Selections
| ^ | Denotes players who are still active in the NHL |
| * | Denotes players inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame |
| † | Denotes inactive players not yet eligible for Hockey Hall of Fame consideration |
| Player (X) | Denotes the number of times a player has been selected |
| Player (in bold text) |
Denotes players who won the Hart Memorial Trophy as the NHL's Most Valuable Player in the same year |
| Player (in italic text) |
Denotes players who won the James Norris Memorial Trophy as the NHL's best defenseman in the same year |
Early years (1930–31 to 1941–42)
Original Six era (1942–43 to 1966–67)
.jpg)
Doug Harvey was selected for the NHL All-Star Team 11 times.
Expansion era (1967–68 to 2004–05)
.jpg)
.JPG)
Post-lockout era (2005–06 to present)
