Elizabeth Kim is the pen name of an American journalist who authored the book Ten Thousand Sorrows, which is described as a memoir.

Early life

Kim was born in South Korea to a Korean mother and an American father. She was conceived most likely after the Korean Armistice Agreement, which ended the fighting in the Korean War.[1] According to Kim's memories, her father abandoned her mother, who was forced to return to her hometown alone and pregnant to seek assistance from her family. After Kim's birth, she lived with her mother in a hut at the edge of town, and worked in the rice fields. When Kim was a child, as she remembers it, her mother was killed by her grandfather and uncle in what she would later describe as an "honor killing".[2][3] Kim herself was left at a Seoul orphanage, with no record of her original name or her family.[4] Eventually, she was adopted by a minister and his wife and given the name Elizabeth.

Ten Thousand Sorrows

Writing and reactions

Kim was working as a journalist at the Marin Independent Journal and living in San Rafael, California, when literary agent Patti Breitman approached her about the possibility of writing a memoir. Kim was initially reluctant, but Breitman slowly convinced her of the idea; Breitman herself says that publishers were quite enthusiastic about the idea, and one even replied to her proposal within a day, simply asking her to "name a price". In the end, Kim received an advance of hundreds of thousands of dollars for her book; when it was published in May 2000, Kim quit her job at the Marin Independent Journal (despite her recent promotion to city editor) to tour in Canada, the United Kingdom, and the United States.[5]

Andrea Behr, writing for the San Francisco Chronicle, praised Kim's writing, comparing her book to Frank McCourt's Angela's Ashes, and stating that "she has the gift of telling her story with such clear-sighted, humble honesty, and such compassion, that it's just as fascinating and compulsively readable as it is devastating".[6] It was also reviewed favorably in O, Oprah Winfrey's magazine.[citation needed] Others were less positive. Salon reviewer Brigitte Frase described Kim's book as "brutal", "haunting and disturbing", and "an act of revenge", ending her review by stating that "I have read it so that you won't have to".[2]

Some critics suspected Kim's book of being fictional rather than autobiographical, with Hillel Italie of Associated Press expressing concern that Kim's vagueness regarding dates and locations prevented the book's facts from being verifiable.[7] It was particularly controversial in the Korean American community, some of whose members accused Kim of "exploiting the issue of biraciality" and "trying to take advantage of the [then] current interest in autobiographies, particularly those that involved violence against women".[8] Others objected to the description of her mother's murder as an "honor killing" as being inconsistent with Korean culture.[7] However, Korean American writer Kim Sun-jung defended the book, criticizing B. R. Myers, who lambasted what he described as the book's "ludicrous inaccuracies" about Korean culture, because Myers himself was not Korean.[9]

Reviews

Editions and translations

Ten Thousand Sorrows was published in the following editions:

It was translated into eleven languages. The below list gives unofficial translations of the foreign-language titles where the original title was not preserved.

Further editions were published in two of those languages:

References

  1. ^ Italie, Hillel (November 12, 2000), "Fact or fiction? The downfall of some memoirs are the flaws in the memories", Chicago Tribune, archived from the original on September 13, 2016, retrieved September 29, 2011
  2. ^ a b Frase, Brigitte (May 17, 2000), "'Ten Thousand Sorrows: The Extraordinary Journey of a Korean War Orphan' by Elizabeth Kim: An immigrant's brutal and disturbing memoir of abuse at the hands of fundamentalist parents and a sadistic husband", Salon, archived from the original on January 30, 2011, retrieved September 28, 2011
  3. ^ Lee, Margaret Juhae (December 25, 2000), "Korea's Fallout", The Nation, OCLC 203159788, retrieved September 26, 2011
  4. ^ Author Elizabeth Kim on being a Korean War Orphan, CNN, June 12, 2000, retrieved September 29, 2011
  5. ^ Marech, Rona (October 6, 2000), "Escaping Her Past: San Rafael author Elizabeth Kim, a Korean War orphan raised by fundamentalist parents in California, tells of her painful upbringing in a haunting memoir", San Francisco Chronicle, retrieved September 29, 2011
  6. ^ Behr, Andrea (May 7, 2000), "A Korean War Orphan Lives to Tell Her Story: A young girl survives a hellish situation in her native land, only to face more horrors in America", San Francisco Chronicle, retrieved September 29, 2011
  7. ^ a b Italie, Hillel (October 27, 2000), "Book Criticized for Factual Errors", Associated Press, retrieved November 14, 2022
  8. ^ Davis, Rocío G. (2007), Begin here: reading Asian North American autobiographies of childhood, University of Hawaii Press, p. 197, ISBN 978-0-8248-3092-2
  9. ^ Kim, Sun-jung (May 29, 2005), "The Remarkable B.R. Myers Revealed", JoongAng Ilbo, archived from the original on July 17, 2012, retrieved September 29, 2011((citation)): CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  10. ^ Koji Nnamdi (2000), Elizabeth Kim: "Ten Thousand Sorrows: The Extraordinary Journey of a Korean War Orphan", Washington, D.C.: WAMU, OCLC 426221805
  11. ^ Seiwoong Oh (2001), "Book Reviews — Ten Thousand Sorrows: The Extraordinary Journey of a Korean War Orphan", Western American Literature, 36 (2), ISSN 0043-3462, OCLC 94147883
  12. ^ Susan Soon-Keum Cox (2001), "Ten Thousand Sorrows, by Elizabeth Kim", Adoption Quarterly, 4 (3): 87–93, doi:10.1300/J145v04n03_06, ISSN 1092-6755, OCLC 207266672, S2CID 218645475
  13. ^ Tracy Dianne Wood (2008), "Chapter 2", Korean American literature: literary orphans and the legacy of Han, Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Riverside, ISBN 978-0-549-52376-5, OCLC 744022321
Categories