Spanish Hill is a hill located in the borough of South Waverly, Pennsylvania. Opinions regarding the origin of structures found on the site vary from embankments created by early farmers, to the remnants of a Native American village and battlements, due to the site's similarity to the description found in the account of Étienne Brûlé of a settlement called Carantouan. The area in the hill's vicinity was previously occupied by Susquehannock Native Americans. It was a common site for both amateur and professional archaeology, as well as relic hunting. The source of the name remains unknown, but various theories have been proposed as to its origin.
Geography
A sketch of Spanish Hill, including a diagram of its structures. The double lines indicate portions still visible in 1898, while the dotted line represents what the author believed to be a palisade.
In 1795, François Alexandre Frédéric visited Spanish Hill while en route to Canada.[1] He described the hill as "a mountain in the shape of a sugar loaf, about 100 feet high, with level top, on which are remains of intrenchments. One perpendicular breastwork is still remaining, plainly indicating a parapet and ditch."[2] In 1833, another individual visiting the hill described "the remains of a wall which runs around the whole exactly on the brow, and within a deep ditch or intrenchment running round the whole summit."[2] In 1898, I.P. Shepard created a sketch of Spanish Hill, including the portions still visible at the time as well as those no longer extant.[3] Shepard enlisted the assistance of a longtime local resident, Charles Henry Shepard, who claimed to remember "fortifications as consisting of an embankment with a trench behind, giving a height of four or five feet on the inside."[3] In addition, an indent was discovered on the site which was pronounced to be a corn cache by Rev. W. M. Beauchamp.[4]
According to John S. Clark, a surveyor and amateur historian active in the area until the early twentieth century, the topography and size of the site were appropriate to correspond with Brûlé's description of Carantouan;[2] Brûlé described a palisaded town, populated by approximately 800 warriors and 4,000 individuals in total.[5] He also described the dwellings and fortifications as being similar to those built by the Wyandot people.[5] Clark's conclusions were based in part on surveys he conducted at the site in 1878, when he observed what he believed were fortifications atop the hill.[1] Amateur archaeologist Ellsworth C. Cowles conducted an excavation at the base of the hill in 1932, uncovering what he described as "seventy five postholes extending east and west," as well as the "effigy of a huge animal."[6]
History
Projectile points and various other Native American artifacts found at the Spanish Hill site
Early scholars believed that the monument was created by receding glaciers;[2] Spanish Hill comprises approximately 10 acres (40,000 m2) of earth in a site that is included within the Sayre quadrangle documented by the United States Geological Survey (USGS).[7][8] Located at an elevation of 978 feet (298 m) above sea level,[8] it rises approximately 230 feet (70 m) over the nearby floodplain of the Chemung River.[7] The hill is located in South Waverly, Pennsylvania, in Bradford County,[7] just south of the state border with New York. This territory was occupied by the Susquehannock people for centuries before European contact.
The remnant of the hill depicted in the late 19th century etching show has a striking resemblance to major earthwork platform mounds of the Mississippian culture and preceding cultures. The most recent of these were built and occupied from the 9th to the 15th centuries CE, and earlier mounds have also been found. These mounds typically were built as the center of villages along the lowland of rivers throughout the Mississippi and Ohio river valleys, and their tributaries. Many such mounds have been found at the site of former Cherokee villages in western North Carolina and eastern Tennessee narrow river valleys in the Appalachian foothills. The mounds were built as earthworks.
The hill has been acknowledged and studied by historians and archaeologists for more than two hundred years.[7] The source of the name is unknown, but individuals traveling through the area between 1795 and 1804 described "Spanish Ramparts" as a feature of the hill.[2] Some of the earliest settlers to the region reported that local Native Americans referred to the hill either as "Hispan" or "Espan."[9]
In 1615, Étienne Brûlé was sent to the area by Samuel de Champlain to meet with Native American tribes in the hope of finding assistance to fight the Iroquois nations, against whom Champlain had allied with the Wyandot people.[10] During his voyage, Brûlé recorded a town called Carantouan (meaning "Big Tree," according to ethnologist William Martin Beauchamp),[11] which was subsequently included on a map published by de Champlain in 1632.[12] In the early nineteenth century, a Native American man who lived in the area near Spanish Hill reportedly refused to ascend it, for fear of a deadly spirit that lived on top.[13] According to the man, the spirit spoke with a thunderous voice and "made holes through Indians' bodies."[13] Archaeologist Louise Welles Murray suggested that this could be a reference to cannon or musket fire.[13]
In the early twentieth century, archaeological and historical research was conducted regarding a potential connection between Carantouan and the structures described in historical accounts of the hill.[14] After surveying the area in spring and fall, archaeologist L.D. Shoemaker discovered evidence of Native American habitation, including shell heaps, corn and flint chips, along with various other implements.[15] In 1918, historian and archaeologist George P. Donehoo, after a survey of the site, determined that it was impossible for Spanish Hill to have been the site of the town described by Brûlé.[16] He cited the sharp incline, which would have made ascent difficult, as well as the lack of water. Archaeological evidence on the hill appeared to be in conflict with its having been the location of Carantouan.[16] But archeology was just being developed as an academic area, and early excavations did not follow current protocols for assessing layers and ages of artifacts. In addition, architectural development and looting could have destroyed important evidence.
Speculation that Spanish Hill was the site of the village was also countered by James Bennett Griffin, who found nothing of interest in the area following an archaeological survey in 1931.[17] But 21st-century historian Deb Twigg suggests that prior excavations conducted by early twentieth-century archaeologist Warren Moorehead, as well as years of extensive farming activity in the area, may have contributed to the lack of artifacts found during the Griffin expedition.[17] As Twig wrote: “Until more information is known, it seems imprudent to eliminate Spanish Hill as a possible site related to the nation of Carantouan, as some researchers have done.”[18]
The site was a popular location, both for archaeological excavations and amateur collecting.[6] According to Twigg, Spanish Hill was "looted" by Moorehead, and his finds likely sold to collectors.[17] In addition, the area was repeatedly scoured by relic collectors approximately since the early nineteenth-century.[15]
In 1970 the hill was threatened with demolition to be used for highway fill. Lobbying by local amateur archaeologist Ellsworth Cowles preserved the hill.[21]
Twigg, Deborah (Fall 2005). "Revisiting the Mystery of "Carantouan" and Spanish Hill". Pennsylvania Archaeologist. Society for Pennsylvania Archaeology. 75 (2).
