This is a list of known American football players who have played for the Buffalo All-Americans of the National Football League in 1920 - 1923. It includes players that have played at least one match with the team.

A

Ockie Anderson

B

Carl Beck, Jack Beckett, Bill Brace, Pete Bahan, Shirley Brick, Scotty Bierce

C

Glen Carberry, Eddie Casey, Bunny Corcoran, Frank Culver

D

Herb Dieter

E

Bill Edgar

F

Jack Flavin, Andy Fletcher, Fritz Foster

G

Moose Gardner, Buck Gavin, Gus Goetz, Gil Gregory, Mike Gulian, Charlie Guy

H

Andy Hillhouse, Tommy Holleran, Steamer Horning, Tommy Hughitt

K

Tex Kelly, Bill Kibler, Glenn Knack, Waddy Kuehl

L

Jim Laird, Barney Lepper, Lou Little

M

John Mahoney, Roy Martineau, Elmer McCormick, Heinie Miller, Frank Morrissey, Jim Morrow, Vince Mulvey

N

Bob Nash

O

John O'Hearn, Elmer Oliphant

P

Earl Potteiger

R

Bob Rawlings, Ben Roderick

S

Johnny Scott, Murray Shelton, Pat Smith, Gus Sonnenberg, Butch Spagna, Frank Spellacy, Herb Stein, Jack Sullivan

T

Karl Thielscher, Tiny Thornhill, Carl Thomas, Mike Trainor

U

Luke Urban, Eddie Usher

V

George Voss, Tillie Voss

W

Bill Ward, Bodie Weldon, James B. Wilson, Mike Wilson Red Werder, Lud Wray

Y

Swede Youngstrom