A proposal has been made to eliminate all portals. Please share your thoughts on the matter at: Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)/RfC: Ending the system of portalsFeel free to edit portals, but they must not be moved or blanked, and this notice must not be removed, until the discussion is closed. For more information, read the Guide to deletion.
This is a WikiProject, an area for focused collaboration among Wikipedians. New participants are welcome; please feel free to participate!
Welcome to the new and improved WikiProject Portals. This project was rebooted on 4/17/2018, and is dedicated to the technological evolution of Wikipedia's portal system.
If you would like to improve Wikipedia's portals, and make them more dynamic, you've come to the right place...
We interrupt this broadcast, to bring you this special report...5...4...3...2...1...
2018-04-24: The discussion about the RfC proposal to delete all portals appears to have swayed heavily in favor of keeping portals, but the RfC may run until around May 8th, so it may be too early to call the result. Over 400 editors have participated in the debate so far, and it has become a long and intricate document...
The following tasks in this section are all new, and were enacted on 17 April 2018 (UTC).
Current focus
The most important activity right now for this WikiProject is to revitalize Wikipedia's portal system...
It follows a huge debate in April 2018 (see here) which has attracted a very wide spectrum of views. These range from: "I don't use them, relatively few others do, so let's get rid of them all"; through: "they're still useful and provide an alternative route for some users to discover a new subject", to: "people put lots of work into them, please don't get rid of them all".
The contents of much of the portal system has certainly grown out of date. Most (but not all) of this can be automated in various ways, to reduce the need for manual updating by editors. Many of the initial edits in this effort may need to be done by hand (to set things in motion).
The purpose of Portals as "topic tasters", providing an alternative and potentially attractive route for new users to sample articles across a broad subject areas, is perhaps also rather misunderstood.
Many of the tasks included below pertain to upgrading and updating the entire portal system, and there are links to design discussions on upgrading particular features. In addition, maintenance is a renewed priority, and that is covered too. You are welcome to join in on the fun...
Reassess function and purpose, minimum content criteria and promotion/branding
Get familiar with the issues involved with revamping them. Help identify what needs to be done, and what portions of that can be automated. Inspect as many as you have time for, and share what you learn on this WikiProject's talk page.
Each item in that list needs to be processed as explained below. Please do as many as you have time for. Every little bit helps...
First, look at a portal on the list, and inspect it to see if it is completed. If it isn't, either complete it, or mark the entry "Not ready" with the ((Not ready)) template. That will let others know it needs work.
If an entry on the list is a completed portal, add it to Portal:Contents/Portals. After you've added it, please mark that entry in the list as " Done", using the ((done)) template.
Most incomplete portals have one or more empty sections that have nothing more than a red subpage link in the middle of them.
Thank you.
Participate in design efforts & discussions
The talk page is divided into major areas of discussion, each covering a portal design component or issue:
Please inspect as many portals in this category as you have time for, and remove the category from those that are complete.
Also, feel free to complete those that are not, or any portion of them.
The upgrading and updating of specific section types are covered below.
Thank you.
Upgrade root excerpts in intro sections
Swap out old excerpts with "selective transclusions"...
Many portals include an intro section with an intro to the portal's main topic, in the form of an excerpt from the lead of the corresponding article.
The problem is, that most of the excerpts are static (they were copied and pasted) and go stale over time, needing to be refreshed from time to time from the root article. This is tedious to do by hand, and is a chore prone to being forgotten.
We are developing a new template ((Transclude lead excerpt)) which displays the current version of an article's lead each time the page is accessed. For an example of its use, see this diff. Beware that the Lua module behind this template is still in alpha testing and may not yet be robust. Improvements are being discussed on the talk page at Creating a template called Transclude lead excerpt.
Below is a list of portal intro pages with root article excerpts. When ready, please replace the static excerpts with selective transclusions as described above. After you've made the replacement, please mark that entry below with Done, using the ((done)) template. If you have any questions, suggestions, or comments, please post them at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Portals#Discussions about selective transclusion of intro excerpt. Thank you.
If you would like your portal's selected pages converted to use ((Transclude lead excerpt)) semi-automatically using JWB, please list it here. You can copy (not cut) the entry from the list above and paste it below. Once converted, the portals will be removed from this list and you can check that the result is what you were hoping for. Note that this automated process may make the resulting extract much longer or shorter than before. Please look at the results!
If you'd like to work on a whole portal that was started but not finished, and get it ready for Wikipedia's readership to view, pick one from the list below.
(WikiGnomes) When you find a portal (from the missing list) that is a work-in-progress (isn't complete), please add it to the list below:
Portal:Prehistory of Africa
Portal:Prehistory of Antarctica
Portal:Prehistory of Asia
Portal:Prehistory of Europe
Portal:Prehistory of North America
Portal:Prehistory of Oceania
Portal:Prehistory of South America
Portal:Grand Canyon
Invite your friends!
Let them know we are going to be having a lot of fun. ;)
For your convenience, a list of all portal pages is provided below. (It is possible to get all portal pages into your watchlist, but it is difficult and tedious). The list is current as of 4/22/2018.
The list of all portal pages is useful for getting a bird's eye view of:
What's in portal space
Monitoring activity on the portal pages using the Related changes feature in the sidebar menu
The list was too long to get onto a single page (there are 149,069 pages in portal space), and so it is split up into 4 parts:
SearchSuite enhances Wikipedia search results. It has a feature (menu item) that reformats search results to one-line entries, which is convenient for looking at portal subpages as a list. It has another menu item that formats the links (asterisk-style, with link delimeters) for copying/pasting into an editor. And another for sorting the results. Each feature works on the output of the others, and the script remembers the setting of each menu item between pages. When one is turned on, it stays on for all searches.
((Transclude random excerpt)) – same as above, but specify multiple sources for alternating display.
Project members
If you'd like to receive task requests and project-related updates on your talk page, please add your name below. Also, please indicate if you are a user of AWB or JWB, and if you know Lua. Follow your name with an asterisk if you do not wish to receive project-wide updates. Those marked with 2 asterisks have not been confirmed as wishing updates.
Dunarc (talk·contribs) - Limited time means I am not sure if I can be of much help, but I have edited a few portals from time to time and happy to keep doing so. Do not use any of the above.
Tisquesusa (talk·contribs), no AWB, JWB, Lua Help to get the automatic update function in would be great, the main point why portals are considered "dead"; not automatically updated for Featured, DYK and Pictures.
If you prefer WikiGnome tasks and would like to receive WikiGnome-oriented updates on your talk page, please add your name below. Also let us know if you are an AWB or JWB user.
Montanabw (talk·contribs), for Portal:Horses, I'm the only person who even keeps an eye on the portal any more, the creator of the portal, who raised it to featured portal quality, has retired from WP.
Nerd1a4i (talk·contribs) - creator of Portal:Quantum Computing which I'm working on. Willing to help out with other portals, but I'm still learning how to edit portals.
BrendonTheWizard (talk ·contribs)- The portals for partially recognized / unrecognized political entities are currently inactive and I intend to fix this. Today I am launching Portal:Limited recognition and I will monitor related portals & WikiProjects to update and feature articles on this topic. Brendon the Wizard✉️ ✨ 13:27, 27 April 2018 (UTC)[reply]