Pakistani YouTuber and religious scholars (born 1977)
Muhammad Ali Mirza (Urdu: محمد علی مرزا; born 4 October 1977) is a Pakistani YouTuber and Islamic scholar. An engineer by profession, he is known for his outspoken style and numerous controversies.
Early life and education
Muhammad Ali Mirza was born on 4 October 1977 in Jhelum, Punjab.[1] His father, Mirza Arshad Mahmud, reportedly used to work in Allied Bank. Ali Mirza obtained his education as an engineer from University of Engineering and Technology, Taxila. He worked as a mechanical engineer for the Government of Punjab on the 19th pay scale but later quit when the department asked him to leave because he had become a public figure.[3][4][5]
Career
Mirza gives online lectures on religious issues and runs a research academy based on his understanding of the Quran and Sunnat.[6][3][7] His critics claim that he uses derogatory terms for Muslim saints.[3][8] Many religious scholars and social media users criticize Muhammad Ali Mirza for his excessive 'pride' and 'ego'.
Mirza allegedly opined that present day Ahmadis are better than Jews and Christians (the people of the book). He also said they are not Muslims and said that his video clips have been presented out of context.[3] He was arrested on 4 May 2020 in suspicion of spreading hate speech towards religious scholars.[9][6] Pakistani actor Hamza Ali Abbasi and anchor Shafaat Ali posted on social media condemning his arrest.[6] He was later released on 6 May 2020.[10][11][12] According to Ali, one of his lectures was presented completely out of context. He later said that if one starts presenting other opinions in such a way then even the verses of the Qur'an can be presented out of context.[6][3]
Assassination attempts
In August 2023, the attacker identified as Ali Hasan, who hailed from Gujrat, armed with a sharp weapon, shoved the guard, in an attempt to barge into the Jhelum Academy’s premises. The attacker was however out powered by the guards and other members of the academy. Meanwhile, a case has been registered and investigations are underway.[citation needed]
On 14 March 2021, Mirza survived a second assassination attempt, first in 2017. The attacker visited his academy in Jhelum, Pakistan at weekly meeting and attempted to kill him with a knife while taking a picture with him. Ali escaped with minor injuries. Police arrested two suspects and registered an FIR against them. The attacker had traveled from Lahore to Jhelum to kill Mirza.[13][14][15]
Controversies
Mirza's views on Mu'awiya I, the first caliph of the Umayyad Caliphate, had made him a controversial figure among the traditionalist Sunni Muslim ulama of Pakistan. He has had a long rivalry with Deobandist scholar Tariq Masood over Mu'awiya.[16] Mirza challenged Masood to arrive in Jhelum and have a debate face to face.[16] In May 2021, the debate was postponed since Masood didn't come in[17] After many months, Masood finally accepted the challenge and went to Jhelum for the debate.[18] However, Masood claimed that he had tried to make contacts with Mirza, but there was no answer.[18] Masood claimed that he took a very long journey from Karachi to Jhelum for discussion.[18] As a result, Mufti Tariq Masood declared victory against Muhammad Ali Mirza and numerous netizens/social media users called the drop scene of this whole saga as Mirza's defeat.[19]
In November 2023, Mirza and Barelvist scholar Mufti Hanif Qureshi were scheduled to have a munazra (face-to-face debate). On 26 November, Qureshi arrived in Jhelum and went to outside of the Mirza Academy of Jhelum, however he was refused entrance inside by security. Mirza then refused to have a munazra. Qureshi subsequently then left Jhelum and his "victory" was celebrated by his supporters.[20]
Nupur Sharma case
In June 2022, Ali Mirza criticized Taslim Rehmani for badmouthing Hindu gods in front of BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma on Times Now. He said Nupur Sharma abused Muhammad in reaction to that. Rubika Liakat praised Ali Mirza for his stand with Nupur Sharma on her Twitter account. Many Indian and Pakistani Ulemas were furious with Ali Mirza for this comment.[21][22]
2023 blasphemy charges
In April 2023, a case of blasphemy was registered against Ali Mirza under section 295C of the Pakistan Penal Code. The accusations against Mirza include mocking Muhammad and downplaying the Pakistani legal ruling that considers Ahmadis to have non-Muslim status. His critics claim that he uses derogatory language when referring to Muslim saints and presents clips from his lectures out of context to support his arguments. Pir Afzal Qadri, a religious cleric, has offered a reward of Rs.500,000 for the assassination of Ali Mirza, stating that he deserves to be killed.[23] The accusations of blasphemy are considered serious in Pakistan, and if convicted, Mirza could face severe punishment under the blasphemy laws.[24]
