"Lay Lady Lay", sometimes rendered "Lay, Lady, Lay",[2] is a song written by Bob Dylan and originally released in 1969 on his Nashville Skyline album.[3] Like many of the tracks on the album, Dylan sings the song in a low croon, rather than in the high nasal singing style associated with his earlier (and eventually later) recordings.[4] The song has become a standard and has been covered by numerous bands and artists over the years.
Bob Dylan version
"Lay Lady Lay" was originally written for the soundtrack of the movie Midnight Cowboy but wasn't submitted in time to be included in the finished film.[5][6]Joel Whitburn said instead that the song was "written for his wife Sarah Lowndes".[7] In a 1971 interview for which transcripts were auctioned in 2020, Dylan said the song was written for Barbra Streisand, with Streisand later adding that Dylan wanted to sing a duet with her.[8]
Dylan's recording was released as a single in July 1969 and quickly became his fourth and last top 10 U.S. hit, peaking at #7 on the Billboard Hot 100 for the consecutive weeks of September 6 and 13.[9][10][11] The single did even better in the United Kingdom where it reached #5 on the UK Singles Chart.[12] Like many of the tracks on Nashville Skyline, the song is sung by Dylan in a warm, relatively low sounding voice, rather than the more abrasive nasal singing style with which he had become famous.[4] Dylan attributed his "new" voice to having quit smoking before recording the album, but some unreleased bootleg recordings from the early 1960s reveal that, in fact, Dylan had used a similar singing style before.[3]
Don Everly of the Everly Brothers recounted in a 1986 Rolling Stone interview that Dylan performed parts of the song for them after a late 1960s appearance by the duo in New York, as they were "looking for songs, and he was writing 'Lay Lady Lay' at the time."[13] Despite a popular story that the Everly Brothers rejected the song due to misunderstanding the lyrics as sexual in nature, Everly continued "He sang parts of it, and we weren't quite sure whether he was offering it to us or not. It was one of those awestruck moments."[13] In a 1994 interview Don Everly further explained the encounter, stating that "It really wasn't a business meeting ... It wasn't that kind of atmosphere."[14] The Everly Brothers later covered the song on their EB 84 album, 15 years after Dylan's release.
Dylan first played the song to group of singer-songwriters including Joni Mitchell, Graham Nash, and Kris Kristofferson at Cash's house outside of Nashville when they were passing a guitar and singing a song.[15] Drummer Kenny Buttrey has said that he had a difficult time coming up with a drum part for the song. Dylan had suggested bongos, while producer Bob Johnston said cowbells. In order to "show them how bad their ideas were", Buttrey used both instruments together. Kris Kristofferson, who was working as a janitor in the studio at the time, was enlisted to hold the bongos in one hand and the cowbell in the other. Buttrey moved the sole overhead drum mic over to these new instruments. When he switches back to the drums for the choruses the drumset sounds distant due to not being directly miked. The take heard on the album is the first take and is one of Buttrey's own favorite performances.[16]
The song was also a favourite of popular singer Madonna, "I used to listen to that one record, 'Lay Lady Lay', in my brother's bedroom in the basement of our house," she recalled. "I'd lie on the bed and play that song and cry all the time. I was going through adolescence; I had hormones raging through my body. Don't ask me why I was crying – it's not a sad song. But that's the only record of his that I really listened to."[17]
Written in the key of A major, or A Mixolydian,[20] the song's chord progression features a descending chromatic line and Dylan's voice occupies a range from F#2 to D4.[21] The bass is most often based on the chromatic descent or otherwise emphasizing the modal center of A. The chief hook in "Lay Lady Lay", a song with far more hooks than is typical for Dylan, is a recurring four-note pedal steel guitarriff.[3] The final verse is separated from the rest of the song by the bridge and an ascending organ riff also recurs in this verse. The song's distinctive drum part is performed by Kenny Buttrey, who regarded his contribution to the song as one of his best performances on a record.[22] Lyrically the song speaks of romantic and sexual anticipation as the singer beseeches his lover to spend the night with him.[3]
Billboard described "Lay Lady Lay" as an "Infectious and appealing folk number with a country flavor."[24]Record World said it was a "lovely and winning number."[25]Cash Box called it a "strong sales prospect to break onto best seller charts."[26]
The Byrds' recording of "Lay Lady Lay" was released as a single on May 2, 1969, and reached number 132 on the Billboard chart but failed to break into the UK Singles Chart.[39][40] The song was recorded as a non-album single shortly after the release of the Byrds' seventh studio album, Dr. Byrds & Mr. Hyde.[41] The Byrds decided to cover the song after Bob Dylan played the band his newly recorded Nashville Skyline album at band leader Roger McGuinn's house.[42] The Byrds recorded "Lay Lady Lay" on March 27, 1969, but producer Bob Johnstonoverdubbed a female choir on to the recording on April 18, 1969, without the Byrds' consent.[43] The single was then released and it was only after it had been issued that the band became aware of the addition of the female choir.[42][43] The group were incensed, feeling that the choral overdub was incongruous and an embarrassment.[44] The Byrds were so upset at Johnston's tampering with the song behind their backs, that they never again worked with him.[42]
Despite the band's displeasure with the finished single, many critics felt that the presence of the female choir added a dramatic touch which heightened the song's emotional appeal.[42] Journalist Derek Johnson, writing in the NME, commented "The harmonic support behind the solo vocal is really outstanding, largely because the Byrds have been augmented by a girl chorus. This, plus the familiar acoustic guitars, the attractive melody and the obstructive beat, makes it one of the group's best discs in ages."[42] When "Lay Lady Lay" was released on The Byrdsbox set in 1990, it was presented without its choral overdub at McGuinn's insistence.[44][45] This alternate version, without the female choir, was included as a bonus track on the remastered Dr. Byrds & Mr. HydeCD in 1997.[44] It was also included on the 2002 reissue of The Byrds Play Dylan and the 2006 box set, There Is a Season.[46][47]
Duran Duran version
Duran Duran recorded a pop rock version of the song, appearing as track five on their 1995 covers album, Thank You.[48] Nick Rhodes has stated on the band's official website (answering an Ask Katy question in 2008 about the second single taken from Thank You) "I seem to remember my concern at that time was, in fact, our record label's—Capitol in America and EMI for the rest of the world—deciding to split their decision on their choice for the first single, "White Lines" in the US and "Perfect Day" for the rest of the world. Hence, there was no worldwide focus and both territories forced to use the other track as their second single, so it didn't really work out to be an ideal situation for anyone. I'm not sure what I would've chosen for a second single, possibly "Lay Lady Lay", but then I am still very happy with the way "Perfect Day" turned out."[49]
American industrial metal band Ministry covered "Lay Lady Lay" during the eighth Bridge School Benefitcharity concert in October 1994, with Pearl Jam lead singer Eddie Vedder performing backing vocals.[50] a studio version of the song was recorded and released as a single from Ministry's sixth studio album, Filth Pig, in February 1996[51] and reached number 128 on the UK Singles Chart.[52] The song also appears on the band's 2008 covers album, Cover Up.[53] Initially, frontman Al Jourgensen wanted to cover Jimmy Webb song "Wichita Lineman", but had to choose another song after watching Urge Overkill performing it live.[54] During the recording, Bill Rieflin was asked to perform drums, but he rejected and quit the band shortly after,[55] with Rey Washam replacing him and thus making his debut with Ministry.[54]
The single release included two versions of "Lay Lady Lay"; one being the standard album version and the other being a shorter edited version. In the Rolling Stone magazine's review of Filth Pig, critic Jon Wiederhorn wrote that the cover "amalgamates a deep distorted bass line, clicking electronic percussion, jangling acoustic guitars, ominous curls of feedback and [Al] Jourgensen's trademark howls."[56] According to Jourgensen, Bob Dylan personally called him to say his version was "badass."[57]
^Rogan, Johnny. (1998). The Byrds: Timeless Flight Revisited (2nd ed.). Rogan House. p. 627. ISBN0-9529540-1-X.
^ abcdeRogan, Johnny. (1998). The Byrds: Timeless Flight Revisited (2nd ed.). Rogan House. p. 289. ISBN0-9529540-1-X.
^ abHjort, Christopher. (2008). So You Want To Be A Rock 'n' Roll Star: The Byrds Day-By-Day (1965-1973). Jawbone Press. pp. 208–209. ISBN978-1-906002-15-2.
^ abc"Dr. Byrds & Mr. Hyde". ByrdWatcher: A Field Guide to the Byrds of Los Angeles. Archived from the original on October 28, 2010. Retrieved September 20, 2009.
^Rogan, Johnny. (1998). The Byrds: Timeless Flight Revisited (2nd ed.). Rogan House. p. 471. ISBN0-9529540-1-X.
^ abDasein, Deena (February 1996). "Ministry Comes Clean"(transcription). Illinois Entertainer. Vol. 22, no. 4. pp. 26, 28. Retrieved June 13, 2018.
^Wurster, Jon (October 2011). "Back Through The Stack: Bill Rieflin"(pt. 1). Modern Drummer. Retrieved October 23, 2017. I have been known to say, with great pride, that my last act in Ministry was to refuse to play on their version of Dylan's "Lay Lady Lay," which appeared on Filth Pig.
