Closer's notes
In this CFD, there is a local consensus to abandon the "Old Fooians" format, and "People educated at Foo" seems to be the most acceptable compromise. Whether a more general consensus exists to rename in a similar manner the other 300+ subcategories of Category:Former pupils by school in England will be determined in a future discussion; if such consensus proves elusive, then this change, too, should be reconsidered.
For the sake of summary, the options which were considered in this discussion included: "Old Fooians" (no change); "Old Fooians (Bar school)", where "Bar" is the location; "Former pupils of Foo"; "Foo alumni" or "Alumni of Foo"; and "People educated at Foo". The main argument for renaming was that "Old Fooians" is school-specific and obscure jargon, and the main argument against renaming was that "Old Fooians" is the official and common form used by the schools (and their alumni/pupils/students).
Two final thoughts:
- I will list Category:Old Edwardians (Sheffield) for renaming to Category:People educated at King Edward VII School, Sheffield as this was the option proposed by Bduke and supported by several other participants. The school's article, however, is titled King Edward VII School (Sheffield).
- If there is general consensus to adopt the "People educated at Foo" format, what will be the new title of the container category (currently, Category:Former pupils by school in England)?