China Merchants Group Limited
FormerlyChina Merchants Steam Navigation Company
Company typeState-owned enterprise
IndustryShipping
Founded16 December 1872; 151 years ago (1872-12-16) in Shanghai
FounderLi Hongzhang
HeadquartersOriginally in Shanghai. Now headquartered at Hong Kong
Websitewww.cmhk.com/en
China Merchants Group
Simplified Chinese招商局集团
Traditional Chinese招商局集團

China Merchants Group Limited (Chinese: 招商局集团; pinyin: Zhaoshangju Jituan) is an international state-owned enterprise (SOE) of the People's Republic of China. The company is operating under the auspices of the Chinese Ministry of Transport.[1]

Founded in 1872 as the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company in Shanghai, the firm has developed into one of China's leading SOEs since the 1980s and has expanded its global role as a result of China's Belt and Road Initiative in the early 2010s. In the Western media, China Merchants Group is mostly known for being criticized as a tool for China's alleged "debt diplomacy"[2][3] and its legal disputes with DP World, another port operator, regarding concession rights at the Port of Djibouti.[4]

Beginnings and growth (1872–1978)

Early history

China Merchants Steam Navigation Company was a shipping company founded on 16 December 1872 by the then Viceroy of Zhili Li Hongzhang, who was also concurrently serving as Commissioner of the Beiyang Fleet.[5] Its purpose was to capture part of the international trade, which had been virtually monopolized by foreign companies based in Treaty ports. 80% of the company's start-up capital was provided by native Chinese, making this the first transportation company using modern technology not based on foreign ownership. It obtained government support and received a monopoly contract to transport the tribute grain from the Yangzi Valley to the capital city of Beijing. The company also received loans from government sources and monopoly rights that prevented the founding of rival Chinese steamship companies.[6]

Initially, Li Hongzhang appointed Zhu Qiang (Chinese: 朱其昂) as manager at the Shanghai office, assisted by his younger brother Zhu Qizhao (Chinese: 朱其詔). The Zhu brothers and extended family had a large and successful sea-going junk business, shipping sand, rice and other cargoes along the regional coast. Zhu Qiang had already purchased an official rank as a sub-Prefect in Zhejiang.[7]

Letterhead for C.M.S.N.Co. 19th Century
Fleet flag & funnel livery of China Merchants Steam Navigation Co. 19th - 20th Centuries

The listed Chinese name for this company in the early 1870s was Zhao Shang Gongsi Ju (Chinese: 召商公司局; lit. 'China Merchants Bureau'), although by the 1880s this had morphed into Lunchuan Zhaoshang Zongju (Chinese: 輪船招商總局; lit. 'China Merchants Shipbuilding Bureau').[8]

In 1872, the company acquired its first steamship, an old combined sail & steam-powered vessel named SS Aden.[9] The ship was previously owned and operated by the Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company (P & O).[10][11] However, the Zhu brothers lacked knowledge about modern steamships and their operations, and that they were unsuitable to head the new endeavour. They subsequently replaced Zhu Qiang as manager with the appointment of Tang Jingxing to this position in 1873. Both Zhu brothers, however, being substantial shareholders, retained positions in the company as "Rice Tribute" managers.[12]

By 1877, the company was still not turning a profit and a decision was taken to expand the fleet significantly in an attempt to break the foreign shipping companies' virtual monopoly on the China coastal trading routes. The company purchased the entire fleet of 17 vessels from the Shanghai Steam Navigation Company whose agents were the old-established American Treaty-port traders, Russell & Company.[13]

The S. S. Kwang Lee

In 1885, Sheng Xuanhuai was named the company's director-general General to improve its fortunes,[14] following the departure of Tang Jingxing for other industrial projects.

During the Sino-French War of 1884-85, ownership of the ships was temporarily transferred to Russell & Co. in order to avoid seizure by French forces, but after hostilities had ceased, they were purchased back by CMSNCo., for the same price they had been sold for.[15]

The company enjoyed profitability for a few years under Sheng's directorship and began paying out annual dividends. However, by 1904, the company's finances had once again slipped into losses. Sheng, who had appointed a whole series of corrupt cronies to the management during his tenure, was eased out of control in 1911 when Dr. Wu Ting-fang took over as managing director with a view to reorganizing the company.[14][16]

By 1912, the fleet size of the company had grown to 29 coastal and river steamers, all manned by foreign (mainly British) captains.[17]

During the early 20th century up until the time of the revolution, there was a long and continual power struggle between Sheng and the various shareholders over control of the company. Following the revolution, in June 1913, shareholders of the CMSNCo. agreed to a scheme for the company to be reorganized with a new constitution. The company at this time possessed 31 ships and owned wharves and property in some 20 Chinese ports, with total assets valued at an estimated 25 million taels of silver.[18]

Following Sheng's death in 1916, Li Hongzhang's grandson, Li Guojie (Chinese: 李国杰), was appointed as a board director of CMSNCo. Li Guojie had previously served as the Chinese Minister to Belgium (1910-1912).[19] In 1924 he was elected as chairman of the board of directors.[20]

Civil war period

In 1927, Li continued to head the company although the entire Chinese shipping industry was placed under the supervision of the Communications Ministry of the Nationalist government. In 1929, the Nationalist government commenced investigations into past financial dealings of the company, and in particular those of the late Sheng Xianhuai. After uncovering evidence of impropriety, the Jiangsu Provincial Government ordered the confiscation of assets from Sheng's estate. Li Guojie also came under suspicion for misappropriating funds from the company and for taking out personal bank loans secured on the company's assets. This culminated in a lawsuit again Li to recover lost monies.

The scandal escalated when on 24 July 1930, Zhao Tieqiao, a senior member of the Shanghai Investment Promotion Bureau tasked with investigating past financial irregularities, was assassinated outside the company's offices in Shanghai.[21] Li immediately fell under suspicion but lacking sufficient he was instead detained on economic fraud charges relating to obtaining personal foreign loans using state-owned assets as collateral. He was convicted and sentenced to 3 years imprisonment. However, through his political connections he was soon released. Li remained in Shanghai, heavily involved in the corrupt political power struggles prevalent in that era. He was shot outside his Shanghai home on 19 February 1939 and died soon afterwards.[22]

The firm was nationalized and reorganized as the China Merchants Group in 1935, acquiring the name it uses today.[23] During the Sino-Japanese war, the company sold four of its ships: Haiyuan, Haili, Haichen and Haiheng to the Hong Kong-based trading company Jardine Matheson & Co. Other ships were scuttled during the hostilities.

During World War II, the headquarters moved around, being for a period in Hong Kong and at Chongqing.

Post-Civil War split

In 1949, following the Chinese Civil War, the company's head office was transferred together with the Republic of China government from the Mainland to Taiwan. The Taipei-based part of CMSNCo. merged with Yang Ming Marine Transport Corporation on 1 July 1995.

Meanwhile, the People's Republic of China retained ownership of some of the company's ships and of the Hong Kong subsidiary, allowing the latter to retain its name (China Merchants Steam Navigation Company Limited) to avoid legal disputes. In 1950, transfer of the original core company was moved to its Hong Kong headquarters but with overall control still being retained by the PRC.[24]

Modern history (1978 to today)

The company slipped into relative obscurity during the Mao era.[25] This only changed with China's opening of its economy in 1978, when the free-trade zones created in China led to the company's revival.[26] On 31 January 1979, Yuan Geng became the first CEO of the PRC-owned company. Yuan had founded the Shekou Industrial Zone in Shenzhen and was made CMG CEO following Beijing's approval of the zone proposal, making it a corner stone of the first special economic zone in Shenzhen as part of Deng Xiaoping's reformist policies.[27]

Throughout its development of the Shekou Zone during the 1980s and 1990s, CMG got involved in business sectors beyond shipping, including investing in and operation of amenities, social and industrial infrastructures, numerous industrial ventures from containers to food manufacturing, real estate and finance.[25] In 1987, it founded the first joint-stock bank in the PRC, China Merchants Bank, making it a "highways-to-banking conglomerate".[26]

Although CMG was involved in numerous horizontal businesses, in 2001 this was rationalized to three "core business sectors", namely transport infrastructures, financial, as well as property development and industrial park operations.[28][25]

Since the Chinese government's adoption of the Belt and Road Initiative in 2013, CMG has been playing a major role in furthering the policy through its flagship port business.[29][30] CMG has been seeking to expand international operations accordingly. Besides operating in Hong Kong and Mainland China, CMG now has operations in strategic locations across South Asia, Europe, for example in Greece, Lithuania and Belarus, and Africa, including most notably Nigeria and Djibouti.[30][31][25][32]

CMG became active in Nigeria in 2010 with the acquisition of a 47.5% stake in the Tin Can Island Container Terminal in Lagos.[33] CMG became involved in Djibouti in 2013, when it acquired a 23.5% stake in the Doraleh container terminal.[34] In January 2021, Djibouti and CMG signed a deal for the Chinese conglomerate to expand the Port of Djibouti at a cost of $350 million. The development plan will follow the Shekou Zone model.[35]

House flag

Structure

China Merchants Group Limited owns 12 main subsidiaries across its core business sectors, employing 230,000 people:[36]

Notable subsidiaries

Controversies

Port of Djibouti

Controversy surrounds the way in which CMG acquired the 23.5% stake in the Doraleh terminal. CMG was sold the stake after Djibouti's government seized the facilities from Dubai-based port operator DP World, co-manager of the facilities since a concession agreement in 2004.[34] One year later, CMG got authorization to construct another port facility, the Doraleh multi-purpose port located within the Chinese military support base.[37] This coincided with Djibouti and CMG establishing the International Free Trade Zone.[38]

In 2018, Djibouti terminated DP World's concession rights, nationalized its shares in the terminal and handed them on to China Merchants Group.[39] Although the Djibouti government has stated it alone controls the port, media reports indicate that CMG is directing day-to-day activities.[40][41]

DP World sued CMG in 2019 in Hong Kong for allegedly causing Djibouti to revoke its concession rights.[42][4] The London Court of International Arbitration ruled in 2020 that Djibouti's actions constituted a breach of contract and ordered Djibouti to return the concession to DP World, but the country rejected the ruling.[43] Thus far, there have been seven rulings in DP World's favor in the matter, most recently in July 2021, all of which have been rejected by the Djibouti government.[44][45]

Hambantota Port development

In 2017, Sri Lanka approved an agreement with CMG regarding the Hambantota port, according to which the company would take a majority stake in the port.[46] This had caused concern that the facilities could be used for Chinese military vessels and that such a large-scale transfer of land could adversely impact Sri Lanka's national sovereignty.[46]

In the years since, the port has been referred to as a "Chinese colony" by critics and an example of China's "debt diplomacy", because CMG provided $1.1 billion in funds to the highly indebted government for the port in exchange for an 85% stake and a 99-year lease.[2] This allowed China to gain a geostrategic foothold in close proximity to India, one of its main rivals in the Indo-Pacific, India, as well as to important commerce and military waterways.[47]

Special investigation by the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection

In 2014, the Hong Kong media reported that the CCP's Central Commission for Discipline Inspection was conducting a special investigation into CMG, along with several other SOEs, on corruption claims.[1]

References

  1. ^ a b "China's anti-corruption campaign reaches Hong Kong". Nikkei Asia. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  2. ^ a b "Sri Lanka's 'debt trap' port thriving, Chinese owners claim". Nikkei Asia. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  3. ^ "The Belt and Road Initiative". Global Risk Institute. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  4. ^ a b "DP World sues China Merchants Ports, says it turned Djibouti against it". Global Construction Review. 2019-02-13. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  5. ^ "Eminent Chinese of the Ching Period by A.W. Hummel1944 ; Vol2.page-951
  6. ^ Kwang-ching Liu, "Steamship enterprise in nineteenth-century China." Journal of Asian Studies 18.4 (1959): 435-455.
  7. ^ “China's Early Industrialization” -Chapter 4- C.M.S.N.Co Management Personnel by A Feuerwerker,published in 1958
  8. ^ Shanghai merchant houses listed in “The China Directory” for 1889
  9. ^ "The Three P&O ss Aden". www.pandosnco.co.uk. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  10. ^ P & O Heritage Website - “ Fact Sheet 0060 1856/0823 ADEN 1856” https://www.poheritage.com/Upload/Mimsy/Media/factsheet/92662ADEN-1856pdf.pdf downloaded 04.04.2021
  11. ^ “The China Year Book 1916" : Chapter XV!! “Shipping"
  12. ^ “China's Early Industrialization” by A Feuerwerker
  13. ^ “The China Year Book 1916 : Chapter XV!! “Shipping”
  14. ^ a b China Year Book 1916
  15. ^ Bell, H. T. Montague; Woodhead, H. G. W. (1916). The China year book: 1916, with a map of Mongolia. George Routledge & Sons. OCLC 28106439.
  16. ^ Wu Ting-fang, a Cantonese native was known in Hong Kong as Ng Choy 伍才 Wǔ Cái
  17. ^ The Chronicle & Directory of China, Japan, Corea etc.etc. “The China Directory” for 1912- Coasting and River Steamers"
  18. ^ China Year Book 1921). A tael of silver varied slightly in value depending on its origin and the fineness of silver content. The “Shanghai Tael” in 1915 was worth about one eighth of a Pound Sterling, valuing the company at that time at about £300,000.
  19. ^ Eminent Chinese of the Qing Period – Hummel page 471
  20. ^ Biography of Li Guojie - Chinese Wikipedia page (in Chinese only) downloaded 2021.04.10
  21. ^ Zhao Tieqiao 1886-1930 Baidu biography (in Chinese only).
  22. ^ ibid
  23. ^ Du, Juan (2020-01-07). The Shenzhen Experiment: The Story of China's Instant City. Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-24223-4.
  24. ^ China Merchants Group corporate website – History 1912 -1949
  25. ^ a b c d Zhang, Jerry J. (2021-09-27). Chinese Business and the Belt and Road Initiative: Institutional Strategies. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-000-45575-5.
  26. ^ a b Montlake, Simon. "Port In A Storm: An Interview With China Merchants Group". Forbes. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  27. ^ "Yuan Geng: Chinese guerilla spy turned economic pioneer, dies at 99". South China Morning Post. 2016-02-01. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  28. ^ Zhang, Zhi-Xue; Zhang, Jianjun (2014-06-19). Understanding Chinese Firms from Multiple Perspectives. Springer. ISBN 978-3-642-54417-0.
  29. ^ "China Merchants plans further overseas expansion | JOC.com". www.joc.com. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  30. ^ a b "China Merchants Port Holdings Co., Ltd". Nikkei Asia. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  31. ^ "Port Strategy | Another win for China's Belt and Road". www.portstrategy.com. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  32. ^ "China Consolidates Its Commercial Foothold in Djibouti". thediplomat.com. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  33. ^ "China Merchants buys into Lagos container terminal". Seatrade Maritime. 2010-11-09. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  34. ^ a b Dahir, Abdi Latif. "A legal tussle over a strategic African port sets up a challenge for China's Belt and Road plan". Quartz. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  35. ^ "China Merchants signs deal for Shekou-style revamp of Djibouti port". South China Morning Post. 2021-01-05. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  36. ^ "China Merchants Group". www.cmhk.com. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  37. ^ Rimmer, Peter J. (2020-11-27). China's Global Vision and Actions: Reactions to Belt, Road and Beyond. Edward Elgar Publishing. ISBN 978-1-78897-897-2.
  38. ^ Park, James (2021-02-03). "How China Uses State Capitalism to Gain Power and Influence in Djibouti". The National Interest. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  39. ^ Kerr, Simeon; Aglionby, John (23 February 2018). "DP World accuses Djibouti of illegally seizing container terminal". Financial Times.
  40. ^ Paris, Costas (2019-02-21). "China Tightens Grip on East African Port". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  41. ^ "China Merchants Consolidates its Hold in Djibouti". The Maritime Executive. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  42. ^ "Legal battle for control of Djibouti Ports comes to Hong Kong". Africanews. 2019-02-12. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  43. ^ Paris, Costas (2020-01-17). "Djibouti Rejects Court Ruling to Hand Back Container Terminal". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  44. ^ Dudley, Dominic. "Djibouti Ordered To Pay $533M In Compensation In Container Terminal Dispute With Dubai". Forbes. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  45. ^ "Arbitration Tribunal Rejects Djibouti Port Company's Bid To Escape Contract With DP World". All Africa. 12 July 2021. Archived from the original on 2021-07-12.
  46. ^ a b Aneez, Shihar (2017-07-25). "Exclusive: Sri Lanka's cabinet 'clears port deal' with China firm after concerns addressed". Reuters. Retrieved 2021-09-02.
  47. ^ Abi-Habib, Maria (2018-06-25). "How China Got Sri Lanka to Cough Up a Port". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2021-09-02.

Further reading

External links

China Merchants Group
Shipping companies of China
Categories