The result was delete Paul Barnes, Andy Little, John Boswell, Steve Butler, Antony Howard and Richard Butler, keep Byron Bubb and Josh Lennie, no consensus for Scott Curley and Mark Rooney. Punkmorten 09:24, 30 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Semi-professional footballer. Hasn't played for a professional club and thus fails WP:BIO. For the same reason I am nominating fellow A.F.C. Wimbledon players Andy Little, John Boswell (footballer) (former clubs listed only as trainees), Steve Butler (footballer), Antony Howard, Byron Bubb, Scott Curley (never played a game for Chelsea) and Richard Butler (footballer). Fellow squad members Josh Lennie and Mark Rooney (footballer) have only ever played Football League Trophy matches for League clubs, and, in my opinion, should be deleted too. If Rooney is deleted, this redirect page - Mark Rooney 19/05/1978 also needs deleting. HornetMike 19:56, 23 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]
And finally,
Keep:Scott Curley , Byron Bubb,Josh Lennie and Mark Rooney. Probably delete the rest as they fail WP:Bio although it is a bit of a mess as it's hard to quickly judge on a large number of players. The articles should have been listed indivually. Or make a sub-page called "AFC Wimbledon Players" and redirect their pages there. Englishrose 18:44, 29 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]