Substance
Compilation album by
Joy Division
Released11 July 1988
RecordedDecember 1977 – March 1980
GenrePost-punk, punk rock, gothic rock[1]
Length37:52 (LP)
62:29 (CD)
LabelFactory
ProducerMartin Hannett, Joy Division
Joy Division compilations chronology
Still
(1981) 		Substance
(1988) 		The Peel Sessions
(1990)
Alternative cover
CD cover design
Singles from Substance
  1. "Atmosphere"
    Released: 6 June 1988
Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic[2]
Robert ChristgauB+[3]
Uncut8/10[4]

Substance is a singles compilation album by British rock band Joy Division. It was released on 11 July 1988 by Factory Records. It is the companion to a similar singles compilation by their subsequent band New Order, also titled Substance. It peaked at number 7 on the UK Albums Chart[5] and 146 on the Billboard 200, the band's only chart appearance in the United States. It also reached number 15 in New Zealand and number 53 in Australia in August 1988.

Content

Substance compiles the four singles released by the band that did not appear on albums — "Transmission", "Komakino", "Love Will Tear Us Apart", and "Atmosphere" — as well as most of their B-sides. It also collects tracks released on various EPs, namely the band's first release, An Ideal for Living, and two samplers issued by Factory Records, A Factory Sample and Earcom 2: Contradiction.

Two of the album's tracks, "Glass" and "Dead Souls", were previously included on the 1981 compilation Still. Additionally, the single "Atmosphere" had been originally issued in France as "Licht und Blindheit" with "Dead Souls" on the B-side; following Ian Curtis's suicide, it was reissued as a posthumous B-side of the "She's Lost Control" 12-inch single. The vinyl version omits the single "Komakino" and does not include the complete titles from the EPs, due to the lower storage capacity of a vinyl record.

Later CD pressings issued by London Records contain a previously unreleased mix of "She's Lost Control" that is slightly different from the original single release. More guitar is mixed within the song, the synthesizer melody is shortened and starts at a later point, and the ending of the song is extended by 15 seconds and does not fade out.

Substance was digitally remastered in 2015, containing not only the alternate mix of "She's Lost Control", but also two additional tracks: "As You Said" (the second B-side of "Komakino") and the initial take of "Love Will Tear Us Apart" (originally released on the B-side of the original single), dubbed the "Pennine Version" after the studio it was recorded at.

Cover

The cover features the title of the album in green spelled with characters from Wim Crouwel's New Alphabet typeface below Joy Division's name and the years of recording in a smaller white font. The letters used in the title actually spell "Subst1mce", rather than "Substance". Brett Wickens, who worked on this cover whilst a partner at Saville Associates, claims this was for aesthetic reasons.[6]

Track listing

LP (Factory FACT 250)

All tracks are written by Joy Division

Side one
No.TitleOriginal releaseLength
1."Warsaw"An Ideal for Living2:25
2."Leaders of Men"An Ideal for Living2:35
3."Digital"A Factory Sample2:50
4."Autosuggestion"Earcom 2: Contradiction6:08
5."Transmission""Transmission" (FAC 13)3:36
Side two
No.TitleOriginal releaseLength
1."She's Lost Control""Atmosphere" (FACUS 2)4:45 (4:59 on later pressings)
2."Incubation""Komakino" (FAC 28)2:52
3."Dead Souls"Licht und Blindheit4:56
4."Atmosphere""Atmosphere" (FACUS 2)4:10
5."Love Will Tear Us Apart""Love Will Tear Us Apart" (FAC 23)3:25

CD (Factory FACD 250) and cassette (Factory FACT 250C)

Same tracks as LP plus the following bonus tracks, titled Appendix:

No.TitleOriginal releaseLength
11."No Love Lost"An Ideal for Living3:43
12."Failures"An Ideal for Living3:44
13."Glass"A Factory Sample3:53
14."From Safety to Where...?"Earcom 2: Contradiction2:27
15."Novelty""Transmission" (FAC 13)4:00
16."Komakino""Komakino" (FAC 28)3:52
17."These Days""Love Will Tear Us Apart" (FAC 23)3:24

2015 remastered edition bonus tracks

No.TitleOriginal releaseLength
17."As You Said""Komakino" (FAC 28)2:00
18."These Days""Love Will Tear Us Apart" (FAC 23)3:24
19."Love Will Tear Us Apart" (Pennine version)"Love Will Tear Us Apart" (FAC 23)3:15

Personnel

Certifications

Region Certification Certified units/sales
United Kingdom (BPI)[7] Gold 100,000^

^ Shipments figures based on certification alone.

References

  1. ^ Soghomonian, Talia (5 March 2009). "Release The Bats - It's The 20 Greatest Goth Tracks". NME. Retrieved 10 June 2016.
  2. ^ Substance at AllMusic
  3. ^ "Robert Christgau: CG: joy division". Robertchristgau.com. Retrieved 10 June 2016.
  4. ^ McKay, Alastair (September 2015). "Joy Division: Substance". Uncut. p. 92.
  5. ^ Joy Division UK Charts. Officialcharts.com. Retrieved 2012-01-04
  6. ^ "Saville Associates | Typophile". Archived from the original on 16 June 2011. Retrieved 27 November 2010.
  7. ^ "British album certifications – Joy Division – Substance". British Phonographic Industry. Retrieved 21 July 2022.
Categories