Six of Diamonds, When Doctors Disagree, from Harlequin Cards, 2nd Series (N220) issued by Kinney Bros. MET DPB872267.jpg

Controversies involving science exists in all aspects. Sometimes defined as a "persistent disagreement"[1] over knowledge, the contrasting opinions of certain topics leaves individuals in a tense setting.

A scientific controversy is a substantial disagreement among scientists. A scientific controversy may involve issues such as the interpretation of data, which ideas are most supported by evidence, and which ideas are most worth pursuing. [2]

Controversies between scientific and non-scientific ideas are not within the realm of science and are not true scientific controversies.[3]

The origin of science-related controversies

Scientific controversies usually exist in the context of geography, history, and social context. Much like other topics, there are individuals that can’t seem to see eye to eye within the world of science. Depending on the demographic, the way a community sides with an opinion varies. With the natural conflict of having varying opinions, an audience having their biases, and more, makes for controversy. Even more in a public setting, contrasting opinions encourage discourse amongst individuals.

Conflict with beliefs

In the situation of even presenting clear and scientifically proven evidence, people will always have their own opinion. “Controversy can be rooted in differing beliefs and values; personal, political, social, and economic interests; fears; and moral and ethical considerations—all of which are central to decisions and typically subject to public debate”. [4]

As described above, individuals have their opinions based on various subjects such as culture, history, ethics, morals, religion, and more. This leads the stance on certain scientific topics to be very different across the board as perceptions vary from person to person, this is the ultimate reason why scientific controversy exists, to begin with. Science-related controversies all follow similar characteristics.

  1. Conflict over personal beliefs, values, and interests
  2. Public perception
  3. Voices behind opinions presented to the public

Nature of science-related controversies

With science being inconclusive in itself, it leads to a disconnect between individuals. Oftentimes, science gets roped into personal morals and social values which leads to contrasting ideas.[5] This arises the issue of communicating science in an appropriate manner. Listed below, there are some of the various examples of scientific controversies.

See also

References