A security deposit is a sum of money held in trust.[1]

The United States Supreme Court ruled in Commissioner v. Indianapolis Power & Light Co. (1990) that a deposit differs from an advance payment because the depositing party has dominion over the funds and retains the right to insist upon repayment in cash. On the other hand, the party making an advance payment retains no right to insist upon the return of the funds as long as the recipient fulfills the contractual agreement.[2]

In leasing

Security deposits are required most often by lessors of automobiles, apartments, and commercial real estate.[1]

The security deposits required by many residential landlords of their tenants are the source of much dispute and litigation. Many states and municipalities have enacted laws that specifically regulate the landlord's ability to withhold tenant security deposits after a tenant moves out. Some states and cities require that interest be paid to the tenant as it is earned on the security deposit. The rate of interest earned on security deposits typically changes each year. Currently[when?] this rate is set at .06% in the state of Connecticut.[3] The rate is .01% in Chicago, Illinois, but this rate is only payable on buildings with a certain occupancy threshold.[4]

A landlord's deductions from a tenant's security deposit must be reasonable. The landlord may make deductions for missing rent payments and for damages beyond ordinary wear and tear, which is the subject matter's depreciation or deterioration in value by reasonable and ordinary use by the tenant. Examples of non-deductible wear and tear include: paint retouching, minor cleaning, small tack holes, and nicks and scratches. Examples of deductible damages include large or excessive holes in the wall, carpet stains, and broken doors and windows.[5][6]

If a landlord wrongfully withholds a tenant's security deposit, the tenant may be entitled to additional damages beyond the amount of the security deposit. These may include statutory damages for violation of a local statute on consumer collection practices, damages that may be two or three times the amount of the deposit (in some states, such as California), consequential (resulting) damages, interest, and in more rare instances punitive damages.[7][8]

In the United States, Washington, DC, Alaska, Illinois, and Wisconsin have notably more tenant-friendly legislation than states like Indiana or Michigan, for example. The cities of Madison, Wisconsin, and Chicago, Illinois, have substantially greater protection of tenants' security deposit rights than the surrounding areas.[9]

Studies have shown that landlords often improperly withhold security deposits after tenants move out, and often get away with it because it's too much trouble to fight.[10]

In metropolitan cities of India[11] like Chennai, Bangalore, Mumbai or others, there is security deposit to be given upfront to the landlord before renting/leasing an apartment. This security deposit amount can range anywhere from 3– 11 months, depending upon city's norm. With rentals soaring high in metropolitan cities, this amount becomes exorbitant.[12]

The recent[when?] changes to the condominium and cooperative laws in New York have created limits for the regulations behind security deposits. Cooperative boards can no longer charge more than one month of prepaid maintenance and another month's maintenance as a security deposit restricting the amount to be owed before moving in.[13][14]

In states like Connecticut that tend to be more tenant friendly, the amount an owner can charge for a security deposit in any property is limited to the equivalent of two month's rent. This limit is reduced to one month's rent for tenants age 62 and over.[3]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b Helewitz, Jeffery A. (2015). Basic Real Estate and Property Law for Paralegals (5th ed.). Frederick, MD: Wolters Kluwer. pp. 174, 255. ISBN 978-1-4548-5122-6.
  2. ^ Commissioner v. Indianapolis Power & Light Co., 493 U.S. 203 (1990)
  3. ^ a b "Landlord's Guide to Security Deposits | CT Edition | Updated 2022". www.robertcwhite.com. 2022-01-18. Retrieved 2022-02-07.
  4. ^ JAbdilla (2020-02-27). "Security Deposits - The 5 Key Questions for Chicago". The Chicagoland Lawyer. Retrieved 2023-03-13.
  5. ^ Sparks, Dana. "What Is Normal Wear & Tear on a Rental Home?". Hearst Communications, Inc. SFGate. Retrieved 21 July 2017.
  6. ^ "Tenancy deposit deductions your landlord can make". Shelter. Shelter England. 30 June 2016. Retrieved 21 July 2017.
  7. ^ Raskin-Zrihen, Rachel (27 October 2008). "The importance of knowing your rights". Times-Herald. Retrieved 21 July 2017.
  8. ^ "Is Tenant Entitled to Punitive Damages?". Los Angeles Times. 10 October 1993. Retrieved 21 July 2017.
  9. ^ Madison's General Ordinance Chapter 32 and Chicago's Residential Landlord Tenant Ordinance.
  10. ^ Tenants Together (2 May 2013). "No deterrent: Improper security deposit withholding in California" (PDF). City of Berkeley. Retrieved 24 March 2022.
  11. ^ "Dafabet Withdrawal and Deposit India in 2022". 2021-11-15. Retrieved 2022-01-13.
  12. ^ Das, Avik (5 January 2019). "Bengaluru pays highest rental deposits". Times of India. Bengaluru. Archived from the original on 8 January 2019.
  13. ^ "Managing the Impact on Your Community - Recent Changes to Co-op & Condo Laws".
  14. ^ Ferré-Sadurní, Luis (21 June 2019). "How New Rent Laws in N.Y. Help All Tenants". The New York Times.

Bibliography