Saint Francis of Assisi, founder of the mendicant Order of Friars Minor, as painted by El Greco.
Saint Francis of Assisi, founder of the mendicant Order of Friars Minor, as painted by El Greco.

In the Catholic Church, a religious order is a community of consecrated life with members that profess solemn vows. They are classed as a type of religious institute.[1]

Subcategories of religious orders are:

Original Catholic religious orders of the Middle Ages include the Order of Saint Benedict. In particular the earliest orders include the English Benedictine Congregation (1216) and Benedictine communities connected to Cluny Abbey, the Benedictine reform movement of Cistercians, and the Norbertine Order of Premonstratensians (1221). These orders were confederations of independent abbeys and priories, who were unified through a leadership structure connected to permanent establishments.

A century later, mendicant groups like the Carmelites, the Order of Friars Minor, the Dominican Order, the Order of the Most Holy Trinity and the Order of Saint Augustine formed their Orders. As such, also the Teutonic Order may qualify, as today it is mainly monastic. These Mendicant Orders did not hold property for their Religious Communities, instead begging for alms and going where they were needed. Their leadership structure included each member, as opposed to each Abbey or House, as subject to their direct superior.

In the past, what distinguished religious orders from other institutes was the classification of the vows that the members took in religious profession as solemn vows. According to this criterion, the last religious order founded was that of the Bethlehem Brothers in 1673.[2] Nevertheless, in the course of the 20th century, some religious institutes outside the category of orders obtained permission to make solemn vows, at least of poverty, thus blurring the distinction.[citation needed]

Essential distinguishing mark

Solemn vows were originally considered indissoluble. As noted below, dispensations began to be granted in later times, but originally not even the Pope could dispense from them.[3] If for a just cause a member of a religious order was expelled, the vow of chastity remained unchanged and so rendered invalid any attempt at marriage, the vow of obedience obliged in relation, generally, to the bishop rather than to the religious superior, and the vow of poverty was modified to meet the new situation but the expelled religious "could not, for example, will any goods to another; and goods which came to him reverted at his death to his institute or to the Holy See".[4]

Weakening of the distinction in 1917

The former 1917 Code of Canon Law reserved the name "religious order" for institutes in which the vows were solemn, and used the term religious congregation or simply "congregation" for institutes with simple vows. The members of a religious order for men were called "regulars", those belonging to a religious congregation were simply "religious", a term that applied also to regulars. For women, those with simple vows were called "sisters", with the term "nun" reserved in canon law for those who belonged to an institute of solemn vows, even if in some localities they were allowed to take simple vows instead.[5]

The Hieronymite monks.
The Hieronymite monks.

However, it abolished the distinction according to which solemn vows, unlike simple vows, were indissoluble. It recognized no totally indispensable religious vows and thereby abrogated for the Latin Church the special consecration that distinguished "orders" from "congregations", while keeping some juridical distinctions.[4]

In practice, even before 1917 dispensations from solemn religious vows were being obtained by grant of the Pope himself, while departments of the Holy See and superiors specially delegated by it could dispense from simple religious vows.[6]

The 1917 Code maintained a juridical distinction by declaring invalid any marriage attempted by solemnly professed religious or by those with simple vows to which the Holy See had attached the effect of invalidating marriage,[7] while stating that no simple vow rendered a marriage invalid, except in the cases in which the Holy See directed otherwise.[8] Thus members of "orders" were barred absolutely from marriage, and any marriage they attempted was invalid. Those who made simple vows were obliged not to marry, but if they did break their vow, the marriage was considered valid.

Another difference was that a professed religious of solemn vows lost the right to own property and the capacity to acquire temporal goods for himself or herself, but a professed religious of simple vows, while being prohibited by the vow of poverty from using and administering property, kept ownership and the right to acquire more, unless the constitutions of the religious institute explicitly stated the contrary.[9]

After publication of the 1917 Code, many institutes with simple vows appealed to the Holy See for permission to make solemn vows. The Apostolic Constitution Sponsa Christi of 21 November 1950 made access to that permission easier for nuns (in the strict sense), though not for religious institutes dedicated to apostolic activity. Many of these latter institutes of women then petitioned for the solemn vow of poverty alone. Towards the end of the Second Vatican Council, superiors general of clerical institutes and abbots president of monastic congregations were authorized to permit, for a just cause, their subjects of simple vows who made a reasonable request to renounce their property except for what would be required for their sustenance if they were to depart.[10] These changes resulted in a further blurring of the previously clear distinction between "orders" and "congregations", since institutes that were founded as "congregations" began to have some members who had all three solemn vows or had members that took a solemn vow of poverty and simple vows of chastity and obedience.

Further changes in 1983

The current 1983 Code of Canon Law maintains the distinction between solemn and simple vows,[11] but no longer makes any distinction between their juridical effects, including the distinction between "orders" and "congregations". Instead, it uses the single term "religious institute" to designate all such institutes.[12][13]

While solemn vows once meant those taken in what was called a religious order, "today, in order to know when a vow is solemn it will be necessary to refer to the proper law of the institutes of consecrated life."[14]

The Annuario Pontificio continues to distinguish between "Ordini" (Orders) and "Congregazioni Religiose Clericali" (Clerical Religious Congregations). Some other authors use the terms "religious order" and "religious institute" as synonyms; canon lawyer Nicholas Cafardi, commenting on the fact that the canonical term is "religious institute", write that "religious order" is a colloquialism.[15]

Authority structure

Thomas Schoen 1903, OCist.
Thomas Schoen 1903, OCist.

A religious order is characterized by an authority structure where a superior general has jurisdiction over the order's dependent communities. An exception is the Order of St Benedict which is not a religious order in this technical sense, because it has a system of "independent houses", meaning that each abbey is autonomous. However, the Constitutions governing the order's global "independent houses" and its distinct "congregations" (of which there are twenty) were approved by the pope. Likewise, according to rank and authority, the abbot primate's "position with regard to the other abbots [throughout the world] is to be understood rather from the analogy of a primate in a hierarchy than from that of the general of an order like the Dominicans and Jesuits."[16]

The Canons Regular of Saint Augustine are in a situation similar to that of the Benedictines. They are organized in eight "congregations", each headed by an "abbot general", but also have an "Abbot Primate of the Confederated Canons Regular of Saint Augustine". And the Cistercians are in thirteen "congregations", each headed by an "abbot general" or an "abbot president", but do not use the title of "abbot primate".

List of religious orders of men in the Annuario Pontificio

Religious orders in the Annuario Pontificio
Religious orders in the Annuario Pontificio
Saint Bruno of Cologne, founder of the monastic Order of Carthusians, as painted by Nicolas Mignard.
Saint Bruno of Cologne, founder of the monastic Order of Carthusians, as painted by Nicolas Mignard.
A genealogical tree of the Order of the Immaculate Conception with the foundress, Saint Beatrice of Silva, and other remarkable Conceptionist nuns.
A genealogical tree of the Order of the Immaculate Conception with the foundress, Saint Beatrice of Silva, and other remarkable Conceptionist nuns.
Maria Vittoria De Fornari Strata was the foundress of the Order of the Most Holy Annunciation.

The Annuario Pontificio presents the list of male religious institutes in an "Elenco Storio-Giuridico di Precedenza" (Historical-Juridical List of Precedence). This list gives priority to certain types of institutes: Orders (divided into Canons Regular, Monastics, Mendicant Orders, Clerics Regular), Clerical Religious Congregations, Lay Religious Congregations, Eastern Religious Congregations, Secular Institutes, Societies of Apostolic Life.[17] The list is found in the 1964 edition of the Annuario Pontificio, pp. 807–870, where the heading is "States of Perfection (of pontifical right for men)". In the 1969 edition the heading is "Religious and Secular institutes of Pontifical Right for Men", a form it kept until 1975. Since 1976, when work was already advanced on revising the Code of Canon Law, the list has been qualified as "historical-juridical".

Historical-Juridical List of Precedence[18]
Canons Regular
Name Abbreviation Founded Members Priest members
Augustinian Canons (Canons Regular) C.R.S.A. 4th century 561 470
Norbertines (Premonstratensians) O. Praem. 1120 1127 853
Canons Regular of the Holy Cross of Coimbra O.R.C. 1131 141 83
Teutonic Order O.T. 1190 79 62
Canons Regular of the Order of the Holy Cross (Crosier Fathers and Brothers) O.S.C. 1211 347 227
Knights of the Cross with the Red Star O.Cr. 1237 18 18
Canons Regular of the Mother of God C.R.M.D. 1969 37 21
Monastic Orders
Name Abbreviation Founded Members Priest members
Benedictines O.S.B. 6th century 6667 3297
Camaldolese E.C.M.C. 1025 66 38
Cistercians O.Cist. 1098 1600 657
Trappists O.C.S.O. 1098 1608 590
Carthusians O.Cart. 1084 275 142
Order of Saint Paul the First Hermit (Pauline Fathers) O.S.P.P.E. 1215 493 366
Hieronymites O.S.H. 14th century 6 4
Mendicant Orders
Name Abbreviation Founded Members Priest members
Dominicans O.P. 13th century 5545 4147
Franciscans (Friars Minor) O.F.M. 1209 12476 8512
Conventual Franciscans O.F.M. Conv. 1209 3981 2777
Capuchins O.F.M. Cap. 1525 10355 6796
Third Order Regular of St. Francis of Penance T.O.R. 1221 813 581
Augustinians O.S.A. 4th century 2500 1826
Augustinian Recollects O.A.R. 1588 955 815
Discalced Augustinians O.A.D. 1592 227 144
Carmelites O. Carm. 2041 1303
Discalced Carmelites O.C.D. 1562 3978 2897
Trinitarians O.SS.T. 1198 612 426
Mercedarians O. de M. 1218 649 483
Discalced Mercedarians O.M.D. 1603 34 29
Servites O.S.M. 1233 786 522
Minims O.M. 1435 161 118
Brothers Hospitallers of Saint John of God O.H. 1537 995 115
Bethlehemite Brothers O.F.B. 1653 13 1
Clerics Regular
Name Abbreviation Founded Members Priest members
Theatines (Clerics Regular) C.R. 1524 161 124
Barnabites B. 1530 335 279
Jesuits S.J. 1540 14839 10721
Somascans C.R.S. 1534 520 327
Camillians M.I. 1582 1125 825
Clerics Regular Minor (Caracciolins) C.R.M. 1588 180 106
Clerics Regular of the Mother of God O.M.D. 1574 115 87
Piarists Sch. P. 1617 1356 945

Religious orders of women in the Annuario Pontificio

The list of religious institutes for women in the Annuario Pontificio does not distinguish between orders (with solemn vows) and congregations (with simple vows). Many of the religious orders for men listed above have comparable religious institutes for women with solemn vows.

See also

References

  1. ^ Ryan, George (2018-01-09). "What Is a Religious Order? The Major Catholic Religious Orders Easily Explained". uCatholic.
  2. ^ Álvarez Gómez, C.M.F., Jesús (1996). Historia de la vida religiosa (in Spanish). Vol. III. Madrid: Publicaciones Claretianas. ISBN 978-8479662417.
  3. ^ Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, II–II, q. 88, a.11
  4. ^ a b Paul M. Quay, "Renewal of Religious Orders, or Destruction?", in Commentarium pro Religiosis et Missionariis, vol. 65 (1984), pp. 77–86
  5. ^ 1917 Code of Canon Law, canon 488
  6. ^ William Edward Addis, Thomas Arnold, A Catholic Dictionary Containing Some Account of the Doctrine, Discipline, Rites, Ceremonies, Councils and Religious Orders of the Catholic Church, Part Two, p. 858 (reprinted by Kessinger Publishing 2004)
  7. ^ 1917 Code of Canon Law, canon 1073
  8. ^ 1917 Code of Canon Law, canon 1058
  9. ^ 1917 Code of Canon Law, canons 580–582
  10. ^ Yūji Sugawara, Religious Poverty: from Vatican Council II to the 1994 Synod of Bishops (Loyola Press 1997 ISBN 978-88-7652-698-5), pp. 127–128
  11. ^ Code of Canon Law, canon 1192 §2
  12. ^ Robert T. Kennedy, Study related to a pre-1983 book by John J. McGrath – Jurist, 1990, pp. 351–401
  13. ^ Code of Canon Law, canons 607–709
  14. ^ E. Caparros, M. Thériault, J. Thorne (editors), Code of Canon Law Annotated (Wilson & Lafleur, Montréal 1993 ISBN 2-89127-232-3), p. 745
  15. ^ Article published in Theological Exploration, vol. 2. no. 1 of Duquesne University and in Law Review of University of Toledo, vol 33
  16. ^ See "The Benedictine Order" in New Advent, Catholic Encyclopedia
  17. ^ Annuario pontificio per l'anno 2022. Citta del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana. ISBN 97888626606897. ((cite book)): Check |isbn= value: length (help)
  18. ^ Abbreviations, dates, and membership numbers from Annuario pontificio per l'anno 2022. Citta del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana. ISBN 97888626606897. ((cite book)): Check |isbn= value: length (help)

Official websites

Acronyms and denominations

Lists