The Midnight Meat Train is a 2008 American horror film based on Clive Barker's 1984 short story of the same name, which can be found in Volume One of Barker's collection Books of Blood. The film follows a photographer who attempts to track down a serial killer dubbed the "Subway Butcher", and discovers more than he bargained for under the city streets.
The film was directed by Ryuhei Kitamura, and stars Bradley Cooper, Leslie Bibb, Brooke Shields, Roger Bart, Ted Raimi and Vinnie Jones. Its script was adapted by Jeff Buhler, the producer was Tom Rosenberg of Lakeshore Entertainment, and it was released on August 1, 2008. The film received mostly positive reviews. Producer Joe Daley, a long-time friend of Buhler's, brought the two writers together and helped develop the script, along with producers Anthony DiBlasi and Jorge Saralegui, for their and Clive Barker's production company Midnight Picture Show, which was responsible for Book of Blood, the next film adaptation from the anthology of short stories that spawned The Midnight Meat Train.
Plot
Leon is a photographer who wants to capture unique gritty shots of the city. He is crushed when, instead of giving him his big break, gallery owner Susan criticizes him for not taking enough risks. Emboldened, he heads into the city's subway system at night, where he takes pictures of an impending sexual assault before saving the woman, who kisses Leon before running to catch the subway. After she thinks she’s safe, a mysterious man comes from behind her and hits her with a weapon. The next day, Leon discovers she has gone missing. Intrigued, he investigates reports of similar disappearances. His investigation leads him to a butcher named Mahogany, whom he suspects has been killing subway passengers for the past three years.
Leon presents his photos to the police, but Detective Hadley doesn't believe him. Leon's involvement quickly turns into a dark obsession, upsetting his girlfriend Maya, who is also disbelieving of his story. Leon follows Mahogany onto the last subway train of the night, only to witness a bloodbath. The butcher kills several passengers and hangs their bodies on meat hooks. After a brief scuffle with Mahogany, Leon passes out on the train. He awakes the next morning in a slaughterhouse with strange markings carved into his chest.
A concerned Maya and her friend Jurgis examine Leon's photos of Mahogany, leading them to the killer's apartment. After breaking in, Jurgis is captured, though Maya escapes with timetables that record over a hundred years of murders on the subway. She goes to the police but finds Hadley still skeptical. When Hadley presses Maya to return the timetables, she demands answers. At gunpoint, Hadley directs her to take the midnight train to find Jurgis. Leon heads to a hidden subway entrance in the slaughterhouse, arming himself with several knives.
Leon boards the train as Mahogany completes his nightly massacre and corners Maya. Leon attacks the butcher with a knife, and the two fight in between the swinging human flesh. Human body parts are ripped, thrown, and used as weapons. Jurgis, hung from a meat hook, dies when he is gutted. The train reaches its final stop, a cavernous abandoned station filled with skulls and decomposing bodies. The conductor appears, and asks Leon and Maya to "please step away from the meat." The true purpose of the abandoned station is revealed, as reptilian creatures enter the car and start eating the bodies of the murdered passengers. Leon and Maya flee into the cavern. Mahogany, battered, fights to the death with Leon, who stabs a broken femur through Mahogany's throat. A dying Mahogany grins and tells Leon "Welcome!"
The conductor tells Leon the creatures have lived beneath the city long before the subway was constructed, and the butcher's job is to feed them each night to keep them from attacking subway riders during the day. He picks up Leon and, with the same supernatural strength as the deceased butcher, rips out Leon's tongue and eats it. The conductor brings Leon's attention to Maya, who has been knocked unconscious and is lying on a pile of bones. The conductor forces Leon to watch as he cuts Maya's chest open and removes her heart. He says that, having killed the butcher, Leon must take his place.
Detective Hadley hands the train schedule to the new butcher, who wears a ring with the symbol of the group that feeds the creatures. The killer boards the midnight train, and is revealed to be Leon.
The film's original director, Patrick Tatopoulos, originally planned to shoot the film in 2005 in New York City and Montreal. Tatopoulos left the production in 2006 and was replaced by Ryuhei Kitamura. Shooting was moved to Los Angeles, due to the prohibitive cost of shooting in New York City. Various locations, including the L.A. Metro subway system, were used instead.[4] Shooting began on March 18, 2007.
Music
The "official" soundtrack from Lakeshore Records (only containing two remixes of the separately available actual film score) was produced and remixed by Justin Lassen and includes the bands and artists Iconcrash, Breaking The Jar, Blind Divine, Manakin Moon, Three Dot Revelation, Apocalyptica, Slvtn, Alu, Robert Williamson, Johannes Kobilke, Second Coming, Illusion of Order, Jason Hayes, Gerard K Marino, Penetrator, and Digital Dirt Heads.[5]
Release
Initially, The Midnight Meat Train was set for a May 16, 2008, release but was delayed.[6][7] Ultimately, the film's release on August 1 was limited to the secondary market, of which only 100 screens showed it, with plans for a quick release on DVD.[8] The world premiere was on July 19, 2008, at the Fantasia Festival in Montreal, in the presence of director Ryuhei Kitamura.[9] An internet campaign was started by several horror websites to draw attention to the scaled-down theatrical release.[10]
Barker was angry with Lionsgate's treatment, believing the studio's president Joe Drake to be shortchanging other people's films to focus more attention on films like The Strangers, where he received a producing credit: "The politics that are being visited upon it have nothing to do with the movie at all. This is all about ego, and though I mourn the fact that The Midnight Meat Train was never given its chance in theaters, it's a beautifully stylish, scary movie, and it isn't going anywhere. People will find it, and whether they find it in midnight shows or they find it on DVD, they'll find it, and in the end the Joe Drakes of the world will disappear."[11]
The Midnight Meat Train was released theatrically in Australia on February 19, 2009. DVD and Blu-ray releases followed on July 14.[12]
Reception
On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 71% of 34 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 5.9/10. The website's consensus reads: "A creative and energetic adaptation of a Clive Barker short story, with enough scares and thrills to be a potential cult classic."[13]
In a review written for The Austin Chronicle, Marjorie Baumgarten awarded the film a score of 2½ out of 5 and wrote, "The Midnight Meat Train, at least until it crumbles in the last act, is a well-done horror movie that harks back to the slasher films of the Eighties."[14] Ken Hanke of Mountain Xpress praised The Midnight Meat Train, deeming it the best English-language horror film of 2008 and writing, "Well, Midnight Meat Train may be no classic of the genre, but it's certainly a better and more interesting film than most of what passes for horror movies these days."[15] In a review written for PopMatters, Bill Gibron opined that the "splatter noir" film was "part genius, part genre excess" in which the ideas of short story author Clive Barker were "wholly realized in brilliant fashion."[16] Jenni Miller of Première gave the film a score of 3/5 and wrote, "While it's difficult to make a short story into a feature length film, and Midnight definitely has its hiccups, director Ryuhei Kitamura's slick direction and Barker's grotesque details make it stand out from today's slew of remakes and sequels."[17]
Luke Y. Thompson of LA Weekly found the film's plot weak, but had an otherwise positive response to it, calling it "worth the trip" with an ending that was "so totally nuts, you've gotta admire the cojones behind it."[18] Kaleem Aftab of The National criticized the film's story and "cartoonish" special effects, but admitted, "Nonetheless, there is a sprightly energy to the proceedings and a neat twist that makes this mindless fun something of a guilty pleasure."[19] Nigel Floyd of Time Out gave the film a score of 3/5 and found that, while it matched the brutality of the Clive Barker short story on which it was based, it lacked the short's "undertow of skin-crawling, mind-curdling horror."[20] While highly critical of the film's "patently ridiculous" finale, Rob Nelson of Variety still commended aspects of it like the acting and atmosphere and concluded, "Film isn't scary, per se, but it's mostly effective nonetheless."[21]
The Midnight Meat Train was labeled a "fan film" by Tim Cogshell of Boxoffice Pro, who gave it a score of 2½ out of 5 and wrote, "It’s intense, perhaps, beyond reason. But one supposes that's the point. Still, one cannot fathom why anyone would deliberately put themselves through such a thing as this, beyond the requirements of one's occupation—say, film critic or coroner."[22] Phelim O'Neill, in a review written for The Guardian, offered mild praise to the film's "unrestrained attitude to gore" and visuals, but lambasted its "rudimentary characterisation and tired jump/scare tactics" and ultimately awarded The Midnight Meat Train a grade of 2/5.[23] Chris Willman of Entertainment Weekly was dismissive of The Midnight Meat Train, giving it a "D" grade and writing, "Jones is a terrifically imposing villain as he slays and flays late-night subway commuters—but the gorefest shifts from a suspenseful '80s slasher template to laughable fantasy/conspiracy mythology, culminating in a finale that redefines train wreck."[24]
