At first, I was worried about some prose issues, but the nominator's dedication has shown that these can easily be fixed! Thanks for bearing with me as I put out the review, too! dannymusiceditorSpeak up!13:45, 17 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]
The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
I'll review this one for my buddy Yeepsi here. Although I was never a fan of this album, I did end up liking TBS later on and I know they're an emo/pop punk icon. I have made one edit to the article about two months ago if I remember correctly, but nothing major enough to get in the way of the GA review rules. Coming soon. dannymusiceditorSpeak up!18:35, 10 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]
Honestly, I think the genres in the infobox would look better in an hlist or flatlist format.
Link Big Blue Meenie Recording Studio in the infobox (idk if that's actually the page title).
Link the members in the second sentence.
Taking Back Sunday released a five-song demo in early 2001 before touring for most of the year. I honestly don't like the way the copyeditor wrote this one. How about ...in early 2001, after which, they toured for most of the year. You know, whatever. Do what you'd like with this one.
They rented a room in Lindenhurst, New York, where they wrote and recorded songs. Songs for the album, I assume?
In the second paragraph, you go from December 2002 ("Cute Without the E") and touring in summer 2003 back in time to November 2002 with "You're So Last Summer". Chronological order, please.
mostly positive, not mostly-positive (I'd have struck a line through it but it's a hyphen and that'd have been confusing)
Note how many shipments in the US gold certifies after you mention it.
as a result of the anniversary tour Still not liking that. How about "The band played an acoustic set on the anniversary tour, which was..." you get the idea.
At a party, Nolan reportedly romanced Lacey's girlfriend and Lacey left the band.and, after which
The mention of where Lazzara's hometown is comes too late. It should be how he moved from North Carolina to New York.
Are you able to give me any details on the relationship between Lazzara and Lacey? According to this source that you used, the two had a beef with each other that caused a rivalry between Brand New and TBS. But then again, it just might be misrepping Lazzara for Nolan, who I did see you mention previously.
O'Connell, a friend of Reyes, heard about the vacancy and joined the group. Who's O'Connell?
DeJoseph left, leaving the band without a drummer. When? (And there's no source for his departure, though I guess it can be assumed because the source at the sentence's end says "they were in need of a drummer" and DeJoseph has been proven to have been a part of the band.)
I don't have a source of DeJoseph leaving (or when he left, for that matter), unfortunately. Should I remove the sentence? Yeepsi (talk) 21:31, 14 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]
their first song was "Great Romances of the 20th Century". First song written? Completed? What? Their first song what?
The band was frequently recorded demos at this time, and wrote all their material. It's unclear and possibly wrong towards the end, and it's just grammatically incorrect at the beginning of the sentence. The lyrics were written by only two members; the band wrote the music together. So fix grammar and say how they wrote all their music together.
Many songs feature Lazzara and Nolan in call-and-response vocals. You can't be in vocals, but you can use them.
Their lyrics, written by Adam Lazzara and John Nolan, Additionally, remove their first names.
Okay, I know I gave you sourcing advice, but a source must always come after a quote, no matter what. Tricky rules, I know.
"Great Romances of the 20th Century" includes a sample from the film, Beautiful Girls (1996). So is this a lyrical reference or an audio sample?
Rewrite the following sentence. I'd suggest: ((xt|Lazzara said "The Blue Channel" and "Head Club" were songs that the band used "to get enough songs to fill a record so we could go on tour".
No comma necessary in the following sentence.
When they listened to these guys, they were searching for influence. I'd say it's safe to call it influence in this case. So you could say they were influenced by them during production.
Release date: I guess I don't mind the two references there, but please order them numerically as currently it says [25][24]. Also don't see the point of the footnote.
Missing a verb in the next sentence. Its cover art done was by John Clark or better.
To promote the album, Victory founder Tony Brummel decided to target people familiar with the label and emo. I feel like this flows poorly. Mess around with it, and if I still don't like it, I'll put up suggestions. Maybe those who were fans of emo?
How does this sound: "To promote the album, Victory founder Tony Brummel targeted people who were familiar with the label and also fans of emo."? Yeepsi (talk) 22:27, 16 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]
A Yahoo! Group with over 1,300 fans allowed them to download demos of "Bike Scene" and "Head Club", a tactic which was hoped would increase sales. Emo fans or early TBS fans?
Actually, I have no complaints about the rest of this section.
One number problem in Commercial performance - around April 2004. And one optional idea for flow - expand the sentence after 790,000 to include Victory's best selling record, and make the chart feat separate.
Accolades, retrospective reviews and legacy:
[t]he 'Hybrid Theory' of emo. Since nobody (surprisingly) got that, I'll be the one to point out that 'Hybrid Theory' is a Linkin Park reference, and comparing anything to it is towards the highest in 2000s rock praise. If you haven't heard it, might as well check it out - it's the most successful American metal album in the millennium (it's a Diamond album in the US). In case you haven't figured out what I want yet, link and italicize Hybrid Theory.