This page is an archive. Do not edit the contents of this page. Please direct any additional comments to the current main page. |
This barnstar can be user to award Wikipedia Youth. I, as a member of the Wikipedia Youth Foundation, believe that young editors should be commended with a seperate, more appropriate star. (Like a Barnstar looking like a plush toy). I don't know how to create barnstars, though. Could someone make it?--walkingencyclopedia 16:34, 21 July 2006 (UTC)
The Constellation Award is awarded to those who make exceedingly good contributions to Wikiproject Constellations. Feel free to edit the image to your liking, as it needs some work.
--Gray Porpoise 13:51, 18 July 2006 (UTC)
I think that there should be a Barnstar for those editors and writers that contribute to Wikipedia, but not just to one particular subject. The Barnstars we have today are "specialized." I know that a lot of people write really weird but really good articles that doesn't fit into any of the Barnstar categories. What I'm proposing is a Barnstar for anything. Any article. Any change. Any contribution. For anyone and everyone. Unfortunatly, I'm not really into image creation, and, so, am having difficulty creating this Barnstar. If anyone is interested, feel free to make one and present it here. Best wishes. -- Wolfie001 20:52, 29 July 2006 (UTC)
We should make it an alternate, and the original barnstar's scope would expand to music videos. -TrackerTV 02:34, 25 July 2006 (UTC)
Can't we have more than one barnstar for any particular thing? They are both nice. Shannonduck talk 04:58, 25 July 2006 (UTC)
Comment I made it specifically because I thought the RMB unsuitable as it is too general. Football is the most popular sport worldwide, and is appropriately well-represented on the project. There may be many other users like me who felt the RMB unsuitable for a football editor, as it shows a stylised runner. I am not suggesting that every sport should have its own barnstar, just football. It seems to me to be big enough to deserve it. Hope that makes sense. --Guinnog 22:47, 30 July 2006 (UTC)
Comment I certainly wouldn't have a problem wit that. --Guinnog 13:51, 1 August 2006 (UTC)
The discussion for the Football (Soccer) Barnstar has been sent back to the proposal page by Evrik for further discussion. When debate is over, please place the new results of the discussion below this message. Thank you.--Ed 18:35, 3 August 2006 (UTC)
Image:A-LeagueMedal.gif Designed to be awarded to the people who make awesome edits to an article associated to Wikiproject A-League. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Daniel.Bryant (talk • contribs)
Other Discussions on this Topic:
This is a proposed series of awards for service: WP:SERVICE
As I have it now, this is unlike other awards in that:
There is no human judgement (=politics) involved here. If nobody likes you, you still get one (if you qualify). If everyone likes you, you still can't get one (unless you qualify).
Right now, I have it as only being for editors who are not admins. The reason being, I was thinking that there ought to be something, that is kind of hard to get, besides becoming an admin.
This would only be very useful if it catches on, though. I think this is kind of unlikely. Partly because people who are currently eligible are likely to be blasé and uninterested. But it's not for them, it's for editors who aspire to be like them, so perhaps they could be be jollied into going along, some of them anyway. (To get a list of eligible editors I'd need to query the database which I don't know how to do, but that's a detail. After the backlog is cleared, and supposing it did catch on, editors just help themselves, I guess.)
I'm wondering if this is even worthwhile. Anyway, I liked making the graphics, and suggesting an entirely different use for them would be fine, too.
Questions:
Comments welcome --Herostratus 05:30, 16 July 2006 (UTC)
In line with the British honours system, we can also create post-nominal letters for each class, and a motto for the Order (e.g. Scientia potentia est). What do you think? —SHININGEYES 17:52, 20 July 2006 (UTC)
Taking all the discussions together, I'm seeing a roughly 50-50 split. So here's what I'm going to do now (which of course any editor can change), which seems a reasonable compromise:
I am proposing a slight modification to the barnstar barnstar. In the existing image there is a black dot in the middle of the smaller star (most likely due to copying the image which changes transparent parts to black, if anyone knows how this can not be done please inform me). I have eliminated the spot, though it is a bit pixely if anyone can fix that, and I am proposing the switch here just in case there is any opposition. --WillMak050389 19:58, 9 August 2006 (UTC)
This is for those Esperanzans who go out of there way to spread the spirit of Hope and Wikilove to which the Project stands for. Esperansa is one of the most active and outgoing projects on Wikipedia and members of said project do many many great things here. This would most likey if approved go in the PUA catergory. Æon Insane Ward 14:30, 9 August 2006 (UTC)
Other Discussions on this Topic: See Esperanza for the discussion on their barnstar.
User:Leroyencyclopediabrown/Support Making it a PUA is a great idea, but there is a huge support from Esperanza, that there is a possibility for it becoming a WikiProject award.--Ed 15:42, 9 August 2006 (UTC)
I'll be moving this, since there is clearly approval from Esperanza, and nobody objects to this award in any way.User:Leroyencyclopediabrown/Sign
I think that there are enough television and radio articles to warrant a barnstar meant for extraordinary contributions to television and radio. This proposal would be used by WikiProjects Television and Radio (plus any subprojects, like Television Stations).
I have also uploaded an image that is my first proposal (or rough idea) of the Barnstar. -TrackerTV 02:15, 24 July 2006 (UTC)
Support--I still support #4.Transcendentalstate 18:14, 2 August 2006 (UTC)
Medicine is a major part of Wikipedia, having tens of thousands of articles, but has no award. It falls awkwardly between Science and Life. It may not be suitable as a barnstar, but if not chosen for that, I'm sure WikiProject Medicine wouldn't mind having this as a WikiProject award. smurrayinchester(User), (Talk) 15:32, 14 July 2006 (UTC)
This is not a proposal for a single new award, but for a new type of award designed to accredit skill rather than distinction. Please see Wikipedia:Skill badges and discuss on the talk page. NeonMerlin 15:09, 11 August 2006 (UTC)
(discussion moved to Wikipedia talk:Skill badges by NeonMerlin 18:11, 11 August 2006 (UTC))
These are two concepts for a barnstar for rail-related articles. EASports 19:29, 30 July 2006 (UTC)
I noticed that Cabalists, Mediators and Arbitrators do an awful lot of work on Wikipedia, and they hardly get any recognition. I thought we ought to roll out a barnstar in their honor. I approached Sango123 to ask her if she would design the barnstar, seeing as I am no good at design. So, she came up with this.
It would be awarded to Cabalists, Mediators and Arbitrators who do an excellent job on a specific job, or just a great job in general. Tell me what you think!
Given what these people put up with, here is this idea:
In this, you take two Gold Barnstars, rotate one until you have a ten pointed star. In that, a Silver Circle is placed, in the circle, is placed a A. Then, a pair of LARGE silver wings is placed, so that it has one wing on the right, one wing on the left of the ten pointed star. This is to be awarded to outstanding Admins. Slight modifications could be done to award this to stewards, to Wikipedia itself, outstanding Users, to the boss himself, Jimbo Wales. Martial Law 18:47, 15 August 2006 (UTC) Category:Wikipedia awards
I wanted to propose this in the Barnstar area, but the format has changed.
I have moved the discussion below from Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard. —Quarl (talk) 2006-08-15 21:41Z
What I had in mind is a ten pointed Barnstar Award. You take two Gold Barnstars, rotate one until you get a Barnstar that has ten points on it. Then in this is placed a silver circle, in that is a large gold A. Outside of the ten point Barnstar, is a set of wings, similar to what is seen in certain USAF designations, so that this Barnstar looks like one that has wings on it. I intend to call this the Admin Gold Medal, to be awarded to outstanding Admins. Appreciate your assisstance, patience in this matter. I know of some Admins I'd like to award this thing to, if it is approved. Martial Law 16:55, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
Discuss :) —Quarl (talk) 2006-08-15 21:41Z
The da Vinci Barnstar
(({1))} |
The da Vinci Barnstar may be awarded to anyone who has enhanced Wikipedia through their technical work (programming and tools, bot building, admin or sysop work, link repair, Mediawiki developers, etc.)
I'd like to create an award for people who help fight POV forks (while still being civil and promoting verifiability and being bold, of course). I don't have a design, although I'd like to base it off of the (GFDL image) fork on the right. --M@rēino 17:53, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
I propose a welcoming commitee barnstar award. It should be awarded to Welcoming Commitee members who tirelessly welcome new users with lots of WikiLove. There are lots of Welcoming Commitee members who deserve an award like this. I encourage people to create a new design for it. Created and designed by Jam01 06:20, 22 August 2006 (UTC).
Image:WCBs2.PNG - A second possible design by Jam01
Image:Welcomer's Barnstar.png - Welcomer's Barnstar
I propose a barnstar for continuting importnat contributions to environmental subjects. My skills of design are not good enough to produce the actual design. Is anyone up for the challenge? --Alex 11:28, 22 August 2006 (UTC)
Lots of editors work hours straight on the bootcamp channel, helping users, dealing with angry users, sorting out ((unblock))'s, but the majority work on ((helpme))'s. I have been edit conflicted many times, (which is good! :) ), by other, equally-eager Bootcamp-er's: and I think it's now time they were honoured with a barnstar :) --Deon555talkReview 01:58, 27 August 2006 (UTC)
I propose that Wikipedia have a barnstar reserved for those editors who are particularly good at finding references to back up really obscure bits of info.--*Kat* 08:28, 4 September 2006 (UTC)
File:Total 90 Yellow Football.jpg | This user won the Football Edit Award, awarded by Footballexpert, in 2006. |
This is for CVU personnel who have shown outstanding ability:
Four Barnstars rotated until you have a 20 point Barnstar. In this, you have a Roman Short Sword. Since they have a thankless job, this is my way of thanking these personnel as well. Martial Law06:35, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
Neutral The RickK Anti-Vandalism Barnstar and the Defender of the Wiki Barnstar are used for and ment for this. Æon Insane Ward 21:05, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
Hey, I just found the big gallery of Barnstars of National Merit for various specific countries over in the Commons. Can we have one for Hungary? I think a few of those may be in order if we manage to get the 1956 Hungarian Revolution article tops on the Article Creation and Improvement drive, and especially if it becomes featured article on Oct. 23 as is our hope! OK....that was kind of a shameless plug for the voting. I still think a Hungarian National Merit barnstar would be very welcome. :) K. Lastochka 16:23, 18 September 2006 (UTC)
Hi again, I'm about to upload it to the commons but I'm not sure what license to put it under. What I did for the image was I pulled one of the existing National Merit barnstars off the gallery and then modified it on Photoshop...would it fit under Public Domain? I'm still pretty new at this Wikipedia stuff...K. Lastochka 22:20, 18 September 2006 (UTC)
I DID, and got confused. That's why I asked. I don't want to inadvertantly break the law. K. Lastochka 02:50, 19 September 2006 (UTC)
I do believe that's what I'll do. :) Thanx guys, off to upload. K. Lastochka 15:25, 19 September 2006 (UTC)
The Computing Star is awarded to those who make outstanding contributions to computing/internet related articles. Also used for WikiProject Computing and all descendant WikiProjects. Introduced by Michaelas10 and designed by Lcarsdata. -- Michaelas10 18:12, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
New image proposed - This one is customized by me, looks pretty simple and focuses on the barnstar. -- Michaelas10 20:51, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
...time passes...
--Gray Porpoise 20:49, 22 August 2006 (UTC)
There we go:
Michaelas10 19:53, 16 September 2006 (UTC)
Can anyone give the award a form of a barnstar instead of just shape? It's really important for it to look more like other awards and have a higher quality. Thanks. Michaelas10 10:50, 4 October 2006 (UTC)
This is a concept for a barnstar an award for exemplary work in Automotive-related articles. Note that there was general support for a Railroad star, and the Automotive section of Wiki is comparable in size, support and need for recognition. SteveBaker 06:01, 13 August 2006 (UTC)
Update - The consensus both here and on the Automobiles project appears to be that we 100% agree that we need an automotive barnstar - and that almost everyone likes the idea of a star overlaid on a custom wheel - but that not everyone likes this particular custom wheel. Whilst I think we have the votes to justify making the image above be the automotive barnstar, it would be better to try some more designs based around the car wheel motif. I'll be working on that as time permits. SteveBaker 15:26, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
After further discussion on the Automobile project page, I am please to announce that there is a clear consensus in favor of adopting this image as the Automobile project Barnstar to be awarded for all significant contributions of an automotive nature. For those who care, the image is of a Simca 1000 GL - the car was originally blue and the hubcap had an ALMOST barnstarish look that took a little GIMPing around to look as it does now. Thanks to Bravada for suggesting it. SteveBaker 20:06, 20 September 2006 (UTC)
I see the Railroad guys have petitioned for a special Barnstar award for their WikiProject - and it looks like it's getting some support. Not to be outdone, I thought I'd throw an image together and propose it.
If you have comments (like Support for example :-) you might take a stroll over to the proposals page: Wikipedia:Barnstar_and_award_proposals/New_Proposals#Automotive_Barnstar
(indent reset) Well, I actually like the railway barnstar very much for what you mentioned - it is not an in-your-face image screaming "BARNSTAR!" with a blinking neon light over it and Elgar's "Pump & Circumstance" playing while Miller's and popcorn are being handed out. No, it is a discreet, elegant, refined picture of high quality by itself, with a small hint recognizable by those in the know. It will always come with loads and loads of info on what it is and there can be no mistake about that, so I guess the fact that it isn't the standard barnstar with Thomas the Tank Engine (who is a subject of a separate project btw) slapped on it is not a problem. If it doesn't fit in with the other barnstars, it says something of the quality of their quality.
What I would strive for is a barnstar that would exude the same qualities, being a refined, high-quality picture itself, with a recognizable reference to the scope of this WikiProject, and a barnstar well-composed into it. Apart from the Railway Barnstar, I can think of two current barnstars that have similar qualities - The Hollywood Barnstar and The Blueprint Barnstar (although the barnstars are pretty evident due to the theme employed). Coming close would be the Stargate Barnstar, although the idea might not be that inventive.
My vision is something quite like the Absolut Vodka ads (excuse me to indirectly promot alcohol here, ApolloBoy and Karrmann please don't click the link ;-) ), where the iconic bottle is cleverly composed into different backgrounds. People who know what it is about can really appreciate those little works of art.
On the other hand, nobody says we should absolutely have our award in the form of a barnstar. The fellow airborne WikiProject employs some very nifty WikiWings. Perhaps we can devise a more unique award like that?
Here's a list of items that one can compose a barnstar in, or can derive a new award from - I hope other will chip in:
^ The above was submitted by the notorious Bravada. Karrmann's comment starts below. Bravada, talk - 18:48, 13 August 2006 (UTC)
(reset indent again) I don't think we "settled on" anything yet - is there any rush? I think we might wait, perhaps some other people will come with other propositions, or Steve will have yet another idea. I have asked some Wikipedia artists, who designed nice barnstars before, whether they would like to submit their propositions, so I suggest we would wait for them.
As concerns the car key, now that you told me it's a GM key I can see the GM logo peeking from behind more and more :D I have no idea how the pre-electronics Mercedes key looks like, but perhaps if somebody could find an image, it would be good to try that too. Finally, I think the wheel itself is a good idea, especially not a sole rim, but a whole wheel with a tire sitting in a wheelwell. I absolutely loathe shiny Pimp-My-Ride Giovannis, but a nice-looking wheel would absolutely do the trick for me. I invite you once again to take a look at the Primula - totally accidentally, Autbianchi designers managed to incorporate the barnstar theme in a very good way! Bravada, talk - 12:11, 14 August 2006 (UTC)
So far, we have:
But how about...
For those who wanted a 'wheel' design for the Automotive barnstar - but not the chrome wheel I did before, here is a suitably doctored Simca1000 wheel following a suggestion from Bravada over on the Wikipedia:Barnstar_and_award_proposals/New_Proposals page. I'm not sure which of the cropped designs looks best. The one at the extreme left is a bit too subtle IMHO - at normal barnstar sizes it's really not obvious that it's a barnstar at all. I think the one that's second from the right is probably the best mix of "This is a Barnstar" and "This isn't obviously a barnstar until you look carefully". SteveBaker 11:31, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
Since y'all are developing this award here instead of on the Award Proposal page I just wanted to bring a couple of things to your attention. The consensus on the WikiProject Awards (which this appears to be) is that only things listed on the Barnstar page are called Barnstars. Everything else is called an award or a star. Just an FYI. If you're making a topical barnstar for automotive related issues, I would suggest moving this debate to the proposal page. Finally, most of the awards listed on the two aformentioned pages tend to focus on the star image. --evrik 02:41, 21 August 2006 (UTC)
The Automotive Barnstar may be awarded to an editor who contributes significantly to expand or improve Wikipedia's coverage of Automobiles. The award was proposed and designed by SteveBaker 2006 following a suggestion by Bravada.
Why did you remove the Automobile barnstar? I believe I followed all the instructions for creating such a thing. If I messed up, it can only be because the rules are pretty vague.
There was 100% agreement about the need for such a thing - not one person objected (either on the barnstar page or on the automotive page) - the image we selected was the one we all wanted - again, we had almost 100% agreement. It doesn't appear to violate any guidelines. Your edit comment says to look in the discussion page - but there is no mention of the reason you removed it. Please respond or I shall assume you made a mistake and go ahead and reinstate it. SteveBaker 03:42, 23 September 2006 (UTC)
I removed the Automotive Award from the topical Barnstar page because I think it was placed there prematurely. There has generally been a different set of standards for WikiProject Awards than for barnstars. I made a couple of comments on the proposal page earlier about the difference between a WikiProject Award and a Barnstar. I will note that the majority of the development of the Award was done at the WikiProject Automoblie pages - which is fine for that type of award. Since the barnstar pages have been devloped there has been a clear move to limit the number of barnstars, or to enable poeple to create awards that fit their needs.
SteveBaker, if you want to propose a barnstar, then you have to do it here, and it has to be vetted by the community. The process may be vague and unevenly applied, but there are some loose standards. I hope that explaisn my actions. --evrik 17:58, 23 September 2006 (UTC)
Oppose - the award's image is good as it is. --Gray Porpoise 02:03, 24 September 2006 (UTC)