The Hon. Justice

David Maraga

EGH
David K. Maraga in October 2016
14th Chief Justice of Kenya
In office
19 October 2016 – 12 January 2021
Appointed byUhuru Kenyatta
Preceded byWilly Mutunga
Succeeded byMartha Koome
Judge, Court of Appeal
In office
January 2012 – October 2016
Presiding Judge, Court of Appeal, Kisumu
In office
October 2014 – October 2016
Personal details
Born
David Kenani Maraga

(1951-01-12) 12 January 1951 (age 70)
Nyamira, Kenya
NationalityKenyan
Spouse(s)Eucabeth Nyaboke
Children3
Alma materUniversity of Nairobi (LLB)
University of Nairobi (LLM)
OccupationChief Justice of Kenya
ProfessionJudge

David Kenani Maraga (born 12 January 1951) is a Kenyan lawyer and jurist. He was the 14th chief justice and president of the Supreme Court of Kenya from October 2016 till his retirement in January 2021.[1][2]

Early life and education

Maraga was born in Bonyamatuta, Nyamira County, on 12 January 1951.[2] He attended Sironga DEB Primary School from 1961 to 1967 for his Certificate of Primary Education (CPE), Maranda High School from 1968 to 1971 for his East African School Certificate (O Level), and Kisii High School from 1972 to 1973 for his East African Advanced Certificate of Education (A Level).

He studied law at the University of Nairobi, and was awarded a Bachelor of Laws in 1977. He also holds a post-graduate diploma awarded in 1978 by the Kenya School of Law.[2] He was admitted to the Kenyan bar in October 1978.

He later obtained a Master of Laws from the University of Nairobi in 2011. He practices Seventh Day Adventist religion.[3]

Early legal career

Following his admission to the Kenyan bar in 1978, David Maraga ran a private law practice for over 25 years in Nakuru, specializing in civil and criminal litigation as well as conveyancing.[4] He served from 1987 to 1989 as the chairperson of the Rift Valley Law Society.

Judicial Career in the High Court and Court of Appeal

High Court

Justice Maraga joined the bench as a High Court Judge in October 2003 having been appointed by President Mwai Kibaki. Subsequently, he served as a judge of the High Court in Mombasa (2003–2007), Nakuru (2008–2010), and Nairobi (2010–2011).

He also served in various leadership roles, including as the resident judge, High Court of Kenya in Nakuru from May 2009 to August 2010 and as the presiding judge of the Family Division of the High Court in Nairobi from April 2010 to December 2011.

Vetting

Main Article: Kenya Judges and Magistrates Vetting Board

Since he was appointed to a judicial office before the 2010 Constitution of Kenya came into force, Justice Maraga went through the mandatory vetting by the Judges & Magistrates Vetting Board in 2012. The Vetting Board unanimously declared him fit to continue serving in office, though his vetting took a dramatic twist when he demanded a Bible and swore before the vetting panel that he had never taken a bribe in his judicial career and would never take bribes in future.[5]

Court of Appeal

He was elevated to the Court of Appeal in January 2012 following an interview process by the Judicial Service Commission.[5]

A year after joining the Court of Appeal, he vied for the position of president of the Court of Appeal, losing by a solitary vote to the Justice Kihara Kariuki who served as the president of the court before his appointment as the attorney general.[6]

Justice Maraga served in the Court of Appeal in Nairobi from January 2012 to September 2014, and as the presiding judge of the Court of Appeal in Kisumu from October 2014 until his appointment as the chief justice two years later.

Judiciary Committee on Elections

Justice Maraga was appointed by retired Chief Justice Willy Mutunga in May 2012 as the vice chair of the Kenya Judiciary Working Committee on Election Preparations (JWCEP) which was constituted to ensure the judiciary was fully prepared to deal in a timely manner, with any disputes that would arise from the March 2013 General Election.[7]

As a result of the committee's work, the judiciary was in position to deal with all election petitions within the strict statutory timelines. The committee was thus reconstituted in August 2015 as a standing Committee and renamed the Judiciary Committee on Elections (JCE) with Justice Maraga as chairperson.[8]

Joseph Mutava judicial misconduct tribunal

In 2013, the president of Kenya named Justice Maraga as the chair of a tribunal which was constituted to investigate the conduct of High Court Judge Joseph Mutava after the Judicial Service Commission recommended a tribunal to investigate complaints that the Judge had been compromised to deliver a judgment which cushioned Goldenberg suspect Kamlesh Pattni from prosecution over his involvement in the Goldenberg scandal.[9]

The tribunal's work was delayed when the Judge challenged its constitutionality in the High Court, but was finally able to complete its work in September 2016. The tribunal submitted a report in September 2016, recommending to the president that Justice Mutava be removed from office for improperly allocating himself the Kamlesh Pattni file when it did not fall under his docket, and proceeding to write a judgment in the case even though the Judicial Service Commission was investigating his conduct.[10][11]

Justice Mutava challenged the findings of the tribunal before the Supreme Court but the highest court affirmed his removal in a March 2019 decision.[12] Justice Maraga abstained from these proceedings at the Supreme Court having chaired the tribunal that recommended the dismissal of the Justice Mutava.

Appointment to the Office of Chief Justice of Kenya

Following the voluntary early retirement of Dr. Willy Mutunga in June 2016, Justice Maraga was among the ten people who applied to replace him. Judge Maraga emerged victorious from a list of eminent judges, legal practitioners and scholars, including law professor Makau Mutua, Supreme Court of Kenya Judges Jackton Ojwang and Smokin Wanjala, East Africa Court of Justice Judge Aaron Ringera and his Court of Appeal colleague Alnashir Visram.[13]

JSC interview

During his interview before the Judicial Service Commission, Maraga told the JSC that in accordance with his Seventh Day Adventist faith, he would not work on Saturdays even if there was a need for Supreme Court Judges to handle presidential election disputes that are to be concluded within just 14 days and may require judges to sit on weekends. "It would be very difficult for me to sit on a Saturday to hear a case," Maraga said to a commission member's question. "I would rather talk with my colleagues in the court to accommodate me and exempt me from sitting if the hearing extends to a Saturday."[14]

Parliamentary vetting and confirmation hearing

Having been nominated for appointment by the Judicial Service Commission, his name was forwarded to the president, who transmitted it to the National Assembly for vetting before formal appointment.[15] The National Assembly voted unanimously to approve his appointment as the Chief Justice on 18 October 2016.[16]

Official appointment and oath of office

He was officially appointed by President Uhuru Kenyatta on 19 October 2016, when he took the oath of office as the 14th chief justice of independent Kenya and the second chief justice in Kenya's new constitutional dispensation.[17] Unlike his predecessor Willy Mutunga who showed up for his oath wearing a normal suit, Maraga took his oath of office in full judicial regalia, marking the return of colonial era British inspired judicial gowns and wigs that Mutunga had worked to eradicate.

Tenure as chief justice and president of the Supreme Court

Nullification of 2017 presidential election

Main Article: 2017 Kenyan general election

Joined by Deputy Chief Justice Philomena Mwilu and associate justices Isaac Lenaola and Dr Smokin Wanjala (with Associate Justices Njoki Ndung'u and Prof. J. B. Ojwang' dissenting), Chief Justice David Maraga made history by nullifying the August 2017 presidential election because of illegalities and irregularities that were presented by the petitioners. President Kenyatta was in the lead with 54% of the vote, but opponent Raila Odinga reported the evidence of the hacking to the Supreme Court. The Chief Justice ruling acquitted Kenyatta of any misconduct. The supporters of the president were disappointed with the ruling, while many Kenyans praised the ruling against President Uhuru Kenyatta, and restoring the independence of the judiciary. After issuing veiled threats against the Supreme Court Judges,[18] President Kenyatta told media outlets that he does not agree with a ruling that disappointed millions of his supporters, but he would respect and tolerate the ruling.[19][20]

While the chief justice and the rest of the Supreme Court Judges who nullified the 2017 presidential election were subjected to verbal attacks by the President, who called them crooks[21] and his supporters, this decision earned Maraga tremendous respect from people who praised him for his bravery and was a key pillar of his legacy as the Chief Justice. He is particularly remembered for stating in the brief ruling nullifying the election that "The greatness of any nation lies in its fidelity to the constitution and adherence to the rule of law and, above all, respect to God."[22]

Advisory on the dissolution of Kenya's Parliament

On 21 September 2020, Maraga issued an advisory calling on the President to dissolve Kenya's Parliament owing to the failure by Parliament to enact legislation which would give effect to a provision in Kenya's Constitution that requires gender quotas in all public bodies.[23] Under the 2010 Constitution, Kenya's Parliament had five years to enact legislation ensuring that no more than two-thirds of members of elective public bodies be of the same gender. The 2010 Constitution gives the Chief Justice the power to issue an advisory to the President to dissolve Parliament if a court has declared that Parliament has failed to enact any of the laws required to give full effect to the Constitution within the timelines provided in the Constitution. These laws, and the timelines within which they are to be enacted by Parliament, are listed in the Fifth Schedule to the Constitution.

The Two-thirds Gender Rule had been the subject of years of litigation by civil society organizations which resulted in numerous Court Orders requiring Parliament to pass the law but the House did not enact any such legislation despite several extensions of the original 5-year deadline. While the High Court issued orders freezing the advisory,[24] this move worsened the relations between the Executive headed by President Kenyatta and the judiciary under Maraga's leadership.

Petitions seeking removal over misconduct

Chief Justice David Maraga was the subject of several petitions inviting the Judicial Service Commission to remove him from office over gross misconduct. One such petition was filed in March 2019 by Yusuf Dimbil through lawyer Charles Koech on grounds that the Chief Justice allegedly attended Jubilee Party's political rallies, employed people from his ethnic Kisii group in the judiciary and made unconstitutional utterances.[25] Maraga had earlier been spotted attending a Jubilee Party rally headlined by President Kenyatta and his Deputy William Ruto in Kisii.[26] He was also accused of tribalism, employing only members of his Kisii tribe in his office. The petition claimed that nearly 85% of the staff in the Office of the Chief Justice under Maraga were from his Kisii ethnic group. These included his chief of staff, personal assistant, legal counsel, secretaries and other staff.

In August 2019, Francis Obilo filed a petition seeking the removal of the Chief Justice over his failure to name a three judge bench to hear a case that had been filed against the judiciary over the institution's failure to pay rent for a building which had been leased to house the Court of Appeal.[27] In 2013, the judiciary entered into a six-year lease agreement of Elgon Place in Upper Hill for an annual rent of Sh603.6 million to be used by the Court of Appeal. However, the building went unoccupied because the judges declined to occupy office spaces citing potential radiation risks.

Another petition seeking Maraga's removal was filed in March 2020 by activist Okiya Omtata who alleged that the Chief Justice had interfered with the independence of a judge in discharging his judicial functions by removing an active case file from the judge while judgment was pending.[28] The activist had filed a case in the Employment & Labour Relations Court to challenge a move by the government to re-advertise the vacancy for the auditor general.[29] On the day the Court was to deliver judgment, the presiding judge informed the parties that he had not been able to prepare the judgment since the Chief Justice had called for the file from his docket for unexplained reasons.

Yet another petition was filed in June 2020 by an activist who alleged that the Chief Justice had breached the Code of Conduct when he made public utterances condemning President Kenyatta for refusing to appoint 41 individuals nominated by the Judicial Service Commission for judicial appointment.[30][31]

Child-support case

On 30 June 2020, a 30-year-old woman caused a dramatic scene at the Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi, where she alleged that Chief Justice Maraga had neglected a child they had together in 2014 following an extra-marital affair. The woman also alleged that the Chief Justice had subsequently used his high office to frustrate her attempts to file a child support case in Kenyan Courts.[32] Speaking through his lawyers, the Chief Justice denied any knowledge of the woman while dismissing her claims as the latest in a well choreographed state-sponsored plot to undermine his office and malign his name. Maraga's lawyers highlighted several gaps in the woman's claims, including inconsistencies in the Birth Certificate she produced to support the child's parentage. The Children's Court in Nairobi dismissed the case three weeks later when it emerged that the woman had not paid the mandatory court filing fees.[33]

Retirement and legacy

Justice Maraga retired on 12 January 2021 when he turned 70 in accordance with Article 167(1) and 167(2) of the Constitution of Kenya which provides that an individual shall retire from the Office of the Chief Justice after serving for 10 years or on reaching the age of 70, whichever comes first. He handed the leadership of the judiciary to Lady Justice Philomena Mwilu, deputy chief justice and vice president of the Supreme Court, who would serve as the Acting Chief Justice and president of the Supreme Court until a substantive chief justice is appointed.[34]

In his valedictory message during his retirement ceremony, Justice Maraga indicated that he was proud to be leaving behind "a strong Judiciary, a professional and enthusiastic corps of Judges and Judicial Officers as well as staff who [were] deeply committed to the administration of justice, and an increasingly enlightened public whose confidence in and demand for [the Judiciary's] services grows by the day."[35]

Many Kenyans admire Justice Maraga's uncompromising fidelity to his faith. He also earned the praise of many Kenyans for his bravery and integrity, especially following the nullification of the 2017 presidential election results, his advisory calling on the President to dissolve Kenya's Parliament and his many public statements condemning the presidency over budgetary cuts and the failure to appoint the JSC's judicial nominees.

However, judiciary insiders have mixed views of his tenure. His reform record pales in comparison to his predecessor Willy Mutunga who achieved far reaching results with the Judiciary Transformation Framework. Maraga's legacy as an administrator was particularly tainted by the widespread perception that he preferred members of his Kisii ethnic group in appointments within the judiciary in general and his office in particular.

By the time he left office, the judiciary's relations with Parliament and the executive branch were at an all-time low. The judiciary suffered from constant budgetary cuts and the refusal of the President to appoint 41 judicial nominees despite several orders from the High Court. These challenges can be blamed in part on the August 2017 decision of the Supreme Court to nullify President Kenyatta's win, following which the President threatened to pursue unspecified retaliatory measures against the judiciary. As a show of this poor relationship, no senior officials from Parliament or the Executive attended his retirement and hand over ceremony. The leadership of the judiciary's close partners such as the attorney general, the police and the director of public prosecutions also snubbed the event.

Legal scholars are equally divided over his jurisprudential legacy. Kenyan judges of appeal (who sit in benches of 3) and the Supreme Court (who sit in benches of 5 or 7) do not publish information on which justice wrote a majority opinion. Unless an individual justice pens a dissenting opinion or a separate but concurring opinion, there is no way for outsiders to know which judge wrote a decision. Consequently, Maraga's judicial philosophy from his time in the Court of Appeal and in the Supreme Court is difficult to discern. Nonetheless, Justice Maraga is most remembered for his work as the chairperson of the Judiciary Committee on Elections and his electoral law jurisprudence which culminated in the nullification of the August 2017 presidential election results.

Personal life

David Maraga is married to Eucabeth Nyaboke, with whom they have three children.

Maraga is a staunch Seventh-day Adventist. He is an elder and a Bible study leader in the church. He was a member of the Constitutional Review Task Force of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, East African Union and the leader of the Public Affairs and Religious Liberty Department Nairobi Central Seventh-day Adventist Church

See also

References

  1. ^ BDA Staff (19 October 2016). "Uhuru swears in new Chief Justice David Maraga". Business Daily Africa. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  2. ^ a b c Kenyanlife.com (22 September 2016). "Chief Justice David Maraga Biography, Profile". Nairobi: Kenyanlife.com. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  3. ^ "Kenyan Adventist Chief Justice Advocates Christian Values for Legal Profession — and More News Shorts". spectrummagazine.org. Retrieved 18 April 2021.
  4. ^ Gisesa, Nyambega (22 September 2016). "David Maraga: CJ nominee who says he has never taken a bribe". Daily Nation. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  5. ^ a b Sandra Chao-Blasto (22 September 2016). "Full in-tray for Maraga after CJ appointment". Business Daily Africa. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  6. ^ Star Reporter (23 February 2013). "Kihara to head appellate court". The Star (Kenya). Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  7. ^ Judiciary of Kenya (24 October 2014). "History of the Judiciary Working Committee on Election Preparations". Nairobi: Judiciary of Kenya. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  8. ^ Judiciary of Kenya (25 February 2016). "Chief Justice Willy Mutunga to launch the Judiciary Committee on Elections (JCE) 2016-2019 Strategic Plan". Nairobi: Judiciary of Kenya. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  9. ^ Nation Reporter (31 May 2013). "Uhuru appoints tribunal to probe suspended judge Mutava". Daily Nation. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  10. ^ Abiud Ochieng, PSCU (21 September 2016). "Tribunal recommends Joseph Mutava's removal for misconduct". Daily Nation. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  11. ^ State House Nairobi (22 September 2016). "President Kenyatta receives report of tribunal that investigated Justice Mutava". State House Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  12. ^ Wakaya, Jeremiah (12 March 2019). "Supreme Court upholds tribunal decision to kick Justice Mutava out of office » Capital News". Capital News. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  13. ^ Ouma Wanzala, and Joel Muinde (12 July 2016). "Six shortlisted in race to fill Chief Justice position". Daily Nation. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  14. ^ "Kenyan Adventist Chief Justice Advocates Christian Values For Legal Profession-And More News Shorts". Spectrum Magazine. Retrieved 11 January 2019.
  15. ^ Agutu, Nancy (22 September 2016). "Judge David Maraga nominated Chief Justice". Daily Nation. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  16. ^ Ngirachu, John (18 October 2016). "MPs approve Maraga's nomination as Chief Justice". Daily Nation. Nairobi. Retrieved 19 October 2016.
  17. ^ "Uhuru swears in new Chief Justice David Maraga". The East African. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  18. ^ "Uhuru's 'wakora' slur angers social media". Nairobi News. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  19. ^ "David Maraga: The brave judge who made Kenyan history". Retrieved 3 October 2018.
  20. ^ "International Media Focus on Top Adventist Justice in Kenya". Retrieved 3 October 2018.
  21. ^ "Kenyan judges criticise Kenyatta over 'veiled threats'". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  22. ^ "Maraga's quote that left Kenyans mesmerized". Nairobi News. Retrieved 11 January 2021.
  23. ^ "Kenya Chief Justice Advises President to Dissolve Parliament". Bloomberg.com. 21 September 2020. Retrieved 11 January 2021.
  24. ^ Ogila, Japheth. "High Court suspends implementation of Maraga's Parliament dissolution call". The Standard. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  25. ^ "Man petitions JSC to sack Chief Justice David Maraga". Nation. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  26. ^ "Uproar as CJ David Maraga attends Uhuru rally in Kisii". Nation. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  27. ^ August 20 2019, Tuesday. "Petitioner wants Maraga removed over judges Sh146m rent row case". Business Daily. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  28. ^ Ogila, Japheth. "Omtatah files petition to remove Chief Justice David Maraga". The Standard. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  29. ^ January 17 2020, Friday. "Court halts recruitment of Auditor-General". Business Daily. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  30. ^ Mburu, Racheal (11 June 2020). "Rights activist seeks CJ Maraga's removal over misconduct » Capital News". Capital News. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  31. ^ "Petitioner seeks to have CJ Maraga removed from office for misbehaviour". Citizentv.co.ke. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  32. ^ "CJ Maraga speaks out as woman claims he's deadbeat dad – VIDEO". Nairobi News. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  33. ^ "Court offers CJ Maraga reprieve in child upkeep case". Nairobi News. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  34. ^ January 11 2021, Monday. "Mwilu takes helm of Judiciary as Chief Justice Maraga retires". Business Daily. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
  35. ^ "Valedictory message by Chief Justice David K Maraga – The Judiciary of Kenya". Retrieved 12 January 2021.