Tracy was born on May 2, 1996, in Camarillo, California.[1] He attended Newbury Park High School, playing football and soccer, starting three years in football.[2] Following high school Tracy went to Assumption University in Worcester, Massachusetts, redshirting as a true freshman. As a redshirt-freshman the following year, Tracy led Division II kickers with 117 points that included 22 field goals made, 51-of-53 extra-point chances and a season-long field goal of 52 yards. He was 22-for-26 in field goal attempts, earning a second-team All-American award from D2football.com.[2] On September 12, against LIU Post, Tracy went a perfect 6-for-6 on field goal attempts.
As a sophomore, Tracy played in 12 games, making 19 out of 29 field goal attempts, 49 out of 51 extra point attempts, and earning the Steve "Merc" Morris All-Star Special Teams player of the Year award. He tied a Division II record with six made field goals against St. Anselm, becoming one of two players in any division to have two 6+ field goal games.[2] As a junior, he won the Fred Mitchell Outstanding Place Kicker Award, given to the best placekicker below the Division I-FBS level. He was 27-of-29 field goals and made all 67 extra-point attempts to finish with a school record in points scored, with 148.[2]
He transferred to Louisiana State University (LSU) as a senior, and was a finalist for the Lou Groza Award, given to the nation's best placekicker. Tracy was a second-team All-America selection from Sporting News, Walter Camp, Football Writer's Association, and the American Football Coaches Association. He was also first-team All-SEC from both Associated Press and the conference's coaches. He was named player of the week after games against Miami, Auburn, Georgia and Mississippi State. He converted on 29 of 33 field goals and all 42 of his extra point attempts.[2]
Tracy ended his college career as one of the most prolific kickers in NCAA history, making 97 total field goals and scoring 502 total points.[2]
