The following articles within the scope of the project have been nominated for deletion at WP:AFD. The results of the discussions were as follows.
| Date | Article | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 17 February 2005 | HMS Jersey (P295) | Keep |
| 20 February 2005 | HMS Hermione | Keep |
| 14 September 2005 | HMS Onyx | Redirect as duplicate of HMS Onyx (S21). Later created as a shipindex page. |
| 14 September 2005 | HMS Plymouth | Redirect as duplicate of HMS Plymouth (F126). Later created as a shipindex page. |
| 3 October 2005 | Victoria Star 2 | No consensus |
| 18 October 2005 | CS Salamis Glory | Keep |
| 19 October 2005 | Carnival Glory | Delete as non-encyclopedic. New article created 2 February 2006. |
| 5 November 2005 | USS Sproston (DD-577) | Keep |
| 13 November 2005 | HMS Duke of Edinburgh | Keep |
| 5 January 2006 | List of LSTs | Keep |
| 4 February 2006 | Flying submarine | Keep |
| 27 April 2006 | Schooner Jenny | Keep |
| 12 May 2006 | USNS Stalwart (T-AGOS-1) | Keep |
| 26 May 2006 | USS Wheatland (AKA-85) | Speedy Keep (Bad faith nomination) |
| 9 July 2006 | HMS Kirkliston (M1157) | Nomination withdrawn |
| 13 October 2006 | List of ship launches in 1946 | Delete, but later recreated per discussion at WP level |
| 5 November 2006 | SS Timothy Bloodworth | No consensus |
| 25 January 2007 | Proteus (WAM-V) | Keep |
| 11 April 2007 | List of Austrian sail frigates | Keep (later boldly merged/redirected} |
| 25 May 2007 | MV Vikartindur | Keep |
| 27 May 2007 | HMS Hornet | Keep |
| 12 June 2007 | Battlecarrier | Delete as a non-notable neologism; later redirected to the CVB-41 class. |
| 10 July 2007 | Grand Staircase of the Titanic | No consensus |
| 13 July 2007 | Schooner Jenny | Keep |
| 16 July 2007 | List of current ships of the Indonesian Navy | Keep |
| 6 August 2007 | The Great Lakes Group | Keep |
| 17 August 2007 | Motor Torpedo Boat PT-337 | Keep |
| 5 September 2007 | Tiamat (sailing) | Nomination withdrawn without any opposes following article improvement |
| 23 October 2007 | Encyclopedia Titanica | Keep |
| 14 November 2007 | USS Watseka (YT-387) | Keep |
| 3 December 2007 | MSC Armonia | Snow Keep |
| 10 December 2007 | Brigantine Yankee | Keep |
| 17 January 2008 | List of Liberty ships by hull number | Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables. |
| 17 January 2008 | List of Liberty ships by hull number, 1 | Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables. |
| 17 January 2008 | List of Liberty ships by hull number, 151 | Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables. |
| 17 January 2008 | List of Liberty ships by hull number, 601 | Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables. |
| 17 January 2008 | List of Liberty ships by hull number, 751 | Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables. |
| 17 January 2008 | List of Liberty ships by hull number, 2101 | Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables. |
| 19 January 2008 | Element Yachts | Keep |
| 29 January 2008 | USS Illinois (BB-65) / USS Kentucky (BB-66) | Keep |
| 29 March 2008 | SS Kiche Maru | No consensus |
| 24 April 2008 | History of Full Rigged Ships | Redirect to Full-rigged ship |
| 29 April 2008 | Queen of the Netherlands (ship) | Snowball Keep |
| 29 April 2008 | MY Nemesis | Delete |
| 2 May 2008 | Titanic alternative theories | No consensus |
| 11 May 2008 | MV Island Sky | Keep |
| 4 July 2008 | Princess Kaguya (ship) | Delete per WP:CRYSTAL |
| 6 August 2008 | MS Prince Albert II | Snow Keep |
| 8 September 2008 | Four Funnel Liners | Keep |
| 5 October 2008 | Japanese minelayer Itsukushima | Snow Keep |
| 5 October 2008 | Japanese minelayer Okinoshima | Snow Keep |
| 11 November 2008 | Princess Kaguya (cruise ship) | Speedy delete under CSD G4 |
| 18 November 2008 | SS Titan (2012) | Speedy delete under CSD G7 |
| 19 December 2008 | Beramba (ship) | Delete as failing WP:V |
| 27 December 2008 | SS Timothy Bloodworth | Keep |
| 25 October 2008 | USS John S. McCain | Keep |
| 16 January 2009 | SS John Stagg | Keep |
| 26 March 2009 | FV Monte Galineiro | No consensus |
| 26 March 2009 | MV Princess of Acadia (1971) | Snow Keep |
| 19 May 2009 | List of ship launches in 1870 | Keep |
| 26 June 2009 | National Historic Fleet, Core Collection | Nomination withdrawn |
| 26 July 2009 | Soho-class frigate | Speedy Keep |
| 10 August 2009 | Exploding warships | Delete as WP:OR |
| 15 December 2009 | United States Naval Gunfire Support debate | Keep |
| 21 March 2010 | Carnival Glory | Snow keep |
| 23 March 2010 | AIDAsol | Keep |
| 21 April 2010 | Carnival Dream 3 | Delete as WP:CRYSTAL |
| 29 July 2010 | HarbourLynx | Keep |
| 24 August 2010 | MV Mariam | Keep |
| 1 September 2010 | Golfo Azzurro | Delete as failing WP:V; was userified and later restored to mainspace after improvements |
| 20 September 2010 | Wherry Maud | Keep |
| 28 November 2010 | RMS Titan | Delete as only a proposed ship, not one currently under construction |
| 9 December 2010 | USS Indianapolis in popular culture | Delete |
| 13 December 2010 | The Sinking of The Adriatic | Move to MV Adriatica |
| 14 February 2011 | RMS Titanic II (proposed ocean liner) | Snow delete, failed WP:N and WP:V. |
| 21 February 2011 | Le Pietre (yacht) | Delete as failing WP:N due to insufficient coverage by secondary sources. |
| 3 March 2011 | USS SC-42 | No consensus |
| 14 March 2011 | HMS Constance (1880) | Snow keep |
| 31 March 2011 | USS LST-766 | Keep |
| 21 May 2011 | MV Portaferry II | Keep |
| 1 June 2011 | USS Weeks (DE-285) | Merge into Rudderow class destroyer escort as never having been constructed. |
| 23 August 2011 | MV Ramsey | Speedy keep |
| 30 August 2011 | MV Peveril (1963) | Keep |
| 17 October 2011 | Brazos Belle | No consensus |
| 5 December 2011 | HTMS Pattani | Nomination withdrawn on way to snow keep following article improvement. |
| 10 January 2012 | MV Spiegelgracht | Keep |
| 16 January 2012 | TSS Manx Maid (1962) | Snow keep |
| 3 March 2012 | Atlanship SA | Nomination withdrawn, sources found |
| 7 March 2012 | Alfa Nero | Nomination withdrawn on way to snow keep |
| 14 March 2012 | Type C6 ship | Snow keep |
| 27 March 2012 | Aker American Shipping | Nomination withdrawn, sources found |
| 8 April 2012 | SS Vesta | Redirect to SS Arctic#Sinking |
| 5 May 2012 | USS Enterprise (CVN-80) | Delete as failing WP:CRYSTAL and WP:V; later recreated when CRYSTAL and V passed. |
| 1 June 2012 | List of littoral combat ships of the United States Navy | redirect to Littoral combat ship as duplicated info |
| 13 June 2012 | Admiralty tug | Keep |
| 15 June 2012 | Frankfurt (icebreaker) | Keep |
| 15 June 2012 | Keiler | Keep |
| 26 July 2012 | USS Illinois (BB-65) / USS Kentucky (BB-66) | Keep |
| 1 August 2012 | North Sea Boats | No consensus |
| 24 August 2012 | Replica Titanic | Keep with leave to merge |
| 29 August 2012 | Delphia Yachts | Keep |
| 27 September 2012 | European Waterways | Keep |
| 27 September 2012 | La Belle Epoque (barge) | Keep |
| 27 September 2012 | L'Art de Vivre | Keep |
| 27 September 2012 | L'Impressionniste | Keep |
| 28 October 2012 | Greek destroyer Doxa | Snow keep |
| 2 November 2012 | Shahrekord super tanker | Keep |
| 13 November 2012 | SS Buskø | Keep |
| 1 December 2012 | USS Enterprise (CVN-80) | Nomination withdrawn on way to snow keep |
| 8 December 2012 | MV Harambee | Keep |
| 7 January 2013 | H-45 | Redirect to H-class battleship proposals |
| 19 January 2013 | John B. Caddell | Keep |
| 19 February 2013 | USS SC-715 | Keep |
| 1 June 2013 | NoCGV Ålesund | Keep |
| 21 June 2013 | MV Golden Jubilee | Deleted due to lack of sources |
| 16 July 2013 | Splash-class cruise ship | Deleted per WP:TOOSOON and WP:CRYSTAL |
| 2 August 2013 | Western World (British ship) | Keep |
| 20 October 2013 | MV Seaman Guard Ohio | Keep |
| 25 October 2013 | Wale | Keep |
| 11 November 2013 | RV Song of the Whale | Keep |
| 20 November 2013 | MV Saginaw | No consensus |
| 4 December 2013 | MV Bni Nsar | Keep |
| 15 December 2013 | CCGS Ann Harvey | Keep |
| 15 December 2013 | Chopin (ship) | Keep |
| 20 December 2013 | S/V Rembrandt van Rijn S/V Noorderlicht |
Keep both |
| 10 February 2014 | Aerial battleship | Delete |
| 24 April 2014 | Project 21956 | Merge to Future of the Russian Navy#Destroyers per WP:CRYSTAL |
| 15 May 2014 | Japanese aircraft carrier Project Number G18 | Delete as failing WP:V |
| 7 June 2014 | LX(R) | Delete per WP:CRYSTAL |
| 20 July 2014 | USS South Dakota (BB-49) / USS Indiana (BB-50) / USS Montana (BB-51) / USS North Carolina (BB-52) / |
Redirect all to South Dakota-class battleship (1920) due to virtually identical content on unfinished ships. |
| 4 August 2015 | MS Southward | Keep |
| 8 August 2015 | MV Nimpkish | Keep |
| 31 August 2015 | Vadne (ferry) | Keep |
| 16 November 2015 | Boka Star | Keep, later moved to Yugoslav auxiliary Ugor. |
| 1 December 2015 | List of countries with warships | Redirect to list of countries by level of military equipment. |
| 20 February 2016 | INS Kolkata Class Destroyer Ship Electrical System | Redirect to Kolkata-class destroyer. |
| 7 April 2016 | SS Hopestar | Nomination withdrawn per WP:NOTCLEANUP. |
| 11 April 2016 | USS Letitia (SP-398) | Delete as failing WP:V. |
| 16 October 2016 | List of Type T2 tankers | Keep |
| 29 November 2016 | USS Chattanooga (CL-118) | Redirect to the class article as a never-completed ship. |
| 6 January 2017 | USS Wistaria (SP-259) | Delete as never having been commissioned and (thus) failing WP:GNG. |
| 8 March 2017 | USS Barracuda (SP-23) | Delete as never having been acquired or commissioned and (thus) failing WP:GNG. |
| 14 March 2017 | USS Turbot (SS-427) | Keep |
| 14 March 2017 | USS Ulua (SS-428) | Keep |
| 17 April 2017 | Long Beach-class cruiser | Merge to USS Long Beach (CGN-9) as a single-ship class. |
| 5 June 2017 | USS Tahgayuta (1863) | Merge to USS Contoocook (1864)#Cootoocook class sloop/frigate as an uncompleted sister ship with no class article yet. |
| 5 June 2017 | USS Mondamin (1864) | Merge to USS Contoocook (1864)#Cootoocook class sloop/frigate as an uncompleted sister ship with no class article yet. |
| 7 July 2017 | High Performance Frigate Program | Delete as failing WP:CRYSTAL. |
| 15 July 2017 | Future of the Bangladesh Navy | Delete as failing WP:CRYSTAL and WP:MADEUP. |
| 28 August 2017 | List of frigates of the Republic of China Navy | Redirect to List of Republic of China Navy ships#Frigates as an unneeded fork. |
| 30 August 2017 | List of Norwegian current frigates | Delete as an outdated content fork. |
| 5 November 2017 | SS Helsingfors | Keep/Withdrawn |
| 1 March 2018 | Irlam (1813 ship) | Snow keep/nom withdrawn following article improvement. |
| 2 March 2018 | SS Corsea | Keep - AfD is not for deleting articles in need of improvement. |
| 31 March 2018 | John (1803 ship) | Delete as non-notable. |
| 1 April 2018 | Minerva (1864) | Delete as unveifiable |
| 2 April 2018 | Jane (ship) | Redirect to List of shipwrecks in 1816 as not indvidually notable. |
| 17 May 2018 | HMS Forth (1813) | Snow keep - AfD is not for deleting articles in need of improvement. |
| 3 October 2018 | List of commanding officers of USS Nevada (BB-36) | Merge to USS Nevada (BB-36). |
| 6 December 2020 | German submarine U-1012 | Redirect to the class article as a never-completed ship. |
| 4 January 2021 | USS Lillie B (SP-1502) | Redirect to List of patrol vessels of the United States Navy as never having been commissioned and (thus) failing WP:GNG. |
| 21 June 2021 | SS Ben H. Miller | Nomination withdrawn following article expansion. |
| 24 May 2022 | German trawler V 206 Otto Bröhan | Keep following article improvement. |