This discussion was subject to a deletion review on 2009 April 4. For an explanation of the process, see Wikipedia:Deletion review. |
The result was delete. Stifle (talk) 08:56, 18 October 2008 (UTC)[reply]
First off I realise that the previous discussion about this article ended just over a week ago and renomination within this time period is not standard practise. However that discussion ended out of process after the nominator withdrew his nomination and was then closed as WP:SNOW by a non-admin and as always on Wikipedia exceptions to policy or convention can be made. To sum up the previous nomination:
The problem with this is that in no way is the page a disambiguation page - at least not what is described in Wikipedia:Disambiguation. Disambiguation is intended to resolve "conflicts in article titles that occur when a single term can be associated with more than one topic" - this page does not do that. There are no articles with the title "beating up" or anything particularly close to beating up - the page does not serve any purpose in terms of disambiguating articles. The initial section of the page is a list of dictionary definitions, Wikipedia is not a dictionary so they should not be the basis of an article and if the page is intended to be a disambiguation page then dictionary definitions are the first thing mentioned in the what not to include section of Wikipedia:Disambiguation. The next section is a list of synonyms, again Wikipedia is not a dictionary. The final section of the page contains some information about things with vaguely similar names such as the game genre Beat 'em ups and the Song Beat Him Up, these are, at best, partial title matches which are the second thing mentioned under what not to include in disambiguation pages. Based on this I think that the page cannot serve as a disambiguation page. As an article the page was roundly criticised in the previous discussion and I think the topic is already covered in an encyclopaedic manner on Wikipedia. From a legal perspective the topic is covered in articles such as Battery (crime) and Assault, from a more general perspective there are articles such as Violence. An article with this title would likely either be simply a dictionary definition of the colloquialism or a content fork of other articles that present the topic in a more definable way. Guest9999 (talk) 18:54, 13 October 2008 (UTC)[reply]