Champions by year
- 1985 Mesa State
- 1986 Mesa State
- 1987 Mesa State
- 1988 Mesa State
- 1989 Adams State
- 1990 Mesa State
- 1991 Western State
- 1992 Western State
- 1993 Fort Hays State
- 1994 Western State
- 1995 Fort Hays State & Western State
- 1996 Chadron State
- 1997 Western State
- 1998 Chadron State & Western State
- 1999 Chadron State & N.M. Highlands
- 2000 Mesa State
- 2001 Chadron State
- 2002 Chadron State & Nebraska-Kearney
- 2003 Mesa State
- 2004 Colorado Mines
- 2005 Nebraska-Kearney
- 2006 Chadron State
- 2007 Chadron State
- 2008 Chadron State
- 2009 Nebraska-Kearney
- 2010 Colorado Mines & Nebraska-Kearney
- 2011 CSU Pueblo
- 2012 CSU Pueblo
- 2013 CSU Pueblo
- 2014 CSU Pueblo & Colorado Mines
- 2015 Colorado Mesa †
- 2016 Colorado Mesa, Colorado Mines & CSU Pueblo
- 2017 Colorado Mesa & CSU Pueblo
- 2018 Colorado Mines & CSU Pueblo
- 2019 Colorado Mines
- 2020 None
- 2021 Colorado Mines & Western Colorado
- 2022 Colorado Mines
† Colorado Mesa declared champion due to CSU–Pueblo's use of academically ineligible players.[4]