Seasons

Season 1 (1951–52)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
1	1	Amahl and the Night Visitors	Kirk Browning	December 24, 1951 (1951-12-24)
Restaged live several times.
N/A^[1]	2	Doctor Serocold	William Corrigan	January 6, 1952 (1952-01-06)
First appearance by child actress Lydia Reed
N/A	3	Love Story	William Corrigan	January 13, 1952 (1952-01-13)
N/A	4	The Big Build Up	William Corrigan	January 20, 1952 (1952-01-20)
Starring: Grace Kelly
N/A	5	The Story of Roger Williams	William Corrigan	January 27, 1952 (1952-01-27)
N/A	6	Florence Nightingale	William Corrigan	February 3, 1952 (1952-02-03)
N/A	7	Woman with a Sword	William Corrigan	February 10, 1952 (1952-02-10)
Starring: Jayne Meadows
N/A	8	The Plot to Kidnap General Washington	William Corrigan	February 17, 1952 (1952-02-17)
N/A	9	Mistress of the White House	William Corrigan	February 24, 1952 (1952-02-24)
Starring: June Lockhart
N/A	10	Prelude	William Corrigan	March 2, 1952 (1952-03-02)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as George Sand, and Alan Shayne as Frédéric Chopin
N/A	11	Juliette Low and the Girl Scouts	William Corrigan	March 9, 1952 (1952-03-09)
N/A	12	Constitution Island	William Corrigan	March 16, 1952 (1952-03-16)
N/A	13	Harriet Quimby	William Corrigan	March 23, 1952 (1952-03-23)
Starring: Sarah Churchill
N/A	14	The Vision of Father Flanagan	William Corrigan	March 30, 1952 (1952-03-30)
N/A	15	Ordeal by White House	William Corrigan	April 6, 1952 (1952-04-06)
Based on the life of Grover Cleveland
2	16	Amahl and the Night Visitors new production	Kirk Browning	April 13, 1952 (1952-04-13)
Live rebroadcast
N/A	17	Anne Bradstreet, Puritan Poetess	William Corrigan	April 20, 1952 (1952-04-20)
Starring: Sarah Churchill
N/A	18	Miracle in May	William Corrigan	April 27, 1952 (1952-04-27)
From the life of Edward Jenner
N/A	19	The Face of Spain	William Corrigan	May 4, 1952 (1952-05-04)
From the life of Francisco Goya
N/A	20	A Woman for the Ages	William Corrigan	May 11, 1952 (1952-05-11)
Starring: Sylvia Field as Abigail Adams
N/A	21	Reign of Terror	William Corrigan	May 18, 1952 (1952-05-18)
James Monroe as minister to France during the French Revolution
N/A	22	The Magnificent Failure	William Corrigan	May 25, 1952 (1952-05-25)
About Louisa May Alcott
N/A	23	The King's Author	Unknown	June 1, 1952 (1952-06-01)
About Ben Jonson
N/A	24	Nefretiti, Queen of Egypt	William Corrigan	June 8, 1952 (1952-06-08)
Starring: Sarah Churchill
N/A	25	Mr. and Mrs. Freedom	William Corrigan	June 15, 1952 (1952-06-15)
N/A	26	Forgotten Children	William Corrigan	June 22, 1952 (1952-06-22)
Starring: James Dean and Cloris Leachman
N/A	27	Our Sister Emily	William Corrigan	June 29, 1952 (1952-06-29)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Charlotte Brontë
N/A	28	The Legend of Josiah Blow	Unknown	July 6, 1952 (1952-07-06)
N/A	29	The Real Glory	Unknown	July 13, 1952 (1952-07-13)
N/A	30	Salvage	Unknown	July 20, 1952 (1952-07-20)
N/A	31	21-Plus	With Martin Huston	July 27, 1952 (1952-07-27)
N/A	32	The Carlson Legend	Albert McCleery	August 3, 1952 (1952-08-03)
N/A	33	The Last Command	Unknown	August 10, 1952 (1952-08-10)
N/A	34	I Lift Up My Lamp	Albert McCleery	August 17, 1952 (1952-08-17)

Season 2 (1952–53)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
N/A	1	Crabapple Saint	Unknown	August 24, 1952 (1952-08-24)
N/A	2	Refresher Course	Unknown	August 31, 1952 (1952-08-31)
N/A	3	Dutch Treat	Albert McCleery	September 7, 1952 (1952-09-07)
N/A	4	Horns of a Dilemma	Unknown	September 14, 1952 (1952-09-14)
N/A	5	The Bride's Teapot	Unknown	September 21, 1952 (1952-09-21)
N/A	6	Sometimes She's Sunday	Unknown	September 28, 1952 (1952-09-28)
N/A	7	The Bachelor and the Ballot	Unknown	October 12, 1952 (1952-10-12)
N/A	8	Faith Is a Nine-Letter Word	Unknown	October 19, 1952 (1952-10-19)
N/A	9	The Secret Vote	Unknown	October 26, 1952 (1952-10-26)
N/A	10	Line of Duty	Albert McCleery	November 2, 1952 (1952-11-02)
N/A	11	Bread of Freedom	Unknown	November 9, 1952 (1952-11-09)
N/A	12	The Blue and White Lamp	Unknown	November 16, 1952 (1952-11-16)
N/A	13	Mrs. Thanksgiving	Unknown	November 23, 1952 (1952-11-23)
N/A	14	Ten Thousand Words	Unknown	November 30, 1952 (1952-11-30)
N/A	15	Joan of Arc	Unknown	December 7, 1952 (1952-12-07)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Joan of Arc
N/A	16	The Hills Are Green	Albert McCleery	December 14, 1952 (1952-12-14)
N/A	17	The Small One	Unknown	December 21, 1952 (1952-12-21)
Starring: Kate Smith
N/A	18	Father Time	Unknown	December 28, 1952 (1952-12-28)
3	N/A	Amahl and the Night Visitors	TBA	TBA
Christmas season. The third new broadcast
N/A	19	Home Is the Sailor	Unknown	January 4, 1953 (1953-01-04)
N/A	20	Span Through Time^[2]	Unknown	January 11, 1953 (1953-01-11)
N/A	21	The General's Bible	Albert McCleery	January 18, 1953 (1953-01-18)
N/A	22	Socrates' Wife	Unknown	January 25, 1953 (1953-01-25)
N/A	23	To My Valentine	Unknown	February 1, 1953 (1953-02-01)
N/A	24	Lincoln's Little Correspondent	Unknown	February 8, 1953 (1953-02-08)
N/A	25	Crown of Audubon	Unknown	February 15, 1953 (1953-02-15)
N/A	26	Dinner for the General	Unknown	February 22, 1953 (1953-02-22)
N/A	27	The Accused	Unknown	March 1, 1953 (1953-03-01)
Starring: Sarah Churchill
N/A	28	Horace Mann's Miracle	Albert McCleery	March 8, 1953 (1953-03-08)
N/A	29	The Harp of Erin	Unknown	March 15, 1953 (1953-03-15)
Starring: Dennis Patrick as Thomas Moore
N/A	30	Photograph by Brady	Unknown	March 22, 1953 (1953-03-22)
Starring: Philip Bourneuf as Mathew Brady
N/A	31	A Queen Is Born	Albert McCleery	March 29, 1953 (1953-03-29)
N/A	32	The Other Wise Man	Unknown	April 5, 1953 (1953-04-05)
N/A	33	Skipper of the Skies	Albert McCleery	April 12, 1953 (1953-04-12)
Starring: Leslie Nielsen as Nathaniel Bowditch
N/A	34	The World on a Wire	Unknown	April 19, 1953 (1953-04-19)
Starring: Russell Hardie as Samuel Morse
4	35	Hamlet	Albert McCleery	April 26, 1953 (1953-04-26)
Starring: Maurice Evans as Hamlet
N/A	36	No Man Is an Island	Unknown	May 3, 1953 (1953-05-03)
Starring: Scott Forbes as John Donne
N/A	37	The Lady of Liberty	Unknown	May 10, 1953 (1953-05-10)
N/A	38	Soldier of Peace	Unknown	May 17, 1953 (1953-05-17)
Starring: Stephen Courtleigh as General Robert E. Lee
N/A	39	Proudly I Love	Unknown	May 24, 1953 (1953-05-24)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Sarah Bernhardt
N/A	40	Spark of Genius	Unknown	May 31, 1953 (1953-05-31)
N/A	41	The Clay of Kings	Unknown	June 7, 1953 (1953-06-07)
Starring: Roger Moore as Josiah Wedgwood
N/A	42	Scott's Castle	Albert McCleery	June 14, 1953 (1953-06-14)
N/A	43	Man Against Pain	Albert McCleery	June 21, 1953 (1953-06-21)
Starring: Tod Andrews as William Thomas Green Morton
N/A	44	The Mercer Girls	Unknown	June 28, 1953 (1953-06-28)

Season 3 (1953–54)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
N/A	1	A Smile for Danger	Unknown	September 27, 1953 (1953-09-27)
N/A	2	Of Time and the River	Unknown	October 4, 1953 (1953-10-04)
Starring: Sara Haden and Thomas Mitchell
N/A	3	A Queen's Way	Unknown	October 11, 1953 (1953-10-11)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Catherine Parr
N/A	4	McCoy of Abilene	Unknown	October 18, 1953 (1953-10-18)
Starring: George Nader as Joseph McCoy
N/A	5	Never Kick a Man Upstairs	Albert McCleery	October 25, 1953 (1953-10-25)
Starring: Sidney Blackmer as Theodore Roosevelt
N/A	6	The Imaginary Invalid	Albert McCleery	November 1, 1953 (1953-11-01)
Starring: Barry Jones
N/A	7	The Lonely Path	Albert McCleery	November 8, 1953 (1953-11-08)
Starring: Gene Barry as John Fremont
N/A	8	Of Time and the River	Unknown	November 15, 1953 (1953-11-15)
A second presentation with the same stars; tv.com shows the title as The Death of Gant
N/A	9	The Courtship of Miles Standish	Albert McCleery	November 22, 1953 (1953-11-22)
Starring: Kenneth Tobey as Miles Standish
N/A	10	The Last Voyage	Albert McCleery	November 29, 1953 (1953-11-29)
Starring: Maurice Manson as Benjamin Franklin and Richard Garland as Thomas Jefferson
N/A	11	TBA	Unknown	December 6, 1953 (1953-12-06)
N/A	12	Aesop and Rhodope	Unknown	December 13, 1953 (1953-12-13)
Starring: Lamont Johnson as Aesop, and Sarah Churchill as Rhodope
5	13	Amahl and the Night Visitors	Unknown	December 20, 1953 (1953-12-20)
The 4th new production. Starring Bill McIver as Amahl.
N/A	14	Blaze of Darkness	Albert McCleery	December 27, 1953 (1953-12-27)
Starring: John Sutton as John Milton
N/A	15	John Marshall and the Burr Case	Albert McCleery	January 3, 1954 (1954-01-03)
Starring: Richard Garland
N/A	16	Crusade to Liberty	Albert McCleery	January 10, 1954 (1954-01-10)
Starring: Douglass Montgomery as James Edward Oglethorpe
N/A	17	The St. Cloud Storm	Albert McCleery	January 17, 1954 (1954-01-17)
Starring: Dorothy Green as Jane Grey Swisshelm
6	18	King Richard II	George Schaefer	January 24, 1954 (1954-01-24)
Starring: Maurice Evans as Richard II
N/A	19	Lone Star	Albert McCleery	January 31, 1954 (1954-01-31)
Starring: Stephen Coit
N/A	20	The Hands of Clara Schumann	Unknown	February 7, 1954 (1954-02-07)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Clara Weick Schumann, and Patrick O'Neal as Robert Schumann
N/A	21	Crusader Against Cruelty	Albert McCleery	February 14, 1954 (1954-02-14)
N/A	22	Miss Tracy of Mount Vernon	Albert McCleery	February 21, 1954 (1954-02-21)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Sarah Tracy
N/A	23	The Turbulent Air	Unknown	February 28, 1954 (1954-02-28)
Starring: John Hudson as Antoine Lavoisier
N/A	24	The Good Samaritan	Unknown	March 7, 1954 (1954-03-07)
Starring: Douglass Montgomery
N/A	25	The Road to Tara	Unknown	March 14, 1954 (1954-03-14)
Starring: Patrick O'Neal as St. Patrick
N/A	26	Out of Jules Verne	Albert McCleery	March 21, 1954 (1954-03-21)
Starring: George Nader as Jules Verne
N/A	27	The Ordeal of Thomas Jefferson	Unknown	March 28, 1954 (1954-03-28)
Starring: Warner Anderson as Thomas Jefferson
N/A	28	Young William Penn	Unknown	April 4, 1954 (1954-04-04)
N/A	29	The Liberator	Unknown	April 11, 1954 (1954-04-11)
Starring: Joseph Jefferson as Simón Bolívar
N/A	30	The Story of Ruth	Unknown	April 18, 1954 (1954-04-18)
Starring: Maria Riva as Ruth
N/A	31	Lafayette for Freedom	Albert McCleery	April 25, 1954 (1954-04-25)
N/A	32	Petticoat Revolution (Hallmark Hall of Fame)	Albert McCleery	May 2, 1954 (1954-05-02)
Starring: Jess Barker and Helen Westcott
N/A	33	Portrait by Whistler	Albert McCleery	May 9, 1954 (1954-05-09)
Starring: Keith Larsen as James Abbott McNeill Whistler
N/A	34	Moby Dick	Albert McCleery	May 16, 1954 (1954-05-16)
Starring: Victor Jory as Captain Ahab and Lamont Johnson as Ishmael
N/A	35	The Story of Father Juniper Serra	Albert McCleery	May 23, 1954 (1954-05-23)
Starring: Robert Warwick as Junípero Serra, alternative title: Serra and San Francisco
N/A	36	The Armour-Bearer	Albert McCleery	May 30, 1954 (1954-05-30)
The story of Russell Conwell
N/A	37	A Reckless Youth	Albert McCleery	June 6, 1954 (1954-06-06)
A story surrounding Samuel Clemens's marriage.
N/A	38	Come to the Window	Unknown	June 13, 1954 (1954-06-13)
Starring: Jan Clayton as Jenny Lind
N/A	39	Flight from Cathay	Albert McCleery	June 20, 1954 (1954-06-20)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Princess Kukschin, Dennis Patrick as Marco Polo
N/A	40	Wife Unto Caesar	Albert McCleery	June 27, 1954 (1954-06-27)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Calpurnia, Hans Conried as Caesar
N/A	41	John Paul Jones	Albert McCleery	July 7, 1954 (1954-07-07)
Starring: Gloria Jean and Lamont Johnson

Season 4 (1954–55)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
N/A	1	Dynamite, the Story of Alfred Nobel	Albert McCleery	September 5, 1954 (1954-09-05)
Starring: Wesley Addy as Alfred Nobel
N/A	2	Don't Cry for Me	Albert McCleery	September 12, 1954 (1954-09-12)
Starring: John Sheppod as Stephen Foster
N/A	3	A Man of Many Ideas	Albert McCleery	September 19, 1954 (1954-09-19)
Starring: Peter Graves as John Wanamaker
N/A	4	The Reluctant Redeemer	Albert McCleery	September 26, 1954 (1954-09-26)
Starring: John Barrymore Jr. as Moses and Natalie Wood as Sephora
N/A	5	The Story of Johann Sebastian Bach	Albert McCleery	October 3, 1954 (1954-10-03)
N/A	6	Immortal Oath	Unknown	October 10, 1954 (1954-10-10)
Starring: John Baer as Hippocrates and Vera Miles
N/A	7	The Story of John Paulding	Unknown	October 17, 1954 (1954-10-17)
N/A	8	Lady in the Wings	Albert McCleery	October 24, 1954 (1954-10-24)
Starring: Peter Hansen as Edward MacDowell and Rosemary DeCamp as Mrs. Macdowell
N/A	9	The Path to Peace	Albert McCleery	October 31, 1954 (1954-10-31)
Starring: Herbert Rudley as Horace Greeley
N/A	10	The Story of Daniel Boone	Unknown	November 7, 1954 (1954-11-07)
N/A	11	A Matter of Principle	Unknown	November 14, 1954 (1954-11-14)
An incident from the life of John Adams
N/A	12	President for a Day	Albert McCleery	November 21, 1954 (1954-11-21)
The story of David Rice Atchison
7	13	Macbeth	George Schaefer	November 28, 1954 (1954-11-28)
Starring: Maurice Evans and Judith Anderson
N/A	14	Deadlock	Albert McCleery	December 5, 1954 (1954-12-05)
Starring: Wesley Addy as Alexander Hamilton, and Ian Keith as Thomas Jefferson
N/A	15	The Province of Man	Unknown	December 12, 1954 (1954-12-12)
Starring: John Sutton as William Harvey
8	16	Amahl and the Night Visitors	Unknown	December 19, 1954 (1954-12-19)
Starring: Bill McIver as Amahl. A fifth new version, the first in color.
N/A	17	The Joyful Tydings	Albert McCleery	December 26, 1954 (1954-12-26)
Starring: Terence De Marney as William Tyndale
N/A	18	The Story of William Tell	Unknown	January 2, 1955 (1955-01-02)
Starring: James Arness as William Tell
N/A	19	The First Mintmaster	Albert McCleery	January 9, 1955 (1955-01-09)
Starring: Mark Dana as Edward Hull, and Lamont Johnson as John Hull
N/A	20	Crusade for Freedom	Albert McCleery	January 16, 1955 (1955-01-16)
Starring: Ben Cooper as Benjamin Franklin, and Dick Simmons as Cotton Mather
N/A	21	Dr. Harvey W. Wiley	Albert McCleery	January 23, 1955 (1955-01-23)
Starring: Paul Langton as Harvey W. Wiley
N/A	22	A Story About Henry Ford	Albert McCleery	January 30, 1955 (1955-01-30)
Starring: Arthur Franz as Henry Ford, and Will J. White as Barney Oldfield
N/A	23	Patrick Henry	Albert McCleery	February 6, 1955 (1955-02-06)
Starring: Jack Kelly as Patrick Henry
N/A	24	The Shining Beacon	Albert McCleery	February 13, 1955 (1955-02-13)
Starring: Whitfield Connor as Alcuin, and Don Megowan as Charlemagne
N/A	25	The Courtship of George Washington and Martha Custiss	Albert McCleery	February 20, 1955 (1955-02-20)
Starring: Marshall Thompson as George Washington, and Karen Sharpe as Martha Custiss
N/A	26	The Talking Wire	Albert McCleery	February 27, 1955 (1955-02-27)
Starring: Peter Hansen as Alexander Graham Bell
N/A	27	The Adventures of Lt. Contee	Albert McCleery	March 6, 1955 (1955-03-06)
Starring: John Drew Barrymore as Lt. Marcus Contee
N/A	28	The Pirate and the Lawyer	Albert McCleery	March 13, 1955 (1955-03-13)
Starring: Ray Danton as Jean Lafitte
N/A	29	Soldier's Bride	Albert McCleery	March 20, 1955 (1955-03-20)
Starring: John Baragrey as Jefferson Davis, Sarah Churchill as Knox Taylor, and Richard Gaines as Zachary Taylor
N/A	30	The Finest Gift	Albert McCleery	March 27, 1955 (1955-03-27)
Starring: Tod Andrews as Lord Byron
N/A	31	The Green Mountain Boys	Albert McCleery	April 3, 1955 (1955-04-03)
Starring: William Bishop as Ethan Allen
N/A	32	Lydia	Albert McCleery	April 10, 1955 (1955-04-10)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Lydia, and Lamont Johnson as Paul
N/A	33	The Man Who Tore Down the Wall	Albert McCleery	April 17, 1955 (1955-04-17)
Starring: Peter Graves as Dr. James Ewing
N/A	34	Aimée de Rivery	Albert McCleery	April 24, 1955 (1955-04-24)
Starring: Sarah Churchill as Aimée De Rivery
N/A	35	The Touch of Steel	Albert McCleery	May 1, 1955 (1955-05-01)
Starring: Jan Merlin as Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.
N/A	36	Cradle Song	Albert McCleery	May 8, 1955 (1955-05-08)
Starring: Osa Massen as Ernestine Schumann-Heink
N/A	37	The Promise	Albert McCleery	May 15, 1955 (1955-05-15)
Starring: Lamont Johnson as Damon, and Marshall Thompson as Pythias
N/A	38	The Man with a Camera	Albert McCleery	May 22, 1955 (1955-05-22)
Starring: Gene Reynolds as George Eastman
N/A	39	The Story of Paul Harris and the Founding of Rotary International	Albert McCleery	May 29, 1955 (1955-05-29)
Starring: Edward Arnold as Paul P. Harris
N/A	40	The Hammer and the Sword	Albert McCleery	June 5, 1955 (1955-06-05)
Starring: Joseph Schildkraut as Baron Friedrich Wilhelm von Steuben. Alternative title: The Tempering of the Sword
N/A	41	Edgar Allan Poe at West Point	Albert McCleery	June 12, 1955 (1955-06-12)
Starring: John Carlyle as Edgar Allan Poe
N/A	42	The Father Who Had No Sons	Albert McCleery	June 19, 1955 (1955-06-19)
Starring: Gene Lockhart as Milton Hershey
N/A	43	The Farmer from Monticello	Albert McCleery	June 26, 1955 (1955-06-26)
Starring: Rhodes Reason as Thomas Jefferson

Season 5 (1955–56)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
9	9	Alice In Wonderland	George Schaefer	October 23, 1955 (1955-10-23)
10	2	The Devil's Disciple	George Schaefer	November 20, 1955 (1955-11-20)
Starring: Maurice Evans as Richard Dudgeon
11	3	Dream Girl	George Schaefer	December 11, 1955 (1955-12-11)
Starring: Vivian Blaine as Georgina Allerton
12	4	The Corn Is Green	George Schaefer	January 8, 1956 (1956-01-08)
Starring: Eva Le Gallienne as Miss Moffat
13	5	The Good Fairy	George Schaefer	February 5, 1956 (1956-02-05)
Starring: Julie Harris
14	6	The Taming of the Shrew	George Schaefer	March 18, 1956 (1956-03-18)
Starring: Maurice Evans as Petruchio. Lilli Palmer as Katherine
15	N/A	The Cradle Song	George Schaefer	May 6, 1956 (1956-05-06)
Starring: Judith Anderson, Evelyn Varden

Season 6 (1956–57)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
16	1	Born Yesterday	Garson Kanin	October 28, 1956 (1956-10-28)
Starring: Mary Martin and Paul Douglas
17	2	Man and Superman	George Schaefer	November 25, 1956 (1956-11-25)
Starring: Maurice Evans as Jack Tanner
18	3	The Little Foxes	George Schaefer	December 16, 1956 (1956-12-16)
Starring: Greer Garson as Regina Giddens
19	4	The Lark	George Schaefer	February 10, 1957 (1957-02-10)
Starring: Julie Harris as Joan of Arc, with Boris Karloff, Basil Rathbone and Jack Warden
20	5	There Shall Be No Night	George Schaefer	March 17, 1957 (1957-03-17)
Starring: Charles Boyer and Katharine Cornell
21	6	The Yeomen of the Guard	George Schaefer	April 10, 1957 (1957-04-10)
Adapted from the Gilbert and Sullivan operetta.

Season 7 (1957–58)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
22	1	The Green Pastures	George Schaefer	October 17, 1957 (1957-10-17)
23	2	On Borrowed Time	George Schaefer	November 17, 1957 (1957-11-17)
Starring: Ed Wynn and Claude Rains
24	3	Twelfth Night	David Greene	December 15, 1957 (1957-12-15)
Starring: Maurice Evans as Malvolio
25	4	Hans Brinker and the Silver Skates	George Schaefer and Sidney Lumet	February 9, 1958 (1958-02-09)
Starring: Tab Hunter and Dick Button
26	5	Little Moon of Alban	George Schaefer	March 24, 1958 (1958-03-24)
Starring: Julie Harris and Christopher Plummer
27	6	Dial M for Murder	George Schaefer	April 25, 1958 (1958-04-25)
Starring: Maurice Evans and Rosemary Harris

Season 8 (1958–59)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
28	1	Johnny Belinda	George Schaefer	October 13, 1958 (1958-10-13)
Starring: Julie Harris and Christopher Plummer
29	2	Kiss Me, Kate (DVD)	George Schaefer	November 20, 1958 (1958-11-20)
Starring: Alfred Drake and Patricia Morison, from the original Broadway cast. Their only video appearance in these roles.
30	3	The Christmas Tree	Kirk Browning	December 14, 1958 (1958-12-14)
A number of stars in short skits, including Carol Channing and Cyril Ritchard on skates.
31	4	Berkley Square	George Schaefer	February 5, 1959 (1959-02-05)
Starring: John Kerr
32	N/A	The Green Pastures	Unknown	March 23, 1959 (1959-03-23)
A restaging of No. 22 with most of the same cast
33	5	Ah, Wilderness!	Robert Mulligan	April 28, 1959 (1959-04-28)
Starring: Lloyd Nolan

Season 9 (1959–60)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
34	1	Winterset	George Schaefer	October 26, 1959 (1959-10-26)
Starring: Don Murray, Piper Laurie and George C. Scott
35	2	A Doll's House	George Schaefer	November 15, 1959 (1959-11-15)
Starring: Julie Harris, Christopher Plummer and Jason Robards
36	3	A Christmas Festival	Albert McCleery	December 13, 1959 (1959-12-13)
Starring: Judith Anderson, Dick Button and the Obernkirchen Children's Choir. This production was soundly beaten in the ratings by CBS's second telecast of The Wizard of Oz, which aired on the same night. It was the spectacular success of this telecast of the film which persuaded CBS to make it an annual television attraction.
37	4	The Tempest	George Schaefer	February 3, 1960 (1960-02-03)
Starring: Richard Burton, Maurice Evans and Lee Remick
38	6	The Cradle Song	Unknown	April 10, 1960 (1960-04-10)
A new presentation of the play with some of the same actors as the 1956 production; starring Judith Anderson, Helen Hayes.
39	5	Captain Brassbound's Conversion	George Schaefer	May 2, 1960 (1960-05-02)^[3]
Starring: Christopher Plummer as Captain Brassbound, with Robert Redford and Greer Garson

Season 10 (1960–61)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
40	1	Shangri-La	George Schaefer	October 24, 1960 (1960-10-24)
Starring: Richard Basehart and Claude Rains
41	2	Macbeth	George Schaefer	November 20, 1960 (1960-11-20)
A new presentation (see season 4 episode 13 for earlier version), again starring Maurice Evans, Judith Anderson.
42	3	Golden Child	George Schaefer	December 16, 1960 (1960-12-16)
Starring: Patricia Brooks, Enrico Di Giuseppe and Stephen Douglass
43	4	Time Remembered	George Schaefer	February 7, 1961 (1961-02-07)
Starring: Janet Munro, Edith Evans and Christopher Plummer
44	5	Give Us Barabbas!	George Schaefer	March 26, 1961 (1961-03-26)
Starring: James Daly and Kim Hunter
45	6	The Joke and the Valley	George Schaefer	May 5, 1961 (1961-05-05)
Starring: Thomas Mitchell

Season 11 (1961–62)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
46	1	Macbeth	Unknown	October 20, 1961 (1961-10-20)
Rerun of #41
47	2	Victoria Regina	George Schaefer	November 30, 1961 (1961-11-30)
Adapted from Laurence Housman's 1934 play Victoria Regina. Starring Julie Harris as Queen Victoria, James Donald as Prince Albert and Basil Rathbone as Benjamin Disraeli.
48	3	Arsenic & Old Lace	George Schaefer	February 5, 1962 (1962-02-05)
Starring: Tony Randall, Boris Karloff and Tom Bosley
49	N/A	Give Us Barabbas!	Unknown	April 15, 1962 (1962-04-15)
Rerun of #44

Season 12 (1962–63)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
50	1	The Teahouse of the August Moon	George Schaefer	October 26, 1962 (1962-10-26)
Starring: Paul Ford, John Forsythe and Miyoshi Umeki
51	2	Cyrano de Bergerac	George Schaefer	December 6, 1962 (1962-12-06)
Starring: Christopher Plummer, Hope Lange and Donald Harron
52	3	Pygmalion	George Schaefer	February 6, 1963 (1963-02-06)
Starring: Julie Harris and James Donald
53	4	The Invincible Mr. Disraeli	George Schaefer	April 4, 1963 (1963-04-04)
Starring: Trevor Howard and Greer Garson

Season 13 (1963–64)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
54	1	The Tempest	George Schaefer	October 20, 1963 (1963-10-20)
Rerun of #37
55	2	The Patriots	George Schaefer	November 15, 1963 (1963-11-15)
Starring: Charlton Heston as Thomas Jefferson, John Fraser as Alexander Hamilton, and Howard St. John as George Washington
56	3	A Cry of Angels	George Schaefer	December 15, 1963 (1963-12-15)
Starring: Walter Slezak as George Frederic Handel, with Maureen O'Hara and Hermione Gingold
57	4	Abe Lincoln in Illinois	George Schaefer	February 2, 1964 (1964-02-02)
Starring: Jason Robards Jr. as Abe Lincoln, and Kate Reid as Mary Todd
58	5	Little Moon of Alban	George Schaefer	March 18, 1964 (1964-03-18)
Starring: Julie Harris and Dirk Bogarde a new presentation

Season 14 (1964–65)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
59	1	The Fantasticks	George Schaefer	October 18, 1964 (1964-10-18)
Starring: Ricardo Montalbán, Bert Lahr and Stanley Holloway. The first television presentation of the stage musical.
60	2	The Other World of Winston Churchill	Louis Clyde Stoumen	November 30, 1964 (1964-11-30)
Starring: Paul Scofield and Merle Oberon, with Patrick Wymark as Winston Churchill
61	N/A	Amahl and the Night Visitors	Kirk Browning	December 20, 1964 (1964-12-20)
Starring: Kurt Yaghjian as Amahl. The controversial version rejected by Menotti. Followed by a 10-minute special hosted by Roddy McDowall, displaying Christmas trees decorated by celebrities Julie Harris, Norman Vincent Peale, Dick Van Dyke, Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward, Helena Rubenstein, Cecil Beaton and Maurice Evans.
62	3	The Magnificent Yankee	George Schaefer	January 28, 1965 (1965-01-28)
Starring: Alfred Lunt as Oliver Wendell Holmes
63	4	The Holy Terror	George Schaefer	April 7, 1965 (1965-04-07)
Starring: Julie Harris as Florence Nightingale

Season 15 (1965–66)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
64	1	Eagle In a Cage	George Schaefer	October 20, 1965 (1965-10-20)
Starring: Trevor Howard as Napoleon, and James Daly as Dr. O'Meara
65	2	Inherit the Wind	George Schaefer	November 18, 1965 (1965-11-18)
Starring: Melvyn Douglas as Henry Drummond, and Ed Begley as Matthew Harrison Brady
66	N/A	Amahl and the Night Visitors	Kirk Browning	December 12, 1965 (1965-12-12)
Rerun of number 61, seemingly without the added segment about Christmas trees.^{[citation needed]}
67	N/A	The Magnificent Yankee	Unknown	February 3, 1966 (1966-02-03)
Rerun of number 62.
68	3	Lamp at Midnight (v)	George Schaefer	April 27, 1966 (1966-04-27)
Starring: Melvyn Douglas as Galileo Galilei

Season 16 (1966–67)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
69	1	Barefoot In Athens	George Schaefer	November 11, 1966 (1966-11-11)
Starring: Peter Ustinov as Socrates, and Geraldine Page as Xantippe
70	2	Blithe Spirit	George Schaefer	December 7, 1966 (1966-12-07)
Starring: Dirk Bogarde and Rosemary Harris
71	N/A	Abe Lincoln in Illinois	Unknown	February 2, 1967 (1967-02-02)
Rerun of #57
72	3	Anastasia	George Schaefer	March 17, 1967 (1967-03-17)
Starring: Julie Harris as Anastasia, and Lynn Fontanne as Grand Duchess Marie
73	4	Soldier in Love	George Schaefer	April 26, 1967 (1967-04-26)
Starring: Claire Bloom as Anne, with Jean Simmons and Basil Rathbone

Season 17 (1967–68)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
74	1	A Bell for Adano	Mel Ferrer	November 11, 1967 (1967-11-11)
Starring: John Forsythe
75	2	Saint Joan	George Schaefer	December 4, 1967 (1967-12-04)
Starring: Geneviève Bujold as Joan of Arc
76	3	Elizabeth the Queen (V)	George Schaefer	January 31, 1968 (1968-01-31)
Starring: Judith Anderson as Elizabeth I, and Charlton Heston as Robert Devereux, 2nd Earl of Essex
77	N/A	Give Us Barabbas	Unknown	March 29, 1968 (1968-03-29)
Rerun of #44
78	4	The Admirable Crichton	George Schaefer	May 2, 1968 (1968-05-02)
Starring: Bill Travers

Season 18 (1968–69)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
79	1	A Punt, A Pass & A Prayer	Tom Donovan	November 20, 1968 (1968-11-20)
Starring: Herbert Anderson and Don DeFore
80	2	Pinocchio	Sid Smith	December 8, 1968 (1968-12-08)
Starring: Burl Ives and Peter Noone
81	3	Teacher, Teacher	Fielder Cook	February 5, 1969 (1969-02-05)
Starring: David McCallum and Ossie Davis
82	4	Give Us Barabbas	Unknown	March 28, 1969 (1969-03-28)
Rerun of #77
83	5	Victoria Regina	Unknown	May 2, 1969 (1969-05-02)
Rerun of #47

Season 19 (1969–70)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
84	1	The File on Devlin	George Schaefer	November 21, 1969 (1969-11-21)
Starring: Judith Anderson and Elizabeth Ashley
85	2	The Littlest Angel (DVD)	Walter C. Miller	December 6, 1969 (1969-12-06)
Starring: E.G. Marshall as God and Johnny Whitaker, with Fred Gwynne, Tony Randall, Cab Calloway, and Connie Stevens.
86	3	A Storm In Summer	Buzz Kulik	February 6, 1970 (1970-02-06)
Starring: Peter Ustinov and N'Gai Dixon
87	4	Neither Are We Enemies	David Pressman	March 13, 1970 (1970-03-13)
Starring: Van Heflin as Joseph of Arimathea, with Ed Begley and Kate Reid
88	N/A	Teacher, Teacher	Unknown	May 1, 1970 (1970-05-01)
Rerun of #81

Season 20 (1970–71)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
89	1	Hamlet	Peter Wood	November 17, 1970 (1970-11-17)
Starring: Richard Chamberlain as Hamlet, and Michael Redgrave as Polonius
90	N/A	The Littlest Angel	Unknown	December 6, 1970 (1970-12-06)
Rerun of #85
91	2	The Price	Fielder Cook	February 3, 1971 (1971-02-03)
Starring: George C. Scott and Barry Sullivan
92	3	Gideon	George Schaefer	March 26, 1971 (1971-03-26)
Starring: Peter Ustinov and José Ferrer
93	N/A	A Storm in Summer	Unknown	April 27, 1971 (1971-04-27)
Rerun of #86

Season 21 (1971–72)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
94	1	The Snow Goose (DVD)	Patrick Garland	November 15, 1971 (1971-11-15)
Starring: Richard Harris and Jenny Agutter
95	2	All the Way Home	Fred Coe	December 1, 1971 (1971-12-01)
Starring: Joanne Woodward and Richard Kiley
96	3	The Littlest Angel	Unknown	December 12, 1971 (1971-12-12)
Another rerun of #85
97	4	Love! Love! Love!	Sterling Johnson	February 8, 1972 (1972-02-08)
Starring: Helen Reddy, Bread and Mac Davis; narrated by Robert Wagner; musical documentary special focused on the life and romance of six couples in various parts of the United States, filmed on location.
98	5	Harvey	Fielder Cook	March 22, 1972 (1972-03-22)
Starring: James Stewart, Helen Hayes and Arlene Francis
99	N/A	The Price	Unknown	May 3, 1972 (1972-05-03)
Rerun of #91

Season 22 (1972–73)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
100	1	The Hands of Cormac Joyce	Fielder Cook	November 17, 1972 (1972-11-17)
Starring: Stephen Boyd, Colleen Dewhurst and Cyril Cusack
101	2	The Man Who Came To Dinner	Buzz Kulik	November 29, 1972 (1972-11-29)
Starring: Orson Welles and Lee Remick
102	N/A	The Snow Goose	Unknown	December 12, 1972 (1972-12-12)
Rerun of #94
103	3	You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown	Walter C. Miller	February 9, 1973 (1973-02-09)
Starring: Wendell Burton as Charlie Brown

Season 23 (1973–74)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
105	1	Lisa, Bright and Dark	Jeannot Szwarc	November 28, 1973 (1973-11-28)
Starring: Anne Baxter and John Forsythe
106	2	The Borrowers	Walter C. Miller	December 14, 1973 (1973-12-14)
Starring: Eddie Albert and Tammy Grimes
107	3	The Country Girl	Paul Bogart	February 5, 1974 (1974-02-05)
Starring: Jason Robards and Shirley Knight
108	4	Crown Matrimonial	Alan Bridges	April 3, 1974 (1974-04-03)
Starring: Peter Barkworth as King Edward VIII
104^[4]	5	The Small Miracle	Jeannot Szwarc	April 11, 1974 (1974-04-11)
Starring: Vittorio de Sica

Season 24 (1974–75)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
109	1	Brief Encounter	Alan Bridges	November 12, 1974 (1974-11-12)
Starring: Sophia Loren and Richard Burton
110	2	The Gathering Storm	Herbert Wise	November 29, 1974 (1974-11-29)
Starring: Richard Burton as Winston Churchill, and Virginia McKenna as Clementine Churchill
111	N/A	The Borrowers	Unknown	December 13, 1974 (1974-12-13)
Rerun of #106
112	3	All Creatures Great and Small	Claude Whatham	February 4, 1975 (1975-02-04)
Starring: Simon Ward and Anthony Hopkins
113	4	Something Wonderful Happens Every Spring	Unknown	March 19, 1975 (1975-03-19)
An abridgement of #104, The Small Miracle

Season 25 (1975–76)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
N/A	1	A Salute to the 25th Anniversary of the Hallmark Hall of Fame	Unknown	October 20, 1975 (1975-10-20)
Included extracts from eight shows
114	2	Eric	James Goldstone	November 10, 1975 (1975-11-10)
Starring: John Savage and Patricia Neal
115	3	Valley Forge	Fielder Cook	December 3, 1975 (1975-12-03)
Starring: Richard Basehart as George Washington, with Harry Andrews
116	4	The Rivalry	Fielder Cook	December 12, 1975 (1975-12-12)
Starring: Arthur Hill as Abraham Lincoln, and Charles Durning as Stephen Douglas
117	5	Caesar and Cleopatra	James Cellan Jones	February 1, 1976 (1976-02-01)
Starring: Alec Guinness as Julius Caesar, and Geneviève Bujold as Cleopatra
118	6	Truman at Potsdam	George Schaefer	April 8, 1976 (1976-04-08)
Starring: John Houseman as Winston Churchill, José Ferrer as Joseph Stalin, and Ed Flanders as Harry S. Truman

Season 26 (1976–77)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
119	1	The Disappearance of Aimee	Anthony Harvey	November 17, 1976 (1976-11-17)
Starring: Faye Dunaway as Aimee Semple McPherson, and Bette Davis as her mother
120	2	Beauty and the Beast	Fielder Cook	December 3, 1976 (1976-12-03)
Starring: George C. Scott as the Beast, and Trish Van Devere as Belle
121	3	Peter Pan	Dwight Hemion	December 12, 1976 (1976-12-12)
Starring: Mia Farrow as Peter Pan, and Danny Kaye as Captain Hook
122	4	Emily, Emily	Marc Daniels	February 7, 1977 (1977-02-07)
Starring: Pamela Bellwood as Emily Ward, with James Farentino and John Forsythe. A sequel to #81. Teacher, Teacher
123	5	All Creatures Great and Small	Unknown	March 29, 1977 (1977-03-29)
Rerun of #112

Season 27 (1977–78)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
124	1	The Last Hurrah	Vincent Sherman	November 16, 1977 (1977-11-16)
Starring: Carroll O'Connor and Leslie Ackerman
125	2	The Court Martial of George Armstrong Custer	Glenn Jordan	December 1, 1977 (1977-12-01)
Starring: James Olson as George Armstrong Custer
126	3	Have I Got a Christmas For You	Marc Daniels	December 16, 1977 (1977-12-16)
Starring: Adrienne Barbeau, Hal Linden, Milton Berle, Steve Allen and Jim Backus Shown on the same night as the first telecast of the Mikhail Baryshnikov Nutcracker.
127	4	Taxi!!!	Joseph Hardy	February 2, 1978 (1978-02-02)
Starring: Martin Sheen and Eva Marie Saint

NOTE: Hallmark's #128 was "Peter Pan", a rerun of #121. The date and season have not been established.

Season 28 (1978–79)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
129	1	Return Engagement	Joseph Hardy	November 17, 1978 (1978-11-17)
Starring: Elizabeth Taylor and Joseph Bottoms
130	2	Fame	Marc Daniels	November 30, 1978 (1978-11-30)
Starring: Richard Benjamin and José Ferrer
131	3	Stubby Pringle's Christmas	Burt Brinckerhoff	December 17, 1978 (1978-12-17)
Starring: Beau Bridges and Julie Harris
132	4	Beauty and the Beast	Unknown	April 6, 1979 (1979-04-06)
Rerun of #120

NOTE: Hallmark #132 was the last episode to air on NBC.

Season 29 (1979–80)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
133	1	All Quiet on the Western Front	Delbert Mann	November 14, 1979 (1979-11-14)
Starring: Richard Thomas and Ernest Borgnine
134	2	Aunt Mary	Peter Werner	December 5, 1979 (1979-12-05)
Starring: Jean Stapleton as Mary Dobkin and Martin Balsam
135	3	Gideon's Trumpet	Robert E. Collins	April 30, 1980 (1980-04-30)
Starring: Henry Fonda as Clarence Earl Gideon, and José Ferrer as Abe Fortas

NOTE: Hallmark #133 was the first episode to air on CBS.

Season 30 (1980–81)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
136	N/A	A Tale of Two Cities	Unknown	December 2, 1980 (1980-12-02)
Starring: Chris Sarandon as both Sydney Carton and Charles Darnay, Alice Krige as Lucie Manette, Billie Whitelaw as Madame Defarge, and Kenneth More as Mr. Lorry
137	1	Mister Lincoln	Gordon Rigsby	February 9, 1981 (1981-02-09)
Starring: Roy Dotrice as Abraham Lincoln
138	2	Dear Liar	Gordon Rigsby	April 15, 1981 (1981-04-15)
Starring: Jane Alexander as Mrs. Patrick Campbell, and Edward Herrmann as George Bernard Shaw
139	3	Casey Stengel	Nick Havinga	May 6, 1981 (1981-05-06)
Starring: Charles Durning as Casey Stengel

Season 31 (1981–82)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
140	1	The Marva Collins Story	Peter Levin	December 1, 1981 (1981-12-01)
Starring: Cicely Tyson and Morgan Freeman
141	2	The Hunchback of Notre Dame	Michael Tuchner	February 4, 1982 (1982-02-04)
Starring: Anthony Hopkins as Quasimodo and Lesley-Anne Down as Esmeralda. with Derek Jacobi and David Suchet

Season 32 (1982–83)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
142	1	Witness for the Prosecution	Alan Gibson	December 4, 1982 (1982-12-04)
Starring: Ralph Richardson, Diana Rigg, Deborah Kerr and Beau Bridges
143	2	Thursday's Child	David Lowell Rich	February 1, 1983 (1983-02-01)
Starring: Gena Rowlands and Don Murray

Season 33 (1983–84)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
144	1	The Winter of Our Discontent	Waris Hussein	December 6, 1983 (1983-12-06)
Starring: Donald Sutherland and Teri Garr
145	2	The Master of Ballantrae	Douglas Hickox	January 31, 1984 (1984-01-31)
Starring: Richard Thomas, Michael York and John Gielgud

Season 34 (1984–85)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
146	1	Camille	Desmond Davis	December 11, 1984 (1984-12-11)
Starring: Greta Scacchi, Colin Firth and John Gielgud
147	2	The Corsican Brothers	Ian Sharp	February 5, 1985 (1985-02-05)
Starring: Trevor Eve and Geraldine Chaplin

Season 35 (1985–86)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
148	1	Love Is Never Silent	Joseph Sargent	December 9, 1985 (1985-12-09)
Starring: Mare Winningham and Cloris Leachman
149	2	Resting Place	John Korty	April 27, 1986 (1986-04-27)
Starring: John Lithgow and Morgan Freeman

Season 36 (1986–87)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
150	N/A	Love is Never Silent	Unknown	December 1, 1986 (1986-12-01)
Rerun of #148
151	1	Promise	Glenn Jordan	December 14, 1986 (1986-12-14)
Starring: James Garner, James Woods and Piper Laurie
152	2	The Room Upstairs	Stuart Margolin	January 31, 1987 (1987-01-31)
Starring: Stockard Channing and Sam Waterston
153	3	Pack of Lies	Anthony Page	April 26, 1987 (1987-04-26)
Starring: Ellen Burstyn, Alan Bates and Teri Garr

Season 37 (1987–88)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
154	1	The Secret Garden	Alan Grint	November 30, 1987 (1987-11-30)
Starring: Gennie James and Barret Oliver
155	2	Foxfire (v, DVD)	Jud Taylor	December 13, 1987 (1987-12-13)
Starring: Jessica Tandy, Hume Cronyn and John Denver
156	3	Stones for Ibarra	Jack Gold	January 29, 1988 (1988-01-29)
Starring: Glenn Close and Keith Carradine
157	4	April Morning	Delbert Mann	April 24, 1988 (1988-04-24)
Starring: Tommy Lee Jones and Robert Urich

Season 38 (1988–89)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
158	1	The Tenth Man	Jack Gold	December 4, 1988 (1988-12-04)
Starring: Anthony Hopkins and Kristin Scott Thomas
159	N/A	Promise	Unknown	December 13, 1988 (1988-12-13)
Rerun of #151
160	2	Home Fires Burning	Glenn Jordan	January 29, 1989 (1989-01-29)
Starring: Barnard Hughes and Sada Thompson
161	3	My Name is Bill W.	Daniel Petrie	April 30, 1989 (1989-04-30)
Starring: James Woods, Jobeth Williams and James Garner

Season 39 (1989–90)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
162	11	The Shell Seekers (v, DVD)	Waris Hussein	December 3, 1989 (1989-12-03)
Starring: Angela Lansbury and Sam Wanamaker
163	N/A	The Secret Garden	Unknown	December 16, 1989 (1989-12-16)
Rerun of #154
164	12	Face to Face	Lou Antonio	January 24, 1990 (1990-01-24)
Starring: Elizabeth Montgomery and Robert Foxworth
165	13	Caroline?	Joseph Sargent	April 29, 1990 (1990-04-29)
Starring: Stephanie Zimbalist, Pamela Reed and George Grizzard

Season 40 (1990–91)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
166	1	Decoration Day (v, DVD)	Robert Markowitz	December 2, 1990 (1990-12-02)
Starring: James Garner and Judith Ivey
167	N/A	Foxfire	Unknown	December 15, 1990 (1990-12-15)
Rerun of #155
168	2	Sarah, Plain and Tall (v, DVD)	Glenn Jordan	February 3, 1991 (1991-02-03)
Starring: Glenn Close and Christopher Walken
169	3	Shadow of a Doubt	Karen Arthur	April 28, 1991 (1991-04-28)
Starring: Mark Harmon, Margaret Welsh and Norm Skaggs

Season 41 (1991–92)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
170	1	One Against the Wind (v)	Larry Elikann	December 1, 1991 (1991-12-01)
Starring: Judy Davis and Sam Neill
171	N/A	Caroline?	Unknown	December 14, 1991 (1991-12-14)
Rerun of #165
172	2	O Pioneers! (v, DVD)	Glenn Jordan	February 2, 1992 (1992-02-02)
Starring: Jessica Lange and David Strathairn
173	3	Miss Rose White (v)	Joseph Sargent	April 26, 1992 (1992-04-26)
Starring: Kyra Sedgwick and Maximilian Schell

Season 42 (1992–93)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
174	1	An American Story (v, DVD)	John Gray	November 29, 1992 (1992-11-29)
Starring: Brad Johnson and Kathleen Quinlan
175	N/A	Sarah, Plain and Tall	Unknown	December 19, 1992 (1992-12-19)
Rerun of #168
176	2	Skylark (v, DVD)	Joseph Sargent	February 7, 1993 (1993-02-07)
Starring: Glenn Close and Christopher Walken A sequel to Sarah, Plain and Tall
177	3	Blind Spot (v)	Michael Toshiyuki Uno	May 2, 1993 (1993-05-02)
Starring: Joanne Woodward and Laura Linney

Season 43 (1993–94)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
178	1	To Dance With the White Dog (v, DVD)	Glenn Jordan	December 5, 1993 (1993-12-05)
Starring: Hume Cronyn and Jessica Tandy
179	N/A	O Pioneers! (v, DVD)	Unknown	December 18, 1993 (1993-12-18)
Rerun of #172
180	2	Breathing Lessons (v, DVD)	John Erman	February 6, 1994 (1994-02-06)
Starring: James Garner and Joanne Woodward
181	3	A Place for Annie (v)	John Gray	May 13, 1994 (1994-05-13)
Starring: Sissy Spacek and Mary-Louise Parker

Season 44 (1994–95)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
182	1	The Return of the Native (v, DVD)	Jack Gold	December 4, 1994 (1994-12-04)
Starring: Catherine Zeta-Jones as Eustacia Vye and Clive Owen as Damon Wildeve
183	2	The Piano Lesson (v)	Lloyd Richards	February 5, 1995 (1995-02-05)
Starring: Charles Dutton and Alfre Woodard
184	3	Redwood Curtain (v)	John Korty	April 23, 1995 (1995-04-23)
Starring: Jeff Daniels and Lea Salonga

Season 45 (1995–96)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
185	1	Journey (v)	Tom McLoughlin	December 10, 1995 (1995-12-10)
Starring: Jason Robards and Brenda Fricker
186	N/A	A Season of Hope	Marcus Cole	December 10, 1995 (1995-12-10)
Starring: JoBeth Williams and Ralph Waite
187	2	The Boys Next Door (DVD)	John Erman	February 4, 1996 (1996-02-04)
Starring: Nathan Lane and Robert Sean Leonard
188	3	Harvest of Fire (DVD)	Arthur Allan Seidelman	April 21, 1996 (1996-04-21)
Starring: Lolita Davidovich and Patty Duke

An additional program, Lily Dale, shown on June 9, 1996 is listed by the Internet Movie Database, but not the Hallmark company, as belonging to this season.

Season 46 (1996–97)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
189	1	Calm at Sunset (v, DVD)	Daniel Petrie	December 1, 1996 (1996-12-01)
Starring: Michael Moriarty, Peter Facinelli and Kate Nelligan
190	2	The Summer of Ben Tyler (v, DVD)	Arthur Allan Seidelman	December 15, 1996 (1996-12-15)
Starring: James Woods and Elizabeth McGovern
191	3	Old Man (v)	John Kent Harrison	February 9, 1997 (1997-02-09)
Starring: Jeanne Tripplehorn and Arliss Howard
192	4	Rose Hill (v, DVD)	Christopher Cain	April 20, 1997 (1997-04-20)
Starring: Jennifer Garner and Jeffrey D. Sams

Season 47 (1997–98)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
193	1	What the Deaf Man Heard (v, DVD)	John Kent Harrison	November 23, 1997 (1997-11-23)
Starring: Matthew Modine and Claire Bloom
194	2	Ellen Foster (v, DVD)	John Erman	December 14, 1997 (1997-12-14)
Starring: Jena Malone and Ted Levine
195	3	The Love Letter (v, DVD)	Dan Curtis	February 1, 1998 (1998-02-01)
Starring: Campbell Scott and Jennifer Jason Leigh
196	4	The Echo of Thunder (v)	Simon Wincer	April 19, 1998 (1998-04-19)
Starring: Judy Davis and Jamey Sheridan

Season 48 (1998–99)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
197	N/A	What the Deaf Man Heard	Unknown	May 31, 1998 (1998-05-31)
Rerun of #193
198	1	Saint Maybe (v)	Michael Pressman	November 22, 1998 (1998-11-22)
Starring: Blythe Danner, Edward Herrmann and Melina Kanakaredes
199	2	Grace and Glorie (v)	Arthur Allan Seidelman	December 13, 1998 (1998-12-13)
Starring: Gena Rowlands and Diane Lane
200	3	Night Ride Home (v)	Glenn Jordan	February 7, 1999 (1999-02-07)
Starring: Rebecca De Mornay and Keith Carradine
201	4	Durango (v)	Brent Shields	April 25, 1999 (1999-04-25)
Starring: Matt Keeslar and Patrick Bergin

Season 49 (1999–2000)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
202	1	Sarah, Plain and Tall: Winter's End (v, DVD)	Glenn Jordan	November 21, 1999 (1999-11-21)
Starring: Glenn Close and Christopher Walken
203	2	A Season for Miracles (v, DVD)	Michael Pressman	December 12, 1999 (1999-12-12)
Starring: Carla Gugino and Kathy Baker
204	3	Missing Pieces (v)	Carl Schenkel	February 6, 2000 (2000-02-06)
Starring: James Coburn and Lisa Zane
205	4	Cupid & Cate (v, DVD)	Brent Shields	May 7, 2000 (2000-05-07)
Starring: Mary-Louise Parker and Peter Gallagher

Season 50 (2000–01)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
206	1	The Lost Child (v, DVD)	Karen Arthur	November 19, 2000 (2000-11-19)
Starring: Mercedes Ruehl and Jamey Sheridan
207	2	The Runaway (v, DVD)	Arthur Allan Seidelman	December 10, 2000 (2000-12-10)
Starring: Dean Cain and Pat Hingle
208	3	The Flamingo Rising (v)	Martha Coolidge	February 4, 2001 (2001-02-04)
Starring: William Hurt and Elizabeth McGovern
209	4	Follow the Stars Home (v, DVD)	Dick Lowry	May 6, 2001 (2001-05-06)
Starring: Kimberly Williams and Campbell Scott

Season 51 (2001–02)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
210	1	In Love and War (v, DVD)	John Kent Harrison	November 18, 2001 (2001-11-18)
Starring: Callum Blue and Barbara Bobulova
211	2	The Seventh Stream (v, DVD)	John Gray	December 16, 2001 (2001-12-16)
Starring: Scott Glenn and Saffron Burrows
212	3	My Sister's Keeper (v, DVD)	Ron Lagomarsino	January 27, 2002 (2002-01-27)
Starring: Kathy Bates, Elizabeth Perkins and Lynn Redgrave
213	4	Little John (v, DVD)	Dick Lowry	May 5, 2002 (2002-05-05)
Starring: Gloria Reuben, Ving Rhames, Robert Bailey Jr. and Patty Duke

Season 52 (2002–03)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
214	1	The Locket (v, DVD)	Karen Arthur	December 8, 2002 (2002-12-08)
Starring: Vanessa Redgrave and Michael Keddington
215	2	Brush with Fate (v, DVD)	Brent Shields	February 2, 2003 (2003-02-02)
Starring: Glenn Close, Thomas Gibson and Ellen Burstyn
216	3	A Painted House (v, DVD)	Alfonso Arau	April 27, 2003 (2003-04-27)
Starring: Scott Glenn, Arija Bareikis and Robert Sean Leonard

Season 53 (2003–04)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
217	1	Fallen Angel (v, DVD)	Michael Switzer	November 26, 2003 (2003-11-26)
Starring: Gary Sinise and Joely Richardson
218	2	The Blackwater Lightship (v, DVD)	John Erman	February 6, 2004 (2004-02-06)
Starring: Angela Lansbury, Marijka Bardin and Sean Campion
219	3	Plainsong (v, DVD)	Richard Pearce	April 25, 2004 (2004-04-25)
Starring: Aidan Quinn and Rachel Griffiths

Season 54 (2004–05)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
220	N/A	A Painted House	Unknown	September 12, 2004 (2004-09-12)
Rerun of #216
221	1	Back When We Were Grownups (v, DVD)	Ron Underwood	November 21, 2004 (2004-11-21)
Starring: Blythe Danner, Faye Dunaway, Peter Fonda, Jack Palance, and Peter Riegert
222	N/A	Fallen Angel	Unknown	December 19, 2004 (2004-12-19)
Rerun of #217
223	2	The Magic of Ordinary Days (v, DVD)	Brent Shields	January 30, 2005 (2005-01-30)
Starring: Keri Russell and Skeet Ulrich
224	3	Riding the Bus with My Sister (v, DVD)	Anjelica Huston	May 1, 2005 (2005-05-01)
Starring: Rosie O'Donnell and Andie MacDowell

Season 55 (2005–06)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
225	1	Silver Bells (v, DVD)	Dick Lowry	November 27, 2005 (2005-11-27)
Starring: Tate Donovan and Anne Heche
226	2	The Water Is Wide (v, DVD)	John Kent Harrison	January 29, 2006 (2006-01-29)
Starring: Alfre Woodard and Jeff Hephner
227	3	In from the Night (v, DVD)	Peter Levin	April 23, 2006 (2006-04-23)
Starring: Marcia Gay Harden and Thomas Gibson

Season 56 (2006–07)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
228	1	Candles on Bay Street (v, DVD)	John Erman	November 26, 2006 (2006-11-26)
Starring: Alicia Silverstone, Annabeth Gish and Polly Bergen
229	2	The Valley of Light (v, DVD)	Brent Shields	January 28, 2007 (2007-01-28)
Starring: Chris Klein and Gretchen Mol
230	3	Crossroads: A Story of Forgiveness (v, DVD)	John Kent Harrison	April 22, 2007 (2007-04-22)
Starring: Dean Cain and Peri Gilpin

Season 57 (2007–08)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
231	1	Pictures of Hollis Woods (DVD)	Tony Bill	December 2, 2007 (2007-12-02)
Starring: Sissy Spacek and Alfre Woodard
232	2	The Russell Girl (DVD)	Jeff Bleckner	January 27, 2008 (2008-01-27)
Starring: Amber Tamblyn and Jennifer Ehle
233	3	Sweet Nothing in My Ear (DVD)	Joseph Sargent	April 20, 2008 (2008-04-20)
Starring: Jeff Daniels and Marlee Matlin

Season 58 (2008–09)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
234	1	Front of the Class (DVD)	Peter Werner	December 7, 2008 (2008-12-07)
Starring: Jimmy Wolk and Treat Williams
235	2	Loving Leah (DVD)	Jeff Bleckner	January 25, 2009 (2009-01-25)
Starring: Lauren Ambrose and Adam Kaufman
236	3	The Courageous Heart of Irena Sendler (DVD)	John Kent Harrison	April 19, 2009 (2009-04-19)
Starring: Anna Paquin and Marcia Gay Harden

Season 59 (2009–10)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
237	1	A Dog Named Christmas (DVD)	Peter Werner	November 29, 2009 (2009-11-29)
Starring: Bruce Greenwood
238	2	The Magic of Ordinary Days	Unknown	January 30, 2010 (2010-01-30)
Rerun of #223
239	3	When Love Is Not Enough: The Lois Wilson Story (DVD)	John Kent Harrison	April 25, 2010 (2010-04-25)
Starring: Winona Ryder

Season 60 (2010–11)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
240	1	November Christmas	Robert Harmon	November 28, 2010 (2010-11-28)
Starring: John Corbett and Sam Elliott
241	2	The Lost Valentine (DVD)	Darnell Martin	January 30, 2011 (2011-01-30)
Starring: Jennifer Love Hewitt and Betty White
242	3	Beyond the Blackboard	Jeff Bleckner	April 24, 2011 (2011-04-24)
Starring: Emily VanCamp, Timothy Busfield, Treat Williams

On May 6, 2011, CBS announced that they had cancelled the Hallmark Hall of Fame from their network.

Season 61 (2011–12)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
243	1	Have a Little Faith	Jon Avnet	November 27, 2011 (2011-11-27)
Starring: Laurence Fishburne, Bradley Whitford, and Martin Landau
244	2	A Smile as Big as the Moon	James Steven Sadwith	January 29, 2012 (2012-01-29)
Starring: John Corbett
245	3	Firelight^[5]	Darnell Martin	April 22, 2012 (2012-04-22)
Starring: Cuba Gooding Jr.

Season 62 (2012–13)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
246	1	Christmas with Holly	Allan Arkush	December 9, 2012 (2012-12-09)
Starring: Sean Faris
247	2	The Makeover	John Gray	January 27, 2013 (2013-01-27)
Starring: Julia Stiles
248	3	Remember Sunday	Jeff Bleckner	April 21, 2013 (2013-04-21)
Starring: Zachary Levi and Alexis Bledel

Season 63 (2013–14)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
249	1	Christmas in Conway	John Kent Harrison	December 1, 2013 (2013-12-01)
Starring: Andy Garcia, Mandy Moore, and Mary-Louise Parker
250	2	In My Dreams	Kenny Leon	April 20, 2014 (2014-04-20)
Starring: Katharine McPhee, Mike Vogel, and JoBeth Williams

From this point onward, all episodes will be seen exclusively on the Hallmark Channel.

Season 64 (2014–15)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
251	1	One Christmas Eve	Jay Russell	November 30, 2014 (2014-11-30)
Starring: Anne Heche
252	2	Away & Back	Jeff Bleckner	January 26, 2015 (2015-01-26)
Starring: Jason Lee and Minka Kelly

Season 65 (2015)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
253	1	Just in Time for Christmas	Sean McNamara	December 5, 2015 (2015-12-05)
Starring: Eloise Mumford, Michael Stahl-David, Christopher Lloyd, William Shatner

Season 66 (2016–17)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
254	1	A Heavenly Christmas	Paul Shapiro	November 26, 2016 (2016-11-26)
Starring: Kristin Davis, Eric McCormack, Shirley MacLaine
255	2	Love Locks	Martin Wood	January 28, 2017 (2017-01-28)
Starring: Rebecca Romijn, Jerry O'Connell, Bruce Davison

Season 67 (2017–18)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
256	1	The Christmas Train	Ron Oliver	November 25, 2017 (2017-11-25)
Starring: Dermot Mulroney, Kimberly Williams-Paisley, Danny Glover, Joan Cusack
257	2	The Beach House	Roger Spottiswoode	April 28, 2018 (2018-04-28)
Starring: Minka Kelly, Andie MacDowell, Chad Michael Murray, Makenzie Vega

Season 68 (2018–19)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
258	1	Christmas Everlasting	Ron Oliver	November 24, 2018 (2018-11-24)
Starring: Tatyana Ali, Dondré T. Whitfield, Dennis Haysbert, Patti LaBelle
259	2	Love Takes Flight	Steven R. Monroe	April 27, 2019 (2019-04-27)
Starring: Nikki DeLoach and Jeff Hephner

Season 69 (2019–20)

Hallmark no.	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Original air date
260	1	A Christmas Love Story	Eric Close	December 7, 2019 (2019-12-07)
Starring: Kristin Chenoweth, Scott Wolf, Keith Robinson, Kevin Quinn

Season 70 (2020-2021)

N/A

Season 71 (2021-2022)

N/A

Season 72 (2022-2023)

))