The following event has concluded. Please do not modify this page. Comments should be made on the talk page.
Wikipedia articles needing copy edit
This Copyediting Backlog Elimination Drive is a one-month-long effort (originally organized by the Guild of Copy Editors ) to reduce the backlog of copyedit requests . Please make sure that you know how to copyedit and that you are familiar with the Wikipedia Manual of Style before you begin copyediting. The coordinator for this drive was ɳorɑfʈ Talk! and he was assisted by Diannaa TALK and S Masters (talk ). If you have any questions, leave a message in the drive's talk page. This drive began on 1 May 2010 00:00 UTC and ended on 31 May 2010 23:59 UTC.
The goal of this backlog elimination drive was to bring the number of outstanding copyedit requests to below 7500 (a 10% reduction from the original size of 8323). Awards will be given out to those individuals who help reduce the size of the backlog.
The backlog elimination drive is open to all, and you do not need to be a member of the Guild of Copy Editors to participate. However, you may want to consider joining as membership has its benefits. For example, you can place a special "page in use" tag when you are copyediting, and another on the talk page page when you finish. Please visit the Guild for more information.
Note the article's wordcount before you copyedit it. You will need it to get credit for the copyedit. There is an automated word counting script available at User talk:Dr_pda/prosesize.js . It is VERY easy to install and you don't need a shred of technical ability! If you can follow a recipe for making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, you can install this script. Instructions are below. If you get anxious, ask ɳorɑfʈ Talk! for help.
Log completed copyedits in the Running Totals section . If you complete a copyedit for an article, don't forget to list it so that you can get credit for the edit. Also don't forget to remove the ((copyedit)) tag from the article itself.
No rubber-stamping of articles . Be thorough and complete in your copyedits, and make sure all the i's are dotted and the t's crossed. The prose in copyedited articles should comply with the Manual of Style and be free of grammatical, punctuation, and spelling errors.
Don't create extra work . Participants should not copyedit any article they themselves added a ((copyedit)) tag to during the month of May.
Have fun . We're here to help bring these articles up to their fullest potential and hence improving the overall quality of the encyclopedia. If you do not enjoy doing that, then there is no motivation to improve these articles and the encyclopedia as a whole.
To add the script that calculates page size: [Credit 1]
If you have never changed your skin , go to your monobook.js page.
If you are not using the default skin or are unsure, go to Special:Preferences and click on the Appearance tab. In the very first section, Skin , locate the skin that is selected and click on the Custom JS next to your selected skin.
Click Edit on the page that opened.
Add the following code to the page and save it: ((subst:js|User:Dr_pda/prosesize.js))
[Credit 2]
Reload the cache.
If you are using Internet Explorer, press Ctrl-F5
If you are using Firefox/Safari for Windows, hold down Shift while clicking Reload (or press Ctrl-Shift-R); for Mac, press Command-R.
If you are using Opera/Konqueror, press F5.
To test it out go to any random article . If you look under the Toolbox menu on the far left of the screen there will be a link for Page size . The backlog elimination drive uses the number of words listed under Prose size (text only) .
Go copy edit!
The May 2010 elimination drive welcomes and encourages those who have not yet tried their hand at copyediting, or those who haven't done so in some time, to join the drive, even if only to copyedit one or two. If you feel like wanting someone to check over your edit and making sure that it's good, the drive coordinator will gladly assist.
Useful tags[ edit ]
While we try as far as possible to copy edit articles, this is not always achievable where the text is confusing or in need of content expertise. We are then forced to use a tag to attract such help for the article. Some useful tags are:
(( off-topic )) ~ (( Expand )) ~ (( Expert-verify )) ~ (( Expert-subject )) ~ (( contradict )) ~ (( confusing )) ~ (( refimprove )) ~ (( nofootnotes )) ~ (( notability )) ~ (( original research )) ~ (( crystal )) ~ (( POV )) ~ (( unreferenced ))
See WP:TC for a full list of cleanup template messages.
GOCE backlog elimination drive chart up to 31 May
Chart by ɳorɑfʈ Talk!
Date
Unreviewed requests
Outstanding tags
Change since previous day[N 1]
Change since beginning[N 1]
30 April 2010
62
8,323
—
—
1 May 2010
57
8,244
79
79
2 May 2010
55
8,211
33
112
3 May 2010
54
8,197
14
126
4 May 2010
52
8,185
12
138
5 May 2010
52
8,174
11
149
6 May 2010
43
8,160
14
163
7 May 2010
36
8,140
20
183
8 May 2010
28
8,110
30
213
9 May 2010
26
8,081
29
242
10 May 2010
26
8,060
21
263
11 May 2010
24
8,027
33
296
12 May 2010
19
8,002
25
321
13 May 2010
19
7,979
23
344
14 May 2010
18
7,956
23
367
15 May 2010
16
7,920
36
403
16 May 2010
17
7,871
49
452
17 May 2010
19
7,858
13
465
18 May 2010
15
7,864
6
459
19 May 2010
15
7,848
16
475
20 May 2010
14
7,818
30
505
21 May 2010
12
7,792
26
531
22 May 2010
10
7,780
12
543
23 May 2010
10
7,779
1
544
24 May 2010
11
7,792
13
531
25 May 2010
13
7,778
14
545
26 May 2010
10
7,769
9
554
27 May 2010
9
7,743
26
580
28 May 2010
5
7,717
26
606
29 May 2010
5
7,648
69
675
30 May 2010
3
7,577
71
746
31 May 2010
3
7,563
14
760
^ a b Change only refers to outstanding tags.
Awards will be given out at the conclusion of the backlog elimination drive as follows:
At least 2,000 words: The Modest Barnstar .
At least 4,000 words: The Working Man's Barnstar .
At least 8,000 words: The Cleanup Barnstar .
At least 12,000 words: The Tireless Contributor Barnstar .
At least 20,000 words: The old school League of Copyeditors Barnstar .
At least 30,000 words: The modern Guild of Copy Editors Barnstar .
At least 40,000 words: The Order of the Superior Scribe of Wikipedia .
At least 80,000 words: A special, VERY exclusive award created just for these few, these happy few, this band of brothers: the Most Excellent Order of the Caretaker's Star.
In addition, the prestigious Guild of Copy Editors' Gold Star Award will also be awarded to the copy editors who complete the following during the backlog elimination drive:
The most copyedits overall (total article count);
The most copyedits overall (total word count); and
The highest amount of articles cleared from the Request page .
Note: If the same person achieves more than one of the above goals for the GOCE Gold Star Award, only one Gold Star will be awarded, and the citation will mention their multiple achievements.
(Unfortunately, because of financial limitations, we are not able to give away iPads at this time.)
And remember, the ultimate winner here is Wikipedia .
You can still join! Feel free to put your name down at any time. Read the directions, and then add your name in Totals below.
Directions[ edit ]
Please log entries in the following format:
;~~~
((Div col|cols=3))
#((completed)) [[John Doe]] (765)
#((completed)) [[Example]]* (440)
#((completed)) [[Jane Doe]]* (2,330)
((Div col end))
*Total articles: ''3''
*Total requests: ''2''
*Total words: ''3,535''
----
The numbers in parentheses are the word counts of the articles before copyediting. Please use an asterisk to indicate full copyedits completed from the Request page .
Will look like:
ɳorɑfʈ Talk!
Total articles: 3
Total requests: 2
Total words: 3,535
The Backlog Elimination Drive Has Ended. Please Post No More Numbers.
A. Parrot (talk )
Total articles: 16
Total requests: 1
Total words: 20,242
Annalise (talk )
Total articles: 14
Total words: 6421
Auntieruth55 (talk )
Total articles: 30
Total requests: 6 (22,696)
Total words: 49,859
Beloved Freak
Total articles: 7
Total words: 871
Bobnorwal (talk )
Article list
Completed Swami Agnivesh (987)
Completed Epitaph (film) (361)
Completed Vishwasrao (173)
Completed Edward Elric (2,391)
Completed Lad, A Dog * (4,918)
Completed Metra Electric Line (1,230)
Completed Necrid * (1,558)
Completed The Naked Brothers Band: The Movie * (2,656)
Completed Henry Allingham * (3,243)
Completed Gary Gygax * (3,578)
Completed The Invisible Hand (The Spectacular Spider-Man) * (1,251)
Completed The Embalmer * (2,181)
Completed Snapper Carr (1,395)
Completed Shinin' (534)
Completed Quagmire's Dad * (1,400)
Completed Lordi * (4,326)
Completed Matsalu National Park * (1,100)
Completed I Never Met the Dead Man * (1,248)
Completed February 2009 tornado outbreak * (3,702)
Completed ER (TV series) * (1,613)
Completed Rena Costa Center for Yiddish Studies (52)
Completed Ultimate X-Men (1,303)
Completed Takarazuka Revue (3,197)
Completed Stargate SG-1 (season 8) (3,639)
Total articles: 24
Total requests: 13
Total words: 48,036
Buggie111 (talk )
Total articles: 6
Total words: 8810
Brickie (talk )
Total articles: 11
Total requests: 2
Total words: 9362
cymru lass (hit me up) ⁄(background check)
Total articles: 2
Total requests: 0
Total words: 11,153
Bullock Talk
Total articles: 47
Total Requests: 9
Total words: 81,021
Diannaa TALK
Article list
Completed Penelope Cruz * (4252)
Completed Indiana class battleship * (3458)
Completed Pune (6076)
Completed War on Terror (6145)
Completed Islamabad * (3846)
Completed USS Constitution * (10,826)
Completed Gilbert Monckton, 2nd Viscount Monckton of Brenchley (713)
Completed Territorial changes of Poland * (4933)
Completed Iowa class battleship (4937)
Completed Paul Kelly (musician) * (6132)
Completed Junkers EF 126 (297)
Completed Heinkel P.1079 (260)
Completed Brimah (601)
Completed Calculating demand forecast accuracy (205)
Completed Equalization pool (971)
Completed Frodsham School (403)
Completed G. Balakrish Nair (647)
Completed Grand-Bourg (730)
Completed Dejan Ilic (418)
Completed Kanekal (297)
Completed Alexandr Kapto (213)
Completed Giacomo Marramao (617)
Completed O Homem do Sputnik (57)
Completed Priscilla Slade (474)
Completed Pierre Tarisel (448)
Completed Vaishnava Center for Enlightenment (97)
Completed Jack Beeching 415
Completed Enrique Caravia Montenegro 331
Completed Ramon Victor Casas Viera 211
Completed Mirta Cerra Herrera 307
Completed David Chambers (television producer) 141
Completed College of Nursing, Trivandrum, Kerala, India 119
Completed Fernando Diaz Dominguez 198
Completed Mount Hermon, California 558
Completed Jaskaur Meena 140
Completed Mauricio Rosenmann Taub 284
Completed Tahar Lamri 442
Completed Samuel Feijoo 292
Completed Jesse A. Fernandez 228
Completed Brian Flanagan 860
Completed Raul Corrales Forno 466
Completed Freshwater Beach 530
Completed Debbie Hughes 577
Completed Janesville Mall 773
Completed Benjamin Kowalewicz 282
Completed Naroda 439
Completed Darren Manzella 286
Completed New Addington Library 110
Completed The Raider Cast 532
Completed Gilberto Andres Romero Pino 208
Completed Swadesh Roy 356
Completed Gilberto Ruiz Valdez 240
Completed Esterio Segura Mora 457
Completed Mitchell A. Seligson 322
Completed Sethwi 297
Completed Severn Vale School 202
Completed Soekarno M. Noer 151
Completed Sucuriju Gigante 165
Completed Tom Sullivan (radio and television personality) 302
Completed The Superpowers 68
Completed Surajmal Misrana 183
Completed Willie Taylor 312
Completed Alexey Cherkassky 274
Completed César E.Trasobares 310
Completed Antonio Vidal Fernandez 306
Completed Manuel Vidal Fernandez 255
Completed Newton Estape Vila 106
Completed Washington State Democratic Party 171
Completed Zentla, Veracruz 158
Completed Juan Pablo Villar Aleman 392
Completed American Academy of Art 176
Completed Ananda Sastralaya, Kotte 99
Completed Leo Ayotte 646
Completed Babu Chhiri (merged to Babu Chiri Sherpa ) 482
Completed Barodiya 263
Completed The Belfry (shopping centre) 890
Completed Beyti (Istanbul) 440
Completed Bhutto 424
Completed Brachialis muscle 311
Completed The Bush School 477
Completed Canal 8 de Tucumán 231
Completed Cariappa Vihar 132
Completed Castell de Castells 285
Completed Coach of the year in China 193
Completed Manuel Couceiro Prado 122
Completed Scotty Coyote 338
Completed Crane House and Museum 528
Completed Crayone 153
Completed Darussafaka Association 118
Completed Juan Eduardo David Posada 191
Completed Dhital 74
Completed Jose Ramon Diaz Alejandro 157
Completed Dean Dillon 368
Completed Dusty Owl 213
Completed Echoupal 551 (moved to E-Choupal )
Completed Simon Farnaby 71
Completed Marcus Fizer 673
Completed Jose Rodriguez Fuster 329
Completed Glacial Lake Ojibway 208
Completed Gungriffon 157
Completed Nina Kiriki Hoffman 361
Completed Susan Hubbard 198
Completed Frances Erskine Inglis, 1st Marquise of Calderón de la Barca 186
Completed Institute of Anthropology and Ethnography 343 (merged with N. N. Miklukho-Maklai Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology )
Completed Jose Iraola 343
Completed Isaac Winslow House 533
Completed Istrobanka 112
Completed [[Jonesboro High School (Arkansas) 946
Completed Kluuvi 205
Completed Kobeseiko Te-Gō 62
Completed Julio Larraz 317
Completed Belkacem Lounes 185
Completed T-26 tank (4941)
Completed Mughal Garden Wah 744
Completed Muse (magazine) 333
Completed Nevada Air National Guard 738
Completed Kinjikitile Ngwale 235
Completed Ottoman return of Mecca 1813 34
Completed Potter Palmer 335
Completed Joel Humberto Rojas Perez 172
Completed Giuseppe Saverio Poli 56
Completed Professional studies 164
Completed Reel Earth Environmental Film Festival 207
Completed Juan Miguel Rodriguez de la Cruz 410
Completed Juan Andres Rodriguez (El Monje) 217
Completed Chris Roebuck 781
Completed Rigoberto Romero Carmona 298
Completed Saihat 360
Completed St. Antony's Inter College, Lucknow 99
Completed Antonio Sanchez (drummer) 423
Completed Richard Schiff 955
Completed Wilhelm Schröter 285
Completed Al Siebert 199
Completed Seta, Greece 412
Completed Sharda 728
Completed Tomáš Eduard Šilinger 171
Completed Stanley Grammar School 163
Completed Sumanth 476
Completed Masanao Takazawa 259
Completed Valley Park Retail Area 717
Completed Julia Emilia Valdés Borrero 100
Completed Tripura Baptist Christian Union 462
Completed José Omar Torres López 442
Completed Tonga High School 248
Completed Territorio Santos Modelo 81
Completed Mina (singer) 4996
Completed José Lázaro Vázquez Xene 180
Completed José Manuel Villa Castillo 440
Completed Jean-Baptiste de Voglie 207
Completed Vagelis Vourtzoumis 125
Completed Wangala 310
Completed Lutz Winde 74
Completed Banana production in the Caribbean 993
Completed Scott Bennett 224
Completed Arthur Bicknell 145
Completed The Birds (story) 791
Completed Blue Metropolis 279
Completed Bram & Alice 63
Completed Francisco Brennand 196
Completed Louis Briffa 277
Completed Brujas F. C. 238
Completed Carbon detonation 433
Completed Chitreshwar 251
Completed Julie Clary 634
Completed Hiram Codd 899
Completed Christopher Augustus Cox 524
Completed Arthur Cusack 531
Completed Jean, Baron de Batz 421
Completed The Death Set 550
Completed desktop video 186
Completed Dhanshiri 107
Completed Erramadu 125
Completed Estonian Record Productions 578
Completed Garhi Dilawar 174
Completed Glasperlenspiel Music Festival 214
Completed Champa Kalhari 491
Completed Jim Kenworth 259
Completed Khiroda 177
Completed Jörg Landvoigt 258
Completed Daniel Levinson 361
Completed Francesco Lotoro 228
Completed James McDade 461
Completed Harold MacKay 194
Completed Media Capital 349
Completed Minimum Rate Pricing 125
Completed Nachiapuram 674
Completed National Building Code of Canada 729
Completed Neleswheram-Parappa 80
Completed Nikhil Bharat Banga Sahitya Sammelan 1`38
Completed Nikolai Nikolaevich Anichkov 819
Completed Matthew Ridgway 3022
Completed SaarLorLux 4865
Completed Orient, the Festival of Eastern Music 239
Completed Posture and occupational health 189
Completed Don K. Preston 334
Completed Benjamin Prins 821
Completed Problems in coal mining 206
Completed Prostitution in the Palestinian territories 86
Completed Ramasamudram 458
Completed Bohuslav Reynek 211
Completed Vincent Riou 62
Completed Bill and Imelda Roche 272
Completed Snow Queen Trophy 64
Completed Sobienie-Jeziory 56
Completed Sonic Me 131
Completed Studentbody 154
Completed Tanda, Gujrat 245
Completed Thill 846
Completed Linda Vallejo 602
Completed Fernando Velázquez Vigil 372
Completed Yaganti 617
Completed Beijing National Day School 695
Completed [[
Completed [[
Completed [[
Completed [[
Completed [[
Total articles: 212
Total requests: 6
Total words: 136,200
dtgriffith (talk )
Total articles: 7
Total requests: 0
Total words: 13,225
fds Talk
Article list
Completed Get Away From My Mom * (1,260)
Completed Joey Hamilton * (1,835)
Completed Just Don't Give a Fuck (395)
Completed Beverly Cleary (1,283)
Completed Eddie Giroux (272)
Completed Carmel High School (Carmel, New York) (1,976)
Completed Bahia Center (241)
Completed Agriculture in Kenya (960)
Completed St. Vincent de Paul Parish School (63)
Completed Garfield High School (Seattle, Washington) (1,708)
Completed Killara Public School (50)
Completed Dormers Wells High School (90)
Completed Talent Development High School (540)
Completed Prostitution in Qatar (76)
Completed Dunia Baru: The Movie (71)
Completed Mezarkabul (633)
Completed Denver Technological Center (412)
Completed Carlos Rodriguez Cardenas (664)
Completed Neuhaus in der Wart (179)
Completed The Richard Pryor Show (816)
Completed Nuclear power in Germany (1,179)
Completed Flynn effect (2,690)
Completed F.C. Copenhagen (2,373)
Completed The X-Files * (6,459)
Completed Geology of British Columbia (629)
Completed Charlotte Secondary School (95)
Completed White Knoll High School (35)
Completed Nick T. Spark (331)
Completed The World Is Full Of Divorced Women (168)
Completed Acupressure pillow (79)
Completed The New York Helmsley Hotel (120)
Completed Matthew McNair Secondary School (243)
Completed Docking (dog) (1,242)
Completed Malcom Judge (107)
Completed Forrest Ward (165)
Completed Walton-Le-Dale Arts College & High School (82)
Completed Never Talk to Strangers (110)
Completed Jennifer Cody (552)
Completed Lopez Middle School (33)
Completed J.A. Cuddon (113)
Total articles: 40
Total requests: 3
Total words: 30,009
—fetch · comms
Total articles: 16
Total requests: 2
Total words: 6335
Guoguo12 (talk )
Total articles: 2
Total words: 656
kojozone
Total articles: 76
Total words: 66,503
Kristin.sweeney (talk )
Total articles: 0
Total words: 0
Laurinavicius (talk )
Total articles: 26
Total words: 12622
Lfstevens (talk )
Article list
Completed 82nd Airborne Division (5,434)
Completed 1st Battalion, 68th Armor Regiment (247)
Completed A123Systems (816)
Completed Bandwidth (543)
Completed Behavioral economics (2,348)
Completed Classical Hamiltonian quaternions (3,283)
Completed Economy of Manchukuo (4,175)
Completed Individualist anarchism in Europe (5,799)
Completed Kenneth Clarke (2,120)
Completed Linux Unified Kernel (759)
Completed Lithium-ion battery (4,177)
Completed Oracle Fusion Middleware (331)
Completed Harlan Ellison (5,194)
Completed Hawaiian art (764)
Completed Instant-runoff voting (7,111)
Completed Organisms used in water purification (385)
Completed OtherOS (1,545)
Completed PHP Development Tools (250)
Completed Power forward (510)
Completed Suavemente (song) * (652)
Completed Santa Cruz Operation (1,469)
Completed Samsung Electronics (706)
Completed Smart card (2,363)
Completed Taliban (7,227)
Completed The Party (film) (911)
Completed USS Caron (DD-970) (608)
Completed Vectorization (computer science) (1,833)
Total articles: 27
Total requests: 1
Total words: 61,600
liquidluck ✽talk
Total articles: 6
Total requests: 0
Total words: 10066
Mike moral ♪♫
Total articles: 5
Total words: 1,328
Mlpearc MESSAGE
Total articles: 18
Total words: 40,441
Mm40 (talk )
Total articles: 0
Total words: 0
m o ɳ o
Total articles: 11
Total words: 28596
Nasir | ناصر یونس have a chat
Total articles: 0
Total words: 0
NielsenGW (talk )
Article list
Completed Jack Benny (7,773)
Completed Eleutherodactylus (559)
Completed Lyman Beecher (646)
Completed Napoleon III (6,843)
Completed Neum (833)
Completed Mesopotamia (6,093)
Completed William Jennings Bryan (5,986)
Completed Apple IIGS (4,526)
Completed Medici Bank (8,422)
Completed Charles E. Courtney (7,054)
Completed Gouldian Finch (1,243)
Completed The Rocketeer (film) (4,169)
Completed Kosovo War (10,774)
Completed Baroque architecture (6,177)
Completed List of W.I.T.C.H. characters (TV series) (13,823)
Completed British Chinese (11,565)
Completed Stanley Kubrick (14,487)
Completed Characters in Tyler Perry plays (17,483)
Completed Bogoljub Karić (983)
Completed Disconnection (2,122)
Completed Paul Cuffee (1,942)
Completed Dallas–Fort Worth metropolitan area (1,948)
Completed Sonya Blade (2,765)
Completed James Edwin Powell (2,225)
Completed The China Study (2,175)
Completed 2010 Toronto Blue Jays season (7,313)
Completed Dirty Projectors (431)
Total articles: 27
Total words: 150,360
ɳorɑfʈ Talk!
Total articles: 10
Total requests: 2
Total words: 10982
Quinxorin (talk )
Total articles: 7
Total requests: 0
Total words: 12438
S Masters (talk )
Article list
Completed Valkyrie * (6,110)
Completed Friday the 13th (franchise) * (7,659)
Completed World War Z * (2,991)
Completed Jimmy Miller (536)
Completed Franco D'Alessandro (245)
Completed Kalbhor (158)
Completed Ivan Bratko (93)
Completed Sayed Hasmat Jalal (147)
Completed Bhagchandra Jain (251)
Completed John David Brewer (487)
Completed Hawaii hotspot * (4,693)
Completed Blunt trauma personal protective equipment * (512)
Completed History of the family * (1,239)
Completed The Day the Earth Stood Still (2008 film) * (2,977)
Completed Harold Pinter * (9,090)
Completed Nicholas Mayall * (2,896)
Completed Jamaica College * (2,223)
Completed 2009 International Bowl * (5,441)
Completed Sassanid Empire * (11,176)
Completed The Climb (song) * (3,922)
Completed Empire State of Mind * (4,609)
Completed RuneScape * (4,934)
Completed Cry (Michael Jackson song) * (1,645)
Completed Family Guy * (5,470)
Completed Abdolhamid Rigi (218)
Completed Takuji Iwasaki (576)
Completed Babak Esmaeili (45)
Completed Motijheel (381)
Completed Budder (437)
Completed Nephi Hannemann (225)
Completed Lavochkin La-126 (326)
Completed Gabriel Sionita (640)
Completed Rubens Gerchman (342)
Completed Prince Shōtoku (407)
Total articles: 34
Total requests: 17
Total words: 83,101
Theo10011 (talk )
Total articles: 7
Total words: 2410
TheTito Discuss
Total articles: 9
Total words: 2460
Torchiest (talk | contribs )
Total articles: 250
Total requests: 2
Total words: 125,000
Truthkeeper88
Total articles: 23
Total requests: 1
Total words: 26,301
The Utahraptor Talk
Total articles: 8
Total words: 24,155
Schrandit Schrandit
Total articles: 2
Total words: 40
YellowMonkey YellowMonkey
Total articles: 10
Total words: 8695
We will spot-check some of the completed copyedits for quality control reasons. If a rough consensus finds a copyedit is not of an acceptable standard, the tag will be readded and the reviewer will be assessed a penalty of 1200 words plus the length of the article reviewed.
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.