The result was keep. WP:SNOW. If the article needs to be merged or moved, that's something that needs to be discussed at the article talk page, AfD is not for cleanup. The Bushranger One ping only 17:34, 6 September 2013 (UTC)[reply]
Four years ago Captain Phillips here captivated us all with his courage and heroism in the face of a pirate attack against his vessel. His exploits have even resulted in a movie deal and other interesting bonus for his life. Despite all this though there are two rather important issues in the article as it stands. First, this still fails WP:ONEEVENT. Now I admit to being an inclusionist, so it kills me to say this, but if I am willing to argue that a Clayton Hartwig, who was accused of causing the largest peacetime death toll in US Navy history is unworthy for an article here on WP:ONEVENT grounds then I am compelled to observe the same thing here. The other issue is that whoever moved the article page neglected to move the talk page as well so at a minimum the histories for the two talk pages need to be merged. Also, as a matter of procedure, we never settled on whether the Phillips article was a ONEVENT or not due to WP:SNOW closure at the last afd. I am therefore renominating this so we can determine if the following: 1) If the good captain deserves an article, 2) where said article should be, and 3) whose going to have the joyless duty of merging two separate talk page histories into one cohesive unit. TomStar81 (Talk) 07:53, 6 September 2013 (UTC)[reply]
Second, Phillips role in the pirate capture -- isn't this distinct from whatever role he played in cooperating with a book or movie deal? Maybe back during the first ((afd)), prior to his signing book deals, prior to invitations for public appearances, he could be described as a "one event" person -- this is no longer true, hasn't been true for four years. Geo Swan (talk) 08:28, 6 September 2013 (UTC)[reply]