As Good as It Gets is known for the confrontation between Alfonso and McGillicutty, described as "five of the most intense minutes in ECW";[3] the bout between Bam Bam Bigelow and Spike Dudley, which featured the "must-see moment" of Bigelow lifting Dudley overhead and hurtling him into the audience;[4] and the bout between the recently debuted Jerry Lynn and Justin Credible, which was used to introduce and showcase the two future ECW mainstays.[5]
The event was attended by approximately 1,600 people.[1]
The opening bout was a tag team match pitting the Full Blooded Italians against the Hardcore Chair Swingin' Freaks. Balls Mahoney pinned Little Guido using the Nutcracker Suite, but Tommy Rich put Little Guido's foot on the ropes to break the pinfall, causing referee Jeff Jones to restart the match. Little Guido then pinned Balls Mahoney with a roll-up while he was still celebrating. Following the match, Jones bragged that with ECW commissioner Tod Gordon having left, he was now the highest authority in ECW, prompting senior referee Jim Molineaux to confront him before Mahoney gave Jones a chair shot.[5][6][7]
The fourth match was a singles bout between Bam Bam Bigelow and Spike Dudley. During the match, the much larger Bigelow used his power to dominate Dudley, at one point lifting him overhead and throwing him into the audience. Bigelow won the match by pinning Dudley with a diving splash. Following the match, Bigelow threw Dudley into the audience once again.[4][5][7][8][9]
Following the fifth bout, the Pitbulls (making their return after being absent for several months) came to the ring with Lance Wright, who was leading a faction of wrestlers who were "invading" ECW from the World Wrestling Federation. Pitbull #1 challenged Taz to face Pitbull #2. Taz came to the ring, receiving a powerbomb from Pitbull #2 before rallying to give Pitbull #2 a T-bone Tazplex following by the Tazmission. After Pitbull #1 pulled Pitbull #2 out of the ring, Taz attacked Lance Wright, giving him a T-bone Tazplex through a table at ringside. Taz then brawled with security guards until his rival Sabu came to the ring, with the two men brawling until they were separated.[6][7]
The sixth bout was a singles match between Sabu and the Sandman. The match ended in a no contest after Sabu threw a fireball in the Sandman's face.[5][6][7]
The penultimate bout was an intergender tag team match pitting Beulah McGillicutty and Tommy Dreamer against Bill Alfonso and Rob Van Dam. Early in the match, Dreamer injured his leg while performing a move from the top rope to the floor of the arena. After several minutes, Sabu came to the ring to help Van Dam, with the two men ultimately putting Dreamer through a table with a combination diving leg drop and Five Star Frog Splash. Van Dam then walked out on the match, while Dreamer was ruled to be unable to continue. The match was left as Alfonso versus McGillicutty. After McGillicutty hit Alfonso with a baking tray she had concealed under her shirt, he began bleeding heavily. The match ended when Alfonso attempted to give McGillicutty a powerbomb, only for her to reverse the move into a Hurricanrana for a pinfall victory.[2][3][5][6][7][10] Following the match, Alfonso was hospitalized for blood loss.[8]
