquiry undermined by association with controversial men's rights group". CBC News.
  48. ^ Piapot, Ntawnis (10 December 2016). "Why are indigenous leaders partnering with MRA groups?". vice.com. Vice.
  49. ^ Bellegarde, Brad (28 June 2016). "Indigenous people 3 times as likely to experience sexual assault than non-Indigenous Canadians: Statscan". CBC News.
  50. ^ a b Berman, Sarah (4 December 2016). "Why an Ottawa Theatre pulled a screening of a men's rights documentary". vice.com. Vice.
  51. ^ Other sources:

External links

Categories