- Lynds
- Wiltse
- Seymour
- Peck
- Rowell (1845–1848)
- Smith (1848–1849)
- Potter (January, 1849)
- Booth (July, 1849)
- Lockwood (1850–1855)
- Batterman (1855–1856)
- Beardsley (1856–1862)
- Hubbell (1862-1864)
- Sutton (1864-1865)
- Johnson (1865–1868)
- Forrest (1868–1869)
- Henry C. Nelson (1869–1870)
- E. M. Russell (1870–1872)
- Henry C. Nelson (1872–1873)
- Gaylord B. Hubbell (1873–1874)
- James Williamson (September 1874)
- Alfred Walker (October 1874)
- George R. Youngs (1876–1877)
- Charles Davis (February 1877)
- Benjamin S. W. Clark (March 1877)
- Charles Davis (1877–1880)
- Augustus A. Brush (1880–1891)
- W. R. Brown (1891–1893)
- Charles F. Durston (1893–1894)
- Omar Van Leuven Sage (1894-1899)
- Addison Johnson (1899–1907)
- Jesse D. Frost (1907–1911)
- John S. Kennedy (1911–1913)
- James Connaughton (June 1913) acting warden
- James M. Clancy (1913–1914)
- Thomas McCormick (June 1914)
- George S. Weed (October 1914) acting warden
- Thomas Mott Osborne (1914–1915)
- George W. Kirchwey (1915)
- Thomas Mott Osborne (July 1916)
- Calvin Derrick (October 1916)
- William H. Moyer (1916–1919)
- Edward V. Brophy (April 1919)
- Daniel J. Grant (1919–1920) acting warden
- Lewis E. Lawes (1920–1941)
- Robert J. Kirby (1941–1944)
- William F. Snyder (1944–1950)
- Wilfred L. Denno (1950–1967)
- John T. Deegan (1967–1969)
- James L. Casscles (1969–1972)
- Theodore Schubin (1972–1975)
- Joseph Higgins (July 1975) acting warden
- Harold Butler (October 1975)
- William G. Gard (1975–1977)
- Walter Fogg (August 1977) acting warden
- Stephen Dalsheim (1977–1980)
- Wilson E.J. Walters (1980–1983)
- James E. Sullivan (1983–1988)
- John P. Keane (1988–1997)
- Charles Greiner (1997–2000)
- Brian S. Fischer (2000–2007)
- Louis Marshall (2007-)
|