• WP:BASIC

  ..If the depth of coverage in any given source is not substantial, then multiple independent sources may be combined to demonstrate notability;.. People who meet the basic criteria may be considered notable without meeting the additional criteria below.

• Policy seems clear article meets WP:BASIC is enough; WP:ANYBIO is an additional criteria and inconsequential in this case since article seems to meet WP:BASIC. Policy clearly mentions multiple independent sources can very well combined to demonstrate notability.
• Coverage may have ups and downs but media coverage Minimum ten years from 2011 to 2021 is not sustained then what it is?
• There is an article about her Guru Kelucharan Mohapatra who seems notable. And that what matters in Indian classical dance. And she has been awarded with a state level award that matters for the form of her classical dance.
• Beccaynr seems to have provided good number of refs from Proquest. This Hindu Newspaper article even OP does not have any issue with this publication. This DNA 2013 news report mentions even editors name and is substantial coverage by all means. As earlier explained Scroll and Times of India are other wise add to substantial and would have been ok to OP. RSN strictures on both these news groups are mainly due to their coverage of Indian politics and high paying Indian movie industry; otherwise those are news papers of record. As explained in detail in the comment above these criteria can't be applied to classical dance, she is beyond age of career take of for publicity dependence, and a cancer patient. What I can see is inadvertently fallacy of Appeal to probability and WP:CSB taking shape.
• WP:BASIC People are presumed notable if they have received significant coverage in multiple published secondary sources that are reliable, intellectually independent of each other, and independent of the subject.

• I would request discussion closing admin to let me know if they want any specific content related clarifications from me for the baseless pile of them submitted by USaamo AKG and TB . Any detail logical scrutiny will prove most of that to be just frivolous much of it making mountains out of molehills intending to smear and hound for their own POVs being hurt in some way.
• Here roughly 9 months before you write to me ".. Love in Pakistan and Urdu Feminist Literature are fascinating (and valid) topics - if you need resources, give a ping. I will take up the article on forced conversion. .." But as soon as women's issues are covered at Public places their patriarchal power on Wikipedia feels threatened.

• At times whether to respond back or not is quite catch-22. On one hand lectures being handed over to me being asked to be concise, long list of even funny charges being added.
• Now usual content deletions of my sourced contributions like at even Non-vegetarian are being cited as great examples of my bad personal record. I am confused Idk whether to laugh or cry. Rather than writing essay TB can give link to my contrib stats page and claim as pure evidence against me.Roughly total 13500 edits 300 are deleted, 42 pages are deleted. Roughly 4000 talk pages I interacted for all those contribs and diatribes received against can easily be cited as incompetence mine or any one's elses.
• I have not deleted any from my talk pages, see history of TB talk page is it okay some one turns up add all allegations without scrutiny and bring them to ARE.
• In one of early interaction aboutt drafts promoted by me TB said to me ".. :Love in Pakistan and Urdu Feminist Literature are fascinating (and valid) topics - if you need resources, give a ping. .." (10). See 10 Sept.22 time stamps of TB is @ WP:Pakistan notice board to post their message.: (11, on the notice board before theirs is my message making RfC invite clearly informing BLP issue. The smart Head student of ARE since last one year before attending BLP priority they first they crosscheck my recent contribs of that time remove sourced content (12) issue threat smacking with anger and arrogance @ my talk (13) without asking my perspective or content related talk page discussion they go over to Hall monitor talk page and smear against me (14). The briefed and influenced inspired hall monitor issues standard notice to me and assures them of a 'deeper look', no need of content discussion on talk pages! One could guess what is coming. The hall monitor leaves my most polite answer unreplyed and smear @ this notice board worth of my answer was just rambling for them. Is beauty of this synchronized symphony new to this board ? (15, 16)

• Best luck to ongoing WP:hounding and synchronized symphonies for times to come. Let me come to content. Articles like Hermeneutics of feminism in Islam or Women related laws in Pakistan are not my own creations, I just helped those after coming on WP shore. Even if you dislodge me slow but steady fourth feminist wave is going to take entry in multiple forms in times to come for sure.
• While ongoing fourth wave of feminism is already moving ahead asking for equal spaces pushing boundaries offline and also on other digital and social media is slow to reach WP that does not mean no one coming here other than me. We already have article on Minto Park women's monument, Anti-monuments in Mexico . We have Anti-monumentalism and my neutral entry there (shenanigans in TB's words) TB & company is most welcome to delete that if they want and in their complaint list against on this board.(17)
• By now everyone would understand I am targeting feminism only to Pakistan is proven fake narrative. If my content is not perfect then should have been discussed on article talk pages
• Take google.com, books.google.com, scholar.google.com search for "Public spaces" "women" and various countries names including Pakistan, for many countries including Pakistan entire WP articles can be written and substantial part can be criticism, let global women know why a sections dedicated to women issues in Public spaces can not be there in Public spaces article and all women related issues are to be compulsively restricted and Public spaces article can not be opened. Was there any restriction to begin with Pakistan and later adding others? Some one already covering those sources will naturally cover that. Show me existing article talk page RfC consensus against. Is that affecting male power structures on Wikipedia that I am being mansplained and dislodged. For that you bring me to ARE with repeating fake bad faith attacks of proven sock accounts?
• Bengal background TB likes or not, as of this day 1969 Rabindra Sarobar Stadium en masse sexual violence controversy is first known on record non conflict time en masse sexual violence controversy with multiple reliable sources for notability. With their misleading misinterpreting interference I strongly recommend TBan on them for Feminism, and South Asia related articles.

• Seems some support lag from WP:BLPN

Attempt of cornering and discrediting by Red herring plus misinterpretations, conflating between contested BLP violation content and Wikipedia users to distract attention. Difs 1

• Thinker seemed neutral facilitator dif 2
• This user was primarily against naming suspects dif 1

• Diyat Deutsche Welle dw.com dated 14.09.2021 Author Warda Imran ".. However, there is an option: "Diyat" is compensation or blood money that can be paid to the victim's family for the damage and suffering caused. .. The pardon received in exchange for compensation can be as effective as the law if the courts accept it, and is part of Pakistan's legal justice system. The amount for the compensation can be determined by law or by the parties themselves. .." ^[1]

*

• Dawn Images ".. This is definitely not a one-off incident, no matter what anyone claims. .." ^[2]
• PPC 149 (unlawful assembly), 147 (rioting) ^[3]
• Time line
• 2021 August, 14 evening sexual assault takes place, police takes note of the incidence. Minar-i-Pakistan Park opened the central gate to let her enter to take shelter
• August, 18 Official complaint registered against attackers after videos go viral on social media
• 9 Sep, 2021 ".. A session court in Lahore trashed the petition, seeking registration of a case against TikToker Ayesha Akram .. “Ayesha is herself to blame for the incident since she had invited hundreds at the park to ‘molest’ her,” the petitioner prayed before the court to order law enforcers to book her along with the accomplice. .." ^[4]
• 2021 December, 14 Accident

Some of other related policies for current requested RfC discussion: WP:BLP, WP:SUSPECT, WP:BLPPUBLIC, WP:NOTPUBLICFIGURE.

Requesting inputs about WP policies regarding, WP:BLP protocols and naming of the accused in relation to mentions of allegations and counter allegations in the given article, against a female victim of sexual assault, her associates and also other accused.

Requesting well studied, carefully thought inputs @ RfC: A TikToker, associates, other accused constitute 'Public figure' or not?

Thanks and warm regards

• It is incorrect to say Image and influencers section is on the top, rather it comes after Lead having 6 paragraphs of all boasting and bragging and two other section out of that overview section also gives more than ample scope to put Pakistan's tourism in positive perspective.
• Image and influencers section just neutrally counter balances all the bragging in the lead. Even within the section in not entirely critical, it first puts positive side then includes critique as per WP policy to preferably have critique. That has been possible because Samira Shackle piece itself is editorially neutral giving all sides of the story and for the same reason section has used it more.
• There is no limit in increasing any section until it becomes big to fork out for a separate article. As such enough RS are available to take problems in Pakistan tourism to an article level.
• Actually there is no policy limit what percentage of article can be critical of the topic. Article is over 75 thousand bytes even if one wants to use 30% for criticism 25 thousand bytes uptil now I have not used even half of it even though various RS sources are available.
• Allegations are strange and bemusing. Part of it resorts to Whataboutism For bragging and boasting about tourism Wiki Voyage is special vehicle for that even that is also supposed to include criticism where valid.
• I do have pro women's rights pov still while including those issues I do reasonably care about editorial neutrality on my part to my best. There is not much scope for personal accusations, on Wikipedia I have taken up women rights issues across continents and wide spectrum. Pakistanis are interested whether one is criticizing situation in India too then I do that too.
• "Dawn our image is being tarnished by the assaulters, not the people crying out for protection for our citizens or the victims
• Rather it is for others to explain why they need to delete well sourced content in entirety. If any one wants an dispute resolution process and RfC per sentence of criticism to be held Idk how such additional burden that is going to help improve Pakistan's image.

• Wikipedia policies allows opinions in fact that brings in multiple views and criticism helps enhancement in neutrality
• Dawn June 20, 2022 LAHORE: Punjab will introduce stricter laws and declare an ‘emergency’ to curb the rising trend of rape cases. .. Punjab Home Minister Ataullah Tarar and Law Minister Malik Muhammad Ahmed Khan told a joint press conference .. that a cabinet committee on law and order met under the chair of Chief Minister Hamza Shehbaz Sharif .. expressed its concern over the increase in rape cases for the last over three years. .. The body decided to introduce a set of legislations to make stricter punishments for rape and set up a dedicated helpline for the victims, they said. An emergency would be declared on rape cases to proceed against the accused on a war footing. .. " If you understand urdu I will arrange to share youtube of press conference. The luck part word tourism is not used in this news but after all that is governments official admission hence that does that change the ground reality. But see the next news
• Dawn July 20, 2022: A social media activist and vlogger (US national woman), the woman was on a trip to the Fort Munro hill station, was allegedly gang-raped by her “guide” and his two accomplices. The News International Editorial Board July 27, 2022 That this happened to a woman of foreign origin makes it particularly disturbing, given Pakistan’s recent attempts at lifting its tourism potential. .. However, for the women of Pakistan, tourism is a distant concern when they are unsafe not only on the streets, in public transport, and at work but also within their homes.
• Bragging and boasting about sudden meteoric rise as attractive tourist place not because government has done any thing significant for tourism industry but facilitated influencer indued image makeover improves image or not is for travelers to decide but in Wikipedia parlance such sources getting influenced by some governmental activity and changing ranking suddenly their credibilty becomes questionable.
• Dawn October 20, 2019 The trouble with tourism Anika Khan, Rabia Nadir
• Shakir Lakhani readers comment to Dawn editorial

Bemusing Earwig finds only 22.5% similarity with guardian and says copyvio unlikely. In that too only half sentence in critique used as it is with proper attribution since usage of alternate words would have only sharpened the critique. Another quarter sentence is not exactly critique either, ".. forbidden from cycling because it is seen as immodest .." this reflection of Pakistani culture as is, I can and I will change words forbidden and immodest if you wish. The rest small matching are just facts and noun word.

• destination for western social media influencers producing glossy, upbeat travel content.
• Realities of tourism By Kamila Hyat January 13, 2022 The News International

• Lack of proper public toilets
• More thoughts on tourism, The Express Tribune Kamal Siddiqi October 25, 2021

All this misplaced criticism of criticism ignoring other glaring copyvio, boasting and bragging. Your goodselves did not find any thing problematic in all that.

Ah yes our concerned Indian friends looking out for Pakistan while their country India is globally recognised as the worlds most dangerous country for women :[1] : "India is the world’s most dangerous country for women due to the high risk of sexual violence and being forced into slave labor, according to a poll of global experts released on Tuesday." You have the audacity to point fingers at others while your nation India is the lowest of the low for women? is internationally known and notorious for the way it treats it women (and other foreign women we will get to that soon). Look at how Indian nationalists have glossed over Rape in India article they make it sound like rape is not an issue how dishonest and pathetic do you have to be to hide and distort information to make it sound all nice and warm while the reality is [2] Your government and officials are hiding it but fortunately global media has exposed India enough for its rape crisis where 95% of rapes are not even reported a child is gang raped every 15 minutes but again lets focus on Pakistan. I have never met such disingenuous and dishonest people in my life Indian nationalists trying to hide their dirty under belly while flinging dirt at others just to divert attention away from them.

Lets first address your "bragging about tourism" thanks for honestly telling us where your obsession comes from so much jealousy over some positive news. You people just cannot hide your petty envy and hatred incapable of digesting any good news from Pakistan so you feel the desperate need to throw in some negative energy to soothe your wounded egos and satisfy your petty Indian nationalism. I know it burns the envy and hate spewing out is common for Bharati nationalists butt hurt over any good press Pakistan gets. Many governments use influencers and Vloggers to promote tourism.

Now then lets discuss how foreign female tourists are treated in India shall we? India a nation where foreign women regularly are not just sexually assaulted but MURDERED in cold blood: [3] "5 recent rape cases of foreign women Recently, a twenty five year old American tourist alleged rape and assault by five men in a five star hotel of New Delhi.

1) Danish woman who was robbed and gangraped in New Delhi Nine men raped and assaulted a 52-year-old Danish tourist who had arrived India in January 2014. After losing her way to the hotel, she asked for help from a group of men near Connaught Place who instead of helping her, took her to an isolated area and raped her."

2) A German national was raped in a moving train in Chennai In January 2014, an 18-year-old German girl on a Mangalore-Chennai reported rape to the Railway police. The German national worked as an English school teacher at a school in Karnataka and was enrolled as a volunteer at a German-based NGO.

3) A 19-year-old German tourist was raped by an unidentified auto driver in December 2015

4) Polish woman drugged, gangraped on Delhi-Mathura Highway A 33-year-old Polish woman was allegedly raped by a cab driver after he offered her a ride on the Mathura-Delhi highway. The incident was reported in January 2014.

[4] Just last month : NDTV " A British woman was allegedly raped near the Arambol beach in Goa in front of her male partner by a local man under the pretext of giving her a massage, police said on Tuesday. The accused, local resident Vincent D'Souza (32), was part of a group that illegally offered massage services near the Arambol beach in North Goa district, which is quite popular with international tourists, they said." Horrific how so many foreign women are getting raped in your motherland yet you have not created a page in regards to this. Why is the Tourism in India page contain so much bragging? where is the section on rape of foreign tourist do you have the courage and dignity to add it? off course thats too much to ask from a Indian nationalist who will shamelessly deflect and point fingers elsewhere.

[5] Innocent 15 year old teenager Scarlett Keeling drugged first and brutally raped then MURDERED by your people in India where is the outrage and energy for these innocent women who made the mistake to visit the RapePublic of India? why is there no article on this disgusting hypocritical behavior.

This just goes on and on and on and on.....shocking and disturbing how no Indian has the honesty to even mention this on the Tourism in India pretending nothing happens there and its some haven for females! https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/article/1673183/three-indians-arrested-over-gang-rape-and-abduction-japanese-woman This time a Japanese female was unlucky enough to make the mistake of travelling to India do you people have no shame? I could list MANY MANY more instances where female tourists have faced murder and rape but still you heart less shameless Indian nationalists would rather fling mud on other nations knowing full well your nation is a cesspit of violence and rape against females.

[6] USA is now warning its citizens particularly its women to stay away from India "The State Department also noted that rape is one of the fastest growing crimes in India. Violent crime, such as sexual assault, has occurred at tourist sites and in other locations, it said. Moreover, the travel advisory also cautioned US citizens that “terrorists may attack with little or no warning, targeting tourist locations, transportation hubs, markets/shopping malls, and government facilities,” it continued. “If you decide to travel to India… Do not travel alone, particularly if you are a woman,” the statement read linking to a guide for women travelers." You people have some nerve to even criticize others while your house is full of filth despicable how you ignore these glaring facts and sources.

Reliable sources detailing how foreign women feel unsafe in India due to rape: https://www.dw.com/en/tourism-numbers-down-sharply-in-india/a-16712581 Sources stating females shunning India for Tourism why is there no mention ? https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/after-attacks-women-tourists-to-india-fall-by-35-per-cent-517748 Female tourism down 35% after mass rapes and assaults on foreign women and native ones shocking how this is not mentioned in the Tourism in India article...

All that outrage over one unfortunate influencer in Pakistan you Indians started celebrating to early no mention of this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myhubCtp-DI&t=0s Karl Rocks female friends were all abused millions of views why is there no Indian attention on this?

When will we get an article on Rape of foreign tourists in India, Love in India etc

Wow what can I say I could go on and on and on and on about rape/abuse of women in India Wikipedia was once a decent place but the advent of Indian nationalist trolls and their minions have turned it into a circus of lies and misleading information. Heres a challenge I dare you if you have any shame or honor add the same information to Tourism in India regarding rape of foreign females and also balance out Rape in India which is now just a pathetic whitewashed article downplaying Indias rape crisis but alas I cannot expect such honesty or decency because you Indians are blinded with such a rabid form of nationalism you are willing to turn a blind eye and allow these things to happen to your daughters, sisters and mothers all the while shamelessly dragging other countries into it as a means to deflect away from your sins. You know the saying right? People in glass houses should not throw stones. ImmortalTruthIII (talk) 22:33, 3 August 2022 (UTC)

First of all I have added those bullet points only after your call, and those are still to be discussed from your side. I waited from my side because some other user intervened with RfC and I wanted to handle discussion in different way.

But even before that, if you are closely following up blasphemy related news from India since N.S.' debate controversy, you would please understand every couple of days a new blasphemy related controversy is getting added up in the debate (most of that is missing from the article) , as a result free speech is getting hit from all sides, keeping aside political and religious polarization the most voiceless are skeptics like 'Saad Ansari', Idk who understands concerns of skeptics and atheists who do not have political or religious backing and not even proper media support. We can see mentions about him just this article went into lock, once that is removed I am expecting those and similar mentions being undermined.

IMHO When free speech is being hit hard to me real concern is not limited to tag of neutrality but underlying political and religious polarization's undermining spirit of encyclopedic neutrality among Wikipedians. It is easier to control POV pushing of novice editors, if all the experienced users decide not to resort to Wikipedia:Civil POV pushing then only spirit of neutrality and quality of neutrality will improve.

All above is for this article only. I am coming up one by one because I am not just remain obsessed

• https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-62033006
• https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/after-indias-objection-canada-expresses-deep-regret-over-kaali-poster-3131162
• https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/leena-manimekalai-kaali-poster-row-case-against-filmmaker-for-hurting-religious-sentiments-3128259
• https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/kaali-poster-row-mahua-moitra-leena-manimekalai-fir-1970943-2022-07-06
  • 
    

• Taha Siddiqi ^[1]
• Age

الآن أطرح السؤال الأهم: من الذى أساء للسيدة «عائشة»؛ السياسى الهندى أم نحن المسلمون؟.. من الذى شوه سيرة نبى الرحمة؟ «الهندى» أم «البخارى»؟ ^{[2] [3]}

https://www.memri.org/reports/egyptian-journalist-problem-not-statements-insulting-prophet-uncritical-acceptance#_edn8

“Islam does not allow women to mingle with men. There should be a curtain between women and men…women can enjoy everything, watch everything from beyond that curtain,’

~ Musaliyar https://indianexpress.com/article/india/kerala/kerala-muslim-cleric-class-x-girl-support-7917078/

• mediated discourse and nexus analysis (MDNA)
• Arabs without God
• discrediting linguistic strategies used by Ex-Muslims on Twitter, including intertextuality, humor, and sarcasm, see Al Zidjaly, 2019b

• https://www.indiatoday.in/world/story/ex-muslims-organise-eating-protests-outside-embassies-in-london-16147-2016-06-24
• https://www.rug.nl/research/centre-for-religious-studies/research-centres/centre-religion-conflict-globalization/blog/exmuslimbecause-popular-terminology-among-islams-non-believers-01-03-2019?lang=en

According to Najma Al Zidjaly

Najma Al Zidjaly says

* ^[4][5]