Algebraic structure → Ring theory Ring theory |
---|

In abstract algebra, a **semiring** is an algebraic structure. It is a generalization of a ring, dropping the requirement that each element must have an additive inverse. At the same time, it is a generalization of bounded distributive lattices.

The smallest semiring that is not a ring is the two-element Boolean algebra, e.g. with logical disjunction as addition. A motivating example that is neither a ring nor a lattice is the set of natural numbers under ordinary addition and multiplication, when including the number zero. Semirings are abundant, because a suitable multiplication operation arises as the function composition of endomorphisms over any commutative monoid.

Algebraic structures |
---|

Some authors call semiring the structure without the requirement for there to be a or . This makes the analogy between **ring** and *semiring* on the one hand and *group* and *semigroup* on the other hand work more smoothly. These authors often use **rig** for the concept defined here.^{[1]}^{[a]} This originated as a joke, suggesting that rigs are ri*n*gs without *n*egative elements. (And this is similar to using *rng* to mean a r*i*ng without a multiplicative *i*dentity.)

The term **dioid** (for "double monoid") has been used to mean semirings or other structures. It was used by Kuntzmann in 1972 to denote a semiring.^{[2]} (It is alternatively sometimes used for naturally ordered semirings^{[3]} but the term was also used for idempotent subgroups by Baccelli et al. in 1992.^{[4]})

A **semiring** is a set equipped with two binary operations and called addition and multiplication, such that:^{[5]}^{[6]}^{[7]}

- is a monoid with identity element called :
- is a monoid with identity element called :
- Addition is commutative:

Explicitly stated, is a commutative monoid. Further, the following axioms tie to both operations:

- Through multiplication, any element is left- and right-annihilated by the additive identity:
- Multiplication left- and right-distributes over addition:

The symbol is usually omitted from the notation; that is, is just written

Similarly, an order of operations is conventional, in which is applied before . That is, denotes .

For the purpose of disambiguation, one may write or to emphasize which structure the units at hand belong to.

If is an element of a semiring and , then -times repeated multiplication of with itself is denoted , and one similarly writes for the -times repeated addition.

The zero ring with underlying set is also a semiring, called *the* trivial semiring. This triviality can be characterized via and so is often silently assumed as if it were an additional axiom.
Now given any semiring, there are several ways to define new ones.

As noted, the natural numbers with its arithmetic structure form a semiring. Taking the zero and the image of the successor operation in a semiring , i.e. the set together with the inherited operations, is always a sub-semiring of .

If is a commutative monoid, function composition provides the multiplication to form a semiring: The set of endomorphisms forms a semiring, where addition is defined from pointwise addition in . The zero morphism and the identity are the respective neutral elements. If with a semiring, we obtain a semiring that can be associated with the square matrices with coefficients in , the matrix semiring using ordinary addition and multiplication rules of matrices. Yet more abstractly, given and a semiring, is always a semiring also. It is generally non-commutative even if was commutative.

Dorroh extensions: If is a semiring, then with pointwise addition and multiplication given by defines another semiring with multiplicative unit . Very similarly, if is any sub-semiring of , one may also define a semiring on , just by replacing the repeated addition in the formula by multiplication. Indeed, these constructions even work under looser conditions, as the structure is not actually required to have a multiplicative unit.

Zerosumfree semirings are in a sense furthest away from being rings. Given a semiring, one may adjoin a new zero to the underlying set and thus obtain such a zerosumfree semiring that also lacks zero divisors. In particular, now and the old semiring is actually not a sub-semiring. One may then go on and adjoin new elements "on top" one at a time, while always respecting the zero. These two strategies also work under looser conditions. Sometimes the notations resp. are used when performing these constructions.

Adjoining a new zero to the trivial semiring, in this way, results in another semiring which may be expressed in terms of the logical connectives of disjunction and conjunction: . Consequently, this is the smallest semiring that is not a ring. Explicitly, it violates the ring axioms as for all , i.e. has no additive inverse. In the self-dual definition, the fault is with . (This is not to be conflated with the ring , whose addition functions as xor .) In the von Neumann model of the naturals, , and . The two-element semiring may be presented in terms of the set theoretic union and intersection as . Now this structure in fact still constitutes a semiring when is replaced by any inhabited set whatsoever.

The ideals on a semiring , with their standard operations on subset, form a lattice-ordered, simple and zerosumfree semiring. The ideals of are in bijection with the ideals of . The collection of left ideals of (and likewise the right ideals) also have much of that algebraic structure, except that then does not function as a two-sided multiplicative identity.

If is a semiring and is an inhabited set, denotes the free monoid and the formal polynomials over its words form another semiring. For small sets, the generating elements are conventionally used to denote the polynomial semiring. For example, in case of a singleton such that , one writes . Zerosumfree sub-semirings of can be used to determine sub-semirings of .

Given a set , not necessarily just a singleton, adjoining a default element to the set underlying a semiring one may define the semiring of partial functions from to .

Given a derivation on a semiring , another the operation "" fulfilling can be defined as part of a new multiplication on , resulting in another semiring.

The above is by no means an exhaustive list of systematic constructions.

Derivations on a semiring are the maps with and .

For example, if is the unit matrix and , then the subset of given by the matrices with is a semiring with derivation .

A basic property of semirings is that is not a left or right zero divisor, and that but also squares to itself, i.e. these have .

Some notable properties are inherited from the monoid structures: The monoid axioms demand unit existence, and so the set underlying a semiring cannot be empty. Also, the 2-ary predicate defined as , here defined for the addition operation, always constitutes the right canonical preorder relation. Reflexivity is witnessed by the identity. Further, is always valid, and so zero is the least element with respect to this preorder. Considering it for the commutative addition in particular, the distinction of "right" may be disregarded. In the non-negative integers , for example, this relation is anti-symmetric and strongly connected, and thus in fact a (non-strict) total order.

Below, more conditional properties are discussed.

Any **field** is also a **semifield**, which in turn is a semiring in which also multiplicative inverses exist.

Any field is also a **ring**, which in turn is a semiring in which also additive inverses exist. Note that a semiring omits such a requirement, i.e., it requires only a commutative monoid, not a commutative group. The extra requirement for a ring itself already implies the existence of a multiplicative zero. This contrast is also why for the theory of semirings, the multiplicative zero must be specified explicitly.

Here , the additive inverse of , squares to . As additive differences always exist in a ring, is a trivial binary relation in a ring.

A semiring is called a **commutative semiring** if also the multiplication is commutative.^{[8]} Its axioms can be stated concisely: It consists of two commutative monoids and on one set such that and .

The center of a semiring is a sub-semiring and being commutative is equivalent to being its own center.

The commutative semiring of natural numbers is the initial object among its kind, meaning there is a unique structure preserving map of into any commutative semiring.

The bounded distributive lattices are partially ordered, commutative semirings fulfilling certain algebraic equations relating to distributivity and idempotence. Thus so are their duals.

Notions or order can be defined using strict, non-strict or second-order formulations. Additional properties such as commutativity simplify the axioms.

Given a strict total order (also sometimes called linear order, or pseudo-order in a constructive formulation), then by definition, the *positive* and *negative* elements fulfill resp. . By irreflexivity of a strict order, if is a left zero divisor, then is false. The *non-negative* elements are characterized by , which is then written .

Generally, the strict total order can be negated to define an associated partial order. The asymmetry of the former manifests as . In fact in classical mathematics the latter is a (non-strict) total order and such that implies . Likewise, given any (non-strict) total order, its negation is irreflexive and transitive, and those two properties found together are sometimes called strict quasi-order. Classically this defines a strict total order – indeed strict total order and total order can there be defined in terms of one another.

Recall that "" defined above is trivial in any ring. The existence of rings that admit a non-trivial non-strict order shows that these need not necessarily coincide with "".

A semiring in which every element is an additive idempotent, that is, for all elements , is called an **(additively) idempotent semiring**.^{[9]} Establishing suffices. Be aware that sometimes this is just called idempotent semiring, regardless of rules for multiplication.

In such a semiring, is equivalent to and always constitutes a partial order, here now denoted . In particular, here . So additively idempotent semirings are zerosumfree and, indeed, the only additively idempotent semiring that has all additive inverses is the trivial ring and so this property is specific to semiring theory. Addition and multiplication respect the ordering in the sense that implies , and furthermore implies as well as , for all and .

If is additively idempotent, then so are the polynomials in .

A semiring such that there is a lattice structure on its underlying set is **lattice-ordered** if the sum coincides with the meet, , and the product lies beneath the join . The lattice-ordered semiring of ideals on a semiring is not necessarily distributive with respect to the lattice structure.

More strictly than just additive idempotence, a semiring is called **simple** iff for all . Then also and for all . Here then functions akin to an additively infinite element. If is an additively idempotent semiring, then with the inherited operations is its simple sub-semiring.
An example of an additively idempotent semiring that is not simple is the tropical semiring on with the 2-ary maximum function, with respect to the standard order, as addition. Its simple sub-semiring is trivial.

A **c-semiring** is an idempotent semiring and with addition defined over arbitrary sets.

An additively idempotent semiring with idempotent multiplication, , is called **additively and multiplicatively idempotent semiring**, but sometimes also just idempotent semiring. The commutative, simple semirings with that property are exactly the bounded distributive lattices with unique minimal and maximal element (which then are the units). Heyting algebras are such semirings and the Boolean algebras are a special case.

Further, given two bounded distributive lattices, there are constructions resulting in commutative additively-idempotent semirings, which are more complicated than just the direct sum of structures.

In a model of the ring , one can define a non-trivial positivity predicate and a predicate as that constitutes a strict total order, which fulfills properties such as , or classically the law of trichotomy. With its standard addition and multiplication, this structure forms the strictly ordered field that is Dedekind-complete. By definition, all first-order properties proven in the theory of the reals are also provable in the decidable theory of the real closed field. For example, here is mutually exclusive with .

But beyond just ordered fields, the four properties listed below are also still valid in many sub-semirings of , including the rationals, the integers, as well as the non-negative parts of each of these structures. In particular, the non-negative reals, the non-negative rationals and the non-negative integers are such a semirings. The first two properties are analogous to the property valid in the idempotent semirings: Translation and scaling respect these ordered rings, in the sense that addition and multiplication in this ring validate

In particular, and so squaring of elements preserves positivity.

Take note of two more properties that are always valid in a ring. Firstly, trivially for any . In particular, the *positive* additive difference existence can be expressed as

Secondly, in the presence of a trichotomous order, the non-zero elements of the additive group are partitioned into positive and negative elements, with the inversion operation moving between them. With , all squares are proven non-negative. Consequently, non-trivial rings have a positive multiplicative unit,

Having discussed a strict order, it follows that and , etc.

There are a few conflicting notions of discreteness in order theory. Given some strict order on a semiring, one such notion is given by being positive and covering , i.e. there being no element between the units, . Now in the present context, an order shall be called **discrete** if this is fulfilled and, furthermore, all elements of the semiring are non-negative, so that the semiring starts out with the units.

Denote by the theory of a commutative, discretely ordered semiring also validating the above four properties relating a strict order with the algebraic structure. All of its models have the model as its initial segment and Gödel incompleteness and Tarski undefinability already apply to . The non-negative elements of a commutative, discretely ordered ring always validate the axioms of . So a slightly more exotic model of the theory is given by the positive elements in the polynomial ring , with positivity predicate for defined in terms of the last non-zero coefficient, , and as above. While proves all -sentences that are true about , beyond this complexity one can find simple such statements that are independent of . For example, while -sentences true about are still true for the other model just defined, inspection of the polynomial demonstrates -independence of the -claim that all numbers are of the form or ("odd or even"). Showing that also can be discretely ordered demonstrates that the -claim for non-zero ("no rational squared equals ") is independent. Likewise, analysis for demonstrates independence of some statements about factorization true in . There are characterizations of primality that does not validate for the number .

In the other direction, from any model of one may construct an ordered ring, which then has elements that are negative with respect to the order, that is still discrete the sense that covers . To this end one defines an equivalence class of pairs from the original semiring. Roughly, the ring corresponds to the differences of elements in the old structure, generalizing the way in which the initial ring can be defined from . This, in effect, adds all the inverses and then the preorder is again trivial in that .

Beyond the size of the two-element algebra, no simple semiring starts out with the units. Being discretely ordered also stands in contrast to, e.g., the standard ordering on the semiring of non-negative rationals , which is dense between the units. For another example, can be ordered, but not discretely so.

plus mathematical induction gives a theory equivalent to first-order Peano arithmetic . The theory is also famously not categorical, but is of course the intended model. proves that there are no zero divisors and it is zerosumfree and so no model of it is a ring.

The standard axiomatization of is more concise and the theory of its order is commonly treated in terms of the non-strict "". However, just removing the potent induction principle from that axiomatization does not leave a workable algebraic theory. Indeed, even Robinson arithmetic , which removes induction but adds back the predecessor existence postulate, does not prove the monoid axiom .

A **complete semiring** is a semiring for which the additive monoid is a complete monoid, meaning that it has an infinitary sum operation for any index set and that the following (infinitary) distributive laws must hold:^{[10]}^{[11]}^{[12]}

Examples of a complete semiring are the power set of a monoid under union and the matrix semiring over a complete semiring.^{[13]}
For commutative, additively idempotent and simple semirings, this property is related to residuated lattices.

A **continuous semiring** is similarly defined as one for which the addition monoid is a continuous monoid. That is, partially ordered with the least upper bound property, and for which addition and multiplication respect order and suprema. The semiring with usual addition, multiplication and order extended is a continuous semiring.^{[14]}

Any continuous semiring is complete:^{[10]} this may be taken as part of the definition.^{[13]}

A **star semiring** (sometimes spelled **starsemiring**) is a semiring with an additional unary operator ,^{[9]}^{[11]}^{[15]}^{[16]} satisfying

A **Kleene algebra** is a star semiring with idempotent addition and some additional axioms. They are important in the theory of formal languages and regular expressions.^{[11]}

In a **complete star semiring**, the star operator behaves more like the usual Kleene star: for a complete semiring we use the infinitary sum operator to give the usual definition of the Kleene star:^{[11]}

where

Note that star semirings are not related to *-algebra, where the star operation should instead be thought of as complex conjugation.

A **Conway semiring** is a star semiring satisfying the sum-star and product-star equations:^{[9]}^{[17]}

Every complete star semiring is also a Conway semiring,^{[18]} but the converse does not hold. An example of Conway semiring that is not complete is the set of extended non-negative rational numbers with the usual addition and multiplication (this is a modification of the example with extended non-negative reals given in this section by eliminating irrational numbers).^{[11]}
An **iteration semiring** is a Conway semiring satisfying the Conway group axioms,^{[9]} associated by John Conway to groups in star-semirings.^{[19]}

- By definition, any ring and any semifield is also a semiring.
- The non-negative elements of a commutative, discretely ordered ring form a commutative, discretely (in the sense defined above) ordered semiring. This includes the non-negative integers .
- Also the non-negative rational numbers as well as the non-negative real numbers form commutative, ordered semirings.
^{[20]}^{[21]}^{[22]}The latter is called*probability semiring*.^{[6]}Neither are rings or distributive lattices. These examples also have multiplicative inverses. - New semirings can conditionally be constructed from existing ones, as described. The extended natural numbers with addition and multiplication extended so that .
^{[21]} - The set of polynomials with natural number coefficients, denoted forms a commutative semiring. In fact, this is the free commutative semiring on a single generator Also polynomials with coefficients in other semirings may be defined, as discussed.
- The non-negative terminating fractions , in a positional number system to a given base , form a sub-semiring of the rationals. One has if divides . For , the set is the ring of all terminating fractions to base and is dense in .
- The
*log semiring*on with addition given by with multiplication zero element and unit element^{[6]}

Similarly, in the presence of an appropriate order with bottom element,

- Tropical semirings are variously defined. The
*max-plus*semiring is a commutative semiring with serving as semiring addition (identity ) and ordinary addition (identity 0) serving as semiring multiplication. In an alternative formulation, the tropical semiring is and min replaces max as the addition operation.^{[23]}A related version has as the underlying set.^{[6]}^{[10]}They are an active area of research, linking algebraic varieties with piecewise linear structures.^{[24]} - The Łukasiewicz semiring: the closed interval with addition of and given by taking the maximum of the arguments () and multiplication of and given by appears in multi-valued logic.
^{[11]} - The Viterbi semiring is also defined over the base set and has the maximum as its addition, but its multiplication is the usual multiplication of real numbers. It appears in probabilistic parsing.
^{[11]}

Note that . More regarding additively idempotent semirings,

- The set of all ideals of a given semiring form a semiring under addition and multiplication of ideals.
- Any bounded, distributive lattice is a commutative, semiring under join and meet. A Boolean algebra is a special case of these. A Boolean ring is also a semiring (indeed, a ring) but it is not idempotent under
*addition*. A*Boolean semiring*is a semiring isomorphic to a sub-semiring of a Boolean algebra.^{[20]} - The commutative semiring formed by the two-element Boolean algebra and defined by . It is also called
*the Boolean semiring*.^{[6]}^{[21]}^{[22]}^{[9]}Now given two sets and binary relations between and correspond to matrices indexed by and with entries in the Boolean semiring, matrix addition corresponds to union of relations, and matrix multiplication corresponds to composition of relations.^{[25]} - Any unital quantale is a semiring under join and multiplication.
- A normal skew lattice in a ring is a semiring for the operations multiplication and nabla, where the latter operation is defined by

More using monoids,

- The construction of semirings from a commutative monoid has been described. As noted, give a semiring , the matrices form another semiring. For example, the matrices with non-negative entries, form a matrix semiring.
^{[20]} - Given an alphabet (finite set) Σ, the set of formal languages over (subsets of ) is a semiring with product induced by string concatenation and addition as the union of languages (that is, ordinary union as sets). The zero of this semiring is the empty set (empty language) and the semiring's unit is the language containing only the empty string.
^{[11]} - Generalizing the previous example (by viewing as the free monoid over ), take to be any monoid; the power set of all subsets of forms a semiring under set-theoretic union as addition and set-wise multiplication:
^{[22]} - Similarly, if is a monoid, then the set of finite multisets in forms a semiring. That is, an element is a function ; given an element of the function tells you how many times that element occurs in the multiset it represents. The additive unit is the constant zero function. The multiplicative unit is the function mapping to and all other elements of to The sum is given by and the product is given by

Regarding sets and similar abstractions,

- Given a set the set of binary relations over is a semiring with addition the union (of relations as sets) and multiplication the composition of relations. The semiring's zero is the empty relation and its unit is the identity relation.
^{[11]}These relations correspond to the matrix semiring (indeed, matrix semialgebra) of square matrices indexed by with entries in the Boolean semiring, and then addition and multiplication are the usual matrix operations, while zero and the unit are the usual zero matrix and identity matrix. - The set of cardinal numbers smaller than any given infinite cardinal form a semiring under cardinal addition and multiplication. The class of
*all cardinals*of an inner model form a (class) semiring under (inner model) cardinal addition and multiplication. - The family of (isomorphism equivalence classes of) combinatorial classes (sets of countably many objects with non-negative integer sizes such that there are finitely many objects of each size) with the empty class as the zero object, the class consisting only of the empty set as the unit, disjoint union of classes as addition, and Cartesian product of classes as multiplication.
^{[26]} - Isomorphism classes of objects in any distributive category, under coproduct and product operations, form a semiring known as a Burnside rig.
^{[27]}A Burnside rig is a ring if and only if the category is trivial.

Several structures mentioned above can be equipped with a star operation.

- The aforementioned semiring of binary relations over some base set in which for all This star operation is actually the reflexive and transitive closure of (that is, the smallest reflexive and transitive binary relation over containing ).
^{[11]} - The semiring of formal languages is also a complete star semiring, with the star operation coinciding with the Kleene star (for sets/languages).
^{[11]} - The set of non-negative extended reals together with the usual addition and multiplication of reals is a complete star semiring with the star operation given by for (that is, the geometric series) and for
^{[11]} - The Boolean semiring with
^{[b]}^{[11]} - The semiring on with extended addition and multiplication, and for
^{[b]}^{[11]}

The and tropical semirings on the reals are often used in performance evaluation on discrete event systems. The real numbers then are the "costs" or "arrival time"; the "max" operation corresponds to having to wait for all prerequisites of an events (thus taking the maximal time) while the "min" operation corresponds to being able to choose the best, less costly choice; and + corresponds to accumulation along the same path.

The Floyd–Warshall algorithm for shortest paths can thus be reformulated as a computation over a algebra. Similarly, the Viterbi algorithm for finding the most probable state sequence corresponding to an observation sequence in a hidden Markov model can also be formulated as a computation over a algebra on probabilities. These dynamic programming algorithms rely on the distributive property of their associated semirings to compute quantities over a large (possibly exponential) number of terms more efficiently than enumerating each of them.^{[28]}^{[29]}

A generalization of semirings does not require the existence of a multiplicative identity, so that multiplication is a semigroup rather than a monoid. Such structures are called *hemirings*^{[30]} or *pre-semirings*.^{[31]} A further generalization are *left-pre-semirings*,^{[32]} which additionally do not require right-distributivity (or *right-pre-semirings*, which do not require left-distributivity).

Yet a further generalization are *near-semirings*: in addition to not requiring a neutral element for product, or right-distributivity (or left-distributivity), they do not require addition to be commutative. Just as cardinal numbers form a (class) semiring, so do ordinal numbers form a near-semiring, when the standard ordinal addition and multiplication are taken into account. However, the class of ordinals can be turned into a semiring by considering the so-called natural (or Hessenberg) operations instead.

In category theory, a *2-rig* is a category with functorial operations analogous to those of a rig. That the cardinal numbers form a rig can be categorified to say that the category of sets (or more generally, any topos) is a 2-rig.

- Ring of sets – Family closed under unions and relative complements
- Valuation algebra – Algebra describing information processing

**^**For an example see the definition of rig on Proofwiki.org- ^
^{a}^{b}This is a complete star semiring and thus also a Conway semiring.^{[11]}

**^**Głazek (2002), p. 7**^**Kuntzmann, J. (1972).*Théorie des réseaux (graphes)*(in French). Paris: Dunod. Zbl 0239.05101.**^**Semirings for breakfast, slide 17**^**Baccelli, François Louis; Olsder, Geert Jan; Quadrat, Jean-Pierre; Cohen, Guy (1992).*Synchronization and linearity. An algebra for discrete event systems*. Wiley Series on Probability and Mathematical Statistics. Chichester: Wiley. Zbl 0824.93003.**^**Berstel & Perrin (1985), p. 26- ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}^{d}^{e}Lothaire (2005), p. 211 **^**Sakarovitch (2009), pp. 27–28**^**Lothaire (2005), p. 212- ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}^{d}^{e}Ésik, Zoltán (2008). "Iteration semirings". In Ito, Masami (ed.).*Developments in language theory. 12th international conference, DLT 2008, Kyoto, Japan, September 16–19, 2008. Proceedings*. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Vol. 5257. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. pp. 1–20. doi:10.1007/978-3-540-85780-8_1. ISBN 978-3-540-85779-2. Zbl 1161.68598. - ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}Kuich, Werner (2011). "Algebraic systems and pushdown automata". In Kuich, Werner (ed.).*Algebraic foundations in computer science. Essays dedicated to Symeon Bozapalidis on the occasion of his retirement*. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Vol. 7020. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. pp. 228–256. ISBN 978-3-642-24896-2. Zbl 1251.68135. - ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}^{d}^{e}^{f}^{g}^{h}^{i}^{j}^{k}^{l}^{m}^{n}^{o}Droste & Kuich (2009), pp. 7–10 **^**Kuich, Werner (1990). "ω-continuous semirings, algebraic systems and pushdown automata". In Paterson, Michael S. (ed.).*Automata, Languages and Programming: 17th International Colloquium, Warwick University, England, July 16–20, 1990, Proceedings*. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Vol. 443. Springer-Verlag. pp. 103–110. ISBN 3-540-52826-1.- ^
^{a}^{b}Sakarovitch (2009), p. 471 **^**Ésik, Zoltán; Leiß, Hans (2002). "Greibach normal form in algebraically complete semirings". In Bradfield, Julian (ed.).*Computer science logic. 16th international workshop, CSL 2002, 11th annual conference of the EACSL, Edinburgh, Scotland, September 22–25, 2002. Proceedings*. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Vol. 2471. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. pp. 135–150. Zbl 1020.68056.**^**Lehmann, Daniel J. (1977), "Algebraic structures for transitive closure" (PDF),*Theoretical Computer Science*,**4**(1): 59–76, doi:10.1016/0304-3975(77)90056-1**^**Berstel & Reutenauer (2011), p. 27**^**Ésik, Zoltán; Kuich, Werner (2004). "Equational axioms for a theory of automata". In Martín-Vide, Carlos (ed.).*Formal languages and applications*. Studies in Fuzziness and Soft Computing. Vol. 148. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. pp. 183–196. ISBN 3-540-20907-7. Zbl 1088.68117.**^**Droste & Kuich (2009), p. 15, Theorem 3.4**^**Conway, J.H. (1971).*Regular algebra and finite machines*. London: Chapman and Hall. ISBN 0-412-10620-5. Zbl 0231.94041.- ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}Guterman, Alexander E. (2008). "Rank and determinant functions for matrices over semirings". In Young, Nicholas; Choi, Yemon (eds.).*Surveys in Contemporary Mathematics*. London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series. Vol. 347. Cambridge University Press. pp. 1–33. ISBN 978-0-521-70564-6. ISSN 0076-0552. Zbl 1181.16042. - ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}Sakarovitch (2009), p. 28. - ^
^{a}^{b}^{c}Berstel & Reutenauer (2011), p. 4 **^**Speyer, David; Sturmfels, Bernd (2009) [2004]. "Tropical Mathematics".*Math. Mag*.**82**(3): 163–173. arXiv:math/0408099. doi:10.4169/193009809x468760. S2CID 119142649. Zbl 1227.14051.**^**Speyer, David; Sturmfels, Bernd (2009). "Tropical Mathematics".*Mathematics Magazine*.**82**(3): 163–173. doi:10.1080/0025570X.2009.11953615. ISSN 0025-570X. S2CID 15278805.**^**John C. Baez (6 Nov 2001). "quantum mechanics over a commutative rig". Newsgroup: sci.physics.research. Usenet: 9s87n0$iv5@gap.cco.caltech.edu. Retrieved November 25, 2018.**^**Bard, Gregory V. (2009),*Algebraic Cryptanalysis*, Springer, Section 4.2.1, "Combinatorial Classes", ff., pp. 30–34, ISBN 9780387887579**^**Schanuel S.H. (1991) Negative sets have Euler characteristic and dimension. In: Carboni A., Pedicchio M.C., Rosolini G. (eds) Category Theory. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol 1488. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg**^**Pair (1967), p. 271.**^**Derniame & Pair (1971)**^**Golan (1999), p. 1, Ch 1**^**Gondran & Minoux (2008), p. 22, Ch 1, §4.2.**^**Gondran & Minoux (2008), p. 20, Ch 1, §4.1.

- Derniame, Jean Claude; Pair, Claude (1971),
*Problèmes de cheminement dans les graphes (Path Problems in Graphs)*, Paris: Dunod - Baccelli, François; Cohen, Guy; Olsder, Geert Jan; Quadrat, Jean-Pierre (1992),
*Synchronization and Linearity (online version)*, Wiley, ISBN 0-471-93609-X - Golan, Jonathan S. (1999)
*Semirings and their applications*. Updated and expanded version of*The theory of semirings, with applications to mathematics and theoretical computer science*(Longman Sci. Tech., Harlow, 1992, MR1163371). Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht. xii+381 pp. ISBN 0-7923-5786-8 MR1746739 - Berstel, Jean; Perrin, Dominique (1985).
*Theory of codes*. Pure and applied mathematics. Vol. 117. Academic Press. ISBN 978-0-12-093420-1. Zbl 0587.68066. - Berstel, Jean; Reutenauer, Christophe (2011).
*Noncommutative rational series with applications*. Encyclopedia of Mathematics and Its Applications. Vol. 137. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-19022-0. Zbl 1250.68007. - Droste, Manfred; Kuich, Werner (2009), "Chapter 1: Semirings and Formal Power Series",
*Handbook of Weighted Automata*, pp. 3–28, doi:10.1007/978-3-642-01492-5_1 - Durrett, Richard (2019).
*Probability: Theory and Examples*(PDF). Cambridge Series in Statistical and Probabilistic Mathematics. Vol. 49 (5th ed.). Cambridge New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-47368-2. OCLC 1100115281. Retrieved November 5, 2020. - Folland, Gerald B. (1999),
*Real Analysis: Modern Techniques and Their Applications*(2nd ed.), John Wiley & Sons, ISBN 9780471317166 - Golan, Jonathan S. (1999),
*Semirings and their Applications*, Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, doi:10.1007/978-94-015-9333-5, ISBN 0-7923-5786-8, MR 1746739 - Lothaire, M. (2005).
*Applied combinatorics on words*. Encyclopedia of Mathematics and Its Applications. Vol. 105. A collective work by Jean Berstel, Dominique Perrin, Maxime Crochemore, Eric Laporte, Mehryar Mohri, Nadia Pisanti, Marie-France Sagot, Gesine Reinert, Sophie Schbath, Michael Waterman, Philippe Jacquet, Wojciech Szpankowski, Dominique Poulalhon, Gilles Schaeffer, Roman Kolpakov, Gregory Koucherov, Jean-Paul Allouche and Valérie Berthé. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-84802-4. Zbl 1133.68067. - Głazek, Kazimierz (2002).
*A guide to the literature on semirings and their applications in mathematics and information sciences. With complete bibliography*. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic. ISBN 1-4020-0717-5. Zbl 1072.16040. - Gondran, Michel; Minoux, Michel (2008).
*Graphs, Dioids and Semirings: New Models and Algorithms*. Operations Research/Computer Science Interfaces Series. Vol. 41. Dordrecht: Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-0-387-75450-5. Zbl 1201.16038. - Pair, Claude (1967), "Sur des algorithmes pour des problèmes de cheminement dans les graphes finis (On algorithms for path problems in finite graphs)", in Rosentiehl (ed.),
*Théorie des graphes (journées internationales d'études) – Theory of Graphs (international symposium)*, Rome (Italy), July 1966: Dunod (Paris) et Gordon and Breach (New York)`((citation))`

: CS1 maint: location (link) - Sakarovitch, Jacques (2009).
*Elements of automata theory*. Translated from the French by Reuben Thomas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-84425-3. Zbl 1188.68177.

- Golan, Jonathan S. (2003).
*Semirings and Affine Equations over Them*. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-1-4020-1358-4. Zbl 1042.16038. - Grillet, Mireille P. (1970). "Green's relations in a semiring".
*Port. Math*.**29**: 181–195. Zbl 0227.16029. - Gunawardena, Jeremy (1998). "An introduction to idempotency". In Gunawardena, Jeremy (ed.).
*Idempotency. Based on a workshop, Bristol, UK, October 3–7, 1994*(PDF). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 1–49. Zbl 0898.16032. - Jipsen, P. (2004). "From semirings to residuated Kleene lattices".
*Studia Logica*.**76**(2): 291–303. doi:10.1023/B:STUD.0000032089.54776.63. S2CID 9946523. Zbl 1045.03049. - Dolan, Steven (2013), "Fun with Semirings" (PDF),
*Proceedings of the 18th ACM SIGPLAN international conference on Functional programming*, pp. 101–110, doi:10.1145/2500365.2500613, ISBN 9781450323260, S2CID 2436826