.mw-parser-output .hidden-begin{box-sizing:border-box;width:100%;padding:5px;border:none;font-size:95%}.mw-parser-output .hidden-title{font-weight:bold;line-height:1.6;text-align:left}.mw-parser-output .hidden-content{text-align:left}@media all and (max-width:500px){.mw-parser-output .hidden-begin{width:auto!important;clear:none!important;float:none!important))You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Russian. (March 2022) Click [show] for important translation instructions. View a machine-translated version of the Russian article. Machine translation, like DeepL or Google Translate, is a useful starting point for translations, but translators must revise errors as necessary and confirm that the translation is accurate, rather than simply copy-pasting machine-translated text into the English Wikipedia. Consider adding a topic to this template: there are already 1,176 articles in the main category, and specifying|topic= will aid in categorization. Do not translate text that appears unreliable or low-quality. If possible, verify the text with references provided in the foreign-language article. You must provide copyright attribution in the edit summary accompanying your translation by providing an interlanguage link to the source of your translation. A model attribution edit summary is Content in this edit is translated from the existing Russian Wikipedia article at [[:ru:Русский национализм]]; see its history for attribution. You should also add the template ((Translated|ru|Русский национализм)) to the talk page. For more guidance, see Wikipedia:Translation.

The flag of Russia.
The Millennium of Russia monument built in 1862 that celebrated one-thousand years of Russian history.

Russian nationalism (Russian: Русский национализм) is a form of nationalism that promotes Russian cultural identity and unity. Russian nationalism first rose to prominence as a Pan-Slavic enterprise during the 19th century Russian Empire, and was repressed during the early Bolshevik rule. Russian nationalism was briefly revived through the policies of Joseph Stalin during and after the Second World War, which shared many resemblances with the worldview of early Eurasianist ideologues.[1]

Following the collapse of Soviet Union, Russian nationalism has been associated with Eurasianism, re-invigorated through the Eurasia Movement of Russian philosopher Aleksandr Dugin. Neo-Eurasian socio-political programme has gained widespread acceptance in Putinist Russia; with Dugin's books, treatises and lectures being advocated through universities, schools, military institutes, police academies and other governmental organizations as part of Putin government's embrace of authoritarianism and condemnation of liberal democracy.[2][3]

The definition of Russian national identity within Russian nationalism has been characterized in different ways. In ethnic terms one including asserting that those identified as ethnic Russians are the Russian nation, another is the All-Russian nation concept developed in the Russian Empire that views Russians as having three sub-national groups within it including Great Russians (those commonly identified as ethnic Russians today), Little Russians (Ukrainians), and White Russians (Belarusians). Russian nationalists have identified Russia as the main successor of the Kievan Rus' and typically view the arising of separate national identities of Belarusians and Ukrainians as having broken away from Russian national identity. In the Eurasianist perspective, Russia is distinctive civilization separate from both Europe and Asia, and includes ethnic non-Russians of Turkic and Asiatic cultures.


Further information: Pan-Slavism, Slavophilia, Russification, and Great Russian chauvinism

Imperial Russian nationalism

Allegory of triune All-Russian nation that views the Russian nation as having three sub-nations within it: Great Russians (those commonly identified as ethnic Russians today), Little Russians (Ukrainians), and White Russians (Belarusians) from an early 20th century poster.

The Russian motto "Orthodoxy, Autocracy, and Nationality" was coined by Count Sergey Uvarov and it was adopted as the official ideology by Emperor Nicholas I.[4] Three components of Uvarov's triad were:

The Slavophile movement became popular in 19th-century Russia. Slavophiles opposed the presence of Western European influences in Russia and as a result, they were determined to protect Russian culture and traditions. Aleksey Khomyakov, Ivan Kireyevsky, and Konstantin Aksakov are credited with co-founding the movement.[improper synthesis?]

Russian World War I era poster calling to buy war bonds.

A notable folk revival in Russian art was loosely related to Slavophilia.[6] Many works concerning Russian history, mythology and fairy tales appeared. Operas by Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov, Mikhail Glinka and Alexander Borodin; paintings by Viktor Vasnetsov, Ivan Bilibin and Ilya Repin; and poems by Nikolay Nekrasov, Aleksey Konstantinovich Tolstoy, among others, are considered[by whom?] masterpieces of Russian romantic nationalism.

Pan-Slavism, an ideal of unity of all Slavic Orthodox Christian nations, gained popularity in the mid- to late 19th century. One of its major ideologists was Nikolay Danilevsky. Pan-Slavism was fueled by and it was also the fuel for Russia's numerous wars against the Ottoman Empire, which Russia waged with the goal of liberating Orthodox nationalities, such as the Bulgarians, the Romanians, the Serbs and the Greeks, from Muslim rule. The final goal was Constantinople; the Russian Empire still considered itself the "Third Rome" and it believed that its duty required it to succeed the "Second Rome", which was conquered by the Ottoman Empire.[7] Pan-Slavism also played a key role in Russia's entry into World War I, since the 1914 war against Serbia by Austria-Hungary triggered Russia's response.[citation needed]

Early 20th century ultra-nationalism

In the beginning of 20th century, new nationalist and rightist organizations and parties emerged in Russia, such as the Russian Assembly, the Union of the Russian People, the Union of Archangel Michael ("Black Hundreds") and others.

Nationalism during the Soviet era

Further information: Soviet patriotism and Sovietization

Bolshevik propaganda poster from the Russian Civil War with an allusion of Saint George and the Dragon with Red Army leader Leon Trotsky as being a Saint George figure who was slaying the dragon which represented counter-revolution. The symbol of Saint George slaying the dragon was and still is a Russian national symbol.
White Russian anti-Soviet poster, c. 1932, depicting the female personification of Russia known as Mother Russia.

Under the outlook of international communism that was especially strong at the time, Vladimir Lenin separated patriotism into what he defined as proletarian, socialist patriotism from bourgeois nationalism.[8] Lenin promoted the right of all nations to self-determination and the right to unity of all workers within nations, but he also condemned chauvinism and claimed there were both justified and unjustified feelings of national pride.[9] Lenin explicitly denounced conventional Russian nationalism as "Great Russian chauvinism", and his government sought to accommodate the country's multiple ethnic groups by creating republics and sub-republic units to provide non-Russian ethnic groups with autonomy and protection from Russian domination.[10] Lenin also sought to balance the ethnic representation of leadership of the country by promoting non-Russian officials in the Communist Party of the Soviet Union to counter the large presence of Russians in the Party.[10] However, even during this early period of Soviet history, the Soviet government appealed to Russian nationalism when it needed support - especially on the Soviet borderlands in the Soviet Union's early years.[10]

Since Russian patriotism served as a legitimizing prop of old order, Bolshevik leaders were anxious to suppress its manifestations and ensure its eventual extinction. They officially discouraged Russian nationalism and remnants of Imperial patriotism, such as the wearing of military awards received before the Civil War. Some of their followers disagreed; in non-Russian territories, Bolshevik power was often regarded as renewed Russian imperialism during 1919 to 1921. In 1922, the Soviet Union was formed with its members combined, but Russia was the largest and most populous member. After 1923, following Lenin's ideas, a policy of korenizatsiya, which provided government support for non-Russian culture and languages within the non-Russian republics, was adopted.[11] However, this policy was not strictly enforced due to domination of Russians in Soviet Union.[12][13]: 394[14]: 24 This domination had been formally criticized in the tsarist empire by Lenin and others as Great Russian chauvinism.[15][13]: 8 Thomas Winderl wrote "The USSR became in a certain sense more a prison-house of nations than the old Empire had ever been. [...] The Russian-dominated center established an inequitable relationship with the ethnic groups it voluntarily helped to construct."[15] Various scholars focused on the nationalist features that already existed during the Leninist period.[15]: 43: 48[16][14]: 24 Korenizatsiya's multinational construction weakened during Stalin's rule. Stalin's policies established a clear shift to Russian nationalism, starting from the idea that Russians were "first among equals" in the Soviet Union, escalating through the "nationalities deportations".[13]: 453[17] According to scholar Jon K. Chang, the Bolsheviks "never made a clean break from Tsarist-era nationalist, populist and primordialist beliefs".[17]: 7  Russian historian Andrei Savin stated that Stalin's policy shifted away from internationalism towards National Bolshevism in the 1930s. In a marked change from elimination of the class enemies, the nationality-based repressions declared entire ethnicities counter-revolutionary enemies, although "class dogmas" declaring targeted nationalities to be ideologically opposed to the Soviets were usually added.[18]

Stalin reversed much of his predecessor's previous internationalist policies, signing orders for the exiling multiple distinct ethnic-linguistic groups which were branded as "traitors", including the Balkars, Crimean Tatars, Chechens, Ingush (see Deportation of the Chechens and Ingush), Karachays, Kalmyks, Koreans, and Meskhetian Turks, who were collectively deported to Siberia or Central Asia, where they were legally designated as "special settlers", which officially meant that they were second-class citizens with few rights and they were also confined within a small perimeter.[19][page needed][17] Various historians see Stalin's deportations of minority and diaspora nationalities as evidence of the Russian nationalism of the Soviet state under Stalin.[19][page needed][13][page needed][20]: 143  Chang wrote that the Soviet deportations of Koreans (and other diaspora, deported peoples such as Germans, Finns, Greeks and many others) illustrated the fact that in whole, essentialized views of race, that is, primordialism was carried over from the Russian nationalism of the Tsarist era. These Soviet tropes and biases produced and converted the Koreans (and the Chinese) into a decidedly, un-Marxist Soviet "yellow peril". The existence of racism lay in the fact that others could occasionally be seen or judged in accordance with a class line or they could be seen or judged on an individual basis but the Koreans could not.[17]: 32–34  Norman M. Naimark believed that the Stalinist "nationalities deportations" were forms of national-cultural genocide. The deportations at the very least changed the cultures, way of life and world views of the deported peoples as the majority were sent to Soviet Central Asia and Siberia.[21] According to historian Jeremy Smith, "As long as Stalin was alive... nationality policy was subject to arbitrary swings. The most disturbing feature of this period was the growth of official Anti-Semitism" including the campaign against "rootless cosmopolitans". Smith observed that "Speeches and newspaper articles raised the spectre of an international Jewish conspiracy to overthrow Soviet power" leading to the purges of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee and the Doctors' plot which was associated with the persecution of Jewish Moscow doctors in planned show trials. If Stalin had not died when he did, the alleged Doctors' plot would have led to the deportation of Jews to Siberia. Meanwhile, the defense of the country during World War II had led to the emergence of a new wave of national pride in the non-Russian republics which led to purges in those republics.[20]: 143–145 

According to Evgeny Dobrenko, "Late Stalinism" after World War II was the transformation of Soviet society away from Marxism to demonize the idea of cosmopolitanism. He argued that Soviet actions up to 1945 could still in some way be explained by Leninist internationalism, but that the Soviet Union was turned into a Russian nationalist entity during the postwar years. Through a widespread study of Soviet literature, he found a vast increase in nationalist themes, cultural puritanism, and paranoia in publications during this eight year period making "Stalinism the heart of Sovietness" well after Stalin's death.[22]: 9–14[23] Historian David Brandenberger contrasts russocentrism characteristic of this era with Russian nationalism. In his view, ethnic pride and promoted sense of Russian national identity didn't cross the threshold of nationalism as "the party hierarchy never endorsed the idea of Russian self-determination or separatism and vigorously suppressed all those who did, consciously drawing a line between the positive phenomenon of national identity formation and the malignancy of full-blown nationalist ambitions." To define the "pragmatic" combination of Russian national identity promotion in Marxist–Leninist propaganda and "symbolically abandoned" earlier proletarian internationalism, Brandenberger describes Stalin's regime with the term "National Bolshevism".[24]: 2, 6 

The creation of an international communist state under control of the workers was perceived by some as accomplishment of Russian nationalistic dreams.[25] Poet Pavel Kogan described his feelings of the Soviet patriotism just before World War II:[26]

I am a patriot. I love Russian air and Russian soil.
But we will reach the Ganges River,
and we will die in fights,
to make our Motherland shine
from Japan to England

According to Nikolai Berdyaev:

The Russian people did not achieve their ancient dream of Moscow, the Third Rome. The ecclesiastical schism of the 17th century revealed that the Muscovite tsardom is not the Third Rome... The messianic idea of the Russian people assumed either an apocalyptic form or a revolutionary; and then there occurred an amazing event in the destiny of the Russian people. Instead of the Third Rome in Russia, the Third International was achieved, and many of the features of the Third Rome pass over to the Third International. The Third International is also a holy empire, and it also is founded on an orthodox faith. The Third International is not international, but a Russian national idea.[27]

In 1944, the Soviet Union abandoned its communist anthem The Internationale and adopted a new national anthem conveying a Russian-centered national pride in its first stanza, "An unbreakable union of free republics, Great Russia has sealed forever."[28][29]

Although Khrushchev had risen up during Stalinism, his speech On the Cult of Personality and Its Consequences and de-Stalinization signified a retreat from official anti-Semitism and Great Russian Chauvinism. Most, though not all nationalities deported by Stalin were allowed to return during Khrushchev, and the Soviet Union to a degree, resumed a policy of cultivating local national developments.[14]: 46 Among the nationalities not allowed to return were Koreans[19] and Crimean Tatars.[20]: 162  The Kremlin during Khrushchev, generally favoring Russification overall, would attempt several variations of nationalities policy, favoring korenizatsiya (indigenization) in Central Asia without extending privileges to Russians. In Latvia however, regional communist elites tried to reinstate local korenizatsiya 1957-1959, but Khrushchev cracked down on these efforts, exiling Eduards Berklavs, and extended privileges to Russians in Latvia.[30] Nonetheless, during Khrushchev's relatively more tolerant administration, Russian nationalism emerged as a slightly oppositional phenomenon within the Soviet elites. Alexander Shelepin, a Communist Party hardliner and KGB chairman, called for a return to Stalinism and policies more in line with Russian cultural nationalism, as did conservative writers like Sergey Vikulov. The Komsomol leadership also hosted several prominent nationalists such as Sergei Pavlovich Pavlov, an ally of Shelepin, while the Molodaya Gvardiya published numerous neo-Stalinist and nationalist works.[14]: 52–53 

After the dissolution of the Soviet Union

The first "State flag" of the Russian Empire (1858–1896) is used by some Russian nationalists and monarchists.
A march of about 7,000 people waving nationalist flags, chanting anti-immigrant slogans and carrying a big banner that reads "Let's return Russia to the Russians" (Вернём Россию русским) in Moscow, 4 November 2011.

Many nationalist movements, both radical and moderate, have arisen after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. One of the oldest and most popular is Vladimir Zhirinovsky's right-wing populist Liberal Democratic Party of the Soviet Union and then Liberal Democratic Party of Russia, which had been a member of the State Duma since its creation in 1993. Rodina was a popular left-wing nationalist party under Dmitry Rogozin, which eventually abandoned its nationalist ideology and merged with the larger Russian socialist nationalist party A Just Russia.[citation needed]

One of the more radical, ultranationalist movements was Russian National Unity, a far-right group that organised paramilitary brigades of its younger members before it was banned in 1999.[31][32] Before its breakup in late 2000 the Russian National Unity was estimated to have had approximately 20,000 to 25,000 members.[33] Others include BORN (Militant Organization of Russian Nationalists) which was involved in the murder of Stanislav Markelov,[34] the neo-monarchist Pamyat, the Union of Orthodox Banner-Bearers, and the Movement Against Illegal Immigration, which revived the slogan "Russia for Russians." These parties organised an annual rally called the Russian March.[citation needed]

Extremist nationalism

Extremist nationalism in Russia is used in reference to many far-right and a few far-left ultra-nationalist movements and organizations. In Russia, the term nationalism is frequently used in reference to extremist nationalism. However, it is frequently mixed up with "fascism" in Russia. While the meaning of this terminology does not exactly match the formal definitions of fascism, the common denominator is chauvinism. In all other respects, the positions vary over a wide spectrum. Some movements hold a political position in which they believe that the state must be an instrument of nationalism (such as the National Bolshevik Party, headed by Eduard Limonov), while others (for example, Russian National Unity) promote the use of vigilantist tactics against the perceived "enemies of Russia" without participating in politics.[citation needed]

Anti-Soviet Russian Fascist Party, inspired by Italian fascism, in the first half of the 20th century. The slogan "Let's get our homeland!" is also used by the modern far-right in Russia.

Historically, the first prototypes of such groups were the Black Hundreds in Imperial Russia, the Russian Fascist Organization and the Russian Fascist Party (two organizations which were based in Manchukuo). More recent antisemitic, white supremacist neo-fascist and neo-Nazi organizations include the Russian National Socialist Party.[citation needed]

In 1997, the Moscow Anti-Fascist Center estimated that 40 (nationalist) extremist groups were operating in Russia.[35] The same source reported 35 extremist newspapers, the largest among these being Zavtra. In spite of repression by governmental authorities, a far-right extremist movement has established itself in Russia.[36]

Neopaganism and the Aryan myth

Main article: Slavic Native Faith

Since the fall of the Soviet Union, the Aryan myth has gained publicity in Russia. Numerous series of collections of works by popularizers of the Aryan idea are published (Secrets of the Russian Land, The True History of the Russian People, etc.). They are available in Russian bookstores and municipal and university libraries. These works are not marginal: they have a circulation of tens of thousands of copies (or millions, for example, for books by Alexander Asov), their content is involved in the formation of the worldview basis of a stratum of the population regarding ancient history.

Authors who develop the Aryan theme are often employees of new amateur academies and geopolitical institutions. Only a small number of them have a history degree. Most of them were educated in the field of technology and exact sciences.[37]

The "Aryan" idea in the version of Slavic neo-paganism (the origin of the Slavs from the "Aryans" from Hyperborea or Central Asia, also called the "race of white gods"; the connection of the Slavs with India; ancient pre-Christian Slavic "runic" books; origin from the "Slavic-Aryans" of the ancient civilizations; the neo-pagan symbol "Kolovrat" as an ancient Slavic symbol; a variant of the alien origin of the "Aryan-Hyperboreans") was popularized in the "documentary" programs of the REN TV television network, including broadcasts by Igor Prokopenko and Oleg Shishkin.[38]

In a number of areas of Russian nationalism, the "Aryan" idea is used to justify the right to the territory of modern Russia or the former Soviet Union, which is declared to be the habitat of the ancient "Slavo-Aryans". In a number of post-Soviet countries, "Aryanism" is cultivated by neo-pagan movements that are not satisfied with the real history of their peoples. The pre-Christian past is idealized, allowing one to present one's ancestors as a great victorious people. The choice falls on paganism, since, according to these ideologists, it is endowed with an "Aryan heroic principle" and is not burdened by Christian morality, calling for mercy and ignoring the idea of the priority of "blood and soil".

Christianity is seen by neo-pagans as a hindrance to a successful "racial struggle". The rejection of Christianity and the return to the "ethnic religion", the "faith of the ancestors", according to neo-pagans, will help overcome the split of the nation and return to it the lost moral "Aryan" values that can lead it out of the crisis. Neo-pagans call for a return to the "Aryan worldview" in the name of public health, which is being destroyed by modern civilization. Within this discourse, the slogans of the Conservative Revolution of the 1920s are once again becoming popular. Declaring themselves "Aryans", the radicals seek to fight for the "salvation of the white race", which results in attacks on "migrants" and other representatives of non-titular nationalities.[39][page needed]

In many areas of Slavic neo-paganism (rodnovery), Slavs or Russians are credited with historical and cultural or racial superiority over other peoples. This ideology includes Russian messianism, with the Russian people being considered the only force capable of resisting world evil and leading the rest of the world.[39][page needed] The "Aryan" idea sets before Russia the task of building an analogue of the "Fourth Reich", a new "Aryan" empire on a global scale.[37] The Russian Aryan myth rejects any territorial disputes, since the Russian people are depicted as absolutely autochthonous throughout Eurasia.

Less common is the model of an ethno-national state associated with the separatism of certain Russian regions. The fragmentation of Russia into several Russian national states, devoid of ethnic minorities, is supposed. In both cases, it is believed that the cohesion of society in the new state should be built on a single "native faith".[39][page needed]

Modern Russian neo-paganism took shape in the second half[40] of the 1970s and is associated with the activities of antisemitic supporters of the Moscow Arabist Valery Yemelyanov (neopagan name - Velemir) and the former dissident and neo-Nazi activist Alexey Dobrovolsky (neopagan name - Dobroslav).[41][42]

Contemporary nationalism

Further information: Eurasianism, Russian irredentism, and Rashism

Vladimir Putin and Vladimir Zhirinovsky are both considered Russian nationalists
A rally in support of Novorossiya in Moscow on 11 June 2014

The Kremlin conducted a campaign against radical nationalists in the 2010s, and as a result, many of them are currently imprisoned, according to a Russian political scientist and a senior visiting fellow at the George Washington University Institute for European, Russian, and Eurasian Studies Maria Lipman.[43] At the same time, Eurasianism has emerged as the dominant nationalist narrative in Putinist Russia. In a poll conducted by Levada Center in 2021, 64% of Russian citizens identify Russia as a non-European country; while only 29% regarded Russia to be part of Europe.[44]

Sociologist Marcel Van Herpen wrote that United Russia increasingly relied on Russian nationalism for support following the 2014 Russian military intervention in Ukraine.[45] Nationalist political party Rodina cultivated ties with Eurosceptic, far-right and far-left political movements, supporting them financially and inviting them to Eurasian conferences in Crimea and Saint Petersburg.[46]

However, the Kremlin scaled nationalism down out of fears that prominent figures such as Igor Girkin began to act independently, following a brief period of stirring activism that resulted in Russian men volunteering to fight in Donbas in 2014 and 2015, according to Lipman. In Lipman's view, the Kremlin's aim is to prevent emotions that "might get out of control and motivate people to act independently".[43]

Academics Robert Horvath and Anton Shekhovtsov described how the Kremlin uses far-right groups to promote Russian nationalist or anti-western views in Russia and abroad. According to Horvath, the Kremlin cultivated neo-Nazis who reject democratic institutions and imposed restrictions on mainstream nationalists who may support free elections.[47][48] (See also Putinism § Relation to far-right.)

In November 2018, Vladimir Putin described himself as "the most effective nationalist", explaining that Russia is a multiethnic and multireligious state and preserving it as such serves the interests of the ethnic Russians. He remarked that Russian ethnicity didn't exist at some point and it was formed by multiple Slavic tribes.[49]

According to Michael Hirsh, a senior correspondent at Foreign Policy:

Graham and other Russia experts said it is a mistake to view Putin merely as an angry former KGB apparatchik upset at the fall of the Soviet Union and NATO’s encroachment after the Cold War, as he is often portrayed by Western commentators. Putin, himself, made this clear in his Feb. 21 speech, when he disavowed the Soviet legacy, inveighing against the mistakes made by former leaders Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin to grant Ukraine even partial autonomy. ... Putin is rather a messianic Russian nationalist and Eurasianist whose constant invocation of history going back to Kievan Rus, however specious, is the best explanation for his view that Ukraine must be part of Russia’s sphere of influence, experts say. In his essay last July, Putin even suggested that the formation of a separate, democratic Ukrainian nation “is comparable in its consequences to the use of weapons of mass destruction against us.”[50]

Putin's views evolved over time. In his speech on 18 June 2004 at the international conference "Eurasian Integration: Trends of Modern Development and Challenges of Globalization", Putin said about the problems hindering integration: "I would say that these problems can be formulated very simply. This is great-power chauvinism, this is nationalism, this is the personal ambitions of those on whom political decisions depend, and, finally, this is just stupidity, ordinary cavemen's stupidity".[51]

Putin's address to the nation on 24 February 2022.[52] Minutes after Putin's announcement, the Russian invasion of Ukraine began.

Since around 2014, the Putin regime has adopted Russian nationalism and great-power chauvinism as its main policy.[53][54] In July 2021, Putin published an essay titled On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians, in which he states that Belarusians, Ukrainians and Russians should be in one All-Russian nation as a part of the Russian world and are "one people" whom "forces that have always sought to undermine our unity" wanted to "divide and rule".[55]

In a speech on 21 February 2022, following the escalation in the 2021–2022 Russo-Ukrainian crisis,[56] Putin made a number of claims about Ukrainian and Soviet history, including stating that modern Ukraine was created by the Bolsheviks in 1917 as part of a communist appeasement of nationalism of ethnic minorities in the former Russian Empire, specifically blaming Vladimir Lenin for "detaching Ukraine from Russia".[57] Putin spoke of the "historic, strategic mistakes" that were made when in 1991 the USSR "granted sovereignty" to other Soviet republics on "historically Russian land" and called the entire episode "truly fatal".[58] He described Ukraine as being turned into the "anti-Russia" by the West.[59]

Russian nationalism and ethnic minorities

See also: Ethnic nationalism in Russia, List of ethnic groups in Russia, and Racism in Russia

Eurasianist ideologue Aleksandr Dugin is regarded as the most influential Russian nationalist theoretician of the 21st century
Russia Day celebrations in Mirny, Sakha Republic, 12 June 2014

The issue of Russian nationalism with regard to Russia's relationship with its ethnic minorities has been extensively studied since the rapid expansion of Russia from the 16th century onward.[60] Since there is no English word which differentiates the meaning of the word "Russian", in Russian, it is either used as a term for an ethnic people ("Русский" – ethnic Russian) and it is also used as a term for the inhabitants of Russia ("Россиянин" – Russian citizen).[61]

The Russian conquest of Muslim Kazan is considered the first event which transformed Russia from a nearly homogenous nation into a multi-ethnic society.[62][63] Over the years and from the territorial base which it gained in Kazan, Russia managed to conquer Siberia and Manchuria and it also expanded into the Caucasus. At one point, Russia managed to annex a large territory of Eastern Europe, Finland, Central Asia, Mongolia and, on other occasions, it encroached into Turkish, Chinese, Afghan and Iranian territories. Various ethnic minorities have become increasingly viral and integrated into mainstream Russian society, and as a result, they have created a mixing picture of racial relationships in the modern Russian nationalist mindset. The work of understanding different ethnic minorities in relation to the Russian state can be traced back to the work of Philip Johan von Strahlenberg, a Swedish prisoner of war who settled in Tsarist Russia and became a geographer.

The concept is strongly understood by various minorities in Russia. The Volga Tatars and the Bashkirs, the two main Muslim peoples in Russia, have long been lauded as model minorities in Russia, and historically, they have been viewed more positively by the Russian nationalist movement. Furthermore, Tatar and Bashkir imams have worked to spread the Russian nationalist ideology in a way which is in accordance with their Islamic faith.[64][65]

Map showing the ethnic republics of the Russian Federation, plus annexed Crimea, that succeeded the national territories of Russian SFSR (pre-1990)

In the Caucasus, Russia gained a significant amount of support from the Ossetians, one of the few Christian-based peoples which live in the mountainous region.[66] There was also a strong amount of support for Russia among Armenians and Greeks, a sentiment which was largely due to the fact that the Armenians, the Greeks and the Orthodox government of Russia all adhered to similar religions.[67][68]

The Koryo-saram (Koreans) have also been regarded as a model minority in Russia, and as a result, they have been encouraged to colonize sparsely-populated parts of Russia, this policy was first implemented during the Tsarist era and it continues to be implemented today, because Koreans were not hostile to Russian nationalism. Although the Korean diaspora in the Russian Far East was loyal to the Soviet Union and also underwent cultural Russification, Koreans were deported to Central Asia by the Soviet government (1937–1938), based on the erroneous charge that they were aligned with the Japanese. When Khrushchev allowed deported nationalities to return to their homelands, the Koreans remained restricted and they were not rehabilitated.[69] On 26 April 1991 the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Socialist Federal Soviet Republic, under its chairman Boris Yeltsin, passed the law On the Rehabilitation of Repressed Peoples with Article 2 denouncing all mass deportations as "Stalin's policy of defamation and genocide".[70]

Ukrainians in Russia have been largely integrated and the majority of them pledged loyalty over Russia, while some Ukrainians managed to occupy significant positions in Russian history. Bohdan Khmelnytsky is one of Russia's most celebrated figures who brought Ukraine to the Tsardom of Russia throughout the Pereyaslav Council.[71] Ukrainian Prince Alexander Bezborodko was responsible for manifesting the modern diplomacies of Russia under the reign of Catherine the Great.[72] Soviet leaders Nikita Khrushchev, Leonid Brezhnev, Konstantin Chernenko and Mikhail Gorbachev also had some ancestral connections to Ukraine.[73][74][75] In addition, Russia's biggest opposition leader, Alexei Navalny, is also of paternally of Ukrainian origin as well as being a potential Russian nationalist.[76]

RT editor-in-chief Margarita Simonyan, who is of Armenian descent, spoke out against the 2022 anti-war protests in Russia, stating that "If you are ashamed of being Russian now, don't worry, you are not Russian."[77]

Akhmad Kadyrov and his son Ramzan defected to Russia during the Second Chechen War, pledging loyalty to Putin while maintaining a degree of autonomy for the Chechen Republic, while using this opportunity for securing funds for their regime from Russian federal money.[78] Vladislav Surkov, who is of Chechen origin, was the chief figure who initiated the idea of Russian managed democracy, in which nationalism is a part of the ideology.[79]

Georgians in Russia do not have a positive view of Russian nationalism, and as a result, vast majority of them maintain a neutral or negative opinion.[80] However, Russian expansion into the Caucasus mountains has been driven by Georgian figures such as Pavel Tsitsianov, who initiated the conquest of the Caucasus.[81] Pyotr Bagration was another Georgian who went on to become one of Russia's most celebrated heroes. Soviet Union's transformation into a superpower was the work of yet another Russified Georgian, Joseph Stalin, who had a complex relationship with Russian nationalism.[82]

Some of Dagestan's revered figures have long been respected by Russian nationalists, such as Rasul Gamzatov, who is one of Russia's most respected poets despite his Avar origin.[83] Khabib Nurmagomedov's rise to popularity and fame has earned a divisive opinion among Russians and Dagestanis.[84] Putin loyalist Ramzan Kadirov has made controversial statements attacking the legendary Dagestani leader Imam Shamil, who led the armed resistance of Caucasian Imamate against Russian imperialism during the Murid War. This has resulted in an outpouring of criticism in Dagestanis, who fear that Kadyrovites seek to control the Kizlyarsky and Botlikhsky districts in Dagestan. The comments by Kadyrov are widely seen as part of government attempts to demean religious and national leaders of Russia's Muslim minority who defended their homeland from Imperial Russia.[85]

Germans in Russia have long been treated with privileges under the Tsarist government and many Germans became prominent in Russian politics, education and economy, including the Tsarist House of Romanov, which also included many German-based figures, most notably Catherine the Great.[86][87][88] Many Germans fought in the Russian Civil War and regarded themselves as Russian nationalists.[citation needed] The Baltic German nobility were significantly loyal to the Russian Empire, but were resistant to nationalism until the Russian Revolution, identifying mainly as members of the Russian nobility.[89]

A number of critics believe the rise of Russian nationalism is belated. The reason is the passive attitude of Russians towards other peoples inhabiting Russia. Passivity arose because of the huge number of peoples of Russia, which were much smaller in number than Russians. They were easy to dominate and subdue.[90]: 251 [91] At the same time, the increase in the representation of Jews, Uzbeks, Germans, Armenians and other representatives of non-Russian peoples in the elites of Russia generates discontent and Russian "belated" nationalism.[citation needed] According to Boris Berezovsky, Russian nationalism is a huge danger that the entire non-Russian population of Russia will face on an increasing scale.[92]

Parties and organizations

Political Party Type Status Years of existence
Liberal Democratic Party of Russia Ultranationalist, Xenophobic Registered, Part of State Duma 1989–present
Communist Party of the Russian Federation Left-wing nationalism Registered, Part of State Duma 1993–present
National Sovereignty Party of Russia Nationalist Denied Registration 2000–2012
Great Russia Nationalist Denied Registration 2007–present
The Other Russia Ultranationalist, Irredentist Denied Registration 2010–present
Pamyat Ultranationalist, Monarchist Defunct 1980–1990s
Front of National Revolutionary Action Neo-Nazi Defunct 1991-1999
Russian All-People's Union Nationalist Defunct 1991–2001
Russian National Union Neo-Nazi Defunct 1993–1998
People's National Party Neo-Nazi Defunct 1994–2006
Rodina Nationalist Defunct 2003–2006
Russian National Socialist Party Neo-Nazi Defunct N/A
Russian National Unity Neo-Nazi Banned 1990–2000
Russian All-National Union Ultra-Nationalist Banned 1990–2011
National Salvation Front Left-Wing Nationalism, Right-Wing Nationalism Banned 1992–1993
National Bolshevik Party Ultranationalist, Xenophobic Banned 1994–2007
Slavic Union Neo-Nazi Banned 1999–2010
Movement Against Illegal Immigration Neo-Nazi Banned 2002–2011
National Socialist Society Neo-Nazi Banned 2004–2010
Northern Brotherhood Neo-Nazi Banned 2006–2012
Russians Nationalist, Xenophobic Banned 2011–2015
National Bolshevik Front Nationalist 2006–present

See also




  1. ^ Nugraha, Aryanta (February 2018). "Neo-Eurasianism in Russian Foreign Policy: Echoes from the Past or Compromise with the Future?". Jurnal Global & Strategis. 9 (1): 99–100. doi:10.20473/jgs.9.1.2015.95-110. Archived from the original on 2023-07-06 – via Global Strategis.
  2. ^ Garman, Liam (2022-05-26). "Neo-Eurasianism – placing Russia on a path of collision with the West". Defence Connect. Archived from the original on 2022-11-19.
  3. ^ Lewis, Lall, Alexandra, Marie (2023-07-04). "From decolonisation to authoritarianism: the co-option of the decolonial agenda in higher education by right-wing nationalist elites in Russia and India". Higher Education. doi:10.1007/s10734-023-01074-0.((cite journal)): CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  4. ^ Riasanovsky, Nicholas V. (1959). Nicholas I and official nationality in Russia, 1825–1855. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0520010659.
  5. ^ Hutchings, Stephen C. (2004). Russian Literary Culture in the Camera Age: The Word as Image. Routledge. p. 86.
  6. ^ Thaden, Edward C. (1954). "The Beginnings of Romantic Nationalism in Russia". American Slavic and East European Review. 13 (4): 500–521. doi:10.2307/2491619. JSTOR 2491619.
  7. ^ Grigorieva, Tatyana. "Откуда пошло выражение "Москва – третий рим"?" [How did the saying "Moscow – the Third Rome" emerge?]. Culture.rf (in Russian). Retrieved 2022-08-05.
  8. ^ The Current digest of the Soviet press, Volume 39, Issues 1-26. American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies, 1987. Pp. 7.
  9. ^ Christopher Read. Lenin: a revolutionary life. Digital Printing Edition. Oxon, England, UK; New York, New York, USA: Routledge, 2006. Pp. 115.
  10. ^ a b c Motyl, 2001, page 501
  11. ^ Timo Vihavainen: Nationalism and Internationalism. How did the Bolsheviks Cope with National Sentiments? in Chulos & Piirainen 2000.
  12. ^ Law, Ian. Red racisms: racism in communist and post-communist contexts. Springer, 2016, p. 19
  13. ^ a b c d Martin, Terry Dean. The affirmative action empire: nations and nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939. Cornell University Press, 2001.
  14. ^ a b c d O'Connor, Kevin (2008). Intellectuals and Apparatchiks: Russian Nationalism and the Gorbachev Revolution. Lexington Books. ISBN 978-0739131220.
  15. ^ a b c Bekus, Nelly (2010). "Nationalism and Socialism: The Soviet Case". Struggle Over Identity: The Official and the Alternative 'Belarusianness'. Central European University Press. pp. 41–50. ISBN 978-9639776685.
  16. ^ "Soviet Policy on Nationalities, 1920s–1930s – Adventures in the Soviet Imaginary: The University of Chicago Library". www.lib.uchicago.edu. Retrieved 2022-08-31.
  17. ^ a b c d Chang, Jon K. "Tsarist continuities in Soviet nationalities policy: A case of Korean territorial autonomy in the Soviet Far East, 1923–1937". Eurasia Studies Society of Great Britain & Europe Journal. 3.
  18. ^ Савин, Андрей (January 2017). "Ethnification of Stalinism? National Operations and the NKVD Order № 00447 in a Comparative Perspective". Ethnic and Religious Minorities in Stalin's Soviet Union: New Dimensions of Research. Edited by Andrej Kotljarchuk & Olle Sundström. Stockholm: 62. The choice of "unreliable nations" as an internal enemy and the "fifth column," as well as the shift in the national policy of the Stalinist regime of the 1930s from internationalism to Russification and "National Bolshevism,"is generally consistent with the theory of the ethnification of Stalinism.
  19. ^ a b c Chang, Jon K. (2018). Burnt by the sun : the Koreans of the Russian Far East (Paperback ed.). Honolulu. ISBN 978-0824876746. OCLC 1017603651.((cite book)): CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  20. ^ a b c Smith, Jeremy (2013). Red Nations. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0521111317.
  21. ^ Naimark, Norman M. (2010). Stalin's Genocides. Princeton University Press. p. 135. ISBN 978-0691152387.
  22. ^ Dobrenko, Evgeny (2020). Late Stalinism: The Aesthetics of Politics. Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0300252842.
  23. ^ Light, Felix (2021-10-24). "Evgeny Dobrenko's 'Late Stalinism: The Aesthetics of Politics' Recasts 20th Century History". The Moscow Times. Retrieved 2022-09-02.
  24. ^ Brandenberger, David (2002). National Bolshevism: Stalinist Mass Culture and the Formation of Modern Russian National Identity, 1931–1956. Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0674009066.
  25. ^ Benedikt Sarnov, Our Soviet Newspeak: A Short Encyclopedia of Real Socialism., pp. 446–447. Moscow: 2002, ISBN 5856460596 (Наш советский новояз. Маленькая энциклопедия реального социализма.)
  26. ^ Резников, Кирилл (2017). Русская история: мифы и факты. От рождения славян до покорения Сибири. Litres. ISBN 978-5457554610.[page needed]
  27. ^ Quoted from book by Benedikt Sarnov, Our Soviet Newspeak: A Short Encyclopedia of Real Socialism., pp. 446–447. Moscow: 2002, ISBN 5856460596 (Наш советский новояз. Маленькая энциклопедия реального социализма.)
  28. ^ "New National Anthem". Seventeen Moments in Soviet History. 2015-06-18. Retrieved 2022-08-31.
  29. ^ "Anthem History". web.stanford.edu. Retrieved 2022-08-31.
  30. ^ Commercio, Michele E. (2011-06-06). Russian Minority Politics in Post-Soviet Latvia and Kyrgyzstan: The Transformative Power of Informal Networks. University of Pennsylvania Press. pp. 42–43, 46. ISBN 978-0-8122-0470-4.
  31. ^ Saunders, R.A.; Strukov, V. (2010). Historical Dictionary of the Russian Federation. Scarecrow Press. p. 69. ISBN 978-0810874602. Retrieved 2022-03-09.
  32. ^ Ekaterina, Ivanova; Andrey, Kinyakin; Sergey, Stepanov (2019-05-30). "The European and Russian Far Right as Political Actors: Comparative Approach". Journal of Politics and Law. 12 (2): 86. doi:10.5539/jpl.v12n2p86. S2CID 189962172.
  33. ^ Blamires, C.; Jackson, P. (2006). World Fascism: A–K. World Fascism: A Historical Encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO. ISBN 978-1576079409. Retrieved 2022-04-02. the RNE was of substantial organizational strength before its breakup in late 2000 and was estimated to have had, on the eve of its fracture, approximately 20,000 to 25,000 members
  34. ^ "Leader of "Kremlin project" found guilty of ultranationalist BORN murders :: khpg.org". khpg.org. Retrieved 2015-07-17.
  35. ^ "Chronology of events – NUPI". Archived from the original on 2007-09-30.
  36. ^ Racist Violence and Neo-Nazi Movements in Russia, Robert Kusche, Dresden, August 2013
  37. ^ a b Laruelle, Marlène (2010). "Арийский миф — русский взгляд / Перевод с французского Дмитрия Баюка. 25.03.2010". Vokrug sveta.
  38. ^ Beskov, Andrey (2017). "Реминисценции восточнославянского язычества в современной российской культуре (статья третья)". Colloquium Heptaplomeres (4): 7–19. ISSN 2312-1696.
  39. ^ a b c Schnirelmann, Victor (2015). Aryan myth in the modern world (in Russian). New literary review. ISBN 9785444804223.
  40. ^ Shizhensky, Roman (2020). "Современное "родноверие": реперные точки". Доклад на круглом столе: «Славянское язычество XXI века: проблемы генезиса и развития», прошедшем 15 февраля 2020 года в Нижегородском государственном педагогическом университете имени Козьмы Минина.
  41. ^ Shizhensky, Roman (2021). "Неоязычество и средний класс" (in Russian). Lecture hall "Krapivensky 4". 02/03/2021.
  42. ^ Schnirelmann, Victor (2015). Aryan myth in the modern world (in Russian). New literary review. ISBN 9785444804223.
  43. ^ a b Chotiner, Isaac (2022-06-08). "Putin Has a Patriotism Problem". The New Yorker. Archived from the original on 2022-06-08.
  44. ^ "Russia and Europe". Levada Center. 2021-03-22. Archived from the original on 2023-05-01.
  45. ^ Van Herpen, Marcel H. (2014). Putin's Wars: The Rise of Russia's New Imperialism. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. pp. 116–117. ISBN 978-1442231375.
  46. ^ Max Seddon (2015-03-22). "Racists, Neo-Nazis, Far Right Flock to Russia for Joint Conference". BuzzFeed. Retrieved 2015-03-23.
  47. ^ Horvath, Robert (2022-03-21). "Putin's fascists: the Russian state's long history of cultivating homegrown neo-Nazis". The Conversation.
  48. ^ Shekhovtsov, Anton (2017-10-27). "Conventional bedfellows: The Russian propaganda machine and the western far right". Eurozine.
  49. ^ "Путин назвал себя самым эффективным националистом". RBK Group. 2018-10-18. Retrieved 2022-04-03.
  50. ^ "Putin's Thousand-Year War". Foreign Policy. 2022-03-12.
  51. ^ "Putin: Obstacles for integration are great-power chauvinism, personal ambitions of some politicians and just stupidity". Archived from the original on 2007-12-14.
  52. ^ "Full text: Putin's declaration of war on Ukraine". The Spectator. 2022-02-24.
  53. ^ Simpson, Jeffrey (2014-03-05). "The return of Great Russian chauvinism". The Globe and Mail.
  54. ^ Kessler, Mario (2022-02-26). "Putin's Anti-Bolshevik Fantasies Could Be His Downfall". Jacobin. Retrieved 2022-03-11.
  55. ^ Putin, Vladimir (2021-07-12). "Article by Vladimir Putin 'On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians'". The Kremlin. Government of Russia. Archived from the original on 2022-01-25.
  56. ^ "Putin orders troops into eastern Ukraine on 'peacekeeping duties'". The Guardian. 2022-02-21. Archived from the original on 2022-02-23.
  57. ^ Gotev, Georgi (2022-02-22). "Putin's world: Selected quotes from a disturbing speech –". Euractiv.com.
  58. ^ JOFFRE, TZVI (2022-06-09). "Russian parliament questions Lithuania's independence with new bill".
  59. ^ "What the West Will Never Understand About Putin's Ukraine Obsession". Time. 2022-01-22.
  60. ^ "Contemporary Russian Nationalism between East and West | IWM Website".
  61. ^ "What is the difference between "русские" and "россиянин"? "русские" vs "россиянин"?". 2024-01-11.
  62. ^ Davies, Brian L. (2014). "Muscovy's Conquest of Kazan". Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 15 (4): 873–883. doi:10.1353/kri.2014.0050. S2CID 159827537.
  63. ^ "Kazan: In Search of a Recipe for Its Melting Pot | Wilson Center".
  64. ^ Shaykhutdinov, Renat (2019). "Volga Tatars: Continuing Resilience in the Age of Uncertainty". The Palgrave Handbook of Ethnicity. pp. 315–330. doi:10.1007/978-981-13-2898-5_148. ISBN 978-981-13-2897-8. S2CID 239374960.
  65. ^ Yemelianova, Galina M. (1999). "Volga Tatars, Russians and the Russian State at the Turn of the Nineteenth Century: Relationships and Perceptions". The Slavonic and East European Review. 77 (3): 448–484. JSTOR 4212902.
  66. ^ "The Ossetian neverendum – European Council on Foreign Relations". September 2016.
  67. ^ Hovannisian, Richard G. (1973). "Armenia and the Caucasus in the Genesis of the Soviet-Turkish Entente". International Journal of Middle East Studies. 4 (2): 129–147. doi:10.1017/S0020743800027409. JSTOR 162238. S2CID 162360397.
  68. ^ Stephen, Riegg (May 2016). Claiming the Caucasus: Russia's Imperial Encounter with Armenians, 1801–1894 (Thesis). The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill University Libraries. doi:10.17615/e59p-c227.
  69. ^ Chang, Jon K. (2016). Burnt by the Sun: The Koreans of the Russian Far East. University of Hawaii Press. ISBN 978-0824856786.
  70. ^ Perovic, Jeronim (2018). From Conquest to Deportation: The North Caucasus under Russian Rule. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0190934675.
  71. ^ Plokhy, Serhii (2001). "The Ghosts of Pereyaslav: Russo-Ukrainian Historical Debates in the Post-Soviet Era". Europe-Asia Studies. 53 (3): 489–505. doi:10.1080/09668130120045906. JSTOR 826545. S2CID 144594680.
  72. ^ "Как сын украинского писаря стал ближайшим соратником Екатерины II". 2019-03-19.
  73. ^ Keating, Joshua (2014-02-25). "Blame Khrushchev for Ukraine's Newest Crisis". Slate.
  74. ^ "How Ukrainians built Communism | the Ukrainian Week".
  75. ^ "The International foundation for socio-economic and political studies (The Gorbachev Foundation) – Mikhail Gorbachev – Biography".
  76. ^ Портников, Виталий (2021-02-09). "Алексей Навальный и украинцы". Радио Свобода.
  77. ^ Popov, Maxime (2022-02-26). "Russia's Anti-War Lobby Goes Online". The Moscow Times.
  78. ^ Russell, John (September 2008). "Ramzan Kadyrov: The Indigenous Key to Success in Putin's Chechenization Strategy?". Nationalities Papers. 36 (4): 659–687. doi:10.1080/00905990802230605. S2CID 154611444.
  79. ^ Casula, Philipp (May 2013). "Sovereign Democracy, Populism, and Depoliticization in Russia: Power and Discourse During Putin's First Presidency" (PDF). Problems of Post-Communism. 60 (3): 3–15. doi:10.2753/PPC1075-8216600301. S2CID 152713348.
  80. ^ Zinam, Oleg (1974). "Georgians in Tsarist Russia and in the USSR". Nationalities Papers. 2 (2): 39–60. doi:10.1080/00905997408407758. S2CID 129148706.
  81. ^ Morshedloo, Javad (2019-08-23). "Double Identity in Favor of Colonial Strategy: Pavel Tsitsianov and the Foundation of Russian Colonialism in South Caucasus (1803–1806)". Historical Study of War. 3 (2): 129–150.
  82. ^ Rees, E. A. (1998). "Stalin and Russian Nationalism". Russian Nationalism Past and Present. pp. 77–106. doi:10.1007/978-1-349-26532-9_6. ISBN 978-1349265343.
  83. ^ Dunlop, John B. (2014). The Faces of Contemporary Russian Nationalism. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-1400853861.
  84. ^ "Feature: Khabib Nurmagomedov and the role of cultural censorship in Dagestan". 2019-03-05.
  85. ^ "Imam Shamil: A contested legacy that still resonates in the Caucasus".
  86. ^ "Russia's Love Affair with Germany". 2015-08-27.
  87. ^ "The Germans from Odessa and the Black Sea".
  88. ^ "Museum für russlanddeutsche Kulturgeschichte – the history of Russian-Germans".
  89. ^ Brüggemann, Karsten; Wezel, Katja (2019). "Nationally Indifferent or Ardent Nationalists? On the Options for Being German in Russia's Baltic Provinces, 1905–17". Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 20 (1): 39–62. doi:10.1353/kri.2019.0002. ISSN 1538-5000. S2CID 166388878.
  90. ^ Se-ho, Zhang (2008). "Предпосылки и причины возникновения современного русского национализма". Politex. 4 (3): 246–258.
  91. ^ Хо, Чжан Се (2009). Современный русский национализм в условиях глобализации: генезис, характеристика, политическая роль (Thesis).
  92. ^ "за всю свою историю Россия не прошла в полной мере через националистическую идею. Через идею национализма проходила Франция, Англия, Турция (не упоминаемая Березовским), евреи и другие. Березовский утверждал, что Россия будет проходить через националистическую идею, однако он не знает как это ударит для остальных нерусских (по евреям, татарам, кавказским народам). Все нерусское население безусловно столкнется с этим. Утверждал, что нерусские сталкивались с национализмом в 1990ые годы. По словам Березовского националистическая идея это огромная опасность, с которой все нерусское население России столкнется и в возрастающем масштабе будет сталкиватся в дальнешем. (from 41 min 00 se)". YouTube (in Russian). Retrieved 2023-01-24.

Further reading