Oppose for now
In the lead, in one sentence, you're stating that there were 8 rounds in the 1974 draft, then after a comma, you're stating that there actually were 10 rounds in the same 1974 draft. Hmm, which one is it?
In the Nationality column, "USA" should be "United States" in order to be consistent, since you spelled out other countries. OR it could be the other way, use the 3-lettered abbreviations for other countries.
- I disagree with The Rambling Man, I don't think a key for the positions is needed, since all of the abbreviations are already linked in the table.
- [Most important]There are some picks that Houston either traded for or traded away after drafting, so there should be notes next to them. Some examples: 15th and 37th picks in 2002 draft, 18th and 23rd picks in 2001 draft, etc.
- All notes should be cited.
In the "College/High School/Club" column, foreign clubs should have their countries in parenthesis next to them.
--Crzycheetah 21:17, 18 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
- I believe I've addressed all your comments. Noble Story (talk) 01:47, 19 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
- Great job, that was quick! Some more comments:
- Footnotes ##17, 19 and 20 need detailed trade notes.
- I don't trust TheDraftReview.com as a reference and I think it should be changed. NBA.com and ESPN.com may have the latest trade news and are more reliable. I may help you out on this.
- Replaced all with reliable sources.
- I strongly recommend to doublecheck the trade notes in a couple of days. I know I will.;)
--Crzycheetah 09:43, 19 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
- I think I've corrected everything you said to. Noble Story (talk) 10:04, 19 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]
- Comments I striked my oppose, but still not comfortable to support. Here are some minor concerns:
- I think it would be better if you used this link as a reference instead.
- All those page numbers need a "p." in front of them to clarify that those are actual page numbers.
- I would also like to see <br /> between the notes and references. It's just too congested now.
- I've added footnotes as suggested below.
- All of those university links should be linked to more specific pages. For example the University of Kentucky should be linked to Kentucky Wildcats men's basketball. After all, people listed here are basketball players, not noble prize winners.;)
--
Crzycheetah 19:56, 25 April 2008 (UTC)
[reply]