1957 British film by Directed by Guy Hamilton
Manuela (U.S. title: Stowaway Girl ) is a 1957 British drama film directed by Guy Hamilton, starring Trevor Howard and Elsa Martinelli.[1]
Plot
James Prothero is the jaded, alcoholic, disillusioned captain of a ship due to leave South America for England. He falls for Manuela, a young Spanish girl smuggled aboard by the ship's first mate. His infatuation leads to the loss of the ship. Realising he has no future with Manuela, he returns to sea alone.
Critical response
The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "[But it is] on the whole an unsatisfying film, with its sum inferior to its parts, with disparate elements which somehow do not come together. This is due in large measure to the casting, with its obvious eye to the international market. Trevor Howard gives a finely-tempered performance as the middle-aged, alcoholic master, an almost Conradian character; but here, as in Outcast of the Islands [1952], he cannot succeed in conveying the illusion of an all-consuming passion, upon which the story of Manuela also hangs. Beside Elsa Martinelli's weakly inadequate lost waif, much of the power of Howard's acting is lost and it appears to be projected in vacuo. ... Otto Heller's camerawork is particularly fine, giving the film a visual quality which ultimately serves to expose a lack of distinction elsewhere."[2]
The Radio Times Guide to Films gave the film 2/5 stars, writing: "This unlikely shipboard romance was later gently lampooned in Carry On Jack [1964]. Director Guy Hamilton does a fair job of reining in Trevor Howard's natural bullishness, coming as close as anyone ever did to discovering vulnerability in his gruff make-up. Elsa Martinelli never really convinces in her boyish disguise, but it's clear to see why tipsy Captain Howard would fall for her. This frippery is beneath the cast, but it still has an easy charm."[3]
Leslie Halliwell said: "Downbeat seafaring malodrama, fine for those seeking a mood piece."[4]
In British Sound Films: The Studio Years 1928–1959 David Quinlan rated the film as "good", writing: "Overall quite powerful romantic drama somewhat after Joseph Conrad in tone."[5]
Accolades
The film was entered into the 7th Berlin International Film Festival.[6]
