Cultural views on the midriff and navel vary significantly. In some cultures the navel is seen as sexually and culturally significant, and its exposure has been subject to a variety of cultural norms and taboos, based on concepts of modesty. The views, customs and fashions relating to the midriff and navel change from time to time, and such exposure has become more widely acceptable, as reflected in the designs of clothing.
Western culture
The public exposure of the male and female midriff and bare navel has been taboo at times in Western cultures, being considered immodest or indecent. It was banned in some jurisdictions.[1] Eventually, only female navel exposure was banned and not male because, it was argued, the simulation or upward displacement from vagina to navel was commonplace and obvious in women.[2]
Community perceptions have changed and exposure of female midriff and navel is more accepted today and in some societies or contexts it is both fashionable and common, though not without its critics. Although American teenage girls are more likely to wear shirts that reveal their midriffs, this kind of clothing is often banned in high schools and stores. It is also inappropriate to wear clothing that reveals the midriff in professional settings like places of work. The exposure of the male navel has not been as controversial nor as common, and is usually in the context of barechestedness. Exposure of the navel by females is commonly associated with the popularity of the bikini, the crop top, and low-rise clothing.
Physical attractiveness of the belly button is also viewed and publicized like celebrities like Kelly Ripa[7] and Emily Ratajkowski[8] for their unusual shaped belly buttons. Belly button plastic surgery that came in into the late 2010s.[9] Celebrities like Kendall Jenner and Kim Kardashian used plastic surgery to alter or enhanced their belly buttons.[10][11][12]Logan Browning opened up about having a outie belly button as a flaw during her upbringing.[13]
Body shaming of women is very common, whether overweight or otherwise.[citation needed] This causes leading to mental disorders, like concern of body image, eating disorder, low self-esteem and body dysphoria.[14][15][16] Body shaming often happens to well known figures like Ronda Rousey,[17]Billie Eilish[18]Selena Gomez[19] and most notably Lady Gaga for her Super Bowl LIhalftime show.[20][21][22][23]Danica Patrick made a post on Instagram the comparison to the way she poses, lightning, cloth adjustments like lower rise jeans to further enhance the look to her midriff that she makes in photoshoots to a picture she doesn't have.[24]Jessie James expressed her struggle with body image and body shaming.[25] In 2022, James bared her midriff in a bikini for the Kittenish show for encouragement and not to be shamed for their bodies.[25][26] Actress Caity Lotz opened up about being body shamed for her muscular midriff and abdomen for "being too boyish".[27] In some cases, there is cultural outlooks of famous celebrities of their tone definition of their midriffs. A story about a fitness TV ad featuring Elisabeth Hasselbeck had her belly button edited out and her midriff retouched to look perfected.[28]
In 2013, Kate Middleton gained national attention for how impressive her midriff was right after giving birth less than three months to her firstborn. While playing volleyball in London at Olympic Park when her shirt flew up numerous of times showing her midriff.[29][30][31][32][33] In May 2023, at the Perfect Days premiere during the Cannes Film FestivalBrie Larson gained a lot of media attention of how toned her midriff is. Larson wore a two piece Chanel dress which is low enough to expose her belly button.[34][35][36][37]Jennifer Lopez is universally known for how tone her midriff looks.[38][39][40][41][42][43][44]
Actress Kiernan Shipka is known for her tone midriff.[45][46][47]
A known 2023 Calvin Klein ad featuring multiple soccer stars including Alex Morgan bare their figures in their underwear.[48] On social media and media outlets was impressed by Morgan's midriff is.[49]
Film
In the United States, the Motion Picture Production Code, or Hays Code, enforced after 1934, banned the exposure of the female navel in Hollywood films.[50] The National Legion of Decency, a Roman Catholic body guarding over American media content, also pressured Hollywood to keep clothing that exposed certain parts of the female body, such as bikinis and low-cut dresses, from being featured in Hollywood movies.[51]
During the 1950s, Joan Collins was prohibited by the censors from exposing her navel in Land of the Pharaohs (1955). To get around the censors' guidelines, she wore a jewel, a ruby, in her navel.[52][53]Kim Novak wore a ruby jewel in her navel for the film Jeanne Eagels (1957); saying in an interview, "they had to glue it in every time. I got a terrible infection from it."[54]Marilyn Monroe, for a scene from Some Like It Hot (1959), wore a dress that revealed skin everywhere but had a small piece of fabric to hide her navel.[55] (The film was condemned by the National Legion of Decency, but for other reasons.[56][57])
By the 1960s, community standards had changed. Marilyn Monroe was allowed to expose her navel in Something's Got to Give (1962) and later commented, "I guess the censors are willing to recognize that everybody has a navel."[58]Ursula Andress, appearing as Honey Ryder in the 1962 James Bond film, Dr. No, wore her iconic white bikini, which exposed her midriff and navel. However, when Annette Funicello was cast in her first beach movie Beach Party (1963), Walt Disney, who held her contract, insisted that she only wear modest bathing suits and keep her navel covered, to preserve her wholesome persona, though she was the only one of the ample number of young women in the film not bikini-clad.[59] In the 1967 film Follow That Camel, actress Anita Harris wore a jewel on her navel for a belly-dancing sequence.[60][61]
In the 1979 Alien film there was some regret from director James Cameron that Sigourney Weaver's underwear scene which was wearing a cropped shirt exposing her midriff that was called "stepped over the line".[62]
The Hays Code was abandoned soon after, with it the prohibition of female navel exposure and other restrictions. The influence of the National Legion of Decency had also waned by the 1960s. With the withdrawal of the Code and the change to a classification regime, the ban on the exposure of parts of the human body that had previously been regarded as immodest or indecent was withdrawn; and with it, there was an increasing level of body exposure over time. The exposure of the navel ceased to be controversial in the context of a general increase in nudity.
In the 2000s, Devon Aoki's bad girl character Suki in 2 Fast 2 Furious wore low rise pants and a cut off crop-top exposing her midriff and belly button was a popular iconic style.[63]
In 1951, the United States Code of Practices for Television Broadcasters came into force, which, besides other things, prohibited female navel exposure on American television.[64] During the 1960s, Barbara Eden was not allowed to show her navel on the NBC TV show I Dream of Jeannie (1965–70).[65][66] Her pants had to be worn above the navel, which became ineffective. After a few frames of her navel exposure went unnoticed, they decided to use fabric and skin-colored makeup to conceal her navel.[67] Her costume became low-rise (without censorship) in 1985[68] and in 2013, 81-year-old Eden attended the Life Ball event in Vienna dressed in the same costume of I Dream of Jeannie but revealing her navel.[69][70][71] In February 1964, Scandinavian Airlines placed an advertisement in newspapers and magazines throughout the United States. It featured a blonde-haired, bikini-clad model exposing her belly button posing on a rock above the caption "What to show your wife in Scandinavia". The image that appeared in most publications had the belly button removed.[72][73]
The first exposure of a navel in a TV series occurred in 1961 on the Dr. Kildare series.[74][75]Dawn Wells and Tina Louise were not allowed to expose their navels in Gilligan's Island (1964–67).[76] Wells was required to wear high-waisted shorts that covered her navel.[77][78]
Wells stated in an interview, "Oh my goodness, I designed the shorts. Because it was the first short shorts ever on television and it had to cover my navel. Gilligan's Island actually gave censors headaches back in the '60s. Ginger's cleavage, and Mary Ann's navel were only allowed 3 seconds an episode."[79] The censors missed Nichelle Nichols, who is showing her navel in the second-season Star Trek episode "Mirror, Mirror" (1967).[80] It is believed that it was due to Bjo Trimble that it went unnoticed.[81] Another episode of Star Trek, called "A Private Little War" (1968), also managed to get past the censors when Nancy Kovack's belly button was clearly visible in some shots and not covered by jewelry as seen when the fringe from her top was not covering it. In 1969, Mariette Hartley was not allowed to reveal her belly button in "All Our Yesterdays" (1969), the penultimate episode of Gene Roddenberry's Star Trek. Gene had Mariette expose not one but two belly buttons in the sci-fi film Genesis II (1973).[82][83][84][85]
Raffaella Carrà was the first Italian woman and first TV personality to show her belly button on TV in 1970 garnering her criticisms from the Vatican.[86][87] In The Sonny & Cher Comedy Hour (1971–74),[88] network censors feared Cher's navel exposure would become a cause célèbre at CBS.[89] Cher once commented, "There were so many things that were censored—ideas and words. All I know is I got in trouble for showing my belly button, and every time I turned around after I went off the air, all you saw were Cheryl Ladd's boobs."[90]People magazine dubbed Cher "Pioneer of the Belly Beautiful".[91]
The U.S. code of practice was suspended in 1983.[92][93] In the 2000s, actress Kaley Cuoco commonly wore clothing that revealed her belly button in TV shows, photoshoots and public events.[94]Kim Possible wore a crop top which bare her midriff in the show until season 4. After the show, the 2019 live action film adaption starring Sadie Stanley which had Kim Possible not wear a midriff baring crop top which left mixed thoughts in many fans of the show.[95]
Navel exposure became common in the culture of 20th-century music, with an establishing foothold during the mid-1970s, then becoming more prominent by the following decade, with many successful female popstars[100] having appeared on and offstage and in music videos with their midriff exposed, usually wearing a crop top, including Madonna, during 1983, she caused controversy when she wore a mesh crop top in her video for the song "Lucky Star". People magazine wrote that Madonna made the bare navel her trademark.[91]
Singer/actress Cher wore an Indian princess outfit with feathers and beads around her navel for the 58th Annual Academy Awards event in 1986. California-based fashion designer Christine Albers commented, "the look is good for anyone who has a great body but especially for women who do a lot of stomach exercises."[101]
Britney Spears wearing a cropped top exposing her midriff and belly button piercing while performing in 2003
1990s and 2000s
During the early 1990s, Canadian country singer Shania Twain appeared in low-rise jeans baring her midriff and navel in her music videos and performances.[102][103][104] It became both the most widely discussed body part in country music and her trademark.[105][106] Shania once commented, "Someone said to me once, 'Well, if I had your belly-button I'd sell 8 million albums too.' But it takes a lot more than a belly-button to sell more than 8 million albums."[107]Jennifer Lopez is believed to have started the trend of exposing the navel on stage and red carpets.[108]People magazine stated, "The 19-year-old hotshot chanteuse behind 'What a Girl Wants', once a Mouseketeer alongside Britney Spears, can't quite pull off pop star flash without belly-flopping."[109]
In 2001, the editors of Britannica commissioned an article on Britney Spears that deconstructs her bare midriff. The article describes Miss Spears's navel as "a heated boundary between baby and babe".[110] She had been a major inspiration for the navel piercing trend.[111]Spin magazine chose Madonna's navel as its "most incredible" rock star body part for a September 2005 feature.[112][113][114] Gregorio Luke, former director of the Museum of Latin American Art who conducted lectures about belly buttons, said, "The belly button has been a sign of beauty in goddesses as different as Astarte, Venus or Aphrodite. We ask which is more beautiful, the perfectly round belly button of Jane Fonda or Raquel Welch's grain of coffee navel? Every star from Madonna to Shakira proudly displays their belly button."[115][116]
On the contrary, American columnist Kathleen Parker in an article about Katharine Hepburn once commented, "Young movie-going girls today don't have access to many in the mold of Katharine Hepburn. Instead by mall observations most are Britney wannabes—hip-hugged, tattooed, pierced and out there. The female navel has become the refrigerator man's continental divide. I hate to break it to you, oh future daughters-in-law, but everybody's got a belly button. Your inney- or outey-ness is not the stuff either of revelation or revolution."[117]
Fashion
Gigi Hadid wearing a midriff baring crop top which exposes her outie belly button
Exposed midriff is associated with the crop top, often in association with low-rise clothing. Another way that the navel may be exposed is via a deep plunging neckline dress or top that drops below the natural waist line.
Low-rise clothing began in the early 1990s, when the British magazine The Face featured Kate Moss in low-rise jeans on its March 1993 issue cover.[118] Models such as Gisele Bündchen frequently flash their midriffs.[119] In 1994, Art Cooper, editor-in-chief of GQ magazine said that his big seller in 1994 was the February issue with Geena Davis on the cover, on which she wore an Armani suit opened at the hips to reveal her navel,[120] It sold about 400,000 copies. He stated, "Part of the success is the navel factor. I think the belly button is really an erogenous zone."[121] In 2000, during the Grammy AwardsJennifer Lopez wored her iconic Green Versace dress a silk tropical jungle gown with a neckline extended below her belly button. Lopez stated "Nobody went out like that ever; nobody had shown skin in the front like that down past the navel".[122]
Navel piercing[123] and navel tattoos[124] has become more common among young women. The trend of piercing or tattooing the navel became popular in the 1990s. Olympic gymnast Simone Biles as a young girl wanted to have a belly button piercing.[125][126] Celebrities such as Beyoncé, Britney Spears, Dua Lipa, Normani, Miley Cyrus and Vanessa Hudgens still wear their belly button piercings.[127] It is popular among middle-aged women.[128][129] Actress Drew Barrymore has a butterfly tattoo beneath her navel.[130][131] The growing popularity of belly dancing, where navel exposure is typical, has also added to the navel exposure trend.[132]Kim Kardashian is most famously for her signature style of her bare midriff is her belly chain.[133]
Contrarily, advice columnist Ann Landers commented, "Navels are neither sexy nor obscene. I do not believe any female of good taste would wear an outfit where her navel shows. This does not include women in costumes or those on beaches in bikinis. The same goes for males. An adult male who wears hip-huggers so low rates zero minus 10 on the scale of taste—it's my opinion but it's one I feel strongly about."[134] Fashion historian James Laver told that he hasn't quite caught up with the idea of exposing the navel, saying, "I have never regarded that as a particularly attractive part of the human anatomy".[135][136] The navel fashion returned in the 1980s, when a New York City ban on exposing the navel in public was lifted.[1]Ronda Rousey stated in her appearance in a Sports Illustrated swimsuit issue “The only thing they changed was they took out my belly button ring,” she said, laughing. “Everything else was exactly the same, they weren’t touched or photo-shopped at all except for I guess they didn’t like it, but they could have just asked me to take it out. I was actually kind of sad. I’ve had it since I was 14 years old. When I fight is the only time I don’t wear it. It was kind of weird. Maybe I should get fancier ones than the $10 ones I buy on Venice Beach.”[137]
From 2010, the crop top evolved by which women started wearing it with a high-rise skirts, jeans, or shorts that are high enough to cover the navel.[138][139][140] The bandeau top also made an appearance in formal wear, usually associated with a high-rise skirt or pants that cover the navel. Actress Halle Berry wore a bandeau with matching pants at the MTV Video Music Awards, fueling the trend of wearing a bandeau top as an out-of-home dress.[141]Miley Cyrus also wore a cropped bandeau top with high-waisted pants at the 2014 MTV Video Music Awards[142] and Jourdan Dunn wore a black bandeau top with matching maxiskirt.[citation needed][143]Anna Kendrick first bares her midriff and belly button in a Elle magazine in 2016.[144]
Into the 2020s, fashion around the midriff or belly button as begin to evolve having cutouts such as Julia Garner's diamond-shaped cut out dress exposing her stomach and belly button at the 2022 Emmys.[145][146] It has become a common fashion design for pregnant women.[147] Cutout outfits has been dating back in the 1930s but through time midriff baring cut out featuring exposure of the navel like Cher's cut out dress in the 1972 baring her navel, Demi Moore's belly button revealing dress in 1993 and Kim Cattrall's zig-zag hole dress baring her navel in 2003.[148]Sheryl Crow wore a yellow Roberto Cavalli gown that had a cutout, that goes beyond her belly button in the 2000 Grammys.[149][150] Trending from many different styles like the crisscrossed bodice diamond cut out worn by Lori Harvey that bare around her toned midriff and belly button at Met Gala and Hailey Baldwin's cut out gown exposing her belly button at Met Gala attending at the Academy Museum Gala in 2022.[151][152]Zoe Kravitz wore a diamond-shaped midriff-baring cutout surrounding her belly button at the GQ Men of the Year Awards in 2022.[153]Olivia Holt wore a blue Ferragamo cutout dress that bare her midriff and belly button while attending at the Billboard Women in Music in 2022.[154][155][156]
In a Vanity Fair magazine during 2022, Australian actress Margot Robbie wore a black midriff baring cutout angled to the side exposing her belly button.[157]
Currently in the begininng of 2024 in the Grammys the cutouts continue to trend featuring Paris Jackson's black assyremical cutout that bares most of her midriff and belly button[158] and Tyla's pistachio green low rise cut out dress that bares her midriff and belly button piercing.[159][160]
Displays of the female navel commenced with the introduction of the bikini in 1946, designed by Louis Réard,[161] though two-piece swimsuits that exposed the midriff but covered the navel appeared in the 1930s. Réard could not find a model who would dare wear his brief design, so he hired Micheline Bernardini, a 19-year-old nude dancer from the Casino de Paris, as his model.[162][163] Acceptance of the new-style swimsuit was very slow, and the bikini was not regarded as suitable clothing beyond the beach or pool. During the 1960s, Mary Quant's designs featured exposed navels and bare midriffs.[164] Exposure of the male navel was limited well into the 1960s. Swimwear covered the lower abdomen and usually the navel. Occasionally the swimwear would be worn immediately below the navel. The swimwear evolved to longer legs and lower waistline. Male swimwear could neither be worn above the navel nor below the knee in events of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA).[165]
Sports bikinis
Bikinis have become a major component of marketing of various women's sports,[166] and female athletes often wear sports bikinis that expose the navel. Bulgarian athlete Ivet Lalova is known for her "tribal sun" tattoo around her navel.[167] Croatian athlete Blanka Vlašić is famous for her navel piercing.[168][169]
A example of Sydney McLaughlin's midriff baring uniform while running during the 4 × 400 metres relay in Oregon 2022
Track and field
Modern Olympics uniforms began with simple cotton tank tops for women beginning in 1900, when they started competing.[170] In the 1990s, track and field athletes started to wear midriff-baring uniforms.[171][172][173]
Uniforms in a beach handball game between Denmark and Norway
Beach sports
Woman athletes' uniforms often include bikini bottoms. By comparison, men wear polo shirts instead of being bare-chested. This became controversial in 2021, when the Norwegian Beach Handball team refused to wear bikini bottoms and was fined 150 euros (about $175) per player. In beach volleyball, players don't mind wearing skimpy uniforms because of the conditions.[174][175][176][177]
The fashion later became increasingly popular through wearing styles, with tops comprising modified sports bras without additional outergarments, sports bikinis, and cheerleading style fashions. These developed largely from the styles originating with the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders in the early 1970s.[178]
Female tennis players are known for exposing their navels or navel piercings on court.[179][180] American tennis player Serena Williams was noted by the media for exposing her belly button piercing during her matches.[181][182][183] Retired Russian tennis player Anna Kournikova was also known for frequent navel exposure during her matches.[184][185][186] In 2009, in an interview with the German magazine Der Spiegel, she said, "These are men's ravings. Why you should hide it, when it isn't necessary? Female beach volleyball players play in bikinis – does it bother anyone?"[187] American female golfer Laura Diaz, commenting on the Ladies Professional Golf Association for Sports Illustrated, said: "The LPGA needs to acknowledge that a lot of people watch women's sports more for the women than for the sports. Why else would Anna Kournikova, who has never won a singles title, be the most popular player in women's tennis? We have quite a few attractive women, and we should use our looks to our advantage. After all, what's so wrong with seeing an occasional belly button?"[188][189]
American football
Males often wear no shirt with low-rise shorts during practice in American football. Cropped jerseys were worn during 1980s broadcasts. Cropped jerseys became dormant for 20 years until male athletes returned to midriff exposure[190] for comfort purposes. However, the NCAA placed an official ban on navel exposure in 2015.[191] The National Football League has long had a ban on navel exposure, requiring jerseys to be tucked in. The NFL banned Ezekiel Elliott's crop top in September 2016.
In the Hebrew Bible the Song of Songs emphasizes the navel as an important element of a woman's beauty.[192][193] It contains imagery similar to that in the love songs of ancient Egyptian literature.[192] Song of Songs 7:2 states: "Your navel is a rounded bowl."[194] The verse preceding the line mentioning the navel (Song of Songs 7:1) states, "your rounded thighs are like jewels, the work of a master hand",[194] ) and the verse following states, "Your belly is a heap of wheat."[194] Thus the treatment of the navel appears placed textually in between the description of the curves of a woman through thigh and the stomach or midriff.[193] "Belly" also suggests the womb, and the combination of the imagery of the womb with that of wheat suggests the link between eroticism and fertility through the imagery of the navel and curvaceous thighs.[193] These passages also celebrate a curvaceous stomach and midriff and plumpness as aspects of female physical attractiveness.[193]
The ancient Mediterranean, Hebrew, Israelite and Middle Easternworldview commonly incorporated beliefs that shrines, important places (such as cities or capitals), or other such places of prominence had a position of centrality to the world and hence equated to the child-bearing, life-giving navel of a mother.[195] These domains constituted what contemporaries could regard as important bonds that linked the universe.[195] Thus Nippur, an ancient city of the Mesopotamian people, was often described[by whom?] as the "navel".[195] This usage expressed connotations of the prominence of the location and the way it was seen to function as a place of centrality and as a link between earth and the heavens and the Universe.[195] The Ancient Greeks regarded the conical stone Omphalos (meaning "navel") located at Delphi as the center of the earth.[195]
In a similar vein, JewishMidrashim state: "God created the world like an embryo. Just as the embryo begins at the navel and continues to grow from that point, so too the world. The Holy One, blessed be he, began the world from its navel. From there it was stretched hither and yon. Where is its navel? Jerusalem. And its (Jerusalem's) navel itself? The altar."[195][196] This passage expresses the centrality of the ancient city of Jerusalem and of the altar of the ancient temple of Jerusalem within a cosmic framework equated to the navel of a mother and the source of life.[195] Similar concepts appear in the Book of Jubilees 8:19 and in the Book of Enoch 26:1, which describes Mount Zion as "The center of the navel of the earth".[195]Samaritan tradition sees Mount Gerizim as the navel of the earth, the only place not submerged in the deluge in the account of Noah's Ark.[195] The phrase "navel of the earth" occurs in (Ezek 38:12; Judg 9:37) Aramaictibbur ("navel") and the concept recurs in Ezek 16:4.[195] According to Samaritan tradition, God made Adam from the dust of Mount Gerizim.[197][need quotation to verify] The belly-dancing tradition of Mediterranean and Middle Eastern cultures also celebrates the navel.[198] When Pope Urban II called (1095) for the First Crusade, he referred to Jerusalem as "the navel of the world".[199]
Bans and controversies
In Egypt, dancing in public with an uncovered navel is illegal, so many dancers wear a body stocking or netting to cover their skin.[200] An Egyptian singer named Ruby upset members of parliament and the TV authority, resulting in a ban on music videos showing a woman's navel.[201][202][203]
Indian culture
Ancient times
Didarganj Yakshi, a sculpture of a woman in navel-exposing attire.Depiction of Vishnu as Padmanabha or 'The Lotus-navelled One' on the cover of the Hindu religious text Vishnu Purana published by Gita Press. According to Hindu belief, the creator deity Brahma manifested out from the lotus which grew on Vishnu's navel, for which Brahma is referred as Padmayoni or 'The One born from the Lotus'.
While the West was relatively resistant to midriff-baring clothing until the 1980s, it has long been a fashion with Indian women.[204] These women, especially those from Southern India, have traditionally worn saris that bare the midriff.[205][206] Women from Rajasthan leave the midriff exposed while wearing Ghagra Cholis.[207] These women often cover their heads with dupattas,[208] and may cover their faces in front of strangers with ghoonghats. There is a belief associated with the religious in India that navel-baring has a symbolic, almost mystical, association with birth and life, and that the display is meant to emphasize the centrality of nature in the nurture role.[209] In ancient Indian tradition, the navel of the god Vishnu is considered to be the center of the universe and the source of life.[210] From his navel a new world emerges. This has been depicted in many ancient Indian sculptures as a lotus emerging from the navel on which god Brahma is seated.[211][212]
Although women in ancient India wore saris that bared the midriff, the Dharmasastra writers stated that women should be dressed such that the navel was never visible,[213] and navel exposure became taboo.[214] The trend of exposing the navel was started by women who were dancers, acrobats, or entertainers, and who developed a technique of wearing the sari like a pair of trousers well below the navel to assist in the free movement of the legs.[215] Women in this type of attire are very common in many ancient Indian sculptures,[216] and paintings.[217]
Indian sculpture emphasised the centrality and sexuality that emanated from the depiction of the woman's navel. One of the most stunning examples would be Didarganj Yakshi, a statue of a woman made during the Mauryan period. Carved out of sandstone, which gives it a natural shine where the navel is deeply embedded within the centre of the torso, drawing the focus of the viewer.[218] Before sculpting, the sculptors created an image and indicated the six structural centers, of which the navel is one, as defined by Yoga principles.[219] Technically, the typical female representation in ancient Indian art includes an hourglass figure with large hips, breasts, and buttocks, and a deep navel.[220] According to Indian physiognomy, if a woman's navel is deep, she is popular and loved by her husband. A broad, fleshy, shallow navel indicates a lucky woman. A woman with deep navel with a whirl to the right side is considered auspicious and is expected to lead a comfortable life.[221][222] Famous Indian painter M. F. Husain once commented, "The belly button has always been in. It has been an intrinsic part of the Indian woman. It has been part of Indian sculptures that go back so many centuries. That is why so many years ago, even in the 50s, all my works had women show their belly buttons."[223][224][225]
Recent times
With their migration to different countries, many Indian women began to wear the normal sari below the waistline, exposing the navel in a style known as a low-rise or low hip sari.[226][227][228] The trend started during the 1950s, when saris were worn below the navel, with big pleats that were tightly draped across the curves of the body.[229] Due to liberalization and changing global markets, saris are re-emerging as erotic apparel.[230][231] As a result, saris began to be designed in innovative ways using different materials, such as transparent and semi-transparent saris made of sheer fabrics like chiffon.[232][233][234] These modern saris may be draped in different ways,[235] such as a petticoat being tied about 10 to 13 cm (4 to 5 in) below the navel, just above the pubic area, and a small blouse ending just below the breasts with a thin pallu exposing some part of the blouse and almost the entire midriff.[236] In September 2012, The New York Times featured a wedding announcement with an image of a woman of Indian heritage displaying her navel in a gagra choli for the first time.[237][238] This style was popularised by Bollywood celebrities[239] and other popular regional film industries, such as Tamil and Telugu cinema.[240][241][242][243]
In ancient Indian tradition, the navel of Lord Vishnu is considered to be the source of life and creativity. It is considered to be a symbol of birth and life. That means in ancient India, women would wear sari that bared their midriffs.[244]
Indian television actors have followed suit, wearing saris that expose more skin, including the navel, with viewers mimicking the styles.[245]
Sometimes the low-rise style is modified, with the navel being covered by the pallu when wearing a low-rise non-transparent sari. In some corporations in India, saris are required to be worn in a manner that avoids navel exposure.[255] Anita Gupta, Senior Vice-president at J. Walter Thompson in Chennai commented that formal wear for woman should not expose the navel.[256]
Indian cinema
Indian actresses have expressed comfort with the practice of exposing their navels in film, preferring it to showing cleavage and calling it uncontroversial.[257][258]
Female dancers of Bollywood have always exposed their navels, since Amrapali (1966),[259][260][261] with cameras focused on them.[262][263][264] In the 1968 Bollywood film Brahmachari, actress Mumtaz was seen in a Sharara sari showing her navel[225][257][265] for a song and dance number, "Aaj kal tere mere".[266] A Sharara has a long blouse top with a unique divided skirt bottom, which has less flow than lehenga. It fits like a loose pant until reaching the knee, where it flares out. The particular style of sari became extremely popular and was dubbed the Mumtaz Sari.[267][268] The 1981 film Ek Duuje Ke Liye, a remake of the 1978 Maro Charitra featured the replication of the "top spinning on the navel" scene with Rati Agnihotri.[269][270][271][272] She had stated in an interview, "Today, when someone asks me how I balanced the top, I don't have an answer.Those days we didn't have monitors, the luxury of too many rehearsals or retakes. I did what was expected of me, telling myself it was like dramatics day in school, only instead of the stage I was facing a camera".[273] The film Khalnayak (1993) was famous for the song "Choli ke Peeche" featuring Madhuri Dixit in navel-exposing attire.[274] In the 2003 film Jism, actress Bipasha Basu appeared in a foreplay scene with an ice cube on her navel.[262][275] Actress Aishwarya Rai showcased her navel in a brocadecholi and dipped ghagra for the hit song "Kajra Re" in the film Bunty Aur Babli (2005).[276][277][278][279]Katrina Kaif became famous for her dance performance showcasing her navel for the item numberSheila Ki Jawani for the 2010 film Tees Maar Khan.[261][280] Film critic Baradwaj Rangan stated on his blog in a review for the film, "Katrina Kaif makes her entry in the well-shot, well-scored Sheela ki jawani song sequence, brandishing a belly button that seems to have a life of its own".[281] For the 2011 film The Dirty Picture, actress Vidya Balan had acted in a scene where an egg put on her navel becomes an omelette.[282] She stated in an interview, "It was difficult to control laughter and Milan used to wait to get me into the character because all this was part of the song and dance of those times to market the Silk phenomenon".[283] Recently, Rakhi Sawant appeared in an item song "Latto Ghuma Re Chora" for the 2012 film Rakhtbeej in which a top is spun on her midriff and navel. She stated in an interview that the filming was painful since the director spun the sharp-pointed top 30 times on her midriff.[284][285]Kareena Kapoor, Katrina Kaif, Deepika Padukone and Priyanka Chopra are the hottest navel and midriff exposing queens of Bollywood. They are also known as 'Fantastic Four' of Bollywood. Actress Richa Chadda had commented in an event that she was asked during a shoot to reveal her navel in high-waisted pants.[286][287]
During the 1990s, scenes focusing on the female protagonist's navel were common in Tamil cinema.[292] Actress Sukanya became famous for a scene in the 1992 film Chinna Gounder, where the male protagonist spins a top on the female protagonist's navel.[293][294][295] The 1993 film Gentleman featured a scene in the song sequence where female protagonist's navel is poked with a sword.[296] In 1996, actress Nagma became known for acting in a food play scene in the Tamil film Love Birds, which involves the male protagonist breaking an egg and cooking it on her navel,[297][298][299] which was similar to a scene from Hot Shots! (1991) involving Valeria Golino.[300] In the early 2000s Simran Bagga was known for her navel exposure in films. Her pierced navel also drew many youths to the cinema for the 2002 film Pammal K. Sambandam. The 2011 film Siruthai has a scene in which Tamannaah shows her navel to Karthi for arousing him because the character of Karthi has a belly fetish.
In his review of Isai (2015), film critic Baradwaj Rangan stated that "Sulagna brings to mind the heroines of a certain era who were chosen not because they had beautiful eyes or a bewitching smile but because of the quiver-quotient of their navel when confronted by a close-up."[301] Film critic Sudhir Srinivasan wrote in a review for the 2016 film Aranmanai 2, "The emphasis is not so much on making a horror story that is novel, than it is on fixating on the heroine's navel."[302]
Telugu cinema
Of the South Indian film industries, Telugu cinema more frequently has actresses expose their navels.[289][303][304] Film scholar Mahesh Kathi commented that Telugu cinema has a long history of "fondness for the navel", citing old South Indian temple architecture, which features numerous prominent displays of navels in their carvings, and calling such displays a "South Indian aesthetic sensibility". He continued, "Cinematically, while cleavage is just a peek at the bosom, the navel encompasses the woman's entire sensuality."[305]
The 1978 film Maro Charitra was the first to feature the scene where a top spins on the female protagonist's navel.[306]
Veteran Telugu film director Kovelamudi Raghavendra Rao's movies always have guaranteed navel show of the heroines.[307] He used to include the navel of the heroine in every possible frame[308] and exploit it in song sequences such as dropping of water, flowers, fruits, ice cubes etc., on the navel.[309] Prominent Telugu actor and director Dasari Narayana Rao had once commented, "When you see a heroine slightly removing her pallu to show her inside assets, you don't feel ashamed of it because of the artistic way in which Ragahvendra Rao projects it on the screen. Especially heroines' navels look most beautiful in his movies."[310][311][312]
Telugu actor and politician Chiranjeevi had commented in a TV show, "If you want to know about fruits, you have to do one film with director K. Raghavendra Rao. He used to put all the fruits around the heroine's navel (boddu)."[313][314]
In 2016, actress Pragya Jaiswal had requested Raghavendra Rao to have a shot with fruits and flowers on her navel as part of a song sequence. She told in an interview, "That's the third day of shooting with KRR sir and we're canning a song. But actually he's not making any flower or fruit thrown at my navel or waist, that's why I took courage to ask him to hit my navel with them."[315][316]
The 2013 Telugu film Action 3D paid tribute to Raghavendra Rao with a song featuring his symbolic acts on the female protagonist's navel.[317][318][319]
A song sequence in the 2012 Telugu spoof film Sudigadu features the main protagonist dropping a watermelon and a pumpkin on the female protagonist's navel.[320][321]
Actress Monal Gajjar who has acted in the scene had commented on an interview, "When the hero throws it on my tummy I am supposed to scream with a strange sound and they told me they are not real, all are toy fruits."[322]
Bengali cinema
The navel culture is moderately popular in Bengali industry. Though during the last decade it has been popularised. During the 1990s, actresses like Rituparna Sengupta, Rachana Banerjee, Indrani Halder, etc. started showing off their navels in sarees mostly. Actress Rituparna Sengupta shows her navel during recent times also. Her navel has been spotted often in her recent films. Actress Koel Mallick kept her navel hidden for a long time, but in the movie Arundhati she bared her tummy completely and showed off her navel which created a storm among the fans. She has not exposed her navel after that movie. Actress Sreelekha Mitra did a bare tummy show in the movie Ashchorjyo Prodeep; in the scene she wore a blouse and petticoat and her stomach was bare. In recent times, actress Raima Sen has shown off her navel twice. In the movie Roga Howar Sohoj Upay, Raima in a scene removes her saree and holds her lower belly in one hand in order to check her lower belly fat, her navel is seen from close up. In the web series Hello Season 1, in an episode, Raima is seen to be lying on her bed removing the pallu of her saree, and her husband is seen to be playing with her tummy. Raima then points to her navel and says that she wants a tattoo below it but her husband objects. Actress Arunima Ghosh has done a couple of navel baring songs in the movies Bonku Babu and Eagoler Chokh. Swastika Mukherjee has shown her navel in the movie Shaheb Bibi Golaam and in the web series Dupur Thakurpo. Actress Subhashree Ganguly has exposed her navel many times during the last eight years. She has bared her navel in the movies like Boss, Romeo, Bachchan, and in the movie Prem Ki Bujhini where the hero often got distracted due to heroine's unintentional navel show. Subhashree is especially known for showing her navel in ultra-low waist dresses where a larger portion of her lower belly is also shown, but after her marriage, she has decreased her expose. Actress Nusrat Jahan is quite regular with her navel show, from the onset of her career, even after her marriage she equally continues to show her navel. In the movie Khiladi the actress teases the hero by intentionally dropping her pallu and showing her navel. Another renowned actress Mimi Chakraborty has also started exposing her bellybutton in the last 2–3 years. Previously she always kept it covered, but in the movie Total Dadagiri she wore belly showing dresses in the songs of the movie. After some time she made a feather tattoo on her lower belly, after this incident she started full-fledged navel showing in her movies and photoshoots mostly to show her tattoo. Her navel can be spotted in most of her recent photographs. Bengali Actress Srabanti Chatterjee has kept her navel hidden till date. Only in one of the songs of the movie Bagh Bandi Khela her pallu flies off and her navel is exposed for a couple of seconds. Actress Madhumita Sarkar showed her navel in the movie Love Aaj Kal Porshu. Madhumita has started full-fledged navel showing in recent times as almost all of her recent posts in social media clearly show her navel. Actress Ritabhari Chakraborty is also known for exposing her navel in her toned abs and mostly ultra-low waist dresses. Actresses like Bibriti Chatterjee and Rii Sen are known for baring their navel piercings in their pics. Besides actresses like Paoli Dam, Sayantika Banerjee, Tanusree Chakraborty, Koushani Mukherjee, Rittika Sen has done occasional navel exposures.
Contradictions
The Censor Board of India for Indian cinema has created some limitations on "vulgar" visuals, such as restricting zoom shots of the navel, kissing the navel, and squeezing the navel and waist. These limitations had been implemented during the 1990s.[323][page needed][324][325][326] Many films have faced censor cuts for navel scenes.[327][328][329][330]
Many actors have expressed mixed views on the display of and emphasis of the navel. Some feel displaying the midriff or navel cannot be considered exposing when compared to Hollywood films.[331] Actress Shilpa Shetty argued, "If navel-showing is obscenity, then our traditional Indian outfit—the traditional sari—should be banned in the first place."[332] Actress, BJP member and CBFC member Jeevitha while speaking on item numbers stated, "Dance numbers are okay, but girls don't need to dress vulgarly. They can wear skirts but not too much below the navel."[333][334] Telugu film director Krishna Vamsi commented, "All film-makers have problems with the censors. They sometimes object to showing the navel of a woman when, in other films, it is allowed. We cannot even question them. The censors should give us general rules in writing as to what is allowed and what is not, instead of taking decisions according to their whims and fancies."[335] Actor R. Madhavan commented, "I have often been embarrassed to see certain films I have done. ... when I see myself kissing a dancing heroine's navel in some films, I feel ashamed."[336] Actress Taapsee Pannu commented, "I believe the navel is overrated. I think sensuality can be expressed in other ways."[305] Bengali actress Swastika Mukherjee said, "I am not very comfortable though I have tried wearing a lehenga choli with a stick-on in my navel."[258] Many actresses have opted to hide their navels by wearing trikinis for beach or pool scenes.[337][338]
Japanese culture
Dogū figurine of the late Jōmon period with the navel indicated with a deep indentation.
Early times
Japanese women performing a traditional Japanese dance Yosakoi in navel-exposing attire in the Yosakoi Matsuri 2006 at Kōchi
Japan has long had a special regard for the navel. During the early Jōmon period in northern Japan, three small balls indicating the breasts and navel were pasted onto flat clay objects to represent the female body. The navel was exaggerated in size, informed by the belief that the navel symbolizes the center of where life begins. On many middle Jomon figurines, the significance of the navel was emphasized with an indentation or hole. Sometimes, the importance of the navel was further enhanced by connecting with a line from the navel towards the chest.[339] Early Japanese poems feature many references to the female navel. In some, the word navel actually refers to an indentation or hole instead of the belly button.[340][341] The shape of the umbilicus of a newborn baby would be discussed at length. If a baby's navel points downward, the parents would brace themselves for a weakling child who will bring them woe. The thunder god Raijin, with his terrifying drums, great horns, and long tusks, was said to have an insatiable appetite for young navels, and mothers had to nag their youngsters constantly to keep themselves well covered up.[342] Due to the mythology, navel exposure was not encouraged in the earlier times. The traditional clothing of Japanese women has a wide cloth belt around the midriff to protect the belly and keep it warm. The Japanese believe the belly is the source of person's warmth and that the perfect navel is an innie.[343]
Modern times
Although navel exposure has become a recent trend in fashion in Japan, annual Heso Matsuri ("belly button festivals")[344] have been held in Japan since the late 1960s. The tradition of the HokkaidoHeso Odori ("belly button dance") began in 1968.[345] Dancers make their heso ("belly button") into a face, using paint, special costumes, and props. Many variations of the dance have been developed, leading to competitions among dancers, who compete for prizes in various categories.[346][347][348][349]
A similar type festival is held at Shibukawa, north of Tokyo. The idea was formed based on the location of Shibukawa, which is also referred to as the "Belly Button of Japan". The festival is based on a traditional Japanese form of entertainment where revelers paint a face on their torsos and stomachs to appear as a head. A kimono is wrapped around the waist, and the person's real head is hidden by a large cloth hat. The belly button is traditionally painted into a mouth. In recent years, modern motifs and Japanese anime designs have appeared in the festival.[350][351]
Sri Lankan culture
7th-century Sigiriya frescoes depicting women in navel-exposed attire
Ancient times
Sinhalese women performing a traditional Sri Lankan dance in navel-exposing attire
Sigiriya frescoes depict royal ladies wearing cloth draped as a dhoti, tied in a knot at the front and pulled down to expose the navel. They wear pleated robes from the waist upwards, as well a necklace, armlets, wristlets, ear and hair ornaments, and display their breasts. The ladies in waiting wear waist clothes, a few ornaments and a firm thanapatiya ("breast bandage").[352]
In the Sinhalese poetic work Kaviyasekara, a father advises his married daughter as to proper clothing, "Dress your garment above your navel, without exposing the fair bosom, and expose not your teeth in laughing."[353]
In his work Daily Code for the Laity (1898), the Buddhist leader Anagarika Dharmapala wrote that a sari blouse must be long, fully covering a woman's breasts, midriff, navel, and back.[354]
Recent times
In the 1980s and 1990s, a visible navel was very rare. By the late 1990s, the Bollywood connection and the media and technological changes that occurred in India had influenced Sri Lanka's fashion outlook, with the navel becoming a focus in the modern Sri Lankan wardrobe.[355] Sri Lankan films commonly depict the women of the country's earliest history as scantily clad with exposed navels, and the country has become more open to the topic in general.[355] In Nov 2015, Western Province Chief Minister Isura Devapriya stated that a school dress code for students and teachers would be issued requiring that the navel be covered. However, the Ceylon Teachers Union President Joseph Stalin condemned it and commented, "We condemn this statement. It is an anachronistic proposal. We see nothing wrong with teachers wearing sarees below the belly button. It may be that there is something wrong with Mr. Devapriya’s eye sight. We like to ask the Chief Minister whether the belly button is the main concern facing the education sector in the Western Province".[356]
In 2004, the President of IndonesiaSusilo Bambang Yudhoyono spoke out against exposed navels, saying, "Indonesian women, who are known for their courtesy, should refrain from exposing their midriffs or belly buttons, which now seems to be taken for granted. There are many ways to express beauty, as part of aesthetics, and to express freedom but not by showing things that lead to pornography." He further added that while the state could not dictate dress codes, citizens were expected to respect the country's moral values and courtesy. A week later, a cabinet minister quoted Yudhoyono as saying that he felt "disturbed and uneasy" to see television shows in which women exposed their navels.[357][358]
In 2006, Agus Suwage, an Indonesian artist, installed his Pinkswing Park exhibit at Jakarta's international biennale. The exhibit was surrounded by massive panels with multiple pictures of a near-naked man and woman frolicking in a park. Within days of the exhibition's launch, Islamic fundamentalists had descended on the biennale, forcing its closure and demanding prosecutions. At first police claimed his work blasphemed the story of Adam and Eve; a few weeks later they told Suwage he faced five years in jail for producing pornography. The Indonesian parliament decided to introduce a sweeping anti-pornography law. The law imposes a rigid social template; couples who kiss in public will face up to five years' jail, as would anyone flaunting a "sensual body part"—including their navel—and tight clothing will be outlawed.[359][360][361] Due to this new anti-pornography law, topless bathing and surfing on the beaches of Bali, a common practice among tourists, would also be prohibited. The law would also affect older tribal women, who often still walk topless.[360][362][363] The introduction of a bill was attacked by women's rights campaigners in the country, who fear it is the first step towards the implementation of Islamic Sharia law.[364][365]
Traditionally, Korean women are expected to dress modestly. The traditional wear such as Hanbok cover the entire body.[369]
South Korean singer Yuri performing at KBS Hope Concert in January 2013
1990s
During the 1990s, the fashion trend among young South Korean women for wearing cropped T-shirts that leave the midriff exposed had started, due to the hot climatic conditions. The trend spread to create changes in female fashion such that when a policeman in Gwangju arrested two young women for flaunting their belly buttons in the street, the judge threw the case out, ruling that the flashing of a female navel was not indecent.[370] It further became popular due to Korean pop culture, where K-pop stars started wearing body piercings[371] and midriff-exposing shirts.[372][unreliable source?] In July 1997, the South Korean broadcaster KBS announced tough new rules for pop stars appearing on TV. One among the many limitations was "no exposing of navels".[373]
2000s
During the 2000s, it became common among young women to expose their belly buttons by rolling up their shirts similar to a crop top. During sport events such as football, the female audience apply body paints or temporary tattoos around their belly buttons.[374] In 2010, Korean girl group Rainbow's dance routine that involved lifting up their shirts to expose their navels became popular. The band stated in an interview, "We have to keep our abs in shape for the belly button dance."[375][unreliable source?] But the routine was subsequently has been banned.[376][377][378][unreliable source?] The SBS TV show Inkigayo told girl groups to restrain showing their skin too much and about their outfits.[379][unreliable source?][380] In 2013, Yoona, a member of Korean girl band Girls' Generation, caused a minor controversy by revealing an exposed midriff featuring a protruding cantaloupe-like outie navel, which started a spirited discussion and polarized opinions on the Chinese-language internet.[381][382][unreliable source?]
Although, the formal wear is expected to cover the stomach and belly button.[383]
Malay models in attire that covers the navel at a fashion show in Kuala Lumpur in April 2011
Malaysian culture
In 2005, Vivienne, a virtual girlfriend created by software maker Artificial Life Inc. of Hong Kong, was reprogrammed not to bare her navel or display body piercings in conservative Muslim countries including Malaysia to avoid problems.[384] In 2006, Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat gave his blessings to an Islamic form of dance clubs to serve as entertainment outlets at Kota Bharu. He commented that there must be proper attire for women, including clothes that do not reveal the navel, saying Muslim women must be covered from head to toe except for their face and hands, while Muslim men must be decently dressed when in public.[385] Under Malaysian government rules for stage performances, a female artist must be covered from her shoulders to her knees. This law prevented pop icon Beyoncé Knowles from performing in navel-exposing attire in 2007.[386][387] Beyoncé canceled the show amid opposition from local groups, calling the cancellation a result of a "scheduling conflict".[388]
Views in alternative medicine from antiquity
Saint Thomas Aquinas considered the navel as the "bodily metaphor for spiritual things".[389]
According to Ayurveda, the navel is an important site in the human body. Nearly 72,000 subtle nerves, or nadis converge in this area.[395] By the principles of Ayurveda and yoga, the human body is made up of six chakras, with the Manipura chakra located at the spine directly behind either the navel or the solar plexus, depending on the system, while its kshetram, or superficial activation point, is located directly on the navel and represents the element fire.[396][page needed][397][398][399]Vayu or vital wind as specified in Ayurveda, is divided into five sub categories. Of these, Samāna Vayu, situated in the navel region, is believed to aid in digestion and give physical strength to the body.[400][401]
According to Ayurvedic principles, navel displacement is a condition in which the navel center shifts.
This might create digestive disorders. Proper practice of yoga is considered to be a remedy to realigning the navel.[402]
Sri Lankan medicine
In Sri Lanka traditional medicine, a composition of herbs, powdered pepper, and water is applied as a paste to the navel as a remedy for stomach aches.[403] During difficulties in delivery, a betel leaf is placed on the woman's navel, which is believed to be under a spell.[404]
Russian medicine
Laying wormwood on the female navel or spreading a paste of reindeer lichen on the navel were considered by Russian women to make the delivery of a child fast and painless.[405]
Chinese medicine
In the Chinese art of acupuncture, the navel is sometimes referred to as 神阙 (shénquè, roughly translating to divine imperfection or mark of the ancestors). Often, the navel is used as a moxibustion point. However, the navel itself is not used in acupuncture due to the likelihood of infection.[citation needed]
^Associated Press. "Broadcasters Decide to Dissolve Their Radio-TV Advertising Codes". The Miami Herald, 6 January 1983, 19A. NewsBank. Web. 22 February 2013.
^Collins, Bill. "Changes Are Few in TV Ads". The Philadelphia Inquirer. 24 February 1983: C08. NewsBank. Web. 22 February 2013.
^ abMurphy Ronald E (1992) "Song of songs, Book of", in The Anchor Bible Dictionary, vol 6. p. 151
^ abcdDobbs-Allsopp F. W. (2001) Annotation and commentary on "Song of Solomon" in 'The New Oxford Annotated Bible' (with the Apocrypha. Third Edition (Ed) Coogan, M.D. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001. page 966 from pages 959–968
^ abcThe New Oxford Annotated Bible. New Revised Standard Version. Oxford: Oxford University Press 2001.
^ abcdefghijSperling, D (1976). "Navel of the earth". In Keith Crim; Victor Paul Furnish; Lloyd Richard Bailey Sr.; et al. (eds.). The Interpreter's Dictionary of the Bible: An Illustrated Encyclopedia (Supplementary Volume). Nashville: Abingdon Press. pp. 622–623. ISBN978-0687192694.
^Gaster T. H. (1962). "Samaritans". In George Arthur Buttrich (ed.). The Interpreters Dictionary of the Bible. Vol. 4. Abingdon Press. p. 196. ISBN978-0687192731.
^Hobin, Tina (2003) Belly Dance: The Dance of Mother Earth. Marion Boyars Publishers Ltd. London. New York p. 173-195. ISBN978-0714530918.
^"Dressing the Indian woman through history". BBC News Magazine. 6 December 2014. In southern India, even in colonial times, some women did not cover the upper part of their body.
^ ab"She who dares to bare". The Telegraph. Calcutta, India. 4 August 2008. Archived from the original on 17 September 2012. Retrieved 13 March 2012.
^Günther Schlee (2010). How Enemies Are Made: Towards a Theory of Ethnic and Religious Conflict. Berghahn Books. p. 95. ISBN9781845457792. Musical films produced in Bombay (Mumbai) target family audiences and are completely harmless in most parts of the world. Due to the particularities of Indian women's fashion, however, the navel of the dancers is often visible.
^Edward Buscombe (2003). Cinema Today. Phaidon. p. 388. ISBN9780714840819. Dancing has become increasingly eroticized, with the camera closing in on the female star's erogenous zones, especially the navel, which traditional costume conveniently leaves ...
^Robin D. Gill (2007). "Balls". The Woman Without a Hole – & Other Risky Themes from Old Japanese Poems. Paraverse Press. p. 192. ISBN9780974261881.
^Robin D. Gill (2007). "Balls". Octopussy, Dry Kidney & Blue Spots, Or, Senryû: Dirty Themes from 18-19c Japanese Poems. Paraverse Press. p. 192. ISBN9780974261850.
^Bret Stephens (3 April 2007). "Hips don't lie"(PDF). The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original(PDF) on 16 January 2013. Retrieved 2 June 2014.
_03.jpg)
