The following is a list of players and who appeared in at least one game for the New York Metropolitans Major League Baseball franchise of the American Association from 1883 through 1887.

B

• Ed Bagley
• Buck Becannon
• Steve Behel
• Steve Brady
• Cal Broughton

C

• Bill Collins
• Peter Connell
• Sam Crane
• Clarence Cross
• Doug Crothers
• Joe Crotty
• Ed Cushman

D

• Jim Donahue

E

• Dude Esterbrook

F

• Bill Fagan
• Tom Forster
• Elmer Foster

G

• Joe Gerhardt

H

• Charlie Hall
• Frank Hankinson
• Mortimer Hogan
• Bill Holbert
• Sadie Houck

J

• Jones (third baseman)
• Charley Jones

K

• Tim Keefe
• Ed Kennedy
• Tom Kinslow
• Jimmy Knowles

L

• Jack Lynch

M

• Fred Mauer
• Al Mays
• Tom McLaughlin
• James McMullin
• John Meister
• Jon Morrison
• Tony Murphy

N

• Candy Nelson

O

• Darby O'Brien
• Tom O'Brien
• Fred O'Neill
• John O'Rourke
• Dave Orr
• Henry Oxley

P

• Charlie Parsons
• Gracie Pierce
• Dick Pierson
• Lip Pike

R

• Paul Radford
• Joe Reilly
• Charlie Reipschlager
• Chief Roseman
• Cyclone Ryan

S

• John Shaffer
• Andy Sommers

T

• Dasher Troy

W

• Stump Weidman

Z

• Chief Zimmer