All-Star Game appearance record

Most games on the roster originally or as a replacement.^[1] Two All-Star Games were held each season from 1959 through 1962.

• Hank Aaron 25
• Willie Mays 24
• Stan Musial 24

All-Star Game MVP Award record

• Willie Mays, Steve Garvey, Gary Carter, Cal Ripken Jr., and Mike Trout 2

Single All-Star Game hitting records

• Runs batted in: Al Rosen, Ted Williams 5^[2]
• Runs: Ted Williams 4^[2]
• Hits: Joe Medwick, Ted Williams, Carl Yastrzemski 4^[2]
• Home runs: Gary Carter, Willie McCovey, Al Rosen, Arky Vaughan, Ted Williams 2^[2]
• Inside-the-park home runs: Ichiro Suzuki 1
• Grand slams: Fred Lynn 1^[2]
• Doubles: Ernie Banks, Barry Bonds, Ted Kluszewski, Paul Konerko, Joe Medwick, Damian Miller, Albert Pujols, Al Simmons 2^[2]
• Triples: Rod Carew 2^[2]
• Walks: Phil Cavarretta, Charlie Gehringer 3^[2]
• Total bases: Ted Williams 10^[2]

Single All-Star Game pitching records

• Runs allowed: Atlee Hammaker 7^[3]
• Earned runs: Atlee Hammaker 7^[3]
• Hits allowed: Tom Glavine 9^[3]
• Home runs allowed: Jim Palmer 3^[3]
• Innings pitched: Lefty Gomez 6^[3]
• Strikeouts: Carl Hubbell, Larry Jansen, Ferguson Jenkins, Johnny Vander Meer 6^[3]
• Consecutive Strikeouts: Carl Hubbell, Fernando Valenzuela 5^[3]

Career All-Star Game hitting records

• At bats: Willie Mays 75
• Batting average: Charlie Gehringer .500
• Runs batted in: Ted Williams 12
• Runs: Willie Mays 20
• Hits: Willie Mays 23
• Extra base hits: Willie Mays, Stan Musial 8
• Home runs: Stan Musial 6
• Inside-the-park home runs: Ichiro Suzuki 1
• Grand slams: Fred Lynn 1
• Doubles: Dave Winfield 7
• Triples: Willie Mays, Brooks Robinson 3
• Walks: Ted Williams 11
• Total bases: Willie Mays, Stan Musial 40
• Pinch hits: Stan Musial 3

Career All-Star Game pitching records

• Wins: Lefty Gomez 3
• Losses: Mort Cooper, Whitey Ford, Dwight Gooden, Catfish Hunter, Claude Passeau, John Smoltz, Luis Tiant, Clayton Kershaw 2
• Earned runs: Whitey Ford 11
• Hits: Whitey Ford 19
• Innings pitched: Don Drysdale 19⅓
• Batters faced: Don Drysdale 69
• Balks: Dwight Gooden 2
• Walks: Jim Palmer 7
• Strikeouts: Don Drysdale 19
• Games pitched: Roger Clemens 9
• Games started: Don Drysdale, Lefty Gomez, Robin Roberts 5
• Games finished: Rich Gossage 6
• Saves: Mariano Rivera 4