Pangamic acid, also called pangamate, is the name given to a chemical compound discovered by Ernst T. Krebs Sr. His son, Ernst T. Krebs Jr., promoted it as a medicinal compound for use in treatment of a wide range of diseases. They also termed this chemical "vitamin B15", though it is not a true vitamin, has no nutritional value,[1] has no known use in the treatment of any disease, and has been called a "quack remedy". Although a number of compounds labelled "pangamic acid" have been studied or sold (including the 1951 d-gluconodimethylamino acetic acid), no chemical compound, including those claimed by the Krebses to be pangamic acid, has been scientifically verified to have the characteristics that defined the original description of the compound.
The Krebses derived the term "pangamic" to describe this compound which they asserted to be ubiquitous and highly concentrated in seeds (pan meaning "universal" and gamic meaning "seed").[2]
Chemistry
Pangamic acid is the name given to the chemical compound with the empirical formula C 10H 19O 8N and a molecular weight of 281 which appeared to be an ester derived from d-gluconic acid and dimethylglycine. In 1943, the Krebses applied for a patent for a process for extracting this chemical compound which they reported had been previously isolated from apricot seeds, and received the patent in 1949.[3] A 1951 paper by the Krebses reported the first isolation of this compound using this patented process, but did not include enough information to confirm that this compound was actually isolated.[4] In 1955, the Krebses received a patent for another synthesizing process for "N-substituted glycine esters of gluconic acid",[5] but the patent contained no supporting data to confirm the process was able to synthesize compounds described by the patent, including pangamic acid.[2]
Subsequent attempts at synthesizing this ester by other researchers found Krebs' purported methods of producing pangamic acid were not reproducible, and research into pangamic acid have focused on compounds of various chemical compositions. A review noted that of all the chemicals described in research about pangamic acid, "[n]ot a single product labeled 'pangamate' or 'B15' has been established in a scientifically verifiable manner to conform to the empiric formula" described by the Krebses.[2] Analysis of a sample of a compound called "pangamic acid" which was provided by a co-worker of the Krebses in the 1950s showed only lactose upon further evaluation by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.[1] Thus, "pangamic acid" is more a label used to describe one of any number of chemical compounds rather than a particular substance.[2]
Chemical compounds sold as "pangamic acid" for medicinal purposes have also had various chemical compositions, and suppliers of "pangamic acid" have regularly changed the chemical composition of the compounds sold under this label.[6] One anecdote noted that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has seized lots of "calcium pangamate" sold by General Nutrition Center (GNC), which agreed to stop selling the compound in those bottles after the FDA filed suit to stop sales. Afterwards, it was noted that GNC was still selling something in the same bottles with the same labels, likely a different compound.[1] Due to ambiguity in situations like this, the FDA considers it "not an identifiable substance".[6]
To summarize, substances that have been claimed to be pangamic acid include:[2]
d-gluconodimethylamino acetic acid (Krebes 1951), never synthesized. Alternative Soviet synthesis of calcium salt also fails to reproduce.
Variety of mixtures containing dimethylamine. Result of attempts to synthesize the 1951 compound. Possibly mutagenic.
Pharmacologically inert materials, ranging from "synthesis attempts" containing calcium gluconate to pure lactose.
Clinical claims and research
The Krebses' original patent claimed pangamic acid could be used for detoxification as well as treatment of asthma, skin conditions, joint pain, and nerve pain, with none of these claims supported by evidence in the patent application. Early promotion for pangamic acid included use by race horses as well as humans. Although given the name "Vitamin B15" by the Krebses, there is no evidence that it meets the definition of a vitamin as there is no evidence it is a nutrient needed by the body.[6]
Much of the clinical research on pangamic acid took place in the former Soviet Union, though that research often did not describe which of the many compounds called "pangamic acid" was used in the study. This research was also of limited quality due to being overwhelmingly anecdotal in nature (as opposed to controlled experimentation) and ignoring short and long term safety in human use.[6]
Although more recent[when?] claims include treatment of a wide variety of conditions including cancer, heart disease, schizophrenia as well as providing improvement in oxygen utilization, there is no significant evidence for any of these claims or that it is safe for human use. One review noted that it meets "the criteria that define a quack remedy".[6]
Safety
Positive results from mutagenicity analysis via the Ames test of compounds commonly found in preparations labelled "pangamic acid" including diisopropylamine dichloroacetate, diisopropylamine,[7]dichloroacetate,[8] as well as dimethylglycine mixed with sodium nitrite[1] suggests there may be concern for the development of cancer with the use of these substances.
Legal status
The FDA has recommended seizing any chemicals advertised as pangamic acid and restraining the importation and interstate shipment of pangamic acid on the grounds that pangamic acid and pangamic acid products are unsafe for use and have no known nutritional properties.[9] Pangamic acid's distribution in Canada has been prohibited by the then-named Canadian Food and Drug Directorate.[6]
^US 2464240, "Therapeutic material and method of obtaining the same"
^KREBS ET Sr; KREBS ET Jr; BEARD HH; MALIN R; HARRIS AT; BARTLETT CL (1951). "Pangamic acid sodium: A newly isolated crystalline water-soluble factor; a preliminary report". International Record of Medicine and General Practice Clinics. 164 (1): 18–23. PMID14840945.
^US 2710876, "N-substituted glycine esters of gluconic acid"
^Gelernt MD, Herbert V (1982). "Mutagenicity of diisopropylamine dichloroacetate, the "active constituent" of vitamin B15 (pangamic acid)". Nutr Cancer. 3 (3): 129–33. doi:10.1080/01635588109513714. PMID6752894.
^Herbert V, Gardner A, Colman N (June 1980). "Mutagenicity of dichloroacetate, an ingredient of some formulations of pangamic acid (trade-named "vitamin B15")". Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 33 (6): 1179–82. doi:10.1093/ajcn/33.6.1179. PMID6992558.
