- Butler (1813–16)
- Tompkins (1816–21)
- M'Crohan (1821–25)
- Goddard (1826–29)
- Farnsworth (1837–38)
- Harney (1838–44)
- Guthrie (1844–46)
- Nicholas (1846–47)
- Guthrie (1847–69)
- Caldwell (1869–85)
- Pirtle (1886–1905)
- Burnett (1905–11)
- Fairleigh (1911–14)
- Ford (1914–26)
- Colvin (1926–28)
- Patterson # (1928–29)
- Kent (1929–43)
- Jacobsen (1943–46)
- Stamm # (1946–47)
- Taylor (1947–50)
- Brown # (1950–51)
- Davidson (1951–68)
- Strickler (1968–72)
- Ekstrom # (1972–73)
- Miller (1973–80)
- Ekstrom # (1980–81)
- Swain (1981–95)
- Shumaker (1995–02)
- Garrison # (2002)
- Ramsey (2002–16)
- Pinto # (2016–17)
- Postel # (2017–18)
- Bendapudi (2018–21)
- Gonzalez # (2022–23)
- Schatzel (2023–)
# denotes interim president