Binzer resigned as auxiliary bishop of Cincinnati in 2020 after a Vatican investigation concluded that he mishandled sexual abuse allegations against clergy.
Biography
Early life and education
Joseph Binzer was born on April 26, 1955, in Cincinnati, Ohio, one of seven children of Robert and Joan (née Metz) Binzer.[1] He received his early education at St. Ann School in Groesbeck, Ohio, and graduated from La Salle High School in Cincinnati in 1973.
After returning to Cincinnati, Binzer served as a resident associate at St. Bartholomew Parish in Finneytown, Ohio and as a member of the archdiocesan tribunal. He was master of ceremonies for Pilarczyk from 2000 to 2003. In 2003, Binzer was named chancellor of the archdiocese, pastor of St. Louis Parish in Cincinnati, and director of the archdiocese's Department of Executive Services. In addition to these posts, Binzer became vicar general of the archdiocese in 2007.[3]
Auxiliary Bishop of Cincinnati
On April 6, 2011, Binzer was appointed auxiliary bishop of the Archdiocese of Cincinnati and titular bishop of Subbar by Pope Benedict XVI.[5] He received his episcopalconsecration on June 9, 2011. Archbishop Dennis Schnurr was the principal consecrator. The principal co-consecrators were Pilarczyk and Bishop Robert Conlon. The episcopal consecration was held at Cathedral of St. Peter in Chains.[1]
In 2013, Binzer, as head of priest personnel, received allegations of improper behavior by Reverend Geoff Drew. According to parishioners of St. Maximilian Kolbe Parish in Liberty Township, Ohio, Drew had been giving bear hugs, shoulder massages, and leg pats to teenage boys in his parish. Binzer notified the Butler County Prosecutor's Office of these allegations, but they chose not to prosecute Drew. However, Binzer failed to notify Archbishop Dennis Schnurr about Drew. In 2018, the archdiocese transferred Drew to another parish.[6][7]
On July 30, 2019, Archbishop Schnurr put Drew on leave, saying that Drew had been sending inappropriate text messages to a teenage boy. In a letter to parents, the principal of St. Ignatius School, where Drew was a teacher, said that the archdiocese had never notified him about past allegations against Drew or mentioned monitoring him.[8] On August 5, 2019, Schnurr reprimanded Binzer for failing to notify them about the 2013 Drew allegations and removed Binzer as head of priest personnel. Some parishioners felt like the archdiocese was using Binzer as a scapegoat to cover its own failures.[6][9] That same month, Binzer resigned from the Child and Youth Protection Committee for the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.[10] In December 2021, Drew went on trial for the unrelated rape of a teenage boy 30 years earlier.[11]
Resignation and legacy
Binzer submitted his resignation as auxiliary bishop of Cincinnati to Pope Francis in late April 2020. At that time, Binzer was age 65, ten years below the mandatory retirement age of 75.[12] On May 7, 2020, the pope accepted it.[13][10] Binzer issued a public apology that said he had tendered his resignation after a Vatican investigation concluded that his handling of Drew's case had "a negative impact on the trust and faith" of the people of the archdiocese.[12]
A year after his resignation as auxiliary bishop, Binzer was assigned to pastoral duties at Corpus Christi Parish in Mt. Healthy, Ohio, and St. John Neumann Parish in Springfield Township, Ohio.[14]
